How can a program that is providing 83% of it's participants financial aid be sustainable?
| Total Number of People Who Have Selected a Marketplace Plan as of March 1, 2014 (Thousands of People) | Percentage of Enrollees Who Have Qualified for Assistance | Number of Subsidized Enrollees(Thousands of People) | Subsidized Enrollees as a Percentage of Subsidy-Eligible Individuals | Average Subsidy per Enrollee | Total Premium Subsidies (Millions of dollars) | |
| Nationwide | 4,242 | 83% | 3,472 | 21% | $2,890 | $10,019 |
| Alabama | 55 | 86% | 47 | 18% | $2,880 | $136 |
| Alaska | 7 | 87% | 6 | 11% | $4,120 | $24 |
| Arizona | 58 | 74% | 43 | 14% | $1,940 | $83 |
| Arkansas | 27 | 91% | 25 | 17% | $3,230 | $81 |
| California | 869 | 88% | 765 | 40% | $3,060 | $2,337 |
| Colorado | 83 | 57% | 48 | 19% | $2,440 | $116 |
| Connecticut | 57 | 73% | 42 | 39% | $4,110 | $172 |
| Delaware | 7 | 79% | 5 | 18% | $2,940 | $15 |
| DC | 6 | 13% | 1 | 9% | $1,350 | $1 |
| Florida | 442 | 90% | 398 | 25% | $2,950 | $1,173 |
| Georgia | 139 | 85% | 118 | 18% | $2,870 | $340 |
| Hawaii | 5 | 35% | 2 | 6% | $1,790 | $3 |
| Idaho | 44 | 91% | 40 | 31% | $2,110 | $84 |
| Illinois | 114 | 77% | 88 | 17% | $2,240 | $196 |
| Indiana | 65 | 88% | 57 | 16% | $3,990 | $228 |
| Iowa | 15 | 84% | 13 | 10% | $2,410 | $31 |
| Kansas | 29 | 78% | 23 | 14% | $1,970 | $45 |
| Kentucky | 55 | 70% | 38 | 20% | $2,620 | $101 |
| Louisiana | 46 | 87% | 40 | 12% | $3,610 | $143 |
| Maine | 25 | 90% | 23 | 30% | $4,070 | $93 |
| Maryland | 38 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Massachusetts | 13 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Michigan | 145 | 87% | 126 | 29% | $2,610 | $328 |
| Minnesota | 32 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Mississippi | 26 | 93% | 24 | 12% | $4,370 | $104 |
| Missouri | 74 | 85% | 63 | 16% | $2,820 | $178 |
| Montana | 23 | 86% | 19 | 20% | $2,850 | $55 |
| Nebraska | 26 | 87% | 22 | 18% | $2,540 | $56 |
| Nevada | 29 | 79% | 23 | 15% | $2,620 | $59 |
| New Hampshire | 22 | 74% | 16 | 20% | $3,180 | $51 |
| New Jersey | 74 | 83% | 62 | 15% | $3,470 | $214 |
| New Mexico | 15 | 78% | 12 | 10% | $2,500 | $29 |
| New York | 245 | 72% | 176 | 23% | $2,650 | $466 |
| North Carolina | 201 | 91% | 182 | 27% | $3,320 | $606 |
| North Dakota | 5 | 84% | 4 | 10% | $2,730 | $12 |
| Ohio | 79 | 85% | 67 | 12% | $2,770 | $186 |
| Oklahoma | 33 | 78% | 26 | 10% | $2,230 | $57 |
| Oregon | 39 | 79% | 31 | 16% | $2,210 | $68 |
| Pennsylvania | 160 | 80% | 128 | 18% | $2,460 | $314 |
| Rhode Island | 19 | 88% | 17 | 41% | $3,050 | $51 |
| South Carolina | 56 | 86% | 48 | 14% | $3,110 | $149 |
| South Dakota | 7 | 89% | 6 | 9% | $3,180 | $19 |
| Tennessee | 78 | 79% | 62 | 16% | $2,020 | $124 |
| Texas | 295 | 82% | 242 | 12% | $2,440 | $591 |
| Utah | 40 | 86% | 34 | 17% | $1,780 | $61 |
| Vermont | 24 | 55% | 13 | 50% | $2,930 | $39 |
| Virginia | 103 | 80% | 82 | 16% | $2,690 | $222 |
| Washington | 107 | 81% | 87 | 32% | $3,280 | $285 |
| West Virginia | 11 | 86% | 9 | 13% | $3,170 | $29 |
| Wisconsin | 71 | 90% | 64 | 21% | $3,590 | $231 |
| Wyoming | 7 | 92% | 6 | 13% | $4,980 http://kff.org/report-section/how-much-financial-assistance-table-8569/ |

Well I keep seeing ACA supporters posting articles on how the enrollment numbers prove ACA is a fantastic success story. But every time I ask them "how is a program that is supplying 83% and up of it's participants financial assistance sustainable?" I never get an answer. What gives?
