Principled Nonvoting: The Beginning of Disengaging From the State
[Some of the comments, from both left and right, at The Standing Armies of Yesterday and the Police State Today lead me to think that this article would be useful in explaining why governments, elections, and constitutions don't work. It was originally posted on my blog on September 15, 2010.]
Labor day has come and gone, and there is an election this November. The campaign season is on. The airwaves, the internet, and whats left of the print media are saturated with political ads. All of this leads many Americans to wonder who theyre going to vote for. Quite a few realize that the choice is essentially limited to the Democratic scoundrel or the Republican scoundrel. Regardless, to too many people voting is seen as a patriotic, almost sacred duty. Clichs abound about how our forefathers gave their lives so we can have the right to vote today. A lot of people see voting as a way to control the government and preserve our liberties. "If you dont vote dont complain", they say. In this article, however, I will explain why none of these positive things attributed to voting are true. In fact the very opposite is usually the case.
What should have been clear for generations is made ridiculously obvious after a year and a half of the Obama administration, namely that elections have failed as a means of controlling or changing the government. The almost seamless continuity of policy from the Bush administration to Obamas presidency is undeniable and represents only the victory of the special interests in thwarting the peoples will.
After more than two centuries of elections the system has become quite good at this. In 1870 Lysander Spooner wrote in " NO TREASON, No. VI., THE CONSTITUTION OF NO AUTHORITY. ":
Dupes --- a large class, no doubt --- each of whom, because he is allowed one voice out of millions in deciding what he may do with his own person and his own property, and because he is permitted to have the same voice in robbing, enslaving, and murdering others, that others have in robbing, enslaving, and murdering himself, is stupid enough to imagine that he is a "free man," a "sovereign"; that this is "a free government"; "a government of equal rights," "the best government on earth," and such like absurdities.
Unfortunately, that is the perception, that voting equates to freedom. The reality is that nothing could be further from the truth. The fact that we are allowed to choose our dictators doesnt make us any freer. It merely gives voters the feeling of power and the illusion of control. All the while they are being manipulated into supporting a government that implements policies detrimental to their well being.
What better way is there to get people to follow the law and pay taxes than to convince them that these things are their will? What better way is there to get people to tolerate the governments evils than by convincing them that the situation is temporary and that they can change the government at the next election? What better way is there to get people to respect elected officials than to convince them that they, the people, chose these scoundrels to represent them? (A mandate, its called.) None of these things are true, but the fraud works. Democracy is held to be the best form of government yet devised. The question is best for whom? Certainly not the people.
It does work best for the ruling elites who can hide their evil plans behind a smiling democratic facade. The formula is to give people just enough freedom to feel free but not so much that the government loses control of them. To assure that the people will put up with their laws, antics, and taxes the ruling class must keep the citizens involved. Most will take the easy route and go along, especially when the economy is doing well and they feel prosperous. Thomas Paine warned of this over two centuries ago:
the portion of liberty enjoyed in England is just enough to enslave a country more productively than by despotism, and that as the real object of all despotism is revenue, a government so formed obtains more than it could do either by direct despotism, or in a full state of freedom
Does all this sound far fetched to you? According to a Georgetown University professor of history Carroll Quigley:
The argument that the two parties should represent opposed ideals and policies, one, perhaps, of the Right and the other of the Left, is a foolish idea acceptable only to doctrinaire and academic thinkers. Instead, the two parties should be almost identical, so that the American people can throw the rascals out at any election without leading to any profound or extensive shifts in policy. Then it should be possible to replace it, every four years if necessary, by the other party, which will be none of these things but will still pursue, with new vigor, approximately the same basic policies.
Unfortunately, he thought this is how the system should work. Dr. Quigley was not some fringe radical either. He was one of President Bill Clintons professors and was cited by him as a major influence.
It is past time for people to face the reality of what voting really is, an endorsement of the evils that governments commit. I call on you not to take part in this fraud any more. Withhold your consent! Have the courage to join us in principled nonvoting and commit not to vote ever again. Remember, if you vote dont complain!
Please join and promote our group on Facebook, Vote for Nobody Campaign

When you consider that the Electoral College elects the president regardless of the popular vote it seems sort of a wasted effort in the long run.
And how are the members of the Electoral College selected?
"...how are the members of the Electoral College selected?"
It varies a by state how the delegates to the electoral college are selected. Some by caucus & the others by people voting. Not that it matters, it's all a show to keep people thinking they have a say.
