╌>

War on Poverty at 50 -- despite trillions spent, poverty won

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  joanne-odel  •  12 years ago  •  13 comments

War on Poverty at 50 -- despite trillions spent, poverty won

Fifty years ago today, President Lyndon Johnson delivered his first State of the Union address, promising an unconditional war on poverty in America.Looking at the wreckage since, its not hard to conclude that poverty won.

If we are losing the War on Poverty, it certainly isnt for lack of effort.

In 2012, the federal government spent $668 billion to fund 126 separate anti-poverty programs.State and local governments kicked in another $284 billion, bringing total anti-poverty spending to nearly $1 trillion. That amounts to $20,610 for every poor person in America, or $61,830 per poor family of three.

How could we have spent so much and achieved so little?

Spending on the major anti-poverty programs increased in 2013, pushing the total even higher.

Over, the last 50 years, the government spent more than $16 trillion to fight poverty.

Yet today, 15 percent of Americans still live in poverty.Thats scarcely better than the 19 percent living in poverty at the time of Johnsons speech.Nearly 22 percent of children live in poverty today.In 1964, it was 23 percent.

http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2014/01/08/war-on-poverty-at-50-despite-trillions-spent-poverty-won/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

hearing some excerpts from johnsons state of the union where he launched this example of liberal foolishness, i was taken at how much the left repeats the same justification garbage with every suggestion of dumping tax dollars today:

"we must invest in housing, education"...sound familiar?

16 trillion, that sounds familiar too!

oh, and before the liberals dismiss as being something from fox. this morning top, lead stories on the big three:

msndnc: a new book by james carville, and 17 min of bush bashing

cnn: its cold in january

fox: obama's secretary of defense: obama cares about troops, but not the mission.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

the nyt works for hillary now, and gates recently stated she is basically unfit to be commander.

i wouldnt wipe my ass with the nyt

and your argument that it would have been worse, sounds alot like the justification for obama stealing that 700 billion from our children for "stimulus"

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Poverty didn't actually win . We merely changed the definition of it ...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

The war on poverty isn't about ending poverty its about buying votes.

This is how Johnson put it in his own words.

Ill have those niggers voting Democratic for the next 200 years.Lyndon B. Johnson to two governors on Air Force One -

These Negroes, theyre getting pretty uppity these days and thats a problem for us since theyve got something now they never had before, the political pull to back up their uppityness. Now weve got to do something about this, weve got to give them a little something, just enough to quiet them down, not enough to make a difference.LBJ

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

well, i suppose it could have been worse...lbj did not have the ability to roll out the program via a website. come to think of it, neither did obama, lol

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Liberals argue that we aren't spending enough money on poverty-fighting programs, but that's not the problem. In reality, we're losing the war on poverty because we have forgotten the original goal, as LBJ stated it half a century ago: "to give our fellow citizens a fair chance to develop their own capacities."

The federal government currently runs more than 80 means-tested welfare programs that provide cash, food, housing, medical care and targeted social services to poor and low-income Americans. Government spent $916 billion on these programs in 2012 alone, and roughly 100 million Americans received aid from at least one of them, at an average cost of $9,000 per recipient. (That figure doesn't include Social Security or Medicare benefits.) Federal and state welfare spending, adjusted for inflation, is 16 times greater than it was in 1964. If converted to cash, current means-tested spending is five times the amount needed to eliminate all official poverty in the U.S.

LBJ promised that the war on poverty would be an "investment" that would "return its cost manifold to the entire economy." But the country has invested $20.7 trillion in 2011 dollars over the past 50 years. What does America have to show for its investment? Apparently, almost nothing: The official poverty rate persists with little improvement.

That is in part because the government's poverty figures are misleading. Census defines a family as poor based on income level but doesn't count welfare benefits as a form of income. Thus, government means-tested spending can grow infinitely while the poverty rate remains stagnant.