I really do wish someone would come back to me and say - "Look, California's numbers are leading the nation." Of course they are dilbert - California has publicly written and stated the all members of the illegal alien world can apply and they will be accepted - with California paying the Subsidies.
Gee - what's gonna happen when this goes bust??? Is Jerry gonna give up on his little choo-choo????
....and their percentage of those getting financial assistance is above the national average too....go figure.
I talked with two people yesterday who signed up within last 3 days who aren't paying anything. One of them took the Bronze Plan at 60/40 and had a $20,000 income from rental property. Without subsidies the silver plan would have cost him $9,100 and the Bronze would have been a couple thousand less, but they don't have to pay anything.
On Colorado public radio today they reported they needed 18 to 34 year olds to make up 40 percent of the enrollees and they only got 20 percent in that age bracket. Most of the news I've been hearing today indicates Obamacare is a failure.
I would appreciate seeing that public statement because
The Tea Party has put out a fraudulent account (the apparent origin of your comment, 1atwarrior) even improperly using the healthcare.gov logo!
...
Go to the above link, start at the top of the page then scroll all the way to the bottom!
Now go to the link below and see if illegals are actually eligible!
UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANTS
No federal coverage.
Regardless of whether or not we are paying for illegals, I still don't see how this healthcare plan is sustainable when 83% of the people on it can't afford it, and even the people who support it can't seem to answer that question. Care to take a stab at it?
Let's be clear; we're talking two separate issues -- one an intentional misrepresentation which I have corrected.
As for the sustainability of the ACA, yeah, I'll take a stab!
Can I prove it will play out this way? No more than you can prove it won't.
We will both have to wait and see.
In the meantime, many human beings who never had health insurance, will have -- and some will live rather than die as a result.
Fair enough stab?
Looks like NPR needs to update their copy/paste articles to make them current.
CBO says Obamacare to cost $2 trillion over next decade, cut employment by 2.5 million
FEBRUARY 4, 2014
President Obama's health care law will cost slightly more than $2 trillion over the next decade, according to a new report from the Congressional Budget Office .
The CBO report also said the health care law will distort the economic incentives for individuals to work and thus the nation will lose the equivalent of 2.5 million full-time jobs by 2024.
When Obama sold the health care law to Congress in 2009, he said it would cost " around $900 billion ," but that was only because the major provisions were delayed until 2014. Now that they have been implemented, the cost of expanding Medicaid and subsidizing individuals to purchase insurance on the exchanges will be just over $2 trillion from 2015 to 2024, CBO said.
Sign Up for the Politics Today newsletter!
The health care law also includes taxes and cuts to Medicare that previous CBO estimates have said would more than offset the costs, though the new report doesn't include a full deficit analysis incorporating these offsets.
According to the report, 6 million individuals will obtain insurance through the exchanges in 2014, which is down slightly from the CBO's earlier 7 million estimate, but still much more optimistic than would have been expected last fall, when technical problems plagued the rollout of the law.
The CBO also said that the "risk corridors" program which has been billed as a "bailout" for insurers would actually generate a net savings of $8 billion from 2014 through 2016, though it didn't give a year by year breakdown and cautioned that there were "many uncertainties" surrounding the CBO estimate due to the limited government experience with such programs.
On the employment front , CBO said, "The reduction in CBO's projections of hours worked represents a decline in the number of full-time-equivalent workers of about 2.0 million in 2017, rising to about 2.5 million in 2024."
CBO wrote that, "For some people, the availability of exchange subsidies under the ACA will reduce incentives to work."
CBO cautioned that this estimate, too, was subject to "substantial uncertainty."
LInk
You comment comes from The Washington Examiner.
And let's get passed the tactic of attacking the posting of information to back a position. In credible venues, it's referred to as "corroborative testimony/evidence". If you can rebut what is posted, go for it -- but to attack the very posting/pasting of information merely begs the questions it asks or answers.
Some people can pull information out of their assess; I prefer to quote sources and invite those who disagree to post rebuttals (from places other than you know).
CBO Report Blows Away GOP ACA Lies
February 4, 2014
And
And
Four health-care takeaways from the Congressional Budget Office report
Well you got me A Mac. Obamacare, it looks like with 87% of the people receiving subsidies or whatever the percentage is will just work out fine.
Now that the government isn't going to suffer, who is going to pay those premiums for them? They didn't say anything about how much more the middle class is going to be taxed, did they?
Tell me how Obama can say your premium is going down by $2500 and now we know that was a lie and he knew it at the time. Does that not have some effect?
I guess by the CBO's calculation the cost to the paying customer isn't considered in their calculations.
