╌>

Protect Teaching, Not Tenure

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  7 comments

Protect Teaching, Not Tenure

Like tweed jackets and same-sex dorms, academic tenure is fast becoming a relic of the past. In 1975, almost half of all teachers at U.S. colleges and universities either had tenure or were in line for tenure; by 2011, that share had fallen to one-fourth. Now, almost two-thirds of instructors are part-time adjuncts, most of them poorly paid, or graduate students.

Reasonable people can disagree on the merits of tenure, which protects professors from summary dismissal. The more pressing question is whether the system that is replacing it makes sense for students or society as a whole.

Students go to college to learn, obviously, and society benefits from both the training they receive and the research they help conduct. The issue, then, is not how to save or end tenure. Its how to restore teaching to its rightful position in U.S. higher education.

Its not as if top universities arent lavishing attention on their tuition-paying customers. Its just that a falling share of money is going toward teaching. Spending on student services has been growing almost twice as fast as spending on teaching costs. The share spent on nonacademic functions, such as alumni and public relations, is also growing faster.

This change may not have been conscious, let alone deliberate. It is a consequence of declining state funding, growing competition for students and a perceived need for a more flexible curriculum.

Like most changes made under pressure, this one is not all good. Administrators may like the ability to fill more positions with cheaper and easy-to-replace nontenured teachers. When four-year colleges increase their use of part-time instructors, however, graduation rates fall. The reason isnt clear -- though it probably has something to do with their relative lack of office hours (for adjuncts, both offices and hours are often in short supply) and their relative lack of familiarity with the latest research (because theyre less likely to be doing any of that research).

The hopeless plight of the comp-lit post-doc student is not necessarily a matter of public concern. It is concerning, however, if fewer Americans are seeking careers in one of Americas most successful (if its not too crass a term) industries.

All of which brings us back to the question of how to make an academic career more attractive to students, and to make teaching a more important part of an academic career. Tenured faculty members can help by insisting their nontenured colleagues receive equal institutional support -- allowing them to participate in department meetings, for example, or get money to attend conferences, or receive support for submitting research grants.

Meanwhile, colleges and universities can adopt new contracts that occupy a middle ground between tenure for life and annual renewal. Multiyear contracts, as some schools are offering, are one option. Another possibility is to offer new professors the possibility of tenure -- but only to the age of 65, followed by contract employment.

The federal government also has a role to play. It can discourage overreliance on adjunct professors by making the share of part-timers at any given school a component of the new university scorecard announced by President Barack Obama last year. Accreditation agencies, whose stamp of approval is required by universities and colleges seeking to qualify for federal student aid money, could also set maximum thresholds for the use of adjuncts.

Ideally, a generation from now, U.S. colleges and universities will still be the envy of the world, and teaching will remain at their core -- both in principle and in practice. In that sense, whats less important for schools is to protect the status of individual teachers as much as the profession itself.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Reasonable people can disagree on the merits of tenure, which protects professors from summary dismissal. The more pressing question is whether the system that is replacing it makes sense for students or society as a whole.

Students go to college to learn, obviously, and society benefits from both the training they receive and the research they help conduct. The issue, then, is not how to save or end tenure. Its how to restore teaching to its rightful position in U.S. higher education.

Its not as if top universities arent lavishing attention on their tuition-paying customers. Its just that a falling share of money is going toward teaching. Spending on student services has been growing almost twice as fast as spending on teaching costs. The share spent on nonacademic functions, such as alumni and public relations, is also growing faster.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Reasonable people can disagree on the merits of tenure, which protects professors from summary dismissal.

Every working person needs to be protected from summary dismissal, that as a matter of fairness.

In the absence of a due process policy in the workplace, individuals are vulnerable to being fired for "reasons" such as "insubordination" -- an oft-used euphemism for otherwise arbitrary, capricious and/or insidious, retributive actions by employers.

In the early 1980's, I represented a female elementary school teacher who was suspended for "insubordination" by a school administrator who suggested the teacher meet him during the Christmas holidays for some "good sex." She declined several such requests and soon thereafter was "written up" for insubordination.

Tenure in teaching at various levels IS NOT IMMUNITY FROM DISCIPLINARY ACTION, RATHER A TENET THAT ASSURES DUE PROCESS AND THE SATISFACTION OF A BURDEN OF PROOF REGARDING ANY ALLEGATIONS LEVELED.

Where there are no such tenets, nepotism, sexual harassment, racism, religious prejudices and other "reasons" for dismissal are an inherent danger to workers.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

I agree that

Every working person needs to be protected from summary dismissal

And that is accomplished through EEOC and other government regulations that protect workers thus can be accomplished without the tenure process

Wrongful termination is an oft litigated issue and workers can indeed be protected from discriminatory termination without tenure in my view

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Wrongful termination is an oft litigated issue and workers can indeed be protected from discriminatory termination without tenure in my view

The difficulty with filing a complaint with the EEOC is what happens in the interim between dismissal and adjudication. An employee can be wrongfully terminated and without any income or benefits while waiting in limbo.

Where there are tenure laws or negotiated agreements with due process provisos, an employee may get a hearing in "a timely fashion" and possibly have his case taken to arbitration by a representative organization.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

There are other agencies and processes other than the EEOC that also protect the worker's rights and far more industries (jobs) without tenure than jobs with tenure

I am not against tenure per se, but the point of the article (at least how I interpreted it) was that preserving and protecting "teaching and learning was more important than tenure.

I agree that there can be issues where employees (teachers and others) are not treated fairly when they are not tenured and I think you might also agree that there those that use tenure to ride along without expending real effort or making real contributions. The options for a different tenure offered in the article might be the answer

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"teaching and learning was more important than tenure.

They are not dependent upon one another; they can co-exist without conflict. Tenure does not protect incompetent teachers -- that's a piece of demagoguery used by those who would privatize learning institutions and arbitrarily cut salaries and erode working conditions.

MYTH:

Tenure is a lifetime job guarantee.

REALITY:

Tenure is simply a right to due process; it means that a college or university cannot fire a tenured professor without presenting evidence that the professor is incompetent or behaves unprofessionally or that an academic department needs to be closed or the school is in serious financial difficulty. Nationally, about 2 percent of tenured faculty are dismissed in a typical year.

If it is difficult --- purposely difficult --- to fire a tenured professor, it's also very hard to become one. The probationary period averages three years for community colleges and seven years at four-year colleges. This is a period of employment insecurity almost unique among U.S. professions. People denied tenure at the end of this time lose their jobs; tenure is an "up-or-out" process.

During the probationary period, almost all colleges can choose not to renew faculty contracts and terminate faculty without any reason or cause. Throughout this time, senior professors and administrators evaluate the work of new faculty-teaching, research and service before deciding whether or not to recommend tenure. The most recent survey of American faculty shows that, in a typical year, about one in five probationary faculty members was denied tenure and lost his or her job.

Faculty members remain accountable after achieving tenure. Tenured faculty at most colleges and universities are evaluated periodically-among other things, for promotion, salary increases and, in some cases, merit increases. Grant applications and articles for publication are routinely reviewed on their merit by peers in the field. If basic academic tenets and due process rights are observed, this kind of accountability is wholly appropriate. A finding of incompetence or unprofessional conduct can still result in firing.

Got lots more if you'd like.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

As I stated I have no disagreement with tenure per se but think that protecting tenure should take a back seat to improving teaching and the learning process.

I appreciate the info and the back and forth

I have been an instructor (military) and teacher/instructor (private sector) and have great respect for good teachers and total disdain for bad teachers which I am sure is how most people feel

Again thanks for the feedback and perspective

 
 

Who is online


70 visitors