Unions Paid MSNBC's Schultz $177,000 in 2012, $75,000 in 2013
MSNBC host often touts "blue collar workers" and unionized "teachers" on his show.
Department of Labor search shows that not only is liberal MSNBC host Ed Schultz paid for his TV show and radio show, but he is getting a hefty amount of money from labor unions. Schultz received at least$177,000 from labor unions in 2012; the average median income for an American family is around $44,000 a year.
This year alone the DOL shows Schultz has been paid $75,000 by the AFL-CIO ;just yesterday AFL-CIO RichardTrumkaappeared on The Ed Show. As we ring in the new year in just a couple of weeks we will keep track of how much union pay for play Schultz gets in 2014.
http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/unions-paid-msnbcs-schultz-177000-2012-75000-2013
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

so, you mean the people vandalizing and threatening during the wisconsin legislation to get govt workers to contribute to their retirement plans may not have been grass root?
fair enough, but it seems obama's name has a much poorer rate of return than trumpka's
And Ed Schultz is paid by the Unions to put union thugs on TV and to praise them. We live in a pay to play universe......I keep saying the two sides of the aisle are nothing but different sides of the same coin.
lets not forget special ed shultz likes to call conservative women sluts, and celebrates a vice presidents possible death, and gets paid for that too.
no wonder hes still on msdnc
Teamster head James Hoffawarming the stage for President BarackObama in Detroit, Michigan. one thing about working people is, we like a good fight, and that they are ready to march he cried, Lets take these sons of bitches out and give America back!
nice obama has a suggestion of mass murder as an introduction, and not surprising
odd, i dont recall hoffa ever walking it back. obama claimed he was not even aware of it.
but of course, there were no apologies.
Ostrich head meet sand.
Pretty sure it was done before this comment.
That is worse than MSNBC getting the ad money. It is clearly a conflict of interest when Shultz uses his show to tout union policy without revealing that his commentary itself is union advertising.
Actually, it started here:
Jealous, Odell?
...
Fox News Paid Sarah Palin Nearly $19,000 Just to Say President Obama's Name
What about "contributions" from profit-making organizations who profit from favorable legislation?
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Invest in Democrats
(For an updated chart that includes contributions from Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae's PACs and employees to ALL lawmakers back to 1989, including to their leadership PACs, go here .) and data The federal government recently announced that it will come to the rescue of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, two embattled mortgage buyers that for years have pursued a lobbying strategy to get lawmakers on their side. Both companies have poured money into lobbying and campaign contributions to federal candidates, parties and committees as a general tactic, but they've also directed those contributions strategically. In the 2006 election cycle, Fannie Mae was giving 53 percent of its total $1.3 million in contributions to Republicans, who controlled Congress at that time. This cycle, with Democrats in control, they've reversed course, giving the party 56 percent of their total $1.1 million in contributions. Similarly, Freddie Mac has given 53 percent of its $555,700 in contributions to Democrats this cycle, compared to the 44 percent it gave during 2006.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have also strategically given more contributions to lawmakers currently sitting on committees that primarily regulate their industry. Fifteen of the 25 lawmakers who have received the most from the two companies combined since the 1990 electionsit on either the House Financial Services Committee; the Senate Banking, Housing & Urban Affairs Committee; or the Senate Finance Committee. The others have seats on the powerful Appropriations or Ways & Means committees, are members of the congressional leadership or have run for president. Sen. Chris Dodd (D-Conn.),chairman of the Senate banking committee, has received the most fromFannieand Freddie's PACs and employees($133,900 since 1989). Rep. Paul Kanjorski (D-Pa.) has received $65,500. Kanjorski chairs the House Financial Services Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Insurance and Government-Sponsored Enterprises, and Freddie Macand Fannie Maeare government-sponsored enterprises, or GSEs. Top Recipients of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Campaign Contributions, 1989-2008