By the way...
Crooks and Liars
Crooks and Liars is a left-leaning American blog founded by John Amato. Journalist Susan Madrak is the managing editor. Along with John Amato, frequent contributors include Nicole Belle, Logan Murphy, Mike Finnigan , David Neiwert , SilentPatriot, Fran Langum [ 1 ] [ 2 ] Nonny Mouse, [ 3 ] Kenneth Quinnell, [ 4 ] and Howie Klein.
Along with a variety of clips from television news media, the site frequently features clips from cable programs such as The Daily Show with Jon Stewart , The Colbert Report , Hardball with Chris Matthews , The Rachel Maddow Show (TV series) , and Countdown with Keith Olbermann .
David Neiwert
David Neiwert is a Seattle -based freelance journalist and blogger . He received the National Press Club Award for Distinguished Online Journalism in 2000 for a domestic terrorism series he produced for MSNBC.com . [ 1 ]
Neiwert was raised in Idaho Falls, Idaho , and attended the University of Idaho , where he obtained his B.A. in English (1984), as well as the University of Montana (198788), where he studied creative writing. He worked at newspapers around the Pacific Northwest from 19781996, notably in Idaho (at Sandpoint, Blackfoot, Lewiston, Moscow, and Twin Falls); Missoula, Montana; and western Washington (Kent, Bellevue, and Seattle). He went to work at MSNBC.com in 1996 as a writer-producer, and continued there through late 2000. Since then, he has focused on writing books and producing his blog Orcinus , which tends to report on the crossover between the mainstream and the far right. The blog won early recognition in the liberal blogosphere in the form of consecutive Koufax Awards for Best Series in 2003 and 2004. [ citation needed ] The Northwest Progressive Institute named its annual awards to the region's best liberal bloggers after Neiwert. [ 2 ] He also writes for the political blog Crooks And Liars
They seem to have an unbiased publication, don't you think?
I guess if you don't consider the cost to the middle class in your calculations it really will work out fine.
So we now have one version from each side of the political spectrum. My version explained from where and how the costs will be sustained. That's quite a different approach from stating or implying that the ACA can't be sustained and leaving it at that.
The actual answer is we'll know when we know and in the meantime, people who might otherwise have died for lack of health insurance might not die.
I'd say such a possible outcome is worth the gamble; your guys say it won't work without proposing a specific alternative. Anyone can sit on the sidelines and take potshots.
OK , here ya go :
Yes Petey and that's only through March 1, 2014. There are 4,242 thousand total people enrolled at that time which is 4,242,000.
There are 3,472 thousand people receiving subsidies at the time which is 3,472,000.
The average subsidy for each one of these people is $2,890.
There are suppose to be approximately twice that many enrolled now. If the percentages stay the same these figures below should be twice as high.
So.....
3,472,000 (number of people receiving subsidies as of 3/1.)
times
$2,890 (average subsidy per person as of 3/1)
is equal to...
10,034,08,0000 (Total cost of subsidies to those who are paying the full premium or 10.03408 billion dollars) And that is approximately half the number they say they have now.
So I don't guess it is not going to hurt the government like the CBO says. The people paying the full premium just got a 10 billion tax increase March 1, 2014.
Now granted everyone can't pay the full premium, that is true. I would like to see preexisting conditions handled in some manner. I don't want to see people lose everything they've worked or all their lives.
But the person making $46,000 a year is going to share the cost of a $10 billion tax increase just on the ones enrolled by 3/1 for this year along. I can see why the CBO is saying the cost is not going to bother the government. It's us who are getting the screws.
Now how many people are going to be covered under this plan?
All but about 30 million, basically the same number as before this plan was passed.
The only difference is we are going to be taxed out of this world.
Remember Obama saying it is not a tax so many times. Well you know when they went to the Supreme, guess what his attorneys argued? They argued it is a tax.
So he lied to us, knowingly, and then when it got to the Supreme court the truth came out, but no one seems to care or even understand that.
He lied to us telling us we could keep our same doctors and our premiums were going down, what was it, $2,500 per family. I guess he was talking to those who will not have to pay anything, which evidently are quite a few on here.
I don't care if it is the CBO or God himself you'll never convince me when a person 63 increases his/her income from $35,000 to $46,000 and only gets to put around $2,500 of it in his/her pocket because they will have to pay an additional $5,000 in premium and another $2,740 in Federal Taxes plus approx another $700 in state taxes what do you have left.
$11,000 minus $5,000 minus $2,760 minus $700 is $2,540 to keep. So what are the taxes on that $11,000? It is 76.9%.
This medicaid expansion is the worse thing we could do for this country in my opinion. It is a motivation to not work. Even a person who did work even at minimum wages would qualify for free Obamacare. But why work when you can get it all free and not have to work?
