The Destruction of "Hidden Law"
While reading about Arizona's recent attempt to essentially cut and paste the Federal Religious Protection Act and apply it to Arizona, I was referred to an article by gay liberal Jonathon Rauch about " the concept "hidden law." The article struck a chord with me because he was able to articulate what I feel instinctually about the way America is heading, where t-shirts become federal lawsuit and routine interactions between citizens are litigation fodder.
Basically, hidden law is the unwritten legal and ethical code of civil society and is distinct form and often in conflict with formal, bureaucratic law. A simple example is the kid with the lemonade stand. For generations, Americans have expected police officers to "look the other way" and allow a kid to make a buck or two in front of his house even though it violates our "formal law". Now, the police officer won't just shut the stand down, he'll probably call the EPA,OSHA and the EEOC and the kid will spend the rest of life paying off the fines.
"Where Formal Law is all thumbs, Hidden Law often works wonders. Universities have always had speech codes; the only innovation was to write them down. In the old days, the rule for insults and epithets was: Don't say obnoxious or abusive things, but if you do, say them only rarely and in a fit of temper or drunkenness so you can apologize and we can all pretend you didn't really mean it, though we all know you did. Only if your obnoxiousness crossed an invisible but decidedly real line did the community hear or see it, in which case you got a talking-to, or even got kicked out. And before speech codes came along in the 1980s and '90s, American university campuses were not known as places where the slinging of vicious slurs was a big problem. Nor were they known as places where being charged with so-called "discriminatory verbal conduct" triggered months-long investigations, draconian discipline often meted out with a presumption of guilt, federal court cases, and regular campus uproars...
Only recently has a really deadly enemy emerged: a systematic ideology that is equipped with powerful institutional support and has the effect, usually unintended, of damaging or demolishing Hidden Law in encounter after encounter. That ideology is Bureaucratic Legalism: the belief that the way to settle practically every conflict is through an elaborate and highly articulated set of procedures... Defenders of Bureaucratic Legalism, on the other hand, still seem to think that more discovery, more pleadings, and more layers of appeal will deliver better justice. They seem confident that the system is rational so long as all the rules are being followed, and all the i's and t's are meticulously dotted and crossed...
But Bureaucratic Legalism, like all outcome-blind bureaucratic ideologies, pushes inexorably toward extremes. It cannot, by its nature, comprehend such rules as: "Up to a reasonable point, targets of slurs are responsible for swallowing their pride and getting on with life." Or: "Up to another reasonable point, if targets of slurs punch their tormentors in the nose, authorities will pretend not to notice." Or: "Beyond that point, if the authorities must notice, they will do something that seems reasonable, which they'll make up as they go along based on what they know of the situation and the characters of the people involved." To Bureaucratic Legalism, those sorts of rules are intolerable. They are "arbitrary and capricious," or "above the law," or "taking the law into your own hands."
If I call you a nasty name in the dorm and you complain to the dean, I'll worry about being keelhauled in a harassment proceeding, so I may say, "Talk to my lawyer" instead of "Oops, I'm sorry." In universities with speech codes, students accused of verbal harassment have learned that apologies will be used against them. Meanwhile, the rules themselves grow ever more complex and unwieldy as administrators and lawyers and legislators try to cover their posteriors by writing rules for every situation. When proliferating bureaucratic rules magnify conflict and block conciliation, they give rise to what is, in effect, antisocial law..
".
http://www.jonathanrauch.com/jrauch_articles/hidden_law_1_the_legal_assault/

This is the result of there being far too many lawyers with not enough to do . When lawyers get bored we all suffer .
I'd also say his use of hidden law to describe the Clinton impeachment is interesting...
"There is no question that Formal Law behaved during the affair (Clinton impeachment) as it was required to behave, according to its own lights. Under a provision of a law called the Violence Against Women Act--which President Clinton himself had signed--a plaintiff in a sexual harassment lawsuit was empowered to make extensive inquiries into the defendant's sexual history. And, under other laws, defendants are required to answer court-sanctioned inquiries truthfully. So, as far as Formal Law was concerned, a prosecutor was duty-bound to investigate credible allegations of lawbreaking by the president. End of story.
Yet the public was deeply and unremittingly hostile to Kenneth Starr's investigation. Indeed, the public rallied to Clinton's side. Bill Bennett and other conservatives suggested that the public, battered by decades of post-'60s cultural relativism, had grown corrupt. But the opposite was true: The public was desperately clinging to Hidden Law--to ancient norms of bourgeois decency--in the face of a frontal onslaught by Formal Law.
Remember, under the Main Street Code, if a man commits adultery and his wife either doesn't know or pretends not to know, the rest of the world's duty is absolutely clear: Shut up. When Gary Hart was confronted with adultery charges in 1987, his wife denied them and added, "In all honesty, if it doesn't bother me, I don't think it ought to bother anyone else." Everyone knew the rules. But, in the Lewinsky case, the law not only insisted on learning what went on, it insisted on penetrating every traditional veil of privacy and then broadcasting its findings to the world. The public saw this kind of inquiry as antisocial, even barbaric. And the public was right.
But the public's view found no political champions. Although liberals defended Clinton, they said not a word against the Violence Against Women Act and the rules of evidence and the sexual harassment jurisprudence that had thrust the prosecutor into Clinton's sex life. Liberals, after all, had promoted those laws--in part because many liberals view Main Street Codes as hypocritical and repressive.
More interesting, and perhaps more disappointing, was the conservative reaction. Social conservatives faced a painful choice. Because the Violence Against Women Act and its kin were already on the books, conservatives could be for a decent hypocrisy or they could be for law and order, but they could not be for both. And they were not about to let liberals get away with breaking the intrusive laws that liberals had themselves passed. Nor could conservatives sound as though they were making excuses for adultery. So conservatives were cornered into stridently advocating zero tolerance and legal formalism--never mind that, by any traditional conservative reckoning of law's proper limits, the law was way out of bounds when it demanded to know exactly what Clinton had done sexually and with whom. Thus Bennett and his allies ended up attacking the public for clinging, in true conservative fashion, to a deeper, older, wiser law.
I have always thought that, and it appeared they used it in industries that most served government agencies. e.g. the Fisheries industry. It's become a very disturbing reality for Fishermen, in light of using EPA regulations to create a 'farmed' product. Why picking on the lemonade stands makes money for them is something I don't understand.
An important factor is that biology trumps law . The law is "supposed to" be the same for all citizens . But it is clear that men & women have different predispositions . The formal law refuses to recognize that . It is only the hidden law which deals with it .
That's another good point, Petey.
The context I'm taking you in, if correct, is law is used to appease one gender and/or another.
I'm also thinking the decision to use Hidden Law would/could be due to a particular gender. i.e., I'm going to generalize a bit, but if male Leaders are determined to imperialize, they are going to use laws that promote their goals, and if a female Leader is of an altruistic nature, she's going to use a different interpretation of Law.. that is hidden.
I agree; punish who committed the harm to someone in particular - don't shoot the messenger.
From my POV the subject you are bringing up is the exact opposite of "hidden law" . It would instead be "overt law" with a hidden purpose ... an important subject to be sure but not the topic .
I agree, just wanted to let BF know that I agreed..
Consider yourself served with legal papers . Now go write your own article . You might even be featured in the articles column ... [insert giant interrobang here ]
Some people have interrobangs thrust upon them , but some shirk from the responsibility ...
Laugh if you must but mullets have led to some important social landmarks :