U.S. military stops tracking key metric on Afghan war as situation deteriorates
S E E D E D C O N T E N T
An Afghan man rides on a bicycle past the site of a car bomb attack where U.S soldiers were killed near Bagram air base, Afghanistan April 9, 2019.
REUTERS/Mohammad Ismail/File Photo
The Taliban announced the start of a spring offensive in early April. Even before the announcement, combat had intensified across Afghanistan in recent weeks and hundreds of Afghan troops and civilians have been killed.
The Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) said in a report published late Tuesday night that the U.S. military had told the watchdog it was no longer tracking the level of control or influence the Afghan government and militants had over districts in the country.
The NATO-led Resolute Support (RS) mission in Afghanistan had told SIGAR that the assessments were “of limited decision-making value to the (RS) Commander.”
Colonel David Butler, spokesman for U.S. Forces in Afghanistan, said that while Resolute Support was no longer doing the analyses, the intelligence community did its own classified assessment of districts controlled by the government and Taliban. He did not speculate on whether the intelligence community analyses would continue or not.
“This much is clear: There’s even less information for American taxpayers to gauge whether their investment in Afghanistan is a success, or something else,” John Sopko, the head of SIGAR, told Reuters.
A January report put districts under government control or influence at 53.8 per cent covering 63.5 percent of the population by October 2018, with the rest of the country controlled or contested by the Taliban.
Experts said that the move to stop tracking the key data was worrying because Washington had publicly set a benchmark which would now be difficult to measure.
In November 2017, the top U.S. general in Afghanistan at the time set a goal of driving back Taliban insurgents enough for the government to control at least 80 percent of the country within two years.
“If the military is not going to be tracking that data anymore, that is going to make it a lot more difficult to get a sense as to how strong the Taliban is,” Michael Kugelman, with the Woodrow Wilson Center, said.
“That may well be the military’s intention,” he said.
DIMINISHING ACCOUNTABILITY
Over the past few years, the U.S. military has restricted data on the Afghan war being shared with the public, including the size of the security forces, casualty numbers and the attrition rate for the Afghan National Defense and Security Forces (ANDSF).
In 2018, the U.S. military said a “human error in labeling” caused it to treat as classified information the amount of territory controlled or influenced by the Taliban and the Afghan government.
The rest of the report painted a bleak picture of the security situation in Afghanistan.
Citing numbers from Resolute Support, SIGAR said the monthly average of enemy-initiated attacks increased by 19 percent from November 2018 through January 2019 compared to between August to October 2018.
ANDSF casualties increased by about 31 percent from December through February compared to the same three-month period last year.
“The latest data from the few remaining publicly available measures of the security situation in Afghanistan - enemy-initiated attacks, general ANDSF casualty trends, and security incidents - show that Afghanistan experienced heightened insecurity,” the report said.
So... now we cannot know who's winning. Ha, ha...
but...but...didn't we elect the winningest president who said he could stop the war in the first months of his term?
Like we were winning under Bush or Obama?
The UN nations that were supposed to be supporting the rebuilding effort are gone. The Afghanistan government is weak and corrupt; is propped up by the US military; and their control doesn't extend much beyond the capital. Warlords and the Taliban control the rest.
What should have always been a search and destroy mission for Al Qaeda and the Taliban has turned into another failed venture of US nation building.
We will not win in Afghanistan. Withdraw the troops; and let drones/special forces take care of Al Qaeda and the Taliban where ever possible.
So basically, out of sight, out of mind. Sounds like the administration doesn't want anyone to hear anything about it.
We're going to leave Kabul llike we left Saigon.
After years of blood lost and fortune squandered.
For no purpose.
Maybe we'll be more successful in Venezuela...
huh?
We must have a Forever War somewhere!
When Blackwater's mercenaries are insufficient, we will absolutely have to send in the Marines.
I'm too young to remember much about Vietnam and you probably are, too, but did the gov't pull this garbage there, too?
Yeah I was young. I remember something about a president elect saying he was going to get out of Vietnam, then once elected, doubled down on troops or something.
If I remember correctly back then the press went over there and reported on it. Our press today seems to be mostly quiet on Afghanistan.
What is to know? It has been a doomed venture from the start.
My only problem with Trump is what the hell is taking him so long to get out? Obama promised to get US forces out; but we are now in the third presidency since it started; and we are still there.
There will be no winning in Afghanistan.
The Russians learned that lesson, seems we have not.