5 Ways The Government Keeps Native Americans In Poverty
"Imagine if the government were responsible for looking after your best interests. All of your assets must be managed by bureaucrats on your behalf. A special bureau is even set up to oversee your affairs. Every important decision you make requires approval, and every approval comes with a mountain of regulations.
How well would this work? Just ask Native Americans.
The federal government is responsible for managing Indian affairs for the benefit of all Indians. But by all accounts the government has failed to live up to this responsibility. As a result, Native American reservations are among the poorest communities in the United States ."
http://www.forbes.com/sites/realspin/2014/03/13/5-ways-the-government-keeps-native-americans-in-poverty/
Tags
Who is online
103 visitors

"Chief Justice John Marshall set Native Americans on the path to poverty in 1831 when he characterized the relationship between Indians and the government as resembling that of a ward to his guardian. With these words, Marshall established the federal trust doctrine, which assigns the government as the trustee of Indian affairs. That trusteeship continues today, but it has not served Indians well.
Underlying this doctrine is the notion that tribes are not capable of owning or managing their lands. The government is the legal owner of all land and assets in Indian Country and is required to manage them for the benefit of Indians.
But because Indians do not generally own their land or homes on reservations, they cannot mortgage their assets for loans like other Americans. This makes it incredibly difficult to start a business in Indian Country. Even tribes with valuable natural resources remain locked in poverty. Their resources amount to dead capitalunable to generate growth for tribal communities."
It is not for want of not trying, it is because of the tremendous road-blocks placed in our way by our Great Father - Congress.
Exactly what they told the Delaware in 1784 - we'll give you a seat in our Congress.
It was because, in those days, we Indians were not considered to be quite human and therefore, as sub-humans, unable to comprehend the complexities of the White Man's world! Didn't take long for the Indians, though, to figure out that this was a first class scam designed for the White Man to steal Indian resources into perpetuity even unto today!
"resembling that of a ward to his guardian" - these words written by Marshall have been the most damaging words written regarding a peoples. Has any other ethnicity in the U. S. states been placed in such a denigrating position?
It would seem, #1, that any of the indigenous peoples, of the world, are not held with any respect by their conquerors. Check Central & South America or the aboriginals of Australia as classics. Wherever the Euros go people wind up suffering.
But, UNDRIP is supposed to change that to where indigenous peoples handle their own affairs with their own governments - even the U. S. signed up to it.
''even the U.S. signed up to it''....Like following through will ever happen with our politicians. Their history tells a whole different story.
In the words of the great American, ''Pogo'', F'em, feed them beans.
During the time that Marshall wrote those words, in "civilized countries all over the world, wards were being bilked of their fortunes by guardians.
During the reign of kings, uncles killed nephews when left as their guardians to become rulers. There is no security in having a guardian. There is only perpetual fear in wondering if the guardian will murder you in your sleep to become the beneficiary of your fortune before you come of age to manage it yourself.
In the case of the Indian, they will never come of age, and as the years go by, their guardian chips away millions and billions of their fortune "for the good of the many" and for the good of their own pockets.
There should be a way through the courts whereby Indians should divest themselves of this parasitic guardianship, citing human rights, as no other ethnicity in this country suffers this indignity. The US government should have to prove in a court of law that this archaic law has validity today, or announce to the world at large that the United States of America is the greatest violator of human rights and the most bigoted and racist country in the history of the world.
You really need to sign up for this "Tribal Law" course - I'm sitting here listening to a archived class (this weeks) dealing with treaties and UNDRIP. Treaties are called, or known as, "Hard" positive international law, i.e. they were developed through negotiations between two foreign/international "states" (tribes/U.S.) and have a firmer, more solidified foundation and numerous precedent. It "can" be enforced through assistance with the International community/law courts. UNDRIP is a "theoretical" or "soft" law - it' not there, it is just a recommendation that most, if not all, have signed up for to further negotiations with the indigenous peoples.
"IF" the treaty violations were to be taken to the International Court and the Court ruled in favor of the tribes, who would enforce those rulings? Would the U.S. again say - "John Marshall has made his ruling - now, let him enforce it."?
Most people are under the delusion that Indian Reservations a separate nations within our nation and yet when looked at bit more closely it can be seen that the White man has never relinquished his hold over the land.
DEFINITION OF INDIAN COUNTRY
What is Indian Country?
