Are Infrastructure Needs Truly Urgent?
After a gas explosion in East Harlem killed at least eight people on Wednesday, New Yorkers were shocked to learn that some gas mains in the area, and probably elsewhere, are 127 years old. While its unclear what caused the blast or whether the main was involved, news that such vital equipment dates to the first Cleveland administration has raised alarm about the state of United States infrastructure and renewed concern that more needs to be done.
Does the nation need to allocate resources more urgently to repairing and replacing transmission lines, roads, bridges, etc., or are these concerns exaggerated?
that such vital equipment dates to the first Cleveland administration has raised alarm about the state of United States infrastructure and renewed concern that more needs to be done.
Does the nation need to allocate resources more urgently to repairing and replacing transmission lines, roads, bridges, etc., or are these concerns exaggerated?
Jonathan Bowles, Center for an Urban Future
What we found out after the blast should remind officials around the nation that much of America's infrastructure is well past its prime.Chris Edwards, Cato Institute |
The problem with infrastructure spending is not the amount but its efficiency. Much of it gets misallocated by politics, and mismanagement.Hope Cohen, The Battery Conservancy
We should incorporate new materials and address new environmental considerations, despite regulatory hurdles and financing difficulties.Rick Geddes, Cornell University
Innovations enhance the resilience of renovated infrastructure, and financial sanctions can ensure that contractors keep their projects in shape.
Tags
Who is online
90 visitors

It is hard for a reasonable person to dispute the fact that the nations infrastructure is in need of repair and replacement; the how it is paid for, who leads the effort and when it begins are more complex questions that will require joint efforts between the government and the private sector as well as cooperative action between the political parties.
One side being right and one side being wrong is doing no good for either side or the country and is certainly getting nothing done.
Ay ideas on things that might be agreeable to everyone and could at least get the process started?
Perhaps then we should elect some new public servants,
Regardless of how urgent it is, the process will be very long and difficult. The problem I see is the lack of urgency in dealing with the issues as they arise. There are reports that the smell of gas was being reported 5 days in advance of the explosion in NY.
I feel that if these reports were taken more seriously then problems could be identified and corrected before buildings blow up and fall down or before bridges loaded with cars fall into the rivers beneath them.
In almost all of the cases where tragedy has struck, officials knew ahead of time that there was a problem.
For the record I work in the bridge rehab industry. For anyone to claim that the problem is being ignored is ridiculous. Fabrication shops and contractors are working at full capacity right now and have been for several years. There are plenty of job openings in the field. Finding qualified candidates is the real problem.
Dan
Good points
You focus mainly on the short term solutions to critical failure points but the long term repair and replace of infrastructure is what we have to come to grips with and soon
Thanks for the perspective
Robert
Just for one second sit back and imagine how many thousands of miles of gas, water, and sewer lines run beneath the streets in NYC alone. It will be impossible to just replace them. You're basically left with an inspect and repair situation that is currently happening anyways.
My point is that we are not just going to dig up all the old infrastructure and replace it. Technology will improve the quality and lifespan of newly installed lines but the process of replacing the old lines is going to take decades. That's why it's critical that inspection reports and the reports from regular people are taken very seriously.
Without more details on where exactly this overaging exists it is difficult to grasp the big picture . Not much effort or expense is put out for certain areas . For example , the levees in New Orleans ... OTOH there have been bridge failures in the midwest ... probably other regions too .
Of course it will take decades and it will be finished sooner than later only if we start doing it on a grand scale sooner rather than later
That is good to know
Sounds like more skilled trades positions going wanting for lack of qualified candidates
Another argument for trade and technical schools
Petey
Good point
Hal
That suggestion (and not a bad one) sort of circles back to a point I made earlier in the thread about the need to elect more responsible public servants.
Otherwise, demanding does nothing but cause sore throats
Appreciate the perspective
FEMA has issued a report (don't have a copy) regarding the dismal condition of our infrastructure and, as you stated, it will take a long time and a lot of money to do the upgrades.
Used to work in a Ductile Iron Foundry making pipe for water, gas and sewer infrastructure. We could "guarantee" that, under normal operating conditions, our pipe would last for up to 75 and in some cases 100 years before replacement. BUT - we strongly empathized "replacement", not repair.
