5 Facts About Social Security
Theres often considerable confusion as tojust how Social Security works, which is perhaps notsurprising given the programs complexity. (The original 1935 Social Security Act was 29 pages long; the current law , much amended and expanded,runsnearly 2,600 printed pages.)Heres a primer onthe program:
1 Social Security touches more people than just about any other federal program . At the end of 2014, according to the most recent trustees report , some 59 million Americans were receiving retirement, disability or survivors benefits from the system; the totalcost was $848.5billion. 166 million people paid payroll taxes into the system.
2 Social Security is, and always has been, an inter-generational transfer of wealth . The taxes paid by todays workers and their employers dont go into dedicated individual accounts (although 32% of Americans think they do, according to the 2014 Pew Research survey). Nor do Social Security checks represent a return on invested capital, though you might be forgiven for thinking so since the personalized Social Security statements that used to be mailed out once a year and now are available online detail your payment history and projected monthly benefits. Rather, the benefits received by todays retirees are funded by the taxes paid by todays workers; when those workers retire, their benefits will be paid for by the next generation of workers taxes (caveat: see Point 3). Your benefit amount is based on your earningshistory and age at retirement , not on how much you and your employer paid in Social Security taxes (although for most people, taxes paid are closely tied to their earnings).
3 Right now, Social Security has plenty of assets. For much of its history, Social Security was a strictly pay-as-you-go system, with current tax receipts funding current benefits. That changed in 1983, when Congress (as part of a comprehensive overhaul of the program) raised the payroll taxes that provide the bulk of Social Securitys revenue, to build up a cushion for the coming onslaught of Baby Boomer retirees. For nearly three decades, the system took in far more revenue than it paid out in benefits; the surplus was invested in special non-tradeable Treasury bonds, with interest credited to the systems two trust funds (one for old-age and survivors benefits, the other for disability payments). As of July 31 , those trust funds together held $2.83 trillion in Treasuries. (Some people characterize that as the government borrowing from or raiding Social Security, but the system is in essentially the same position as any other investor who buys Treasuries.)
4 But since 2010, Social Securitys cash expenses have exceeded its cash receipts. Negative cash flow last year was about $74 billion, according to the latest trustees report, and this year the gapis projected to be around $84 billion. While the credited interest on all those Treasuries is still more than enough to cover the shortfall, that will only be true until 2020. After that, Social Security will begin redeeming its hoard of Treasuries for cash to continue paying benefits as was the plan all along.
5 Social Securitys combined reserves likely will be fully depleted by 2034 , according to the trustees intermediate forecast. The disability-insurance trust fund could run dry as soon as the end of 2016, while the old-age and survivors fund is expected to be depleted in 2035 assuming its not tapped to backfill the disability fund. (The Congressional Budget Office, in a separate report that uses somewhat different demographic assumptions, projects that thedisability fund will be exhausted in fiscal 2017 and the old-age and survivors fund in calendar 2031; if the funds are combined, they would be exhausted in calendar 2029.) The exact depletion dates depend, of course, on future demographic and economic trends. After the reserves are exhausted, the system still will be receiving tax revenue, but it will only be enough to pay about three-quarters of scheduled benefits unless Congress changes the benefit formulas, raises the payroll tax, or makes other changes such as raising the cap on taxable wage income (currently $118,500).
http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/08/18/5-facts-about-social-security/

There are as many different opinions about what is good or bad about social security and ideas for what should or should not be done to improve and maintain the social support network it provides as the people you ask, but that changes will be made in the future seems a surety.
But what will those changes be, that is the question?
What changes should be made? Your thoughts and suggestions?
I think a lifting of the cap on income subject to FICA tax should be eliminated or at least changed and that based on total income in retirement, social security benefits of those with higher total retirement incomes should be taxable while social security for lower retirement incomes should not be taxed.
What are your ideas?
By the way I am a baby boomer!
such as raising the cap on taxable wage income (currently $118,500).
Bingo!
Randy
Thanks for the feedback
As I noted above I also think this cap should be lifted, if not eliminated
I'm in agree with both you and Randy, eliminate the cap completely.
No it shouldn't high wage earners have no need for the government to do their saving for them. Everyone should have the option to opt out.
