Justices skeptical of Obama’s recess apointments -- Stephen Dinan, The Washington Times 1/13/2014
Supreme Court justices took a dim view Monday of President Obamas claim of almost unlimited powers to appoint top government
officials, saying he appeared to be breaking with the founders vision of separation of powers between the branches of government when he tried an end-run around the Senate in 2012.
Both liberal and conservative justices seemed skeptical of the presidents claim, though they struggled with how far to go in deciding the limits of a presidents recess appointment power.
SEE ALSO: Obamas end run around Congress draws further review from Supreme Court
If they ruled narrowly, they could simply overturn Mr. Obamas 2012 appointments by finding he tried to act when the Senate considered itself still in session. But the court could act more broadly and rule that the presidents recess powers only apply to a narrow set of positions that become vacant when the Senate has finished business for the year, and that the president can only fill those jobs during that same recess break.
Obama administration Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli urged the justices not to interfere with the system, saying that even if it violates the Constitutions language, the executive and legislative branches over the decades have reached a balance that could be upset by the court s intervention.
We have, I would submit, an equilibrium that has emerged, he said. What we are advocating here is the status quo.
He acknowledged that the recess appointment power has become a safety valve for the president.
But Justice Stephen Breyer said the administration is trying to use the recess powers as an end-run around senators who want to block appointments something the justice said wasnt part of the Constitutions plan.
I cant find anything so far that says the purpose of this clause has anything to do with power has instead become a tool presidents of both parties have used to circumvent Congress when senators have tried to obstruct his nominations.
At stake in the case before the court is when the presidents powers can be used, and on what nominations.
Read more: http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/jan/13/justices-skeptical-obamas-recess-appointment-claim/#ixzz2qJ0ZaIhD Follow us: @washtimes on Twitter
Tags
Who is online
80 visitors

Clipping the dictator's wings?
did the king get slapped once before for these shenannigans?
Not seriously!
This is serious for him.
PresidentObama treats limits on executive power like college students treat the 21-year drinking age, and judging from oral arguments Monday the Supreme Court may respond by limiting his driving privileges. The vote may even be 9-0 that a President can't tell Congress when it is in recess so he can shred the Senate's power to offer "advice and consent" on his nominees.
If the President can arbitrarily declare the Senate in recess when it gavelled in the day before, what's to stop him from making recess appointments overnight, or on the weekend, or any other time the Senate is "unavailable" to act on his nominees? Contrary to White House claims that pro-forma sessions are a sham, the Senate conducted business during those days, even passing an extension of the payroll tax cut.
As JusticeAnthony Kennedy put it to Mr. Obama's lawyer, Solicitor General Donald Verrilli: "Your argument [that the President can define a recess] is, it seems to me, in search of a limiting principle. A lunch break, a one-day breakyou've thought about thisa three-day break, a one-week break, a one-month break. How do you resolve that problem for us?"
More: