Results of the Vote on th CoC

  

Category:  meta

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  2 years ago  •  0 comments

Results of the Vote on th CoC

clear.gif  groupIcon.gif Questions pertaining to the discussion on the updating of the  CoC

Should off topic questions be removed by moderators, without a warning by the author?

Response Count Percent Rank Graph
No leave it as per the current CoC 37 56% 1 No leave it as per the current CoC
Yes if the author flags the comment 28 43% 2 Yes if the author flags the comment
Should long strings of gratuitous cursing be allowed?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
No 48 73% 1 No
Yes 17 26% 2 Yes
Should usage of STFU, FU, and GFTS be forbidden? (This would preclude the usage of the F bomb though).
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 35 53% 1 Yes
No 30 46% 2 No
Should name calling of entire political groups be allowed?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
No 38 58% 1 No
Yes 27 41% 2 Yes
Should creative name calling of political groups be allowed, i.e. Rethuglicans, Libtards, etc.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
No 46 70% 1 No
Yes 19 29% 2 Yes
How should comments mocking an article be treated?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Should never be removed 24 36% 1 Should never be removed
Be removed only if the author flags it 23 35% 2 Be removed only if the author flags it
Be removed if any member flags it 18 27% 3 Be removed if any member flags it
Should death wishing be prohibited when dealing with public figures?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 48 73% 1 Yes
No 17 26% 2 No
You can’t call a member a Nazi, commie, socialist, un-American etc. but you can refer to these terms as part of a discussion.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 56 86% 1 Yes
No 9 13% 2 No
You can use the word \"bigoted\" to a concept or comment (i.e. That statement is very bigoted), but you can’t call a member a \"bigot\", (i.e.You are a bigot or you are bigoted against X)
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Agree 53 81% 1 Agree
Disagree 12 18% 2 Disagree
Phrases meant to denigrate should not be allowed, i.e. \'You and your ilk\"
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 42 64% 1 Yes
No 23 35% 2 No
Seeds that are Op/Eds should be clearly marked in their title.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 55 84% 1 Yes
No 10 15% 2 No
Adding to the impasse rule an “Agree to disagree” call. Unlike impasse, which ceases all discussion, the two parties can still engage but not on that topic.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Agree 54 83% 1 Agree
Disagree 11 16% 2 Disagree

groupIcon.gif Sexual Identity and Religion

You can not condem any faith as a whole, or any group based on their sexual identity.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 44 67% 1 Yes
No 21 32% 2 No
Drilling down, is it OK to say that in the bible homosexuality is a sin?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 56 86% 1 Yes
No 9 13% 2 No
Again drilling down, is it OK for a member to say that they think it\'s a sin?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 63 96% 1 Yes
No 2 3% 2 No
Can a member say that a faith's beliefs are bigoted? (please note you may not say a member is bigoted)
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 54 83% 1 Yes
No 11 16% 2 No
Members are not allowed to proselytize on the site.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 51 78% 1 Yes
No 14 21% 2 No
You can not call a member any term that is inflammatory based on their faith or sexual orientation or use terms regarding a religion or sexual orientation that is derogatory.
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 49 75% 1 Yes
No 16 24% 2 No

groupIcon.gif CoC infractions and Punishment.

Should the number of 4 CoC infractions before suspension be reduced and if so by how much?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes it should be reduced to 3 infractions 22 33% 1 Yes it should be reduced to 3 infractions
No 18 27% 2 No
Yes it should be reduced to 2 infractions 13 20% 3 Yes it should be reduced to 2 infractions
it should not change 12 18% 4 it should not change
Should we keep skirting the CoC?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 43 66% 1 Yes
No 22 33% 2 No
If you voted for keeping skirting, should the number of skirts be reduced?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes reduce to 2 skirtings = 1 CoC infraction 39 60% 1 Yes reduce to 2 skirtings = 1 CoC infraction
No 26 40% 2 No
Should we keep the policy of wiping members CoC violations clean at the end of the month?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
Yes 46 70% 1 Yes
No 19 29% 2 No
How should suspension time be measured?
Response Count Percent Rank Graph
2 days and add 2 days for each additional infraction 37 56% 1 2 days and add 2 days for each additional infraction
2 days and double for each additional infraction 28 43% 2 2 days and double for each additional infraction

https://www.ballotbin.com/members.php?panel=results

*Please note: Question number 1 in  CoC infractions and Punishment mistakenly offered 2 ways of saying no to changing the number of infractions. The total number is the largest, so for now there will be no change to the number of violations. 

I am not taking comments on this vote. This is just for information. The new CoC will be drawn up and presented to the community and will be open for questions. 


Article is Locked

smarty_function_ntUser_is_admin: user_id parameter required
Loading...
Loading...

Who is online





JohnRussell
Save Me Jebus
Just Jim NC TttH
JBB
Kathleen
Trout Giggles


36 visitors