╌>

Censorship Is Free Speech, US Judge Rules

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  13 comments

Censorship Is Free Speech, US Judge Rules

The censorship of Chinese search engine Baidu Baidu is simply the exercise of free speech, a Manhattan judge has ruled.

US District Judge Jesse Furman was hearing a case brought by pro-democracy activists in May 2011. They complained that Baidus search algorithms illegally removed political information from search results, violating their civil rights, and asked for $16 million in damages.

The judge dismissed the case on rather surprising grounds.
The First Amendment protects Baidus right to advocate for systems of government other than democracy (in China or elsewhere) just as surely as it protects plaintiffs rights to advocate for democracy, he wrote.

His reasoning is that Baidu is operating in the manner of a newspaper, and has a right to editorial control. If it wants to ban posts on the topic freedom of speech which it does its entitled to on the grounds of free speech.

And the evidence for the fact that it acts like a newspaper in making editorial judgements? Why, the fact that it chooses not to include such topics.

Plaintiffs do not and, in light of their own allegations, cannot make any argument that Baidu is merely an infrastructure or platform that delivers content in a neutral way, says the judge.

The plaintiffs are planning to appeal.

Quite apart from tying ones brain up in knots, the decision has implications for other search engines: something the judge acknowledges.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/emmawoollacott/2014/03/28/censorship-is-free-speech-us-judge-rules/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Very Interesting!

I am sure this case will work its way to the 9 Wise Ones in Washington

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Banning free speech is an exercise in free speech?

Well, we are in America, after all, where orange is actually black...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Ultimately the users of search engines have the final say based on their choice of which ones they use . However , the Chinese government restricts what is available to their populace .

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Petey

You cut exactly to the point

If people do not like how the search engine works, they may choose to use another one

Thanks

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Robert G

What is the difference between the search filtering and how a US newspaper, like the NY Times, decides what should be on the front page, and on what is included and what is excluded?

Absolutely nothing!!

Thanks for clearly illustrating that this is really a non-issue and an example of frivolous litigation

Or perception of significance

And that makes this (non)issue even clearer.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

scremminmimi

The search engine is a tool and like any other tool one might own, borrow or use if the tool does not perform an action in the manner that we like we simply choose another tool. We do not sue craftsman because a wrench they offer for sale does not work as we think it should.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Robert G

Totally understand

The point you made is a good one and as you say there is no way the government can or should control the content of this web site, at least they are open about the filtering methods that are being used.

The lunacy in my view is that someone (government or private citizen) would consider suing or anything other than not using the search engine

Appreciate the feedback and perspective

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

if you use Jay Carney as your search engine, take the results with a grain of salt.

Excellent point

If the government were sued every time Mr. Carney gave a "filtered" response the courts would be in business 24/7

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

at some point they thought better of it. To their delayed credit. I don't know if they are available to the Chinese anymore.

Google pulled out of China after they were attacked by Chinese hackers [possibly from the govt ?] .They are not reachable by people in mainland China anymore ... not sure about Hong Kong .

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I thought the lawsuit was frivolous which was why I made my comment. After all, China is going to control whatever they feel they have to and I couldn't see how filing a suit in the US was going to benefit anyone even if they had won. Who was going to enforce it?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

I read this notion elsewhere a few weeks ago, and couldn't find in my own mind how removing something was the same thing as saying something; but putting it into the context of editorial practices - 'that' does make sense. As usual, if we don't interpret in the right context, we're going to make a mistake. :)

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

We may not trust our government, but do you trust Russia, China or any government more than our government. I feel at least we have a chance here to pull the reins in, but giving the ability to other governments to make decisions for us is a disaster. But it seems we're in the habit of giving up that right, even though we may have to fight for it these days.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

SIxpick

I agree in principle, but a question for you

Shouldn't the Chinese (or the U.S.) regulate their own businesses (search engines) as they see fit?

 
 

Who is online



85 visitors