╌>

The Myth of the Great Wages 'Decoupling' -- There is no disconnect between productivity and worker pay if you use more accurate measures. 3/6/2014

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  15 comments

The Myth of the Great Wages 'Decoupling' -- There is no disconnect between productivity and worker pay if you use more accurate measures. 3/6/2014

By Donald J. Boudreaux and Liya Palagashvili

Many pundits, politicians and economists claim that wages have fallen behind productivity gains over the last generation. This "decoupling" explains allegedly stagnant (or in some versions of the story, declining) middle-class incomes and is held out as a crisis of the market economy.

This story, though, is built on an illusion. There is no great decoupling of worker pay from productivity. Nor have workers' incomes stagnated over the past four decades.

The illusion is the result of two mistakes that are routinely made when pay is compared with productivity. First, the value of fringe benefitssuch as health insurance and pension contributionsis often excluded from calculations of worker pay. Because fringe benefits today make up a larger share of the typical employee's pay than they did 40 years ago (about 19% today compared with 10% back then), excluding them fosters the illusion that the workers' slice of the (bigger) pie is shrinking.

Milken Institute Chairman Michael Milken on why excessive housing incentives have hurt economic growth and the American dream. Photo credit: Associated Press.

The second mistake is to use the Consumer Price Index (CPI) to adjust workers' pay for inflation while using a different measurefor example the GDP deflator, which converts the current prices of all domestically produced final goods and services into constant dollarsto adjust the value of economic output for inflation. But as Harvard's Martin Feldstein noted in a National Bureau of Economic Research paper in 2008, it is misleading to use different deflators.

Different inflation adjustments give conflicting estimates of just how much the dollar's purchasing power has fallen. So to accurately compare the real (that is, inflation-adjusted) value of output to the real value of worker pay requires that these values both be calculated using the same price index.

Consider, for instance, that between 1970-2006 the CPI rose at an average annual rate of 4.3%, while the GDP deflator rose only 3.8%. Economists believe that such a difference arises because the CPI is especially prone to overestimate inflation. Therefore, much of the increase in the real purchasing power of workers' pay is mistakenly labeled by the CPI as mere inflation.

Mr. Feldstein and a number of other careful economistsincluding Richard Anderson of the St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank and Edward Lazear of the Stanford University Graduate School of Businesshave compared worker pay (including the value of fringe benefits) with productivity using a consistent adjustment for inflation. They move in tandem. And in a study last year, Joo Paulo Pessoa and John Van Reenen of the London School of Economics compared worker compensation and productivity in both the United States and the United Kingdom from 1972-2010. There was no decoupling in either country.

The empirical reality in both countries is consistent with economic reasoning. Firms cannot afford a misalignment of their workers' pay and productivity increasesthe employees will move to other firms eager to hire these now more productive workers. Higher economy-wide productivity, after all, means that workers add more to the bottom lines of employers throughout the economy. To secure the services of these more-productive workers, firms bid up worker pay. This competition for labor services is what links pay to productivity.

Competitive markets also deliver the goods, so to speak, to workers in their role as consumers. Higher productivity means the prices of consumer goods and services decline as output increases. As this happens, workers' spending powertheir real incomeis enhanced.

The claim that ordinary Americans are stagnating economically while only "the rich" are gaining is also incorrect. True enough, membership in the middle class seems to be decliningbut this is because more American households are moving up.

The Census Bureau in 2012 compiled data on the percentage of U.S. households earning annual incomes, measured in 2009 dollars, in different income categories (for example, annual incomes between $25,000 and $35,000). These data reveal that between 1975 and 2009, the percentage of households in the low- and middle-income categories fell. The only two categories that saw an increase were households earning between $75,000 and $100,000 annually, and households earning more than $100,000 annually. Remarkably, the share of American households earning annual incomes in excess of $100,000 went to 20.1% in 2009 from 8.4% in 1975. Over these same years, households earning annual incomes of $50,000 or less fell to 50.1% from 58.4%.

This household-income trend can't just be dismissed, as some analysts do, by noting that it was amplified by the greater number of married women in the workforce. The increase in income earned by these women itself reflects greater economic productivity. Women's increased employment has been facilitated by lower-priced and higher-quality home appliances, prepared meals and other modern conveniences.

Households in the past enjoyed income earned in the market by the husband, with meal preparation, dishwashing and the like performed by the wife. The women who engaged in this household production were not paid a wage in the market, but their work had real economic value to the household (and to the economy). Households today enjoy market incomes earned by both spouses, while the time necessary for household work has been reduced thanks to microwave ovens, automatic dishwashers and other inventions that are themselves reflections of a thriving marketplace.

Middle-class stagnation and the "decoupling" of pay and productivity are illusions. Yes, the U.S. economy is in the doldrums, thanks to a variety of factors, most significantly the effect of growth-deadening government policies like ObamaCare and the Dodd-Frank Act. But by any sensible measure, most Americans are today better paid and more prosperous than in the past.

