Startling Rift on Supreme Court Springs From Error by Kagan On Text of Obamacare Law By BETSY McCAUGHEY, Special to the Sun | March 29, 2014
A startling rift appeared Tuesday on the Supreme Court as the three female Justices came out swinging like Brunnhildes women warriors for what they erroneously labeled an entitlement to employer-provided contraceptives and morning-after pills.
The Justices were hearing oral arguments in Sebelius v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. , a case hyped by the Democratic Party as a test for womens rights. Justices Kagan, Ginsberg, and Sotomayor sprang on Hobby Lobbys attorney , interrupting his every sentence and pummeling him with questions taken right out of the Democratic Partys war on women playbook.
That playbook was laid out in a brief that had been filed by 19 senators and 91 members of the House, all Democrats , supporting the Obama administrations legal war against Hobby Lobby, a chain of craft stores that provides health insurance to all employees but refuses to cover morning-after pills such as Plan B and Ella. The owners, the Green family, try to run their business according to Biblical principles, including closing on Sunday, foregoing hauling beer even when their trucks have to run empty, and not providing abortion drugs.
Senator Murray claimed that Whats at stake in this case before the Supreme Court is whether a CEOs personal beliefs can trump a womans access to free or low-cost contraception under the Affordable Care Act.
Nonsense. Not one word in the Affordable Care Act guarantees health plans will cover birth control products. There is no right. President Obama and his Secretary of Health and Human Services added that requirement by regulation. Women have a constitutionally protected right to use birth control, but nothing guarantees that they can get it from an employer.
It was shocking to hear Justice Kagan make the same spurious claim that women are entitled to employer provided contraceptives during oral argument: Congress has made a judgment and Congress has given a statutory entitlement and that entitlement is to women and includes contraceptive coverage. Wrong, Justice Kagan. Did you also forego reading the law, like most members of Congress?
The distinction between a regulation and a law is no small matter. As Hobby Lobbys lawyer stressed in his closing statement, a statute, in this case Congresss Religious Freedom Restoration Act, trumps a regulation.
Congress passed the Religious Freedom Restoration Act in 1993 expressly to shield believers such as the Green family from any government requirements that would impinge on their ability to practice their faith.
Justice Kagan showed little patience for that concept, and asked whether a victory for Hobby Lobby would invite employers to object to other treatments, such as blood transfusions and vaccines.
So one religious group could opt of out this and another religious group could opt out of that and everything would be piecemeal and nothing would be uniform. Correct, Justice Kagan. Her vision of a uniform society where all are forced to put aside their diverse beliefs and march in lockstep with the governments mandates, sucked the oxygen out of the courtroom.
What a contrast to the six male Justices, who, despite their ideological differences, searched for a way to accommodate the administrations goal without injuring the Greens and other employers spiritually opposed to abortion drugs. These justices called attention to the fact that these drugs are not expensive. Perhaps the government could step in and pay for them. Poor women already get help with birth-control products through Medicaid federal community health plans and Planned Parenthood.
Justice Kennedy, often regarded as the Courts swing vote, asked the Obama administrations lawyer: Under your view, a profit corporation could be forced in principle to pay for abortions? The lawyer replied, but there is no law like that on the books. Justice Roberts shot back, Isnt that what we are talking about ?
Later, Justices Samuel Alito and Stephen Breyer asked what would happen if Congress passed a law similar to a recent Danish enactment that bars slaughtering animals while they are conscious. Would for-profit butcher shops run by Jews or Muslims be allowed exemptions? The three women justices were disinclined to exempt for-profit companies. Not so, the six men.
Look for a likely 6-3 ruling that if you like your god, you can keep your god, even if you also have to make a living.
http://www.nysun.com/national/startling-rift-on-supreme-court-brsprings-from/88646/
Tags
Who is online
85 visitors

Ehh maybe . This is all legalese to me . What does that even mean ?
What it basically boils down to is whose name is in that little black book.
I'm assuming this has nothing to do with dating ...
Statutes set up the requirement for a regulation - hence the statute is the law, the regulation is how to implement the law.
But, Kegan is correct - "whether a victory for Hobby Lobby would invite employers to object to other treatments, such as blood transfusions and vaccines."
