For quite a few decades the political system in the US has been functioning on the concept of oscillation between the two ends of the spectrum . Most of the time that worked fairly well . When the preponderance of problems developed on the incumbent's side then it was time for a change in the leadership . However , there are issues which transcend that type of partisanship . This is about one of those issues .

For this issue neither the left nor the right has gotten it correct . I am referring to the price of oil . It is well known that the price of petroleum fuels have an enormous effect on the US economy . Most of the recessions were preceded by a large increase in the price of oil .

But the partisan opinions on this issue consist of the usual blame aimed at the opponents . The left usually complains bitterly that it is speculators who drive the price of oil . [BTW , I do not mean to include every left leaning person in that description .]
There have  in fact  been some speculators who have been charged with manipulating petroleum prices and making huge profits by doing that .
Here , for example is an article from last year about that subject .
http://money.cnn.com/2011/05/24/markets/oil_price_speculation/index...
But if you read it carefully , you will see the following significant excerpt :
" The price of crude during the months of the alleged misdeeds changed very little, generally staying within a $10 range but the traders made their money off the daily fluctuations. Crude traded at $99 a barrel Jan. 2, 2008, and ended March 2008 at $101 a barrel. "

There it is . It is possible to make small manipulations in the price and still make large profits . That's what these speculators did . But they did NOT drive large changes in the price . And that is the point . It is not possible to create long trends in the price by manipulations unless you are someone who controls a major amount of supply [like OPEC] . The most that can be done by speculators is to day trade on small changes . But that has no effect on longer trends and larger price changes . One more thing : These were no ordinary speculators . They were able to manipulate the price because some of this cooperating group were in the energy business . They knew the details of how to buy petroleum and how to dispose of it . 

All right , so we've demonstrated that it is not speculators who have driven the recent volatility in petroleum prices . But what is it that is causing those enormous gyrations ?
And now it is the right's turn to be criticized .They assert that if we only had another George W. Bush type as President , he would pull  some strings [especially if he had contacts in the oil industry] and the price would magically recede .
Oddly enough , I think there was something to that . It was possible only a few years back to influence the direction of the price by having connections in the global oil industry . That was the good news . But now for the bad .

That approach is no longer possible . Why you ask ? Here is a summary of an important article just published in the science journal Nature .
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/01/120126223609.htm
The conclusions it makes are unambiguous and not just a little scary . Here's one of them :
[[
the economic pain of a flattening oil supply will trump the environment as a reason to curb the use of fossil fuels.

"Given our fossil-fuel dependent economies, this is more urgent and has a shorter time frame than global climate change," says James W. Murray, UW professor of oceanography, who wrote the Nature commentary with David King, director of Oxford's Smith School of Enterprise and the Environment.

The "tipping point" for oil supply appears to have occurred around 2005, says Murray, who compared world crude oil production with world prices going back to 1998. Before 2005, supply of regular crude oil was elastic and increased in response to price increases. Since then, production appears to have hit a wall at 75 million barrels per day in spite of price increases of 15 percent each year.

"As a result, prices swing wildly in response to small changes in demand," the co-authors wrote. "Others have remarked on this step change in the economies of oil around the year 2005, but the point needs to be lodged more firmly in the minds of policy makers."
]]

The rest of their explanation has to do with the details of the supply of oil and the problems with the recent discoveries as well as the economics  involved . If you are at all interested in this subject read the link . To conclude here is the graph which summarizes their work . Those who understand scatterplots will find it compelling and hard to ignore . It shows a clear case of "inelastic supply" in the petroleum industry .
http://images.sciencedaily.com/2012/01/120126223609-large.jpg

 © 2012 by Rich Scott . All rights reserved .

