Cull the Stupid Tax Breaks
U.S. lawmakers return this week from their holiday recess to perform what has become an annual ritual: pretending to decide whether to extend dozens of temporary tax breaks .
The just-expired shelters -- for Hollywood filmmakers, rum producers and dozens of other constituent groups -- are a showcase for why the U.S. tax code is so mind-numbingly complicated and overdue for simplification. There are 55 breaks in all, costing taxpayers about $50 billion annually.
They are the essence of special-interest legislating. Every year or two, lawmakers lament that the tax breaks are oh so expensive; anxious lobbyists attend their fundraisers over the recess, campaign checks in hand; when Congress resumes, lawmakers somehow find a way to pass the tax bill, adding a few new breaks on top of the perennials (all retroactive to Jan. 1, of course).
Its crazy for Congress to be in this business at all. The best remedy would be a top-to-bottom tax-code housecleaning. Instead of granting special-interest favors through the annual pay-to-play ritual, throw out the thousands of exclusions, credits and deductions -- then lower rates for individuals and corporations alike.
Granting tax breaks on a temporary basis only makes matters worse. Millions of taxpayers are left hanging when Congress leaves town without renewing them. Consumers and corporations cant plan for their tax liabilities, so they postpone their spending and investment, leading to stalled economic growth and fewer new jobs.
Sadly, theres no immediate prospect of comprehensive reform . In the meantime, its worth distinguishing among the defensible, the indefensible and the downright ridiculous. Closing the stupidest tax breaks shouldnt have to wait. And in this respect, the automatic expiration of so many provisions could be a blessing in disguise. Congress can abolish the worst by simply letting them die.
Pending comprehensive reform, some deductions are worth preserving -- one for teachers who buy their own school-room supplies, for instance, and one that relieves underwater homeowners from having to pay taxes on forgiven mortgage principal. The research-and-development tax credit mitigates the too-high corporate tax rate and gives innovative companies a boost. Some provisions might be worth retaining if their design could be improved, such as the tax credit for wind power that isnt available to all low-carbon power sources and can therefore skew markets.
In the realm of the ridiculous are an excise-tax rebate for Caribbean island rum distillers and accelerated write-offs for Nascar racetrack construction. The financial-services industry is lobbying hard to win renewal of a 13-year-old break, costing more than $9 billion a year, to shelter revenue from overseas lending.
In general, breaks aimed at single industries or companies should go. Typically these have more to do with lobbying and campaign contributions than fiscal logic. Incentives that promote job creation and innovation are worth retaining. Likewise, breaks that make the code more progressive by favoring middle-income households, such as one for making homes more energy-efficient, are justified as part of a less-than-ideal system.
Congress shouldnt lose sight of the fact that comprehensive tax reform is the right answer. Until then, mini-reform is better than none.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-01-05/cull-the-stupid-tax-breaks.html
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

All of these deductions (and many more) need to be eliminated from the tax codes (personal and corporate) but until that is accomplished ......
The NFL is tax exempt, (not the teams)as is PGA. Yup, they are really hurting for money. /s
Comprehensive tax reform is a dream, way to much at stake for the politicians. (campaign donations, and plain old pay offs, in one way or the other).
Kavika
Should we then accept how it is as how is should be?
As for me, I think not and continue to try and get public servants back in office supplanting professional politicians and I keep expressing my views to those that are in office to work for the people and not for themselves.
Comprehensive tax code reform is complicated and will not come easy but it is an essential step in truly addressing the income inequality issues gripping the nation along with addressing the minimum wage issue, education reform an social safety net reforms
I refuse to give up but perhaps I am a modern day Quixote and tax reform is my windmill
No, we should not accept the status quo...The problem is that we are outgunned by the ones that want to keep it as it is. If the politicians wanted to change it they would.
I refuse to give up as well as you do Robert. But, as you said, some time I feel like Don Quixote, and the damn windmill keeps moving.
Kavika
But we must continue to joust with the windmill or give up
Neither options are that appealing but I choose the former as I am sure that you do
We need to enlist more knights to assist in the jousting and get rid of the folks building the windmills.
How is that for a convoluted metaphor
BadFish
Targeting any one group those that pay a lot or those that pay little or nothing is not real ta code reform
We need to revise and reform the entire tax codes to broaden the base, to eliminate deductions, credits, subsidies and adjustments and to make the rates in the tax code reflect the actual amount people and corporations will pay
That is what is needed
Where is Sancho Panza when you need him Mike?
flat tax, 15%, for all fed, state, and local..no deductions...no exceptions save poverty level. period
In my state of Florida , the sugar industry has been ripping off rest of the tax payers for decades :
But it isn't just tax breaks . Imported sugar subsidies also contribute to the support of the domestic industry and draining of the everglades st it can be used to grow cane [supported by the Army Corps of engineers ] is also a gov subsidy to this ripoff industry .
Are you kidding Petey. The Corp of Engineers are supporting the draining of one of the true natural wonders of the world.. What a bunch of crooks/assholes.
Petey
It seems to me that those subsidies are de facto tax breaks
Thanks for this as I have heard a lot of folks talk about the inequities of the sugar industry. I live din Ft Lauderdale for about four years but truly don't know a lot about the state any more
Kavika
To say that there environmental concerns in Florida is to understate the case I think
JoAnne
Not as equitable as it sounds and not likely to ever be accepted by the citizenry as a whole
Kavika
I foresee another article entitled "Tilting at Windmills" or "Where's Sancho?"
They are merely following orders . It's a shame that this industry has so much lobbying clout . Letting the glades go back to its pristine condition would be an ecological benefit ...
Should have been clearer in my comment. It is the politicians that are allowing this to happen.
What a wonderful thought of seeing the Glades in their pristine condition.