Indian country includes:
1. All land within the limits of an Indian reservation under the jurisdiction of the United States government;
2. All dependent Indian communities, such as the New Mexico Pueblos; and
3. All Indian allotments still in trust, whether they are located within reservations or not.
What is the ownership status of land within Indian Country?
There are three basic categories of land tenure in Indian country; tribal trust lands, allotted trust lands, and fee lands.
Tribal trust lands are held in trust by the United States government for the use of a tribe. The United States holds the legal title, and the tribe holds the beneficial interest.
Allotted trust lands are held in trust for the use of individual Indians (or their heirs). Again, the federal government holds the title, and the individual (or heirs) holds the beneficial interest.
Fee lands are held by an owner, whether Indian or non-Indian.
Other lands in Indian country can be held by federal, state, or local (nontribal) governments. These lands include such areas as national wildlife refuges and state parks.
mimi , assimilation has been one of their great failed tasks. It was that reason that my family left the rez shortly after I was born. They planned on taking all of the children of my family and placing us in one of their Church schools in order to take the savages out of us and never returning us to our families. For all of their great talk today nothing has really changed except they are being held to task today better than they were back in the middle 20s.
If the Court ruled in favor of the tribes and the US refused to honor the ruling, the member nations could always refuse to sit down with the US in any further negotiations of any kind at an international level.
I do realize that the US pays billions to other countries for them to be our "friend" but the colossal loss of integrity and face, the lack of ability for the US to ever again speak out on human rights or try to negotiate for consideration of human rights with other countries, would be devastating. It would throw the world off balance if the US failed to comply with such a ruling concerning the human rights of our own indigenous population.
If brought before a court, how could it rule that our people are not intelligent enough or competent enough to handle their own affairs when we have attorneys, senators, representatives, judges, doctors, accomplished people in all walks of life that discount the notion that Indians are not capable people?
There is no argument that would hold, other than the one that the US government does not want to let go of the Indian land, which would irreparably damage the face of the United States in the eyes of the world.
This all stems from the almost universally held view that indigenous people are not quite human. I call this the two step! One step down from humanity, and one step up from animalism. Confirmation of this can be seen in just how the indigenous peoples are treated by their conquerors.
Oh, yeah - don't forget Charles Curtis - Kaw - Vice President of the U. S.
Hmmmm - would that be a step up or down
Charles Curtis...Apple
Hmmm - a little harsh? How many other Indians have made the national scene as he (other than Ben Nighthorse Campbell)?
IMO, not harsh at all...The point isn't how many Indians have made the national scene, but rather what they did when in the position.
While serving as a Congressman, Curtis originated and helped pass the Curtis Act of 1898 , with provisions that included bringing the Five Civilized Tribes of Oklahoma under land allotment and restructuring provisions. It limited their tribal courts and government. By his own experience, Curtis believed that the Indians could benefit by getting educated, assimilating and joining the main society. The government tried to encourage Indians to accept individual citizenship and lands, and to take up European-American culture. In application of these goals, some administrators went too far in terms of threats and breaking down families. (see Indian Boarding Schools )
Ahh HAH - you went to the same link I did
No, I was thinking more on his being raised by his grandparents in the traditions of the Kaw and how his dad tried to get his deceased mom's allotted lands taken from Charles and given to him - which never happened. He was more a traditionalist - back then.
What happened to him after he went to law school and started his own practice and rise up the political ladder - I just don't understand.
I have a whole file on Charles, 1st. Have read most everything that I can find about him. I'm not impressed by him at all. At one time he was a fighter for Indian rights. That changed, and he became part of the establishment. That is where my ''Apple'' comment came from.
Regarding Campbell, I don't believe that he sold out.
Ben would never sell out - hey, former AF makes him almost - well maybe not - almost as good as a Marine - nah - going too far on that one.
I'd be curious to know what changed his attitude. Was it law school?
To bad Ben wasn't Army Airborne, then he would have been at the top of ladder.
It could have been law school 1st. Look at it this way. He saw away to advance his own agenda by becoming part of the establishment. He, would be accepted that way. If he fought the system, and tried to help Indians, he would be an outcast.
Also remember that in 1994, Bill Clinton stood on the Rosebud Sioux Reservation and "swore" that his administration would bring industry to Indian Country - the government would "fund", as required under the Indian Reorganization Act and the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act, start up programs for the tribes and industry, working hand in hand.
Still wait'n Billy.