Well as the saying goes, both my wife and myself have skin in the game (though it's not a game). My wife retired at the age of 70 and is collecting her benefits and Medicare. When I reach the youngest age Social Security sets for me to collect regular benefits (66), I'll be moved over to standard retirement, but my benefit will remain the same when I am coming off of Social Security Disability. The money will stay the same, it just will come out a different part of the budget. However since I am on Social Security Disability, that is supposed to go broke just before the election. It doesn't mean I would lose all of my benefits, but they would be cut and yes it would hurt both of us. Medicare would stay the same and we both have Medigap insurance through UnitedHealthcare, so that's not a worry.
I agree to a point with the republicans that the program needs to investigate fraud more and encourage more disabled persons to return to the work force (though I think both fraud and returning to work is just a small number of beneficiaries), but that that should not be allowed to be used as an excuse to just let the fund run dry and cut benefits while those things are happening.
Also, far too many people are living under the delusion that all a person has to do is to go to a doctor, have that doctor say they are disabled, apply for Disability and the checks start coming in. It is a very long and very, very detailed and very difficult process to qualify. It took 18 months just for my application to rise to the top of someones desk to even be looked at to decide what other department to send it to and that's just the first step. What your doctor (or Psychiatrist) says is nearly meaningless to the doctors who work there deciding on these cases. Luckily my mental heath condition is bad enough and I have more then 35 years of mental hospital, psychotic breaks and Psychiatric documentation showing that it is getting worse and qualified on the first time. However most people can't provide such a long history of documentation (or even be able to get it) or prove something such things as a soft tissue soft tissue injury is real. That's why about 70% of the people who apply are turned down the first time.
So this ignorant idea that a person can just walk into someones office and ask for disability and get it, is something some who hates Social Security Disability in the first place came up with and they just pulled that concept out of their ass. Sadly some people believe those idiots. It just doesn't work anywhere close to that. It's a total lie.
You guys do realize the more they pay in the more the government has to pay them back. They are more likely to invest that money into ventures that benefit the entire economy when they are in the prime if their life buy letting them keep it. What's the point of paying them a huge wad of cash at the end of their life when they are sitting around doing nothing.
Kavika
I agree and the payout would be adjusted upward as well, but capped at a maximum payout as well a increasing the taxability of social security benefits based on adjusted gross income levels of retirees.
Dean
As part of the change a cap on the maximum payout could be established, since changes are being made to the overall process and based on a retiree's total adjusted gross income more or even all of the social security benefit would be treated as taxable income.
Randy
My oldest son works for the social security administration and he has talked about how much misinformation is peddled by politicians and the press about how easy it is for people to et on permanent disability.
WTF let the government steal their money no thank you. They are already carrying the bulk of the tax load. I quit paying into that scam at the age of 32 by not taking a salary and receiving my income in the form of rent from an LLC that owns the buildings that house my equipment.
Everyone should have the option to opt out.
I couldn't disagree more. First of all retirees do not just sit around doing nothing. Also my wife and I had FICA removed from our checks our entire working lives. If you want to change the system, it has to take into account the financial destruction it would cause to the people who are already retired and disabled. That's not the American way. Change the system if you want, but it should leave people who have paid into system alone and keep their benefits the same. If you want to opt out and put your money in the Stock Market or something like that, go ahead. But it must NOT affect the benefits of us. Besides, a lot of people didn't and don't have the means to invest. If FICA stopped coming out of their checks, the vast majority of Americans would spend it on luxuries like food, housing, utilities, etc and would end up having to work until they die or die in the streets when they can no longer work. And no, it would not be their fault. This country has been there before. It was in the late 1800's and it was called the Golden Age, but it was only Golden for the rich and the poor and elderly were literally dying in the streets and alleys. Homeless and starved.
And yes yes I know a lot of retirees get back more then they paid in, but isn't that just showing a good return on their investment? An investment we had no choice in making, so we deserve a decent return on it. Or do you just expect everyone collecting Social Security die so you and others can opt out and start from scratch?
A robust economy, with more people gainfully employed, will both reduce the government's burden of care (especially for those whose only disability was being unemployable) and increase it's revenue.Of all our financing problems, Social Security's is theleastmysteriousand there arestraightforwardsolutions (more than one).