Tags: US-economy, global-warming, peak-oil, petroleum, politics

Views: 623

Reply to This

Replies to This Article/Seed

I know there is a supposed "everyone knows" position on the right that George W. Bush opened up more acreage to oil and gas exploration and that brought down the price at the pump. Now, even if that was true then (and there is no reason at all to suspect that it was), it is no longer. Barack Obama has opened up millions of acres to oil and gas exploration and is in the process of opening more, yet the price at the pump is rising to record levels. In my mind that gives the lie to the idea that the President's stand on exploration has any effect on the price of gas at the pump. It's simply right wing bullshit and a politically driven lie.

RDS ,

I covered that in my article :
Oddly enough , I think there was something to that . It was possible only a few years back to influence the direction of the price by having connections in the global oil industry . That was the good news . But now for the bad .

That approach is no longer possible ....

A most excellent article Rich! 

Well, that it that. The day has come that we have maxed out the consumption of oil, and all that can happen now, is that prices will go up. The sooner that the worlds nations come to this same conclusion, the quicker we can come up with an alternative fuel.

I don't see this a political move. The day has come that both Democrats and Republicans have to know the common sense of this situation. Now, instead of fighting over climate change, they might have to work together to solve this problem, before it eats into our economy even more.

Thanks P . Now if only I can get a few more hot headed replies from both the left and the right , I'll have a hit on my hands . Yuk yuk ...

BTW , although oil prices should trend up there will also be more volatility . That is what the graph shows . Small changes in either supply or demand will cause large changes in price .

Really a great Article Rich!

Not read all the links and will be back afterwards. It does seem though that there is no way that we can expect supply to ever meet demand again in a way that is efficient or affordable. It's time to pull a "Manhattan type program" and get alternative fuel sources figured out ASAP!

Thanks Larry . Something different is needed . Of course my suggestion has never changed . It was my first article on our Grouply site . Can you remember that far back ?

Barely, It seems you been an advocate for electric vehicles but I seem to barely rememcber some type of hydrogen dealie....

Yup electric cars ; That was it .Your memory is doin' fine .  And it would work to free us from our petroleum addiction today .
But in general anything which improves the fuel efficiency of transportatation system including fuel cell vehicles would be a workable solution .

For those who argue that oil reserves have been increasing, that more crude oil will be available in the future, the co-authors wrote: "The true volume of global proved reserves is clouded by secrecy; forecasts by state oil companies are not audited and appear to be exaggerated. More importantly, reserves often take 6 -- 10 years to drill and develop before they become part of the supply, by which time older fields have become depleted."

Ok now this is something that we should not be a problem. A little transparency could go a long way and there is no reason why the forecasts can't start to be more truthful either.

"Historically, there has been a tight link between oil production and global economic growth," the co-authors wrote. "If oil production can't grow, the implication is that the economy can't grow either."

Placing all our economic eggs in one basket isn't great. No more gold standard, we now carry around a quart of oil in our wallets.

Transparency might be good for the economists . I'm not sure what it would do for the economy .

I like your analogy : "a quart of oil in our wallets" . It also indicates how messy things might get [in our pants !] .

Transparency might be good for the economists . I'm not sure what it would do for the economy .

Ha! LOL

Well yeah that's true; but still, it might help to narrow down what's actually transpiring on the supply front. Reading through some of that link again and ya know, this is not an easy task trying to pull energy outta the ground.

" this is not an easy task trying to pull energy outta the ground. "

Not today . It hasn't been that way for a long while now . It seems that all of the easy-to-get oil has already been gotten . Now they've got to do extraordinary things to find new petroleum , like fracking and deep sea drilling . No wonder they are planning on exploring the ice free parts of the Arctic [at least that is what the Russians are doing] .

RSS

Blog Posts

Guns, One Hand Washes The Other

Posted by JohnRussell on December 21, 2014 at 8:00am 9 Comments

Ten days ago or so, there was a shooting incident inside a Chicago neighborhood bar. I won't give the name but if one were to google something like 'chicago bar shooting' the bare facts won't be difficult to find.

