Another slip down the slope from gay marriage -- Jeff Jacoby, Boston Globe12/22/2013
THE FEDERAL court decision this month that struck down most of Utah's anti-polygamy law as unconstitutional is a fresh reminder that slippery-slope arguments, so frequently ridiculed , deserve more respect than they get.
" Conservatives foresaw polygamy ruling ," a story in the Washington Times was headlined last week. It cited the "we-told-you-so" reactions of several longtime opponents of same-sex marriage, who have long argued that the radical transformation of marriage wouldn't end with gay wedlock.
"Sometimes I hate it when what I predict comes true," former Senator Rick Santorum tweeted after US District Judge Clark Waddoups held in favor of Kody Brown and his four wives, who had challenged Utah's ban on polygamy as a violation of their right to privacy. The judge's ruling still leaves plural marriage technically illegal in Utah, but only "in the literal sense" of having two or more marriage licenses. Otherwise, polygamy has now been effectively decriminalized in Utah a state admitted to the union on the condition that it forever ban the practice of polygamy .
Not every change in law or policy is the first step down a slippery slope to a more drastic or unwelcome change. No one imagines that requiring a license for a pet dog today means you'll have to get a license for a pet fish tomorrow. But when a longstanding consensus on the meaning of a bedrock societal institution is altered especially one as entwined with moral values and social attitudes as marriage it is nave or disingenuous to claim that even more extreme changes won't follow.
Yet time and again, advocates of same-sex marriage have pooh-poohed the warning that if marriage is redefined so that the sex of the spouses is irrelevant, it can be further redefined so that the number of spouses, or the family relationship of the spouses , is also irrelevant.
To be sure, many gay-marriage proponents oppose polygamy. Andrew Sullivan has long said society's rule should be: "We won't let you legally marry more than one person, but we encourage you to marry one." But if the essence of marriage is a right to marry whomever you love, what reasonable grounds are left for saying no to polygamists like Kody Brown and his multiple wives? Or to any other union of consenting adults ?
When the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled in 2003 that same-sex couples had a constitutional right to marry, the majority opinion dismissed such concerns. "Plaintiffs seek only to be married, not to undermine the institution of civil marriage," Chief Justice Margaret Marshall wrote . "They do not attack the binary nature of marriage, the consanguinity provisions, or any of the other gate-keeping provisions of the marriage licensing law."
But ideas have consequences often, unintended consequences. That is particularly true in a legal system that places so much emphasis on precedent and analogy.
In 1989, as Massachusetts lawmakers were about to enact a law barring discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation, the Boston Globe assured its readers that the bill wouldn't legalize gay marriage or confer on same-sex couples the right to marriage-like civil unions. "Nor does passage of the bill put Massachusetts on a 'slippery slope' toward such rights," it editorialized. Yet when the SJC ruled that same-sex couples could not be barred from marrying, as UCLA law professor Eugene Volokh has noted , "part of its reasoning rested on the legislature's decision to ban sexual orientation discrimination." That slope was slippery, after all.
This happens frequently in the law. The US Supreme Court ruled in the 1965 case of Griswold v. Connecticut that married couples had a constitutional right to privacy that encompassed the freedom to use contraceptives. During oral argument, Justice Hugo Black wondered whether the court's logic could lead to "invalidat[ing] all laws that punish people for bringing about abortions." The suggestion was dismissed, as slippery-slope arguments so often are, as groundless.
"Yet only seven years after Griswold , in Eisenstadt v. Baird , the Court relied on Griswold to hold that unmarried couples have a right to use contraceptives," Volokh points out. "The following year, the Court used Griswold and Baird as the foundations for recognizing a right to abortion" in Roe v. Wade just as Black had warned.
Supporters of same-sex marriage or of any other controversial policy should be honest enough to acknowledge that it may pave the way to future changes that they don't support. What they shouldn't do is sneer that slippery-slope arguments are inherently baseless. As a judge in Utah has just reminded us, X can indeed lead to Y .
( Jeff Jacoby is a columnist for The Boston Globe ).
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

Rick Santorum was pilloried 10 years ago but he was prophetic:
REVIEW & OUTLOOK
WS Journal
A pril 25, 2003
"
Santorum and Tolerance
Excerpts:
In his now-famous interview with an AP reporter, the Pennsylvania Republican discussed the implications of the Supreme Court's pending decision on a Texas sodomy law. If the Supreme Court says that you have the right to consensual sex within your home," Mr. Santorum said, "then you have the right to bigamy, you have the right to polygamy, you have the right to incest, you have the right to adultery. You have the right to anything."
His political critics quickly accused him of bigotry and Trent Lottism. But what he really said is that there is no "right to privacy" on sexual relations in the penumbras and emanations of the Constitution, a view held by tens of millions of Americans. If individual consent (or privacy) were to become the only Constitutional measure involved in sanctioning sexual relations, then no legislature anywhere would be able to draw lines against any kind of sexual conduct.
Mr. Santorum's argument is almost identical to that of Justice Byron White in 1986 when the Supreme Court refused to overturn another sodomy law in Bowers v. Hardwick: "[I]f respondent's submission is limited to the voluntary sexual conduct between consenting adults, it would be difficult, except by fiat, to limit the claimed right to homosexual conduct while leaving exposed to prosecution adultery, incest, and other sexual crimes even though they are committed in the home. We are unwilling to start down that road." White was appointed by Jack Kennedy.
It's true that Mr. Santorum also made clear that, while he had no problem with homosexuality, he disapproves of "homosexual acts," the condoning of which he believes is, like adultery or polygamy, "antithetical to strong, healthy families." That's pretty much the position of the Catholic church, which teaches that homosexual acts are sinful but demands that its faithful (Mr. Santorum is one) "love the sinner." Gay Americans may disagree, and they can make that clear in the next election, but the Constitution doesn't have religious tests for holding public office.
The demonization of Mr. Santorum tells us that his opponents really aren't interested in a legal or moral debate. To the contrary, their aim is to eliminate any debate by tagging as a bigot anyone who dares hold an opposing view -- especially if that view happens to be grounded in religious orthodoxy. It strikes us that their argument for tolerance would be far more persuasive if its advocates could bring themselves to extend it to Mr. Santorum.
URL for this article:
Of the five acts forecast, homosexual marriage, polygamy, incest, adultery and bestiality, two have been approved by the courts in just the first ten years while the msm is shifting popular opinion in their favor.
Can the others be far behind as our nation morphs into Sodom (Recall what happened to that city)?
If that isn't a slippery slope I don't understand the meaning of the phrase.
Wait, Len. I will get you a banana.....
I knew you were rooting for something
I hope you didn't hurt yourself reaching for that, because that big of a stretch should have resulted in a much less feeble response.
I would trade you for nuts but you already exhibit plenty of that.