Why Economic Mobility Is Stuck In Neutral
The big news in the policy world on Thursday was the release of a new paper by Harvard economist Raj Chetty and four other authors on economic mobility.
The study found that, contrary to popular belief, economic mobility has remained stable over the past few decades.
Economic mobility is the ability of individuals to move up or down the income distribution ladder. This is a fundamental feature of the American Dream.
Politicians on both sides of the aisle have worried in recent years that economic mobility has been decreasing meaning that a person has less ability to make a better life for themselves.
Though this study suggest they're wrong on that point, they are not wrong about income inequality. Income inequality has grown in recent decades.
Here's how the authors describe these dueling trends:
"A useful visual analogy is to envision the income distribution as a ladder, with each percentile representing a different rung. The rungs of the ladder have grown further apart (inequality has increased), but children's chances of climbing from lower to higher rungs have not changed (rank-based mobility has remained stable)."
As BI's Steven Perlberg pointed out this morning , here's the visual representation of that:
This begs the question: If the rungs have grown further apart, why isn't economic mobility decreasing? Why isn't it harder for an individual to move up the income distribution as the gaps grow farther apart?
One reason is because the rungs of the ladders are not all moving apart. It's only the top rung and more like a sliver of the top rung that has separated from the rest of the pack.
The rise in income inequality is not driven by each income quintile moving away from one another as the ladder image above indicates. It's driven by the Top 1% skyrocketing away from everyone else. That means that moving up and down the income distribution hasn't grown more difficult - except for people trying to reach the very top. For everyone else, the distance between the bottom rung and middle rung has stayed the same.
In fact, the authors point this out in the study.
"One explanation for why this prediction [of reduced economic mobility] was not borne out is that much of the increase in inequality has been driven by the extreme upper tail," they write.
Here's a better representation of the ladder analogy that Chetty et al. used earlier:
Read more: http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-why-economic-mobility-hasnt-increased-2014-1#ixzz2rQQzxm1I

A I understand the results of this study is that upward economic mobility, climbing the ladder of succcess in pursuit of the American Dream has diminished very little in recent years, though the separation of the most
If you click on the link the author also provides a chart showing income changes for different societal segments over the past nearly thirty years
So the opportunity for our children and grandchildren to achieve a better life (a higher rung on the ladder) than we or their patents did, while not steadily increasing as it has in the past is at least not declining at this point in time.