Mr. Boudreaux is an economics professor at George Mason University, where Ms. Palagashvili is a graduate student in economics; she is also a visiting Ph.D. fellow in the economics department at New York University.

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702304026804579411300931262562?mod=WSJ_Opinion_LEADTop&mg=reno64-wsj


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

How do they explain, then, the increase in top level management pay?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

They explain what they explain.

How do you explain it and what is your source?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The authors provided two reasons for the "worker pay"illusion but the two-worker household was not one of them. It was an aside.

This household-income trend can't just be dismissed, as some analysts do, by noting that it was amplified by the greater number of married women in the workforce. The increase in income earned by these women itself reflects greater economic productivity.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

Personally, I explain it as a bunch of greedy people sucking off of the work of many, siphoning more off the top while giving their workers less. Even if the compensation rates are in line with productivity increases and not decoupled for the middle class, how can the compensation of the upper level management increase so dramatically more than the average compensation of the other people employed by the companies.

The fact that they do not address this issue is telling, and in my calculus, leads to a disingenuousness of the report in total.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

If you understood human nature you would know that greed is not exclusive to any income level.

The authors explained that fringe benefits have greatly increased.

If a company is successful its mover and shaker is entitled in proportion to his contribution. Their major benefit is through their stock ownership and the rise of the share prices. Their major contributors are rewarded by the rise of their options.

Do you expect a secretary or accountant to be rewarded proportionately to a Zuckerberg, Buffet or Gates?

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    12 years ago

So it is your contention that the executives have increased their value to the company by a factor of 10 or more? How is that consistent with increased productivity, even if they did have anything to do with it (besides laying off and firing people)?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

So you contend that only owners are greedy, not workers. Dream on.

And you alsothink it's a load of crap that fringe benefits have doubled as the authors say.

What is your source for these assertions?

Why don't you think a founder of a successful business does not deserve the rewards that go with that success?

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   Paul    12 years ago

Why don't you think a founder of a successful business does not deserve the rewards that go with that success?

Len, after correcting for the erroneous double-negative in your question, the implication was that "The Squirrel" and John don't believe that the actual founders of successful businesses deserve great rewards. I believe that they would not begrudge the actual founders reward.

What they are actually referencing are the CEOs who had nothing to do with the founding/startup of the corporations they direct, who are paid many millions a year, receive enormous stock options, and spend most of their time doing stock buy-backs to inflate (market manipulation, pure and simple) the share price, further enriching themselves, but leaving the share price with a bubble-like overevaluation. The rest of the time, they are crushing unions, suppressing wages, cutting benefits, pillaging pension plans, and generally bending real working folks over a barrel and.....doing a bad job of actually running the corporation.

From Why startup founders can make solid CEOs

Unfortunately, the tendency to replace founder CEOs with "professional CEOs" still has a strong following. If it didn't, then Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz wouldn't have gotten so much flack for insisting from the outset of their venture capital firm that they had a strong preference for the founder to be CEO in 2009. They stated:

Not all founders can become great CEOs, but most of the great companies in our industry were run by a founder for a long period of time, often decades, and we believe that pattern will continue. We cannot guarantee that a founder can be a great CEO, but we can help that founder develop the skills necessary to reach his or her full CEO potential.

and

Their preference was preceded by a 2005 study of stock market returns for founder-led vs. non-founder-led companies by Martin L. Martens, which was featured in Harvard Business Review . The article states:

Founder-led companies had a market-adjusted return of 12% over the course of three years and a survival rate of 73%, compared with a return of -26% and a survival rate of 60% for firms that hired a new CEO

In fact, financial results in the wake of founders stepping aside -- voluntarily or involuntarily -- have been so bad that they caused many founders to return to their companies as CEOs to try to save (or reinvigorate) the companies they established. Large company examples of this trend include Larry Page at Google ( GOOG ), Michael Dell at Dell ( DELL ), Howard Schultz at Starbucks ( SBUX ), Charles Schwab at Schwab ( SCHW ), Richard Schaden at Quiznos, Reid Hoffman at LinkedIn, Tim League at Alamo Drafthouse, Jeffrey Citron at Vonage ( VG ), and the pioneer of the trend: Steve Jobs at Apple ( AAPL ). Small-company examples abound as well, such as Rob Kalin at Etsy, David Ulevitch at OpenDNS, and Philip Rosedale at Second Life.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Founder-led companies had a market-adjusted return of 12% over the course of three years and a survival rate of 73%, compared with a return of -26% and a survival rate of 60% for firms that hired a new CEO

Interesting stats but they may be comparing Apples to tennis shoes ... How do we know what the stats were based on ?