What if an employer is a Jehovah's Witness and, based on his religious beliefs, denies his employees cancer treatment coverage or blood transfusions, etc. ?
Where does it end? Let me make it personal -- you have a young child who needs a bone marrow transplant. Your employer refuses to provide health insurance that covers such things and does so based on his religious beliefs.
As for the author of the seeded article
And yes, I posted backup information objections? no problem just post counter information.
FYI: Doing so is a protocol employed is many venues/forums where simply asserting a position as "fact" doesn't cut it.
Indeed, I could.
Could you respond specifically to the points I made and the questions I asked instead of avoiding them with your question?
If you not only could, but, if you would, we could have an actual discussion.
Wouldn't that be refreshing?
The parade of horribles argument doesn't fly in a RFRA case. Every person or company seeking its protection is weighed on its own merits. The governmental interest in ensuring free access to birth control which is already available over the counter at low costs is not the same as its interest in protecting access to cancer treatment or blood transfusions, which are not.
To compare the two situations is to misstate how the Court evaluates religious freedom claims.
Just answer the questions.
Companies are not people nor are they religions.
So-called "birth-control/contraceptives" are not necessarily prescribed for that purpose; they are often prescribed to prevent endometriosis; who the f' is the employer to determine how an individual employees is using her prescription?
Further
Incorrect! A BAD PRECEDENT COULD COST LIVES IN THE EVENT OF SUBSEQUENT LITIGATIONS ON A MEDICAL-CONDITION-BY-MEDICAL-CONDITION BASIS.
I just love how religious folk decide what are the proper beliefs for everyone.
Which religion's freedom has the right to impinge on that of another?
Top Law Professors: Arizona Religious Freedom Bill Has Been 'Egregiously Misrepresented'
The law does not say that businesses can discriminate for religious reasons.
...
And
SEC. 3. FREE EXERCISE OF RELIGION PROTECTED.
In General
Exception
The SCOTUS has already ruled on the ACA.
It would be even more refreshing if some herein would proceed as if they knew enough to participate without first being educated to grade-level qualification status.
You still haven't answered the questions.
Except for the gender-discrimination part
Otherwise, air-tight solution.
"Equitable" is admirable except that by definition it requires being "fair and impartial" -- if you're gonna' fire all the female employees you'll have get the males, transgenders, heterosexual Filipino dwarfs and more.
Slippery slope, dude!
Actually, that's the beginning of the actual solution to health care in America.
Take health insurance off the backs of employers
Institute Universal Single Payer and fuck the Health-Care/Insurance for-Profit industries that suck up 17% of the economy and make living or dying a commodity.
Conservative legislators don't want this for obvious reasons; their anti-trust-proof-owners-Insurance-companies would be out of the election-contribution picture!
And the dumb-ass liberal legislators would have to have the political balls to suck it up and go for it!
Imagine if businesses could do business without this albatross and Americans could pay lower premiums as with Medicare.
It would be more rewarding if you could have an actual discussion without your usual ad hominem-avoid-the-issue-because-you-can't-mount-a-viable-rebuttal crap.
But not causing you to cease making weak ass excuses to conceal your inability to exchange ideas at this level.
Not exactly;
Hi Mac,
Glad you're back even though you are up to your old ad hominem attacks.
It ends when SCOTUS says it ends. RFRA allows a lot of leeway and Obama is trying to foreclose it as much as possible.
We shall see in June.
Robert G. said, and I quote
To which I can only respond
Imagine if you possessed any.
Would you at last care to answer my questions which actually deal with the discussion, or, would you care to go on as usual?
Unfortunately too many justices put their politics above the law.
Other than my usual back-and-forth with Robert G and giving the specifics regarding sources, I challenge you to cite any ad hominem attacks.
Perhaps you should read the exceptions in the law. Further, the SCOTUS made its original ruling on the ACA with full awareness of the Religious Freedom law.
I'll be waiting for you to specifically cite any ad hominem attack I initiated.
Thanks for the detailed explanation [in English !] . They never taught that in high school civics ...
Why should it end ? If employers would be required to indicate to prospective employees where they differ from universal coverage due to religious grounds this system could be one which gives "fair warning " to prospective employees .