Trump's Executive Orders Laid a Dangerous Trap for Democrats
By: Philip Elliott (Time)
Ignore the talking heads for a moment. Yes, Trump's executive order can legitimately be called a 'stunt'. But that's not the important point.
Trump has definitely told the public and Congress that he wants extended unemployment with at least $400 additional aid. It was necessary to require states to pony up 25 pct because Trump is using disaster relief funds to extend unemployment. Congress can nullify Trump's order by passing legislation.
Trump has definitely told the public and Congress that he wants eviction protections and student loan deferrals (or forgiveness). Congress can nullify Trump's order by passing legislation.
Trump has definitely told the public and Congress he wants tax relief through payroll tax deferrals or holidays. (IMO, that's a political gimmick to pursue a different political agenda). Congress can nullify Trump's order by passing legislation.
Trump's political stunt exerts pressure on Congress to pass legislation. While it is possible to go through a protracted legal challenge to the President's authority, Congress can nullify Trump's orders today by simply passing legislation.
The real political stunt has been Democrats holding the American public hostage to pursue partisan BS. Trump hasn't laid a trap for Democrats; Democrats did this to themselves. Trump's orders break the impasse; get it done. There isn't any need for Democrats to run to the courts; just pass the damned legislation.
S E E D E D C O N T E N T
The Sharpies squeaked as President Donald Trump put his signature on four documents over the weekend promising aid for Americans feeling the economic brunt of the coronavirus pandemic. The orders were ostensibly meant to deliver action after lawmakers on the Hill failed to reach an agreement last week on the terms of the next federal aid package and further talks are on permanent hold. But beyond the toxic fumes, there's still no tangible help on the way for Americans facing evictions, student loans, payroll taxes or even reduced unemployment checks — the four threats that the memos covered. Instead, what Trump signed over the weekend sets in motion a constitutional standoff over federal powers and a political quagmire for Democrats trying to check this President's wanton rebudgeting of taxpayers' dollars.
The President knew exactly what he was doing. The political show was one designed for cameras' flashes, not action. When pushed by reporters at his golf club in New Jersey for details of how the orders will work, Trump couldn't confirm when any of his promises would turn into reality. They weren't designed to. The eviction relief plan was merely an encouragement for landlords and tenants to find a compromise, his student-loans and payroll-tax holidays were merely suspensions of due dates, and the plus-up on unemployment benefits was only an idea that requires states' buy-in, which is not going to happen.
During normal times, Congress decides how much programs like student-loan deferments can have and the Administration spends the cash. These days, Trump is redirecting money as if Congress didn't weigh in at all. For instance, Trump, in his edicts, re-imagines hurricane-relief dollars as pandemic bailout cash.
Theoretically, that leaves Congress primed to challenge the White House, a move that would demand Democrats stand up and say Trump has no power to repurpose taxpayer dollars this way. It's a constitutionally-sound objection, but one that puts Democrats arguing against rescuing struggling Americans. Do Democrats, in an election year, want to be the ones signing onto lawsuits that challenge a President's power to unilaterally re-budget dollars that help the 30-plus-million Americans who have lost their jobs so far? On Sunday, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi called the orders bypassing Congress "absurdly unconstitutional," but dodged the question whether she and fellow Democrats would take Trump to court over them.
Trump has been buoyed by last month's Supreme Court ruling that permits him to retool Pentagon dollars to build his border wall — despite the fact that Congress didn't mean for those dollars to do that. In interviews, Trump has cited that ruling as rationale for near-absolute power to reprogram taxpayer dollars as he sees fit. It is inevitably a course that will send him back to the Supreme Court. His efforts to shift dollars through these orders is a prime example of where Democrats have good cause to check him. But, with fewer than 100 days before Election Day, the ground is plenty shaky. Democrats may end up prevailing in the long run — but their win would mean the pandemic's victims lose out on Trump's promised bounty.
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors
Congress can nullify Trump's orders today without any need to run to the courts. Pass the damned legislation and get it done.
Do Democrats, in an election year, want to be the ones signing onto lawsuits that challenge a President’s power to unilaterally re-budget dollars that help the 30-plus-million Americans who have lost their jobs so far?
The dopey Dems just don't seem to get it....once again.
The bad optics of her stubbornness are very damaging
Why are Democrats negotiating with the White House? That's nothing more than a political stunt to lay blame on Trump for not passing legislation. Democrats arguing that a President doesn't have the authority to authorize expenditures undermines their claimed purpose for negotiating with the White House. Democrats brought the President into the legislative process.
The negotiations that matter are between the House and the Senate. Trump's orders are also telling Senate Republicans what is acceptable to the White House. Republicans can't drag their feet by using Trump as an excuse.
Trump's orders only highlight that Congress isn't doing its job. While Trump's orders may be a trap for Democrats, the orders are also a trap for Republicans. Trump is correctly blaming a do-nothing congress.
My bet would be that the Democrats will bitch about what President Trump has done and complain about how it's all slop and crumbs.. But they will try to pass legislature around what he did so that it doesn't look like they are taking anything away. There will also be no movement on any forgiveness of the postponement of the payroll taxes. They might figure they can get away with that because nothing will change before the election and right after the first of the year when people have to start repaying that tax Washington policy makers can see that it's two years until the next election and hope to the poor memory of the American voter.