The simple-minded populism that controls the GOP
of the Washington Post
Ive often been critical of outsider candidates who claim that their lack of experience in politics and government is precisely what will enable them to succeed in politics and government. Business-people seem particularly prone to believe that they can bring solutions that no one has ever contemplated before, and now Carly Fiorina is showing that she has some truly innovative policy ideas , after hearing from a veteran having trouble navigating the VA health system:
Listen to that story, Fiorina said. How long has [VA] been a problem? Decades. How long have politicians been talking about it? Decades.
Fiorina said she would gather 10 or 12 veterans in a room, including the gentleman from the third row, and ask what they want. Fiorina would then vet this plan via telephone poll, asking Americans to press one for yes on your smartphone, two for no.
You know how to solve these problems, she said, so Im going to ask you.
I guess it took someone with Fiorinas business savvy to come up with the idea to address complex policy challenges with a focus group followed by an American Idol-style telephone vote. If only we had thought of that before.
Seriously, this episode tells us a lot about the state of Republican populism these days.
Its obviously important to understand the experience veterans have with the system if youre going to determine where its biggest problems are. But the inane idea that that would be all you need to solve the problems of an enormous agency that spends billions of dollars and has thousands of employees is characteristic of a particular kind of conservative populism, one that seems to be expanding now that Donald Trump has taken control of the entire presidential race.
Both parties are drawn to populist appeals, but they come in different variants. The Democratic version tends to be both performative and substantive theyll rail against the top one percent, but also offer policy ideas like upper-income tax increases and minimum wage hikes that are intended to serve the interests of regular people. Democratic populism says that the problem is largely about power: who has it, who doesnt, and on whose behalf its wielded.
Republican populism, on the other hand, is aimed against elites that are decidedly not economic. Its the egghead professors, the Hollywood liberals, the government bureaucrats whom they tell their voters to resent and despise. And part of that argument is that despite what those know-it-all experts would have you believe, all our problems have simple and easy solutions. All you need is common sense to know how we should reform our health care system, fix the VA, or control undocumented immigration. Understanding how government works isnt just unnecessary, its actually a hindrance to getting things done.
There may be no candidate who has ever sung this tune with quite the verve Trump does, but hes following in a long tradition. Ronald Reagan used to say, there are no easy answers, but there are simple answers all it takes is the courage to embrace them. George W. Bush trusted his gut more than his head, and saw a world where there are only good guys and bad guys; once you know whos who, the path forward is clear and only a wuss would worry about the unintended consequences that might arise from things like invading foreign countries.
In its somewhat less extreme version, this belief in the simple truths that only regular folks can see is what drives the common belief that whatevers wrong in Washington can be solved by bringing in someone from outside Washington. So Ted Cruz proudly trumpets the fact that all of his colleagues in the Senate think hes a jerk. And Scott Walker criticizes his own partys congressional leaders, saying, We were told if Republicans got the majority thered be a bill on the presidents desk to repeal ObamaCare. It is August. Where is that bill? Where was that vote?
Well, the answer is that theres this thing called a filibuster, which Democrats used to stop that bill from getting to the presidents desk, where it would have been vetoed anyway (the real problem is that those leaders promised their constituents something they knew they could never deliver). But in this particular populist critique, the way institutions work is irrelevant, and a straight-talking, straight-shooting Washington outsider can come in and clean the whole place up wielding nothing more than the force of his will, some common sense, and good old fashioned American gumption.
The real mystery is why voters would fall for this kind of claptrap again and again. If the Obama years have taught us anything, its that policy problems are guess what complicated. Understanding policy doesnt get you all the way to solutions you need a set of values that guides you and creativity in imagining change, among other things but you cant do without that understanding, at a minimum. Yet a significant chunk of voters continues to believe that everything is simple and easy, no matter how many times reality tells them otherwise.
Tags
Who is online
60 visitors

Personally I think Donald Trump has pretty much peaked and won't go more the one or two percentage points. He has done it by appealing to Americans who think that if they just vote for a candidate that promises them that he or she can solve all of the problems in Washington and the nation, through sheer force of will. Just by being the President. It doesn't work like that and it never will, because there are three branches of power in Washington.
For example,Trump says he's going to make all 11 million illegal immigrants (or 20 million, depending on who you are listening to) go back to where they came from and actually make them want to. He also said he is going to build a wall all across the Southern border and make Mexico pay for it. Another fantasy that he is trying sell. Of course thinking people know that those are promises no President, republican or democratic can keep. Trump has tapped into a group of people who are really mad at Washington and want to hear huge and outrageous promises that no President can actually deliver on. They think (for some reason) that the President has a lot more power then they actually do. They don't and that was done by the founding fathers on purpose. It's just that some people think or wish that there are simple, commonsense solutions to all of the problems of the nation and everything can be solved with them and there just are not. It's a lot more complicated then that and no matter what any candidate says it or what any President does, it's going stay that way.
Source Link
The simple minded populism of the Dems :
If or when Trump drops out (and he is an embarrassment to the entire US electoral process) I see most of his supporter moving to Cruz. But I still think that the eventual nominee will end up being Bush, IMHO. I just can't the GOP nominating someone with no governmental experience at all.
That's nevertheless what happened for BO's first term . He was woefully unprepared for the job as president having mostly experience as a "community organizer" .
A Kasich/Rubio ticket would be hard to beat.
I would have to agree with that and, much like I feel about Jeb, while I certainly don't agree with them on many issues, having them win is not nearly as frightening as having an ideologue like Cruz anywhere on the ticket.
Are you suggesting that the Dems are quixotic, that they are tipping at windmills which are mistaken as giants?
Are you suggesting that you are capable of objective thought ?
Petey, I don't believe you believe any of the nonsense you post in here. I only wonder why you spend your time doing it.