What happened was that there was an argument between two guys in one pub, and one of the two left and walked across the street to a different establishment to continue drinking. Shortly thereafter the second fellow followed the first in to the bar across the street and they…

Continue

Crack Whore. Crack Whore? Crack Whore!

Posted by Wheel on December 16, 2014 at 8:52am 7 Comments

Crack Whore. Crack Whore. Crack Whore.

My granddaughter is almost 3. She's learning to talk at a really amazing rate. She is learning new words, repeating phrases, even entire sentences that she hears us say, and saying things that we never taught her. I've been fussing at her grandmother and her mom, both of them potty mouths, about their language around the kid. They ARE getting better, but....

Laural and I were playing the other day and Dan-Dan, her dog, ran behind her and…

Continue

Why the NewTown families’ lawsuit against Bushmaster will fail

Posted by Bruce "ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ" Tarleton on December 15, 2014 at 7:45pm 2 Comments

It’s called the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act.  Signed into law in 2005, the Act provides immunity to Gun Manufacturers and dealers from negligence when their product has been used in crimes.  Prior to its passing, Ruger, Smith & Wesson, and many other gun manufacturers spent billions of dollars in settlements for lawsuits arising from criminal use of their products.

The law is somewhat narrow in its immunity.  All regulations must be followed with the sale of the…

Continue

Two Years

Posted by jwc2blue on December 13, 2014 at 6:48pm 4 Comments

TWO YEARS

 

Not such a lengthy span. Or a lifetime. Seven hundred and thirty days. Seventeen thousand five hundred and twenty hours, or one million five hundred one thousand two hundred minutes.

 It depends on your perspective, doesn’t it?

“Time flies when you’re having fun,” they say. And so it does.

Of course, they also say; “Time flies like an arrow. Fruitflies like a peach.”

Both, of course are true, though I think that I envy the fruitflies that…

Continue

Character - Different Meanings to Different People

Posted by Robert in Ohio on December 13, 2014 at 4:49pm 5 Comments

Character, integrity and loyalty are three qualities that my grandfather told me were the basis of what kind of person we turn out to be and what kind of example we are to others/

I saw this on line and it captured a lot of what he meant

83DA5B4E-35A8-45C0-8D61-1E5C304E203C.jpg

Character - what does it mean to…

Continue

Surprise! More Blacks say Gun Ownership Protects People from Crime

Posted by Bruce "ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ" Tarleton on December 11, 2014 at 1:00am 9 Comments

Recent Pew Research polling shows a growing support for Gun Rights.  For the first time in more than two decades, support for Gun Rights exceeds support for Gun Control, 52% to 46%

Further polling indicates that more people believe Gun Ownership does more to protect people from crime (57%) than believe it endangers personal safety (38%).

But the big change over the last two years of polling is the attitude of blacks to gun ownership. …

Continue

My tribute to William Dunn, the first American Ace of WWII

Posted by Bruce "ΜΟΛΩΝ ΛΑΒΕ" Tarleton on December 10, 2014 at 11:51am 11 Comments

History is usually marked in time with firsts. First to fly. First jet aircraft. First man on the moon. Usually there is a general agreement on what we are taught about who was first doing what. But there are some cases that require strict definition to define the first.



Take for instance the first man to break the sound barrier. When asked, most people will quickly say it was Chuck Yeager in the Bell X-1 aircraft in 1947. But the fact is, the sound barrier was broken years…

Continue

Hillary Is "Finished" , Or So Say Her Enemies

Posted by JohnRussell on December 8, 2014 at 8:46am 6 Comments

by John Russell

If you can think of a right wing or conservative news source, there is a good chance that in the last 4 days they promoted a story to the effect of "Hillary Is Finished" , or "Hillary Is History", a reference that is much more pertinent to an appearance by Oliver North on an anti-Hillary television network than it is to Clinton's presidential chances. One might say the reference is ENTIRELY connected to Oliver North.

I cannot find a single non…

Continue

Follow NT's Forum

© 2014   Created by Perrie Halpern.

Badges  |  Report an Issue.  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service