And what is to keep this new movement, "Withholding Consent", from turning into the wolves Jefferson spoke of?
What's to be gained when a populace doesn't vote in elections ?
"And what is to keep this new movement, "Withholding Consent", from turning into the wolves Jefferson spoke of?"
OM, The govt has become "the wolves Jefferson spoke of" despite all the voting going on. (There's even a book picking up on that theme " A Government of Wolves: The Emerging American Police State " by constitutional attorney John W. Whitehead) Voting has failed as a means of controlling the govt. As long as they can force us to fund them the rest is irrelevant. What we need is to eliminate the coercion by putting what have traditionally been govt services on the market. History abounds with examples of this working. Lex Mercatoria is but one example of private law. Education & security to this day are often privately provided. The key here is that any service must be provided by someone or some company that can be voluntarily hired & fired.
"A principled non-vote is fine. As policy, it is irrational, and not principled at all."
RG, It only seems irrational & unprincipled if you assume that we need govt as we know it. If the goal is a stateless society it is the only way to go. For more see my reply to OM
"What's to be gained when a populace doesn't vote in elections ?"
PW, A stateless society. I don't want to keep repeating myself please see my previous comment:
"We might as well be discussing when man colonizes Jupiter, for all this thread has to do with reality.
"This is an urban/suburban nation of 320 million people and he wants to privatize every function and iota of society. Security forces will all be privatized. Whoopee, what fun!"
John, thank you for showing that you have no arguments to present against what I advocate. Surrender accepted.
Speaking of reality did you know that over 200 million people were murdered by govts during the 20th century? It was a govt that committed the Holocaust, it was the Soviet govt that instituted the Gulag system & murdered 10s of millions, It is the communist Chinese govt that holds the record for being the most murderous. The US govt has directly & indirectly killed its share too. It wasn't anarchists who did these things.
It is also govt that stifles economies leading to ruinous poverty. Are you going to defend the govt of Zimbabwe? How about Haiti? A fine job they're doing, aren't they?
Welcome to the real world. If you don't agree with living in a stateless society at least offer a viable alternative.
Badwabbit, if my ideas are so wrong I would think you could do better than insulting sarcasm & name calling. Surrender accepted.
I mean no disrespect, but thank you Captain obvious. I thought that was the point of this article/discussion. However, my point, as was Jefferson's, was that every institution descends into corruption overtime and the founders of this government must remain active or suffer the same fate. How long will it take the new US government, under this principled nonvoting concept take to do the same? Case in point, unions, a great step forward for abused working class heroes, which has been corrupted over time.
For the sake of argument let's just say these stats are close. Feel free to present others. But all that voting amounted to a 64% turnout in 2008, meaning 36% of us already practice what is being preached here. I'm thinking that, if it had been any democrat, besides Obama, the turnout would have been less. Just how much of a non-turnout will bring about a change?
And aspresented in the article, the transition was seamless. Even when the 36 percenters gave a vote of no confidence in both parties, by not voting, at least that is my position. This government has never gain my trust in its dedication to the people of this country, never. Bush, Obama or the next woman are exactly what Ike called, The Military Industrial Complex.
Shame on us all for letting it come to be.
I read it and you're dreaming.
Ads hominems, ad hominems but no rebuttal. Refusing to participate in a bad system isn't surrender. As the physicians say, first do no harm. You can keep deluding yourself that voting & participating in the system do some good. In the mean time I'll keep advocating something that works.
Ah, Badwabbit, how little you know. This idea first evolved in a prestigious economics journal, Journal des Economistes . It was written by the journal's editor Gustave de Molinari. Read & learn The Production of Security
And in 1967 I recollect about exactly the same conversation around a bong with 20 something wanna-be hippie leftist activists. I hope the quality of the dope has improved, 'cause the quality of the dialogue clearly hasn't.'Principled nonvoting' has exactly the same effect as 'non-principled nonvoting': a smaller and smaller group of manipulated knotheads still decide who runs their city, county, state, and the USA... now there's a recipe for social evolution!
Badwabbit,
Remember what Einstein said, "Insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." Keeping on trying to make govt work is exactly that. I've been through this before on the internet, a lot of mockery & dismissal but very few real arguments presented against the stateless society. The few that I've had to deal with are based on mental inertia &/or fear of seeming radical or extremist rather than on facts & reason.