The Standing Armies of Yesterday and the Police State Today
This post is directed mainly to conservative gun rights advocates though all are invited to comment. Too often the very people that think they stand for liberty are the staunchest advocates of the institutions that are destroying it.
I gave this presentation at the Citizens for Liberty meeting on August 20, 2013 near Norristown, Pennsylvania. Below are links to source material so readers can do their own research and come to their own conclusions.
And if we enquire how these unhappy nations have lost that precious jewel liberty...we shall find their miseries...proceed from this, that their necessities or indiscretion have permitted a standing army to be kept amongst them......no nation ever preserved its liberty, that maintained an army otherwise constituted within the seat of their government...
...the Israelites, Athenians, Corinthians, Archaians, Lacedemonians, Thebans, Samnites, and Romans; none of which nations whilst they kept their liberty were ever known to maintain any soldiers in constant pay within their cities...It's the misfortune of all countries, that they sometimes lie under an unhappynecessity to defend themselves by arms against the ambition of theirgovernors, and to fight for what is their own; for if a prince will rule us with arod of iron, and invade our laws and liberties...we...must patiently submit to our bondage, or stand upon our own defense; which if we are enabled to do, we shall never be put upon it...This subject is so self-evident, that I am almost ashamed to prove it: for if look through the world, we shall find in no country, liberty and an army standtogether; so that to know whether a people are free or slaves, it is necessaryonly to ask, whether there is an army kept amongst them?
I will venture to say, that if this Army does not make us Slaves, we are the only People upon Earth in such Circumstances that ever escaped it If this Army does not enslave us, it is barely because we have a virtuous Prince that will not attempt it; and it is a most miserable thing to have no other Security for our Liberty, than the Will of a Man, though the most just Man living: For that is not a free Government where there is a good Prince (for even the most arbitrary Governments have had sometimes a Relaxation of their Miseries) but where it is so constituted, that no one can be a Tyrant if he would. Cicero says, though a Master does not tyrannize, yet it is a lamentable consideration that it is in his Power to do so; and therefore such a Power is to be trusted to none, which if it does not find a Tyrant, commonly makes one; and if not him, to be sure a Successor.
It is certain, that all parts of Europe which are enslaved, have been enslaved by armies; and it is absolutely impossible, that any nation which keeps them amongst themselves can long preserve their liberties; nor can any nation perfectly lose their liberties who are without such guests: And yet, though all men see this, and at times confess it, yet all have joined in their turns, to bring this heavy evil upon themselves and their country.
It is on a supposition that your American governors shall be honest that all the good qualities of this government are founded; but its defective and imperfect construction puts it in their power to perpetrate the worst of mischiefs should they be bad men; and, sir, would not all the world blame our distracted folly in resting our rights upon the contingency of our rulers being good or bad? Show me that age and country where the rights and liberties of the people were placed on the sole chance of their rulers being good men without a consequent loss of liberty! I say that the loss of that dearest privilege has ever followed, with absolute certainty, every such mad attempt.
Did you ever read of any revolution in a nation, brought about by the punishment of those in power, inflicted by those who had no power at all? You read of a riot act in a country which is called one of the freest in the world, where a few neighbors cannot assemble without the risk of being shot by a hired soldiery, the engines of despotism. We may see such an act in America.
A standing army we shall have, also, to execute the execrable commands of tyranny; and how are you to punish them? Will you order them to be punished? Who shall obey these orders?
No discussion of the police state these days is complete without mentioning Radley Balko's just published book Rise of the Warrior Cop: The Militarization of Americas Police Forces . A great article by the author offering a glimpse at what is in the book can be read here .
During the question and answer portion of the night I brought up Edward Bernays' 1928 book Propaganda. I highly recommend reading at least CHAPTER VI PROPAGANDA AND POLITICAL LEADERSHIP ( )

John R, By all means prove that you have nothing intelligent to add to the discussion by substituting mockery for argument. I'm sure you think as little of my way of thinking as I do of yours but we have to respect each other. Please have a real discussion or don't comment.
