How A Federal Judge In Utah Adeptly Dismantled All Of The Arguments Against Marriage Equality
Fridays decision by a federal judge overturning Utahs constitutional ban on same-sex marriage (Amendment 3) represents the first major legal victory for marriage equality since the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the federal Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA). In that case, United States v. Windsor, the Court only addressed the question of federal recognition of marriage, and though procedural rulings in cases in other state have cited it, the Utah decision is the first time Windsor was cited to completely overturn a state law banning same-sex marriage. In an extremely readable opinion, Judge Robert Shelby an Obama appointee whose nomination was supported by both Sens. Orrin Hatch (R-UT) and Mike Lee (R-UT) explained not only why Windsor applied, but why the states arguments against same-sex marriage fell flat . - http://thinkprogress.org/lgbt/2013/12/21/3098351/utah-marriage-equality/#
Here is the link to the actual decision - http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/files/kitchen-court-ruling-131220.pdf
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
This is a must read for all students of jurisprudence and logic. Judge Robert Shelby does an excellent job of tearing holes the Utahs case. What makes it even more interesting is Judge Shelby uses the words and logic of Justice Antonin Scalia [who] wrote a scathing dissent in which he defended the idea of traditional marriage in the DOMA case.
The delicious irony here is that the Mormon Church (based in Utah), has been exporting their objections to same-sex marriage to other states in the form of hundreds of thousands dollars of ads urging people to vote against gay marriage such as in Californias Prop 8.
This just in : 10th Circuit Court denies Utahs Emergency Motion for Temporary Stay - SALT LAKE CITY Utah Gov. Gary R. Herbert filed seeking an Emergency Motion for Temporary Stay following a federal judges ruling that struck down Utahs ban on same-sex marriage, and on Sunday the United States Court of Appeals Tenth Circuit denied the motion.
Tags
Who is online
80 visitors
