╌>

Professor Roth Says “...Guns Aren't the Problem”

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  darren-wolfe  •  12 years ago  •  10 comments

Professor Roth Says “...Guns Aren't the Problem”

4605_discussions.jpg?width=250 During his presentation Why Is The United States The Most Homicidal Nation In The Affluent World? Professor Randy Roth of Ohio State University speaks for an hour about the causes of murder and why the murder rate fluctuates. What are most conspicuous for their absence is that he doesn't mention guns. They only come up during the question and answer period because of an audience question.

Read the rest at http://theinternationallibertarian.blogspot.com/2014/04/professor-roth-says-guns-arent-problem.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

"I am at a complete loss as to why you think passages like this are good for your side."

John, They aren't good for my side. I don't have to agree with everything he says to find value in his work. Listen to his whole presentation. He talks about murder rates for an hour without once mentioning guns. His idea is that the legitimacy & inclusivity of the system are what drive the murder rate. Guns only come up because of an audience question. Then he says "because guns arent the problem." & "So in other words, what I told you was that guns arent the fundamental problem, wed be killing each other with rolling pins because we hate each other, we hate our country." He strangely also lapses into anti-gun mythology that you quoted. He seems to ignore the deterrent effect guns have too, looking at only one side of the equation. Bottom line is, as I point out at the end of the article:

I don't agree with everything Professor Roth says in his presentation but he does knock down the gun rights haters argument that the problem is guns and that eliminating them will make everything great. In fairness, his words don't completely favor gun rights either but they do support the view that guns aren't the cause of the problem. Thank you, Professor Roth.

"Weve had, weve always had, a high level of gun ownership from, say, the colonial period right down into the 1940s. And at times weve been the most violent society in the affluent world, and at times weve been the least homicidal, havent we? So is it just guns?" No, obviously not.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Without a gun in the old man's hand, the murder never would have happened.

You don't know that, John. It would have been harder to accomplish, given his age, but you don't know that he would not have accomplished it nevertheless. He could have run them over with a car.

The situation had been building for a long time, it was not a "flare up."

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Also, one can't use anecdotal evidence to form one's view. That's why I stated I don't agree with everything the professor says. His idea about political instability driving up the murder rate is well researched. At other times he sounds like Brady Bunch propaganda.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

He's right. Guns are not the problem. But no one is ever going to convince the anti-gun crowd they are not, just as no one is ever going to convince the pro-gun crow they are.

This conversation, this debate, is a hamster in a cage, going round and round.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

I ask both of you to explain why so many countries with so many fewer guns per capita have higher murder rates than the US? It is obvious & common sense that the availability of guns isn't the issue. Social dynamics drive the murder rate. Oh, & don't forget that Switzerland with all its guns has a lower murder rate than gun ban UK.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

I didn't sneeze Smile.gif

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

"The army sells a variety of machine guns, submachine guns, anti-tank weapons, anti-aircraft guns, howitzers and cannons. Purchasers of these weapons require an easily obtained cantonal license, and the weapons are registered, In a nation of six million people, there are at least two million guns, including 600,000 fully automatic assault rifles, half a million pistols, and numerous machine guns. Virtually every home has a gun."

I think you're wrong about Switzerland, jtj I notice that you didn't touch the fact that so many countries with so many fewer guns per capita have higher murder rates than the US. For example, my wife's country Guyana. They have strict gun control & few guns yet their murder rate is at least 3x that of the US

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Lunatics kill people and we have way too many of them in America, including on this site.

So you are saying, Randy, that there are killers lurking here on NT? Perhaps you should inform the FBI and Homeland Security, as you appear to have identified them.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago
 
 

Who is online