Not even government, though, can spend $9,000 per recipient a year and have no impact on living standards. And it shows: Current poverty has little resemblance to poverty 50 years ago. According to a variety of government sources, including census data and surveys by federal agencies, the typical American living below the poverty level in 2013 lives in a house or apartment that is in good repair, equipped with air conditioning and cable TV. His home is larger than the home of the average nonpoor French, German or English man. He has a car, multiple color TVs and a DVD player. More than half the poor have computers and a third have wide, flat-screen TVs. The overwhelming majority of poor Americans are not undernourished and did not suffer from hunger for even one day of the previous year.

Do higher living standards for the poor mean that the war on poverty has succeeded? No. To judge the effort, consider LBJ's original aim. He sought to give poor Americans "opportunity not doles ," planning to shrink welfare dependence not expand it. In his vision, the war on poverty would strengthen poor Americans' capacity to support themselves, transforming "taxeaters" into "taxpayers." It would attack not just the symptoms of poverty but, more important, remove the causes.

By that standard, the war on poverty has been a catastrophe. The root "causes" of poverty have not shrunk but expanded as family structure disintegrated and labor-force participation among men dropped. A large segment of the population is now less capable of self-sufficiency than when the war on poverty began.

More at: (Subscription required)

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

So Gen...... How's that "Hope and Change" going for ya?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Nailed it Dean!

JoAnne....

How could we have spent so much and achieved so little?

Only approximately 28 cents of every dollar gets to the people who need it. Sounds like a lot of overhead, doesn't it?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    12 years ago

I agree, Egilman. I was just reading an article on the topic, with this statement that spurred me to think about it once again:

"So, what we learned is that big government can't solve the problem of poverty because it has exactly the wrong tools and exactly the wrong principles."

I commented on what I think needs to be done locally, with another commenter replying with thoughts that aligned:

" The causes of poverty are not the same everywhere. People in Detroit have different reasons for being poor than people in Seattle, Los Angeles, Miami and New York, so how could one massive plan ever possiblywork for everyone?

The Founders understood the diverse nature of our nation back when they wrote the Constitution. That's why they had only a few limited powers granted to the federal government and left everything else up to the states. Unfortunately, somewhere along the way, some politician decided that the federal government could be used to solve these sorts of problems while lining his pockets and helping his friends at the same time.

It's time to cut most of these programs loose and let the states run their own affairs again. "

I agree - a 'one-size-fits-all' approach does not work. And the only way to have a customized approach is to handle it locally.

Another comment I liked:

" But, if a state were to decide on some sort of program designed to help the people that are deemed to be "poor" in that state, why should a taxpayer in another state be obligated to fund that program?

I disagree completely with Romneycare in Massachusetts, but then again, I don't live there andit costs me nothing, so why should I care about what Massachusetts does?

If states were forced to fund their own programs without any federal funding, you'd see a lot less of those programs and a lot more fiscal responsibility. "

Makes sense.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Why You Should Forget About the Poverty Rate

According to the the official poverty measure, the U.S. has barely made a dent in eliminating economic deprivation since LBJ declared war on poverty. But remember: There are lies, damn lies, and outdated statistics.
Lyndon Johnson's administration created the official poverty rate. Ironically, it tells us little about his legacy fighting economic hardship. (Reuters)

If you want to appreciate just how much progress America has made fighting poverty since Lyndon Johnson declared his war on it 50 years ago this week, here's a tip: Forget the official poverty rate.

Well, don't forget it entirely . But do understand its limits. In 1964, the rate was 19 percent. Today, it's 15 percent, which, as my colleague Derek Thompson wrote yesterday , suggests we've barely made a dent in economic deprivation. But for such an influential and obsessed-over number, there's widespread agreement that the government's standard poverty measure is deeply flawed, and it almost certainly understates how much the social safety net has improved U.S. living standards over time.

In other words, there are lies, damn lies, and in this case, outdated economic statistics.

The poverty line itself is sort of the shag carpet of economic indicatorsa poorly-aged, 1960s throwback. It was first set during the Johnson administration at three times the cost of a basic diet because,at the time, the typical family was thought to spend about one-third of its income on food. Since then, it has mostly been adjusted for inflation rather than our changing spending habits , which today are geared less towards groceries, and more towards things like housing and healthcare.

The Census Bureau's method for deciding whether a family falls above or below the poverty line is also a problem, because it only considers pre-tax cash incomemeaning wages and government benefits like Social Security payments. What's wrong with that? Well, it ignores massive anti-poverty programs like food stamps, which families spend just like cash, or the Earned Income Tax Credit, which gives their finances a boost after tax season.

Our current approach to calculating poverty is so full of holes that, for the past few years, the Census Bureau has produced an alternative number known as the "supplemental poverty measure" or "SPM"which is bone-dry government speak for "the statistic you should really be paying attention to." Think of it as the official poverty rate's smarter, more realistic cousin.On the one hand, it accounts for additional expenses, like medical care and regional variations in housing. On the other, it better incorporates government benefits, like food stamps and housing subsidies. In the end, it usually comes out to be a little less than a percentage point higher than the official poverty rate.

That might not seem like an enormous difference, but what happens when the Census's new method is stretched back through time? That's what a group of researchers from Columbia University sought to find out in a pair of recent papers . They conclude that a) The U.S. has done a far better job fighting poverty than the official rate lets on and b) the safety net has played a key role in that success.

Unfortunately, the Census hasn't always collected all of the information it now uses to calculate its new poverty measure. But by pulling in data from other official sources and using some reasonable inferences, the studies reconstruct what the SPM might have looked like dating back to 1967. The results? If you hold living standards constant based on how families spent in 2012, the government has reduced real poverty by 10 percentage points since 1967, from 26 percent to 16 percent, even though the official poverty rate has stayed almost the same.


If you assume living standardsshouldhave increased as the economy did, the gains are a bit less impressive. In other words, if you think there should be a higher threshold for poverty today than in the 1960s, the SPM has only declined from 19 percent to 16 percent.

Finally, if the entire safety net from Social Security on down to food stamps, were entirely yanked away, the researchers find today's poverty rate would nearly twice as high today at 29 percentup from 27 percent in 1967.


In the end, even a 16 percent poverty rate is still unacceptably high. But it's important to recognize the progress that we've already made, and how we've made it. If you only look at the official poverty rate, you might be tempted to think the government's entire approach to solving it has been a flopthat it's time to embrace a conservative alternative by cutting benefits and (maybe) forcing more adults to work.But if you take a more nuanced view, it's clear that while the percentage of low-earning Americans has stayed stubbornly high through the years, the government has prevented a great deal of hardship through the safety net. It seems cruel to backtrack now.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

Fox stopped reporting news in 2007

all those millions who watch fox, where cnn and msdnc cannot even compare in viewiers, are obviously idiots. Kind of like the 5 million who had their own insurance policies and were happy, simply didnt know as much as obama did, that they were junk policies. right?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago
Luke 11:39-42
Luke 11:39-42 Then the Lord said to him, "Now you Pharisees clean the outside of the cup and of the dish, but inside you are full of greed and wickedness. You fools! Did not the one who made the outside make the inside also? So give for alms those things that are within; and see, everything will be clean for you. "But woe to you Pharisees! For you tithe mint and rue and herbs of all kinds, and neglect justice and the love of God
Liberalsprefer to give a fish instead of teaching to fish. It relieves the pang of guilt felt for having more than others, yet does nothing to lift those others up so they may gain.
Justice and love go hand-in-hand, or do not go at all.
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Aye, Larry.

There is clearly a difference between doing things to make the poverty-stricken more comfortable, and doing things to lift those people out of poverty.

Too much former, not enough latter.

 
 

Who is online



87 visitors