Why try to make that extra $11,000 if you are going to only be able to keep around $2,500 of it. That's real motivation to improve oneself, isn't it? I figured it from the Federal tax tables and it is 24.7%.
Tell me it isn't anything more than income redistribution as the author of it said it was.
So by the end of March 2014 the American people paying to full premium have just inherited a $20 billion dollar tax bill by the end of March. And we're just getting started.
But don't feel sorry for the rich people. They will continue to get the best of care, paid right out of their pockets.
Thanks Six . That seems to be a pretty solid accounting of the subsidy totals . I haven't encountered any errors in your results . I find it hard to argue with the possibility of severe red ink from instituting the program and that might even get worse in the future .
I already explained how ACA will be paid for including the taxation. I also corrected the misinformation about illegal immigrants and gave the link to the Tea Party misinformation website that uses the healthcare.gov logo to start the deception ball rolling.
Again
The health care legislation signed into law in March 2010 is large in its scope - its coverage provisions will cost $800 billion over the next decade. This is paid for $500 billion in cuts elsewhere, as well as $400 billion in new taxes. This calculator shows how these new taxes affect you, and explains how they work.
But the authors of the Affordable Care Act didn't want the subsidies to become a drain on the Treasury and add to the deficits. So they included provisions designed to offset the cost of the subsidies.
MIT , who helped develop the law, says about half the costs are offset by projected savings in Medicare payments to insurers and hospitals. Another quarter is offset by added taxes on medical-device makers and drug companies.
"The other source of revenue is a tax increase on the wealthiest Americans," he says. "Those families with incomes above $250,000 a year will now have to pay more in Medicare payroll taxes."
Those provisions actually make the bill a net positive for the federal budget, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. By the CBO's accounting, Obamacare will produce a surplus. Gruber says the law will "actually lower the deficit by about $100 billion over the next decade and by $1 trillion in the decade after."
Yes I think we will see, but I doubt we will have to wait long.
So far they have no where near the participation of young healthy adults they need to keep this program afloat.(off by about half)I also believe the number of people who need assistance aremuch higher thanwhat they had planned for. That figure in the last column is MILLIONS of dollars.... 10,019 MILLION. That is roughly 10 Billion in subsidies alone, and I think we are still a far cry from full enrollment. This is a very bad sign IMO.
The other problem with the 500 billion in cuts figure is thatmost of itcomes from reducing payments to hospitalsand Medicare advantage payments for Medicare services. How do you think that will affect standards of care?
Disagree; it comes from taking back and mitigating overcharges and fraudulent charges to Medicare orchestrated by folks like the current Governor of Florida.
Florida voters gave gubernatorial candidate Rick Scott the nod of approval in the November 2, 2010 elections. However, Scott who beat Alex Sink in the Florida Governors race, admitted to 14 counts of Medicare fraud and paid the federal government more than $600 million dollars in fines for his fraudulent billing practices.
American Family Care to pay Medicare $1m in overcharges
Posted: Mar 18, 2014 4:44 PM EDT Updated: Mar 19, 2014 11:06 AM EDT
The thing that worries me is that the 800 billion numbers just don't add up and I am not the only one that believes this. Current enrollment numbers don't support it, I am talking about overall numbers not just the healthy which is an even bigger problem.
h ttp://thefederalist.com/2014/02/11/the-cbo-score-of-the-obamacare-risk-corridor-bailout-makes-no-sense/
I also have a bit of a problem with this, sure there are 6 million or whatever who signed up, but the INCREASE in those insured is surprisingly small:
This less than 2% drop illustrates most enrollees signed up because they lost their old insurance. This is more of a insurance switch than the vast expanse many would lead us to believe.
And in this explanation A Mac, you completely disregarded this comment, completely. Except you did use one thing out of it, the 30 million the CBO say will still be without insurance.
It seems that crowing the Administrations plan constitutes proof regardless of all the evidence provided to the contrary.
...
h ttp://thefederalist.com/2014/02/11/the-cbo-score-of-the-obamacare-r...
...
Again I will mention that I think it is ridiculous that people are crowing about all the people who didn't have insurance that now have it when the uninsured figure has dropped less than 2%
We disagree on the outcome but we don't know.
Regarding,
To you that's a politically motivated number; to the MILLIONS OF HUMAN BEINGS WHO WILL NOW HAVE HEALTH INSURANCE FOR THE FIRST TIME, it could be a life saver literally!
Get a soul.
Below is how "proof" is portrayed by the right wing lie machine; at least Fox et al recognize the ignorance of those who get their "news" from such sources.
Is 6,000,000 less than 50% of 7,600,000. That's the way Fox is selling it to its audience!
I admit it is good almost 2% of people who did not have insurance now do, I just hope they can keep it, and by the numbers, that does not look likely.