╌>

The UAW Demands a Mulligan -- And the Obama labor board may use a dubious theory to give it one. WSJ Editorial, March 9, 2014

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  7 comments

The UAW Demands a Mulligan -- And the Obama labor board may use a dubious theory to give it one. WSJ Editorial, March 9, 2014

Having lost an election at Volkswagen's Chattanooga plant, the United Auto Workers are charging unfair political interference and demanding another vote. Though the union's case is dubious, the union-friendly referees at President Obama's National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) may grant a replay anyway as part of its larger campaign to muffle anti-union political speech.

The UAW has filed an election objection with the labor board alleging that Republican politicians conducted "a coordinated and widely-publicized coercive campaign" to deprive "workers of their federally-protected right" to "support and select the UAW as their exclusive representative." The union says intimidation by third parties should void the results based on the constitutionally shaky doctrine known as "laboratory conditions."

The NLRB invented this doctrine in the 1948 General Shoe case when it assumed responsibility to provide "a laboratory in which an experiment may be conducted, under conditions as nearly ideal as possible, to determine the uninhibited desires of the employees." The board ruled that, "When, in the rare extreme case, the standards drop too low" then "the experiment must be conducted over again."

Note the words "rare" and "extreme." The NLRB has traditionally been reluctant to invoke that doctrine, even in cases of egregious misconduct. In 2010 the NLRB overruled Downtown Bid Services Corporation's charge that pro-union workers had upset laboratory conditions by threatening employees with job losses. The board said the threats were mitigated by Downtown's assurances that employees would not be fired regardless of the election's outcome.

One year later, the NLRB dismissed MasTec Direct TV's objection that pro-union employees had threatened to "whip [an employee's] ass," "sabotage his work," and "get even" with another worker if "he backstab[bed] us" and "cost us the election." The union won the election by a single vote, but the NLRB held that these threats were not "so aggravated as to create a general atmosphere of fear and reprisal rendering a free election impossible" in part because such "loose talk is common." Note that those complaints were filed by companies against unions.

In Tennessee, the complaint is by the union against politicians. Senate Speaker Pro Tem Bo Watson said before the vote that "additional incentives from the citizens of the state of Tennessee for expansion or otherwise will have a very tough time passing the Tennessee Senate" if voters unionize. But that's a statement of fact, and neither he nor any other state politician threatened to yank existing incentives.

The UAW is also making much ado of U.S. Senator Bob Corker's claim that he was "assured" that Chattanooga would be rewarded with a second production line if workers rejected the union. The Senator's "threat was made using United States Government resources," the union complains to the NLRB, and "we believe that Senator Corker used government travel funds specifically to fly to Chattanooga to make his threat in the most open and notorious manner." Nice of the UAW to care so much about taxpayer dollars.

The legal problem for the UAW is that Volkswagen immediately disavowed Mr. Corker's claim. UAW regional director Gary Casteel also assured Chattanooga workers prior to the election that Volkswagen officials "specifically said that this vote will have no bearing on the decision of where to place the new product." The union complaint also never mentions that Mr. Obama tried to influence the election by telling Democrats on Capitol Hill the week of the election that Republicans were more concerned with German shareholders than U.S. workers.

If anything, Volkswagen favored the union by giving labor organizers the run of the plant while denying similar access to anti-union workers. Germany's IG Metall Union, which holds several seats on the Volkswagen board, also promoted the UAW to Tennessee workers. So although the UAW had ample opportunity to directly make its case to workers, the union is now calling a foul because workers exercised free choice and the vote didn't go its way.

The Obama-appointed majority on the NLRB is the most overtly partisan in memory, and its behaviorrecall its anti- Boeing assault for building planes in South Carolinashows it will use any pretext to side with the union. It may give the UAW a mulligan even at the risk of losing again.

The larger NLRBand UAWgoal may be to establish a precedent that political statements opposing a union election are enough to invalidate "laboratory conditions" and thus require a revote. That would deter politicians from speaking up in the future. This is bad labor law, and it violates the First Amendment, but modern union politics is all about using government power to overrule worker choice.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    12 years ago

Be interesting to see which side pops up. I still don't see the whole VW willbuild another plant somewhere else in the state if the union is voted down as a player-how would that affect the current plant's employees?

The union says intimidation by third parties should void the results based on the constitutionally shaky doctrine known as "laboratory conditions."

Really, so SEIU members intimidating people at political gather ings is okay? Hypocrites.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

People just might want to chew on this one for awhile.

Germany has some of the strongest unions in the world, yet corporations manage to build plants here and produce millions of cars all while making a profit doing it. And yes..... some of them are even Volkswagen plants.