"Not quite a police state. The last time I talked to one was four years ago, or so."
Lucky you I wish I could say that. The police state isn't just the local guys in uniform. It includes state & federal agencies too. Speaking of which we will soon have to interact with the tax branch of the police state on April 15.
"I like to read the history of ancient civilizations to learn lessons about human nature, not as a guide as to how we should materially conduct 21st century civilization."
We're making progress here & I agree with the above statement. The lesson to be learned is the rest of the quote "none of which nations whilst they kept their liberty were ever known to maintain any soldiers in constant pay within their cities...". We have a standing "army" among us. It's called law enforcement & it is taking our liberties not to mention making us less safe. Not only was there less police abuse before the introduction of police forces in the mid 19th century there was less crime. Another part of the book I quoted above sums it up nicely:
The police are certainly among us.
It may not happen in my lifetime, or in my grandchildren's, but we are headed toward another revolution simply because elected politicians don't believe there can be one in the United States of America. They fail to realize that we are no longer "united."
They have become so adept at keeping us divided so that we can be controlled they have forgot the adage that "united we stand, divided we fall." We have been told we have no national language. We have been told we have no national culture. We have been told we have no national borders. We have been told we have no national pride (i.e., burn the flag, can't wear/fly the flag it will upset "immigrants").
Therefore, we have no nation.
"And when the parties from which we elect are corrupt, their selection of candidates are corrupt, what are our choices? "
RL, great point. I used to be with the Libertarian Party. Then I realized the futility of being part of a 3rd party in what is openly called a 2 party system.
The choice IMHO is to realize that govt as we know it doesn't work. Constitutions & elections don't give people control of the govt nor do they protect the people from the govt. As long as they can force us to pay for their mischiefs they control us. What we need are institutions voluntarily hired & financed to order society.
"At least you acknowledge, if tacitly, that you are an extremist."
Once again you show that you have no arguments to present. That's why the attempt to dismiss. Surrender accepted.
"Quite to the contrary Darren, people who espouse extremist beliefs should and do have the responsibility to own them. Otherwise you are just trying to fool people. Funding private groups to "order" society is about as extreme a position one can take. "Order" society for whose benefit? Libertarianism is now, always has been, and always will be a utopian fantasy, appropriate for discussion forums and talks at little attended meetings, but not having anything to do with reality."
Now I'm trying to fool people? What planet do you live on?
You must know a lot about my views on a stateless society since you feel qualified to counter them. Oh wait, you don't know anything about them, do you? I guess it just doesn't sound right to you so you make some dismissive noise. Once again you dodge & evade. Respectfully present some serious arguments or don't comment.
RL,
AMEN!
I have voted since I was 18, and when elections come and I have to pick out the least offensive candidate and seriously think I may not even bother to vote, that is sad.
When I find that many other people have done the same thing, that is a catastrophe.
@Egil:
When I say what I am about to say, there are always a few snarky comments but I'm going to say it anyway..
In my part of the country we still believe in the things our government has told us we don't have. "We say grace, and we say 'Mam' and if youain't into that then we don't give a damn"
We have a culture here and a hard core pride not only in our own fractured history but in the history of the United States of America. And you are right, we don't start the fight but we do finish it. It's coming. This government keeps ignoring the wishes of the majority of the people who call this country "home," and it evidently has no desire to represent Americans but to reshape the US into whatever convoluted mess the loudest thugs and wealthiest slime bully and pay them to.
"You are the one who needs to present your positions. You are the one who wants to privately fund the ordering of society."
You still haven't presented an argument against what I posted. Let me help you with that:
Darren, I would respectfully say that a stateless society won't work because (a)..........(b)............(c).............
All you need to do is fill in the blanks.
BTW, I have no more or less need to present or defend my positions than anyone else on this website. We are all equals, both those we agree & disagree with. If you don't like that then don't post.
Be honored to have you.