Social security is the institutionalization of the age old practice (still in use in most of the world) of the young taking care of their elders. It is sad that our downward mobility has left our young unable to take care of their elders and, in some cases, to depend on them past their adulthood. A revived economy will correct all of this.Social Security was intended only as a"safety net"(to catch those jumping out of tall office buildings, on Wall Street, when theirmarketinvestments tanked). I am happy my Social Security benefits werenotinvestedin the same private sector "financial instruments" as my 401-Ks and IRAs. Hopefully, future retirees will not be as reliant on thesafety netas are current ones, and will benefit from retirement incomes fromprivateretirement accounts, built from a well-performing economy. Hooray for the day when Social Security income will be thesmallest share(a supplement) to private pensions.Social Security shouldneverbe privatized.Everyone is free to get their private retirement investments toout-performtheir Social Security "investment".
And by Gawd, so should ALL Americans! (someone play the National Anthem now please). Everyone has that opportunity, they just haven't noticed any buildings they can rent.
The point is that what works for you can not work for everyone! It just can't!
My mom works for Social Security, even though she is 80 years old and she says the same. Surprising fact, when she does decide to retire, she can't collect Social Security and will have to pay for Medicare out of her pocket every month because she won't have Social Security Part A for it to be automatically deducted from. Same with nearly all government employees on every level. Well, except for politicians of course. They tend to get very, very generous retirement packages. Just before they go to work for a company they used to sit across the table from.
Randy
Why can she not get ss when she retires? I am confused, please explain.
rimbauda
Excellent points, thanks for sharing your perspective and for the feedback.
K W
Perhaps some who can afford to will, many, actually almost allwill not
The benefit was earned and should be received, but in the case of high levels of retirement income, it should be axed while for lower retirement income levels it is not taxed
Appreciate the feedback - thanks.
Dean
Good for you.
I am sure you will have a good retirement based on your plans, but the options listed (or a variation) of them) are the best options for improving the strength of the social safety net, insuring its long term solvency and taking care of our seniors which we have a responsibility to do after they have spent their lives working hard.
Randy
Excellent point!
For some reason most government employees, at all levels, are not allowed to pay FICA (even voluntarily) and must rely on their government pension (which is too small for her to afford keep her apartment and cover her health problems and she has been told it is too big for her to get Section 8 housing). She has the option of purchasing Medicare from the government, but will probably go with a plan on the Obamacare network, because, since she can't collect Part A of Social Security, she can't qualify for Medigap insurance (or Part D) and would have to pay for 20% of all of her medical bills out of pocket.
She has said she may not retire at all and just work until she dies because she has so many friends there and likes her job, but it's getting a lot harder for her bad lung to handle the cold Michigan winters. We have offered to let her move in with us down here in the CA desert, but the bulk of my family lives around where she does and doesn't want to leave. Besides she has an irrational fear that if she moves this far away, she won't be buried next to her late husband (who she loved very much and who she visits at the cemetery at least once every two weeks.) even though the plot and headstone are already paid for.
My wife worked almost her entire nursing career at the Arizona State Hospital and in the Department of Corrections in Arizona and for some strange reason that wasn't considered governmental enough to where they didn't take FICA out of her paycheck, so she built up credits for Social Security for those years. However when she worked the last seven years of her career for Los Angeles County (even as a union worker) they did not take FICA out of her check, so she couldn't claim those years as contributing to her Social Security, but did get a small pension from the county for those years. Fortunately she had worked far more then enough years in the private system and the prison system to get full Social Security Benefits when she retired last year at 70.
Randy
Thanks for the feedback and all the info - really appreciate it
It is sure a complicated system
I sure could use a raise in my benefits. So could my wife.
I think the pay out would also be raised to a limit (what that limit is I do not know), the main difference I would propose is that social security benefits be non-taxable below a certain AGI amount and fully taxable above that AGI amount.
I have no idea how or why the government determines which government employees and at which levels, have FICA taken out of their checks. There really doesn't seem to be any rhyme or reason to it. Or do the local states and/or counties do it within their states for their employees and the federal government just doesn't do it? The Social Security Department moves in strange and mysterious ways.
According to my son it is only slightly less complicated than the tax system
It is with percentage taxed I am saying that if AGI is above a limit (and that limit should be fairly low $150K perhaps) then all SS would be taxed as regular income with none excluded (including investment income, property income, stock dividends)