Honest question about the PPACA
After reading the Forbes article about the Republican plan to replace Obamacare and the comments that followed, I was left wondering about a point that one commenter tried making over and over. Usually the left is quick to discredit known lies or exaggerations about this law but none were which peaked my interest in the truth. The claim is as follows:
If you sign up through one of the exchanges and receive a subsidy, the dollar for dollar equivalent of that subsidy will be deducted from any tax return that you would have received. In basic terms, if you received a subsidy reducing your monthly premium by $100, then $1200 would be deducted from your tax return. ($100 per month x 12 months = $1200)
I tend to doubt this claim asI've never heard it before but that doesn't necessarily mean it's not true. Does anyone here know if this is true or not?
Thanks for stopping by and for any information you might be able to provide.
Tags
Who is online
60 visitors

Like I said I tend to believe that this is not true but assuming that it is, that would be a major tax increase on those making under 400% of the federal poverty level. Basically using people's tax returns to fund this law.
Dan
I do not have a simple answer to your question, but this question came up in a discussion a few months ago and I cam across this article that might provide you information on the subject
Thanks for the reply Robert. It's much appreciated.
This actually does answer my question. According to the article, you only have to repay the subsidy if your income increases which in turn lowers your subsidy. It seems that if you report (to the IRS I presume) and income increase as soon as possible then the repayment of the subsidy would be very minimal but if you don't report the income increase it could end up being substantial. Depending on the amount of income increase and subsequent subsidy decrease of course.
Thanks again Robert.
We recommend that the health insurance exchanges mandated by the Affordable Care Act educate consumers about how the subsidies work and the need to promptly report income changes, the researchers said. We also recommend that they provide tools and assistance to determine the amount of subsidies that enrollees should take in advance.
This would seem to be an extremely important duty of the government. With all of the problems with the website I wonder if this is being done at all. No matter what there will people that were not aware of the way that this works and will be pretty ticked off at tax time when they do not get or get a significantly smaller refund than they were anticipating.
jennilee
You are suggesting that people will use the tax code complexity to avoid paying taxes.
Preposterous!
Dan,
As near as I can tell with the law, there is no mechanism in place to adjust subsidies during the year. So if Jan 1 you sign up and are getting a subsidy, and on May 1, you get a substantial increase in income, there is no way to adjust that subsidy as it has already been paid to the insurance company. So when you file your taxes, if you are getting a refund, the amount overpaid in subsidies, will be deducted. If you are not getting a refund, the amount overpaid in subsidies, you will owe as income tax.
Example:
We have a single 63 year old making $35,000 a year in NC. We have to consider this person is a non-smoker because he doesnt qualify for Medicaid which allows you to smoke all you want without any repercussions in premiums for doing so.
So this 63 year old using the same plans as above with 70/30 co-insurance and out of pocket of $6,350 will have a premium of $8,495 per year but will receive a subsidy of $5,171 leaving him to have to pay $3,325 per year for his healthcare premium plus the $6,350 out of pocket per year. Sounds pretty good.
Now lets say this 63 year old is not making $35,000 but is making $46,000 instead, what is his premium he has to pay now? The total premium will be $8,495 per year and will not receive a subsidy so he will have to pay the total of $8,495 per year.
So heres the difference. $8495 minus $3,325 is $5,170. So for making an additional $11,000 he will pay an additional $5,170 in premium and the Federal tax on that $11,000 will be 24.67% or rounded to 25% of $11,000 which is $2,750 totaling $7,920. This means he will clear less than $3,080 on his $11,000 additional income after paying the additional premium plus the Federal taxes on the $11,000 here in NC. Thats like having a 72% tax on that extra $11,000 income. Now I didnt calculate the additional state tax.
So what this means. If a person made $35,000 last year and his/her premium is based on that he will receive a $5,170 subsidy. But the question is, what happens when someone either takes on an additional job or receives a salary increase and makes an additional $11,000 in the current year?
Next year it appears he/she will owe that $5,170 back to the government because he/she didn't make $35,000 but made $46,000 instead. And the next year premium will be $5,170 more as well because he/she will not qualify for a subsidy.
It's just a big mess, that's all I can say.
Thanks Jim. It seems that you are correct, I just wonder because of this statement in the article:
We recommend that the health insurance exchanges mandated by the Affordable Care Act educate consumers about how the subsidies work and the need to promptly report income changes, the researchers said. We also recommend that they provide tools and assistance to determine the amount of subsidies that enrollees should take in advance.
Is there something in the law that the author of the article was aware of? One thing is for sure, tax time just got a lot more complicated for millions of Americans.
Thanks for responding jennilee. You bring up another point that I was wondering about. I haven't been on the exchange website so I'm not sure about the income portion that determines the amount of your subsidy. Do they ask for individual income, family income, total household income? It would seem to make a huge difference based on how you file taxes. For example, if you put your individual income into the subsidy calculator but you're married and file a joint return, your tax liability will be different than if you file single. You could end up owing the IRS a lot of money.
It's obvious to me now why the IRS is in charge of the financial part of this law. Once again, for the people not doing their homework on this they could be in for a very rude awakening come tax time.
You lose your subsidy in this example because if you live in NC and make $46,000, you're considered a one-percenter.
Six,
I thought about your post for a while before responding. Although I believe it is a bit of a spin on the situation to make it look bad for the law, the one thing I keep coming back to is that this is a major tax increase on those making over 400% of the federal poverty level because of the fact that they are mandated to buy insurance but are not eligible for any subsidy. The only quirk is with the people (a majority of Americans) that receive their insurance through their employer as part of their compensation package. Right now that money isn't taxed but I believe it will be in the near future. I'll have to spend a little more time investigating and thinking about how that plays into this.
Thanks for theresponse. It's much appreciated.