Just how can they make it happen and America can't. This should give you an idea.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Robert G

I don't care what anyone else says that was funny!!!!

Smile.gif Smile.gif Smile.gif Smile.gif

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

I always thought that safe sex was when the thingamajig is in the hand, and the hand is in the thingamajig, but the thingamajig is never in the thingamajig......

I'm just a sailor, what do I know about safe sex anyway.....

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

My perspective on this issue : American "professional" management is basically an accounting function . They have no interest in nurturing creativity . And their only approach to customer needs is to appeal to customer wants . They design for big & flashy not small & efficient .

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I heard a fellow that worked there said having the union would just lower his pay by $5.00 and then he would have to pay union dues on top of that.

Here's something interesting.

The UAW began knocking on Volkswagens doors before the first Passat rolled off the assembly line three years ago. The 400,000-member union - one-fourth the size it was 35 years ago - gained a key ally when the powerful IG Metall union in Germany pushed Volkswagen management to allow the Chattanooga plant to be organized.

Pro-union workers like Jabbar Ecton, 42, dont complain about low wages or lousy benefits. New hires at Volkswagen make $15 an hour; more senior workers like Ecton can pull $20 an hour.

The anti-union critics also complain that VW wont allow their supporters to campaign inside the factory. The UAW, which maintains a table with pamphlets near the company cafeteria, was also given a list of employees names and addresses by VW.

...

Wonder why?

The IG Metall union has given its clear support to the formation of a grand coalition between the Social Democrats (SPD) and the Christian Democrats and Christian Social Union (CDU/CSU).

There was further applause when Merkel stated that there would be a universal minimum wage. The unions have raised the demand for a minimum wage of 8.50 per hour, which equates to a gross salary under 1,440 a month for a full-time employeea net salary for an individual that is just above the poverty line. The grand coalition has now negotiated that the national minimum wage will only come into force in 2015, and that lower, collectively-agreed wages remain exempt from it until 2017.

That 8.50 Euro is 11.86 USD

The 6th extraordinary IG Metall union conference had been convened because the 63-year old Huber was about to enter his high-paying retirement. Together with Detlef Wetzel, he had been elected to lead the union in 2007. Both have received the highest praise from political and big business circles for their roles during the economic crisis.

Three years ago, on Huber's 60th birthday, Merkel organised a celebration at the chancellery. Only a few others have received this honour, such as former Deutsche Bank CEO Josef Ackermann. Hubers birthday party included, among others, the president of the metal and engineering industries association Martin Kannegiesser, Siemens CEO Peter Lscher and VW CEO Martin Winterkorn , as well as works council leaders of major corporations, such as Klaus Franz from Opel and Uwe Hueck from Porsche.

Although he faced no opponent, Wetzel was elected as Hubers successor with only 75 percent of the vote. Many delegates, largely full-time officials and works council representatives, have taken umbrage with him for greatly diminishing their career prospects.

Wetzel has been through the old hard slog to the union leadership. An apprenticed toolmaker and qualified social worker , he became a member of the IG Metall and the SPD (Social Democrats) in the late 1960s, slowly rising in the union hierarchy.

And all this was brought to you by........

World Socialist Web Site

WSWS.org

Published by the International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI)

German IG Metall union supports grand coalition government

I guess the question is, do you want your president negotiating with the unions for your future? I mean the labor union members making the scene near the top of the list when unions really don't have that much power in this country as they once had 11.6% approximately, it makes you wonder and with IG Metall, which it sounds like pretty much runs Germany and it seems had a position in getting the unions in the plant and probably keeping the anti-unions member out. After all the unions did have a table near the cafeteria with names and address of all the employees and the anti-union member had nothing.

Somehow I just can't relate to these guys....

Anyway....

The UAW isnt good for my plant; they cant offer me or any worker anything we dont have already, said Greg Bo Poteet, 53, a VW technician. Im a Christian and a conservative and I refuse to give my (union dues) to things I oppose, like Planned Parenthood, gun control and the Democratic Party.

To summarize......

It will be historic if it passes, said Stephen Silvia, an expert on German industrial relations at American University in Washington. If they lose, its hard to imagine the UAW would be able to organize in the South, or at foreign automobile plants, in the foreseeable future.

All information is either from....

or

...

And my thoughts on it.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

The difference that I have learned about unions here in Germany from ours in the states is that they truly have a cooperative association vs. an adversarial one. Furthermore, this cooperation was legislated by the government.

Bottom line, the Germans are pumping out cars than we are in the states, using much higher cost labor with their respective companies making plenty of money.

 
 

Who is online