"Jesus (PBUH) and Mohammed" (PBUH) religious satire - protected freedom of speech or racist hate speech?
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 12 years ago • 9 commentsFrom their website (Link ):
About
What is Jesus and Mo?
Its a weekly comic strip, dealing in religious satire.
Who's in it?
Questions:
1. Should these be banned because they might insult some people-- or even because they might make some people act violently?
2. Should the rights to free speech guaranteed by the Constitution allow speech that insults public figures be allowed (for example, insults to Pres. Bush, Pres. Obama, Ted-Cruz, Bernie-Sanders, Miley Cyrus, Justin Bieber, etc)-- but speech that might insult a religion (and therefore force members of a religion to become violent ) be banned?
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

Oh dear-- I hope that posting this does not offend anyone (and therefore force them to become violent!
)
Whether it should be banned because it might insult some people and make them act violently is a moot point, because you just can'tinsulate everyone from everything that might upset and anger them.
People have to hit the "Reset" button and go back to the common sense scale of what is socially acceptable instead of doing and sayingjust what they damn well please because the courts say their interpretation of the letter of the law allows it.
You can insult someone's religion because the law allows you to, but be ready to accept the consequences of an unlawful reaction from the insulted party.
You can ignore the stated rules of a movie theatre when they tell you for the courtesy of other patrons to turn off your cell phones, but be ready to accept the consequences of an unlawful reaction from a ticked off fellow viewer if you don't.
I don't find the cartoon offensive, but I am neither Christian nor Muslim nor Jewish. I wouldn't show the cartoon to my sister who is Christian, nor my friend who runs the corner store and is Muslim, but I would show it to my Jewish friend who has a great sense of humor. (He once told me his Dad was a great guy, "but he's so old fashionedmight have killed Jesus." This was many years ago when we wereyoung and irreverent.)
Actually that point was raised several times during the "Mohammed Cartoon Crisis", I believe it was in 2005 (a Danish newspaper published several satirical cartoons about Mohammed. Many Muslims, acting out on the erroneous belief that Islam forbids depictions of Mohammed, started riots and boycotts of Denmark-- resulting in over 140 deaths and, ultimately, increased business for Danish companies).
There was a lot of discussion about events. But some people agreed with a point you made-- basically, just because the law allows you to do something, that does not necessarily mean its a good idea to do it.
Along that line of thinking, I've wondered if it was by accident or design that the Westboro Baptist Church bastards never got around to trying to "attend" the services of a fallen service member from certain areas of the Deep South.
Just because the less than honorable Supreme Court decreed it lawful for them to do so doesn't guarantee they would have been able to walk away from such a stupid and disrespectful and SOCIALLY UNACCEPTABLE farce without serious consequences had they tried it in certain areas.
It's odd that the letter of the law has stripped away the glue that held the fabric of society together... common courtesy and respect for others.
I think that there are primarily two reasons why it may not be a good idea to do something-- even if its perfectly legal:
1. Out of respect for other person(s). "Common courtesy".
2. Out of respect for yourself!-- if taking that action in all likelihood would result in harm to yourself.
Doing something that flies in the face of strongly held (and emotionally charged) beliefs of others can be quite risky-- whether or not you judge your actions to be justified-- even to be taking "the moral high ground".
And, speaking of the Deep South-- civil rights protestors-- doing "in your face" protest marches-- even sit-ins-- were going against the prevailing system of values. Many suffered the consequences-- enduring beatings...and in some cases even death.
It does seem that in the last few years such concepts as common courtesy and respect for others have, for the most part, fallen by the wayside. However I wonder if rulings of the Courts have been the cause...? (And if that's not the cause of this-- what then actually accounts for it?)
How dare you offend the goddess Miley Cyrus !
Civil Rights was worth dying for and it was past time for that change.
If anyone can give me a good reason to disrespect the burial services of anyone being sent to walk on by their loved ones... regardless of the life style of the deceased or the religion of the mourners... I will entertain a discussion on the subject.
We used to have laws that said stated you could not swear in common public places. If you were in a bar and heard such words, it could be expected. But families with children shopping in grocery stores and department stores, visiting parks and playgrounds, did not, and juveniles on the street did not engage in it for shock value.
The courts say it is free speech and now you can't go to a restaurant without having to listen to it. It was the beginning of the breakdown of common courtesy in society.
Who, now, can you NOT gutter-talk to? Why, a policeman with a gun, of course, and a high and mighty judge in a court of LAW surrounded by bailiffs wearing guns to protect the judge who will not allow you to swear at him.
Not allowed to yell fire in a crowded theatre? Do you know how much rage a person takes home every day because a boss or a customer or a rude cop or just a few dozen rude people in the course of a day may have called him/her an idiot/stupid/fool/bitch/motherfucker/bastard/sonofabitch/ in public or at work and they couldn't do anything about it?
It's legal, it's free speech. Someone on a ball field can call your child a lamebrain, a dumb ass who missed the ball, someone can call your wife a bitch to your face, or a hag... it's legal, and you are impotent. The law says you have the DUTY to retreat. Your wife or child is looking at you with tears in their eyes and as a dad you have the DUTY to protect them and stand up for them, and just a few years ago you could have knocked the jackass on the nose and even if he beat your ass you could have felt some pride that you gave it your all... but, no, if you throw a punch you get arrested, go to jail, your family finances take a hit on the bail bond, you could lose your job with the arrest, you have to miss work to go to court, you have a record of assault, you're stuck with the bills for the other guy's medical and your own, he can sue for civil charges, your child is kicked off the team or you're banned from attending games... the law says you have a DUTY to retreat and from then on the bully OWNS you and your child is the object of ridicule at school.
Oh, yeah, I think it started with the courts throwing common sense out the window.
I would miss Doonesbury, too, JT.
But I remember clearly the day Doonesbury was moved, in my local paper, from the "Cartoon" section to the "Editorial" section.
True. And I for one am glad to live in a country where we have that right.
But those rights vary from country to country. Some go to the other extreme, meting out severe punishments-- even death-- for allegedly insulting a religion or its prophets.
Some people freak out when they feel their religion or one of their so-called "holy" men are insulted.
Yet some of the protesters themselves said some insulting things. Here's a protest in front of the Danish Embassy in London-- notice what they are chanting, and notice what some of their signs say: