Americans Renouncing Citizenship Up 221%, All Aboard The FATCA Express
America is a great land and lures immigrants worldwide, yet record numbers of U.S. citizens and permanent residents are giving up their citizenship or residency. For all the immigrant arrivals the trickle the other direction is increasing. The number is still small, with the published expatriates for the quarter 630 for the last quarter of 2013.
That brings the total number to 2,999 for all of 2013 . The previous record high for a year was 1,781 set in 2011. Its a 221% increase over the 932 who left in 2012. You can call it a shaming or a public record, but the Treasury Department is required to publish a quarterly list of Americans who renounced their U.S. Citizenship or terminated their long-term U.S. residency. The public outing puts Americans on notice who relinquished their rights.
Those seem like tiny numbers, yet the total thus far for 2013 is 2,369. See Number of Taxpayers Who Renounced U.S. Citizenship Skyrockets to All-Time Record High , quoting Andrew Mitchel. Under U.S. tax law, it is not relevant why someone expatriates. Whether the expatriation was motivated by tax avoidance or something else used to matter, but the law was changed in 2004.
Since then, the tax and other consequences do not depend on why one leaves. Yet after Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin departed permanently for Singapore with his Facebook IPO riches, there was an angry backlash. Mr. Saverins post-Facebook fly-away prompted such outrage that Senators Chuck Schumer and Bob Casey introduced a bill to double the exit tax to 30% for anyone leaving the U.S. for tax reasons.
So far, that bill remains unpassed. Meantime, are people following Tina Turners lead ? No, and not Eduardo Saverins either. Most expatriations are probably motivated primarily by factors such as family and convenience. Many people like Ms. Turner have built a life somewhere else and may not plan to need a U.S. passport.
Complex or costly taxes can help sway a decision but are often only one factor. Although statistics are not available for why people say a final good-bye, many now find Americas global income tax compliance and disclosure laws inconvenient and nettlesome. Some go so far as to say that the U.S. tax and disclosure laws are downright oppressive.
No group is more severely impacted than U.S. persons living abroad. For those living and working in foreign countries, it is almost a given that they must report and pay tax where they live. But they must also continue to file taxes in the U.S. Whats more, U.S. reporting is based on their worldwide income, even though they are paying taxes in the country where they live.
Many can claim a foreign tax credit on their U.S. returns, but it generally does not eliminate all double taxes. These rules have long been in effect, but enforcement was historically less of a concern with expats. Today, enforcement fears are palpable.
Moreover, the annual foreign bank account reports known as FBAR forms carry civil and criminal penalties all out of proportion to tax violations. The penalties for failure to file these forms, civil and criminal, are severe. Even civil penalties can quickly consume the balance of an account.
The coup de grace is FATCA, which is ramping up now worldwide . It requires an annual Form 8938 to be filed with income tax returns for foreign assets meeting a threshold. And foreign banks are sufficiently worried about keeping the IRS happy that many simply do not want American account holders. Americans abroad can be pariahs shunned by banks for daily banking activities.
Even Canada has now agreed to turn over data to the U.S., though many in Canada are hopping mad about it. See Canada Signs U.S. FATCA Deal, IRS To Get Data . Still, leaving America can have a special tax cost. To exit, you generally must prove 5 years of tax compliance in the U.S. Plus, if you have a net worth greater than $2 million or have average annual net income tax for the 5 previous years of $155,000 or more (thats tax, not income), you pay an exit tax .
The theory of the exit tax is that is the last chance the U.S. has of taxing you. It is a capital gain tax as if you sold your property when you left. At least theres an exemption of $668,000.
Citizens arent the only ones to suffer. Long-term residents giving up a Green Card can be required to pay the tax too. See High Cost To Go Green: Giving Up A Green Card . A decision to expatriate should never be taken lightly. Taxes or no, it can be a big step. And around the world, more people are talking about taking this giant leap.

Looks like we're trying to chase away all the money for income redistribution and increase the number of people on entitlements.
I've been working overseas for the last two years, and will be here for a few more.
Yes, I am paying taxes both to my country of residence, and to the US. A quick calculation indicates that what I am paying is what I would be paying to cover my social security requirements plus about another 3%.
You want to play the entitlements game, that's fine. What I don't understand is why you are willing to ignore are those that gained their money IN the United States, and then hide it offshore. These are people doing real harm to the US economy and increasing the national debt simply because they are taking the money out of the economy where it needs to be circulated. Money acquired in our economy needs to stay in our economy. That is what the FBAR is trying to achieve.
Then Fly you could be informative as to how the taxes work for Americans like yourself who are spending time out of the USA.
I think these taxes are affecting people with a lot bigger tax bill than I have to deal with.
Is that the .001% of the 1%? Wow! Had me scared. That still leaves enough of them to continue the income redistribution. You do know that the top 1% pay 30% of the taxes and the top 40% pay 109% of the taxes and down toward the bottom they pay minus 9%. Glad to hear such a small percentage are renouncing their citizenship. We need those top 1%. Heck we need the top 20%. They pay 93% of the taxes for income redistribution.
The way I look at it is that America, for better or worse, has been there and helped me since I was born. From what I can see, it will be there upon my return and long after my death. Given all that I have been provided over the years, I feel obligated to see to it's continuation so others can have the same opportunity as I have enjoyed..
When you compare the US to many other countries you realize that it asks very little of it's citizens in comparison to what we enjoy. Does our government do things that I don't approve of? Sure it does, but I'm not willing to throw the baby out with the bath water either. So yes, in my mind, paying taxes while I'm out of the country is still the right thing to do. I guess my love and pursuit of money being less when compared to those that willingly seek out offshore tax havens needs to be take into account as well.
I was not long ago having this discussion, and did not know the US required a tax payment when living and working outside of the US. It's essentially a 'tax' just because one is a citizen! That seems absurd to me.
Does that mean when living (not working) abroad, US citizens 'must' pay a tax to any country they are living in, just like the US requires? What I'm wanting to clarify is if this law is particular to just the US, and if it matters if they are 'working' in that other country or not - to that other country for tax collection.
My confusion on that is that we're often reading the wealthy are able to avoid paying taxes. If true, how is it that the top 1% are paying 30% of the taxes?