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   Paul    12 years ago

Petey, from the link in the 2nd article quotation above.... a 2005 study

Concordia University graduate student Jean-Philippe Arcand and I, aided by assistant professor Thomas J. Walker, studied the short-term and midterm performances of 435 North American high-tech firms that issued IPOs between June 1996 and December 2000.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

OK , I'll take a look .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Three years later, however, the numbers told a different story. Stocks of the founder-led firms had significantly better returns over that time and were more likely to remain listed than stocks of professionally led firms. Founder-led companies had a market-adjusted return of 12% over the course of three years and a survival rate of 73%, compared with a return of -26% and a survival rate of 60% for firms that hired a new CEO and moved the founder to a different position on the top management team. (Companies whose founders left altogether performed somewhat better than those in which founders remained on the management team, although not as well as companies whose founders stayed at the helm.)

The dynamics of change of management are complex . Often it has a lot to do with rapid growth . Founders are often people who are not as involved in a company once it becomes huge . That info is lacking in the study .
From my POV it is essential to include info on the relative size of the firms . I expect to see firms with sudden growth in personnel numbers to be more likely to have had a change in management .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

See my editorSmile.gif

Regardless, if the founders are replaced, for better or worse, it is because a majority of the shareholders think the replacements can do better and are rewarded accordingly.

Notwithstanding your list of founders (which at least partially supports my point) there are many replacement CEOs who have done a great job. Off the top of my head I can mention Thomas J. Watson, Sr. and Jr., and Louis V. Gerstner of IBM, and Jack Welch of GE.

But in addition:

During the dot com era, Yahoo!s Tim Koogle helped build Jerry Yang and Dave Filos startup into the worlds most valuable internet company. Meanwhile, Meg Whitman helped Pierre Omidyars eBay become the second most powerful ecommerce company in the world (trailing only Amazon). The Web 2.0 era provides successful examples like Joe Kennedy and Tim Westergren at Pandora, and the current social era provides even more, including Dick Costolo at Twitter and Tony Zingale and Dave Hersh at Jive.

Sure, there are plenty of cautionary tales about how VCs have ousted founders in favor of professional CEOs who run companies into the ground. But its hard to call the evidence one-sided and overwhelming when there are so many strong counterexamples.

Noam Wasserman of Harvard Business School has been studying what he calls the founders dilemma for nearly a decade. In his academic paper, Rich versus King , he looked at 460 American startups from the 2000s. His statistical analysis showed that, paradoxically, founders maximized the value of their equity stakes by giving up the CEO position and board control: The results show that, controlling for company size, age, and other factors, the more decision-making control kept (at both the CEO and board levels), the lower the value of the entrepreneurs equity stake.

In another study of 212 startups , Wasserman found that it was rare for Founder-CEOs to run their companies in the long term; less than half were still CEO after 3 years, and less than a quarter of the CEOs of the companies that reached an IPO were Founder-CEOs.

Given the evidence that bringing in an outside CEO can often pay off financially and, more importantly, in terms of overall scale and impact of the company, its important to explore the possibilityeven if it isnt your first choice. I speak from personal experience, since I hired and partnered with a CEO, Jeff Weiner, very successfully at LinkedIn five years after co-founding the company.

 
 
 
Paul
Freshman Silent
link   Paul    12 years ago

Speaking of myths, here's a good one directly related to this discussion

The Myth of Maximizing Shareholder Value

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Do you expect a secretary or accountant to be rewarded proportionately to a Zuckerberg, Buffet or Gates?

That's a fairly ridicules question to ask Len. I don't think anyone discussing this issue expects rank and file employees to earn salaries even closely proportionate to to Zuckerberg or Gates.

What most people are saying in regard to disproportionate incomes in the US is, the level of CEO packages has become grossly disproportionate to rank and file incomes.

A few years ago the average difference was about 40%, and most people didn't ave a problem with that. CEOs are supposed to make a lot more money than the rank and file. However, today the average difference is about 295% more than the average rank and file worker, and a LOT of people have a problem with that!

cnnmoney_mainnav.gif?width=80

Fortune 50 CEO pay vs. our salaries

Exactly how much more do Fortune 50 CEOs make than their workers? In many cases, quite a bit more. Here is an interactive breakdown of a handful of Fortune 50 top exec salaries compared to typical employee pay at their respective companies.

See Chart

It's good to be the king, or CEO, as the case may be. At least when it comes to pay. With a staggering total compensation package of $378 million for 2011, Apple's Tim Cook takes the cake for the highest Fortune 50 CEO-to-typical-worker pay ratio. Indeed, it takes 6,258 typical Apple worker salaries to match Cook's total pay. On the opposite side of the spectrum, the ratio for Berkshire Hathaway's Warren Buffett was 11-to-1. Overall, most CEOs took home an average 379 staffers' worth in base pay. And those looking for a bump might want to check out Microsoft's openings. The software giant had the highest typical worker salaries among the 35 companies we've highlighted, at $110,000

 
 

Who is online