1stwarrior
A lot of things I have read also highlight that the need to replace is as large or larger than the need to repair which makes getting started on a process that will simply be ongoing is of paramount importance.
appreciate the info and perspective
Some of us have mentioned several times of NT about the Civilian Conservation Corps that was active during the World War and how effective it was in putting young men to work and in helping to shore up areas of infrastructure in the country; specifically the national parks.
Kavika posted a very informative comment about the involvement of Native Americans in the program and how helpful it was to them in terms of employment and to the improvements to the environment.
We now have hordes of professional people available for work on infrastructure... engineers, contractors, welders, brick layers, carpenters, electricians... all saying they can't find work.
Restart the CCC, from the inner cities to the reservations.
How are you fixed for meat ?
To the question, absolutely. To one side that one need not look further than any city or town road (in many to most areas), take a peek underneath an overpass and note the flaking rust on some of the beams and the exposed rebar.
Point being that much of our infrastructure is in state of great disrepair. Not that I am for blowing up the deficit further, but now is the time while money remains cheap to invest in this area as there are other benefits to this.
In the course of improving our infrastructure we are also addressing another major problem, we are creating jobs and those people will pour their dollars back into the economy. For me it seems a common sense solution, but that's me.
Agreed ...
That's the problem with government in all things... being reactive instead of proactive. But in the case of our infrastructure, they are going to keep putting things off until a dam breaks or a major bridge collapses and the loss of life will more than outweigh what the cost of preventive repair would have been.
When it happens, whichever state it happens in, the political cost will be so massive the unlucky politician left holding the bag will never recover his/her political capital.
Spot on, mimi...
The CCC actually ran from 1933 to '42-- it was a significant part of the 'New Deal' that pulled America out of the Great Depression. For the most part, the CCC employed unskilled or marginally-skilled low-income men, who thereby learned marketable skills. (Hardly anybody ever mentions that the CCC siphoned hundreds of thousands of unemployed young men out of urban areas, reducing the potential for rioting by the poor.)
The only 'drawback' is that the CCC worked projects only on undeveloped/ underdeveloped land owned by federal, state or local government-- primarily federal & state parks, recreation areas, etc. CCC workers were never in competition with private-enterprise or doing work that displaced (or replaced) 'business employees'.
Politicoes today probably don't have the cojones to deal with reviving the CCC, however; even though bridges, dams & highways are 'government property' for the most part, there'd be screams of outrage. Nowadays, it would instantly be labelled as 'socialism', 'vote-buying handouts' and of course, undermining private enterprise. The fact that a new CCC would make sense, actually do some good with our tax dollars, and benefitthe entire nation for at least the next 30 or 40 years... well, that doesn't count.
scremminmimi
Good points that are hard to argue with when considering the current state of politics and governing in the country
In my view. we need to change who is making those governing decisions or at the very least influence those currently in office to change the approach to infrastructure issues
scremminimimi
Totally agree with a government works effort (or cooperative with the private sector) that puts people to work getting this infrastructure done
A lot of jobs would require skilled tradesmen an technicians but there would be a lot of hard work to do for the semi or unskilled labor force
Not sure how many would rush to those jobs but it is a good idea
swami
Good points
If this was a pure government effort there would surely be cries from the left (unions) and from the right (private industry) but there must be a way through that controversy if we are to fix the problem.
Roral
I too live in the country, but my view and my concern is not limited to the acreage around me but extends to the whole country
Good point
Perhaps the money being used to buy treasury bonds all these months, or from trimming the DoD and other wasteful budgets in Washington ....
People such as Royal Lancer must recognize that their greatest threat comes from the "city people" who, once the infrastructure fails, will not huddle together waiting to die from the lack of amenities, but willhead to the rural areas to take by force what they are lacking in the cities.
Even now, those who can afford to do so are moving out of the cities to the "country" and placing demands on the infrastructures that are beginning to overload them. And the "city people" who are moving to the country are, on the whole, more wealthy and demand more amenities, thereby using more electricity, water and sewage.
We must all realize we are indeed our brother's keeper and try to find solutions.
Badfish
As you wait for the government (which I am told by good authority there is no substitute for) to fix the pot hole, please do not hold your breath and drive around the pothole
.... or, BF, get a shovel and fill it in yourself, which might be the quickest way to get it fixed.
scremminimi
If you do that you are going to run afoul of a union or two or three