Israeli military says its troops shot and killed three hostages by mistake | Israel-Gaza war | The Guardian
S E E D E D C O N T E N T
IDF identifies hostages killed as Yotam Haim, Alon Shamriz and Samer El-Talalqa, saying they were mistakenly believed to be a threat
- Israel-Gaza war - live updates
The Israeli military has said that its troops shot and killed three hostages being held by Hamas after mistakenly identifying them as a threat during fighting in a battle-torn neighbourhood of Gaza City.
The announcement on Friday came amid heavy fighting across the embattled territory that led to an influx of dead and wounded into hospitals in Deir al-Balah, Khan Younis and Rafah.
Separately, the Qatar-based television network Al Jazeera said that one of its journalists was killed and and another was injured in a drone strike while reporting in Khan Younis.
The army identified the three killed hostages as Yotam Haim and Alon Shamriz, who were taken from Kfar Aza kibbutz during Hamas's 7 October attack, and Samer El-Talalqa, taken from Nir Am kibbutz.
The hostages were killed in the Gaza City area of Shejaiya, where troops have been engaged in fierce fighting with Hamas militants in recent days.
The exact circumstances of their deaths were not immediately clear. In a statement late on Friday, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) said: "During combat in Shejaiya, the IDF mistakenly identified three Israeli hostages as a threat. As a result, the troops fired toward them and they were killed."
Army spokesperson Rear Adm Daniel Hagari said it was believed that the three had either fled their captors or been abandoned. "Perhaps in the last few days, or over the past day - we still don't know all the details - they reached this area," he said. He said the army expressed "deep sorrow" and was investigating.
Israel's prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, said in a statement: "Together with the entire people of Israel, I bow my head in deep sorrow and mourn the death of three of our dear sons who were kidnapped. My heart goes out to the grieving families in their difficult time."
Al Jazeera initially said that video journalist Samer Abu Daqqa and its chief correspondent in Gaza, Wael al-Dahdouh, had been injured by shrapnel when they were reporting at a school that had been hit by an earlier airstrike.
In a subsequent statement condemning the Israeli military, Al Jazeera attributed the injuries to a drone strike: "Following Samer's injury, he was left to bleed to death for over five hours, as Israeli forces prevented ambulances and rescue workers from reaching him, denying the much-needed emergency treatment."
Dahdouh, who lost several members of his family in Israeli bombings last month, was wounded in the arm and transferred to Nasser hospital in Khan Younis.
Earlier on Friday, the IDF recovered the bodies of three other hostages in Gaza: Elya Toledano, 28, a French-Israeli civilian, and two soldiers, Nik Beizer and Ron Scherman, both 19.
The military said they were identified in a process carried out by medical officials, military rabbis and forensic experts. It did not give further details of the circumstances of their death, or from where in Gaza they were recovered.
About 240 people were taken hostage when Hamas gunmen breached the separation barrier into Israel on 7 October and killed 1,200 people, mostly civilians.
Israel's ensuing offensive in Gaza has killed more than 18,700 people, mostly women and children, according to Palestinian officials.
The Israeli government has repeatedly stated that bringing home all of the hostages is one of its chief war aims. But in seven weeks since ground troops pushed into northern Gaza, troops have not rescued any hostages, though they freed one early in the conflict and have found the bodies of several more.
Families of the hostages said this week they were "shocked" by the announcement by the director of Israeli intelligence agency the Mossad that he was refusing to conduct new negotiations to free them, and demanded an explanation from the authorities.
During a week-long truce in late November, Hamas released more than 100 women, children and foreigners it was holding in Gaza in exchange for the release of 240 women and teenagers Israel had imprisoned, many without charge.
According to the Israeli military, more than 130 of the hostages taken to Gaza are still being held. Some have been declared dead in absentia by Israeli authorities.
The Palestinian Prisoners' Association said Israel has detained more than 4,400 Palestinians since 7 October and is holding around half without charge.
Toledano, who turned 28 in captivity, was among an estimated 240 people taken hostage during the Hamas attacks in southern Israel. A resident of Tel Aviv, he was at the Nova music festival along with his friend and fellow French-Israeli Mia Schem, who was released under a truce agreement at the end of November.
The two friends had tried to flee by car at the start of the attack on the Nova music festival, but their tyres were shot out. Schem had messaged other friends: "They're shooting at us, come to help us."
Schem, 21, who was training to be a tattoo artist, was later shown in the first Hamas video of a hostage speaking from captivity. She was released on 30 November.
Explore more on these topics
- Israel-Gaza war
- Israel
- Gaza
- Middle East and north Africa
- Palestinian territories
- news
Reuse this content
OFF-TOPIC COMMENTS WILL BE REMOVED WITHOUT WARNING.
STAY ON-TOPIC
Tags
Who is online
228 visitors
One of the horrors of war is friendly fire incidents. Sadly this incident is horrible but not unusual in a combat zone.
RIP hostages.
... additional reports on this incident are less than reassuring for bibi's government.
I just saw additional reports that are not good. They were waving a white flag, shirtless as to show no weapons or suicide vests and one was yelling ''Help'' in Hebrew. Another report said there was writing on the wall (s) of the building that said something like ''hostages here'' and IDF thought it was a trap.
Not only are the lives of the hostages over but the devastating effect on their families will be just overwhelming and the IDF that opened fire lives are over.
The whole thing is just so fricking sad.
Yes, the IDF will investigate. Hamas out of uniform is a problem but they have been for decades and this intense fighting has not changed their MO.
Dead man walking.
surviving 2 months of captivity and then escaping, only to be killed by their rescuers.
It's all on Benji's watch, we should be rid of him soon.
Exactly, it’s like Bibi’s finger was on the trigger.
Fog of war, it's a shame but hardly unusual
I agree, Freefaller it is not unusual.
The minute the exchanges stopped the rest of the hostages were considered gone as well.
Sadly, that may well be true, SP.
an uncomfortable truth for those still holding any hope...
At Munich, all of the hostages were killed during the rescue.
At Entebbe 4 of the hostages were killed along with the IDF leader, Yoni Netanyahu,
Olevashólem
Yes, Palestinians have a long history of kidnapping, it’s one of the few things that they are successful at.
It appears that Hamas intentionally killed 3 hostages, and that Israel accidentally killed 3 more. It seems some IDF soldier got nervous and trigger happy and shot them, even though they were waving a white flag. This soldier(s) will undoubtedly be severely punished.
Of course, if Hamas had not taken hostages in the first place or had released them during the short lived cease fire which they broke, it's not likely any of these hostages would have died.
The punishment that they do to themselves will be worse than any punishment that the IDF could dish out.
Al Jazeera = Hamas Terrorist Mouthpiece Network.
Worst possible outcome, and I know the IDF soldiers involved feel worse than anyone. Hostage extractions are about as difficult as it gets, when it come t9o anything. Difficulty setting 10/+15
They didn't get this one...
Yep, really sad but surprising there hasn’t been more of this considering the difficulty of the mission.
Never forget, why the IDF is there in the first place.