╌>

Cherokee Children Part of Pivotal Study on Poverty

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  loretta-mashkawidee-kemsley  •  12 years ago  •  8 comments

Cherokee Children Part of Pivotal Study on Poverty

Growing up poor has long been associated with reduced educational attainment and lower lifetime earnings. Some evidence also suggests a higher risk of depression, substance abuse and other diseases in adulthood. Even for those who manage to overcome humble beginnings, early-life poverty may leave a lasting mark, accelerating aging and increasing the risk of degenerative disease in adulthood.

Today, more than one in five American children live in poverty. How, if at all, to intervene is almost invariably a politically fraught question . Scientists interested in the link between poverty and mental health, however, often face a more fundamental problem: a relative dearth of experiments that test and compare potential interventions.

So when, in 1996, the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians in North Carolinas Great Smoky Mountains opened a casino, Jane Costello, an epidemiologist at Duke University Medical School, saw an opportunity. The tribe elected to distribute a proportion of the profits equally among its 8,000 members. Professor Costello wondered whether the extra money would change psychiatric outcomes among poor Cherokee families.

When the casino opened, Professor Costello had already been following 1,420 rural children in the area, a quarter of whom were Cherokee, for four years. That gave her a solid baseline measure. Roughly one-fifth of the rural non-Indians in her study lived in poverty, compared with more than half of the Cherokee. By 2001, when casino profits amounted to $6,000 per person yearly, the number of Cherokee living below the poverty line had declined by half.

What Happens When the Poor Receive a Stipend?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    12 years ago

The poorest children tended to have the greatest risk of psychiatric disorders, including emotional and behavioral problems. But just four years after the supplements began, Professor Costello observed marked improvements among those who moved out of poverty. The frequency of behavioral problems declined by 40 percent, nearly reaching the risk of children who had never been poor. Already well-off Cherokee children, on the other hand, showed no improvement. The supplements seemed to benefit the poorest children most dramatically.

When Professor Costello published her first study , in 2003, the field of mental health remained on the fence over whether poverty caused psychiatric problems, or psychiatric problems led to poverty. So she was surprised by the results. Even she hadnt expected the cash to make much difference. The expectation is that social interventions have relatively small effects, she told me. This one had quite large effects.

 
 
 
Larry Crehore
Freshman Silent
link   Larry Crehore    12 years ago

Great article Loretta Thank you for sharing it her. My own opinion is that the last nine paragraphs say the most about this test. It was done by the Cherokee for the Cherokee and the out come is monumental.

5022_discussions.jpg

"Professor Costellos findings are not necessarily a sweeping endorsement of Native American gaming, and casinos generally. Rather, they suggest that a little extra money may confer long-lasting benefits on poor children. And in that respect, the Cherokee experience is unique in several important ways.

First, this was not a top-down intervention. The income supplements came from a business owned by the beneficiaries. The tribe decided how to help itself. Moreover, the supplements werent enough for members to stop working entirely, but they were unconditional. Both attributes may avoid perverse incentives not to work.

Also, fluctuations in the casino business aside, the supplements would continue indefinitely. That ad infinitum quality may both change how the money is spent and also protect against the corrosive psychological effects of chronic uncertainty.

And maybe most important, about half the casino profits went to infrastructure and social services, including free addiction counseling and improved health care. Ann Bullock, a doctor and medical consultant to the Cherokee tribal government, argues that these factors together which she calls the exercising of collective efficacy also may have contributed to the improved outcomes. She describes a sea change in the collective mood when the tribe began to fund its own projects. A group that was historically disenfranchised began making decisions about its own fate.

You feel controlled by the world when youre poor, she said. That was simply no longer the case.

Professor Costello and Professor Akee dont entirely agree. They think cold hard cash made the real difference. For one thing, Professor Akee says, outcomes started improving as soon as the supplements began, before many of the community-wide services went into effect.

If thats the primary take away, then we have some thinking to do. Some people feel that if youre poor, its because you deserve it, Professor Costello said. If youre sick, its because you deserve it, she said.

But if giving poor families with children a little extra cash not only helps them, but also saves society money in the long run, then, says Professor Costello, withholding the help is something other than rational.

Youre not doing it because it pains you to do it, she said. Thats a very valuable lesson for society to learn.


 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

This is astounding, Loretta. And it will be kept well under wraps for the most part. The federal government cannot afford for this study to be well circulated for it would mean that the government itself, by not honoring its treaties with Indians and providing promised schools (education), economic development on the reservations (jobs, thus a rise from poverty), and even nominal sanitation and heath opportunities, has itself been the cause of the abysmal conditions affecting the Indians on the poorest reservations.

The bastards in Washington, over the last couple of hundred years, all "need killin'" even the ones that are already dead. (That is a colloquialism, folks, heartfelt though it is.)

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Loretta - it is sad that psychologists and psychiatrists have been given ample source material from many, many other tribes who haven't had the influx of outside funds to change the conditions on/off the reservations, and they haven't utilized those resources or the studies they conducted weren't published and discussed as openly.

Poverty impacts all who are in that stage and it makes no difference as to your ethnicity nor background.

I am glad to see the publication of this study - I just hope the meaning and future of the Indians stuck in poverty reach the "Great Hallowed Halls" of Congress and they act on the recommendations of the study.

Good find.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    12 years ago

My own opinion is that the last nine paragraphs say the most about this test. It was done by the Cherokee for the Cherokee and the out come is monumental.

The money was provided by the Cherokee for the Cherokee. That's true, but it wasn't a test. That was done without any knowledge this study would occur. The study was not planned or done by the Cherokee. That was accomplished by Costello.

But yes, those paragraphs are important. They contain conclusions we can use to alter how we help the poor. Thanks for pointing that out.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    12 years ago

While I spotlighted the Cherokee involvement, you are correct in stating all who are stuck in poverty would be similarly affected.

Here's a line that really struck me:

You feel controlled by the world when you're poor, she said. That was simply no longer the case.

That's an important observation. That is exactly how it feels. The poor have no power, thus those who do have power feel free to make their life even more miserable whenever they choose to do so. They make decisions that adversely impact the poor without any adverse consequences. I suspect they make them because it makes them feel powerful while callously ruining the lives of so many others.

 
 
 
Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Loretta Mashkawide'e Kemsley    12 years ago

Of course it is the government's fault they broke those treaties, which makes them responsible for all the ill-effects that resulted. This is right on when it comes to the role of government and those who support its policies toward both Indians and the poor wherever they're found:

But if giving poor families with children a little extra cash not only helps them, but also saves society money in the long run, then, says Professor Costello, withholding the help is something other than rational.

Youre not doing it because it pains you to do it, she said. Thats a very valuable lesson for society to learn.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

That's an important observation. That is exactly how it feels. The poor have no power, thus those who do have power feel free to make their life even more miserable whenever they choose to do so. They make decisions that adversely impact the poor without any adverse consequences. I suspect they make them because it makes them feel powerful while callously ruining the lives of so many others.

BINGO, tried and true assessment....

 
 

Who is online



70 visitors