Name
Office
Party/State
Total
1. Dodd, Christopher J
S
D-CT
$133,900
2. Kerry, John
S
D-MA
$111,000
3. Obama, Barack
S
D-IL
$105,849
4. Clinton, Hillary
S
D-NY
$75,550
5. Kanjorski, Paul E
H
D-PA
$65,500
6. Bennett, Robert F
S
R-UT
$61,499
7. Johnson, Tim
S
D-SD
$61,000
8. Conrad, Kent
S
D-ND
$58,991
9. Davis, Tom
H
R-VA
$55,499
10. Bond, Christopher S 'Kit'
S
R-MO
$55,400
11. Bachus, Spencer
H
R-AL
$55,300
12. Shelby, Richard C
S
R-AL
$55,000
13. Emanuel, Rahm
H
D-IL
$51,750
14. Reed, Jack
S
D-RI
$50,750
15. Carper, Tom
S
D-DE
$44,389
16. Frank, Barney
H
D-MA
$40,100
17. Maloney, Carolyn B
H
D-NY
$38,750
18. Bean, Melissa
H
D-IL
$37,249
19. Blunt, Roy
H
R-MO
$36,500
20. Pryce, Deborah
H
R-OH
$34,750
21. Miller, Gary
H
R-CA
$33,000
22. Pelosi, Nancy
H
D-CA
$32,750
23. Reynolds, Tom
H
R-NY
$32,700
24. Hoyer, Steny H
H
D-MD
$30,500
25. Hooley, Darlene
H
D-OR
$28,750
Includes contributions from PACs and individuals. 2008 cycle totals based on data downloaded from the Federal Election Commission on June 30, 2008.
Interesting, JoAnne. I wonder how much outside orgs pay Rachel Maddow, too? ...Just like all the talking heads, regardless of Party, are supported to 'say to play...and we'll pay'. To me, the point with the Unions is that union dues, imo, shouldn't be used to make talk show hosts wealthy, or union leaders, or WH Staff, but rather should be just enough to cover basic expenses to maintain a local. Unions are just a bunch of money-grabbing, opportunistic thugs. They might start out with good intentions, but any entity that accumulates wealth, doesn't stay in-line with 'good intentions,' imo.
I'll look for you to mention that again when the subject of INCOME DISPARITY comes up; it's heartening to see such a recognition. Until then
CEO-To-Worker Pay Ratio Ballooned 1,000 Percent Since 1950: Report
Beyond that,
Ben Shapiro Editor-in-Chief of TruthRevolt is
a Shillman Senior Fellow at the David Horowitz Freedom Center.
What credentials! No axes to grind in that crowd, JoAnne.
That's just the tip of the iceberg here's the part of that iceberg TRUTH-REVOLT(ING) did not bother to share.
All funds from speaking engagements were donated to charity, in keeping with company policy.
Ed has donated the honorarium from speaking engagements to charity, per network policy.
All the money he received for speeches went to charity; in this case, the American Cancer Society. A letter from the Society shows that it received $100,000, roughly half the total Schultz received from unions.
TRUTH REVOLTED AGAINST TELLING THE ACTUAL TRUTH!
I'm shocked.
_________________________________________________
Count on me as a friend to augment your posts, JoAnne.
i suppose msdnc has to make its money somehow, it really cant compete as a news network
And I thought we were friends having a mutual respect for one another.
I hardly have any thug friends so you're to be commended for having at least one me.
Many thanks it's so lonely here in UnionThugVille.
Broad brush much?
And I suppose you either did not read the reality I posted or are pretending you missed it.
In summary
All the money he received for speeches went to charity; in this case, the American Cancer Society. A letter from the Society shows that it received $100,000, roughly half the total Schultz received from unions.
Nothing I've said [or ever say - generally, is personal...that's not discussion of a topic when it goes there]. I've worked with the AFL-CIO, went to local meetings occasionally, and did not agree with where much of the money went.
My original statement stands... they are all about money.
sorry, that was suposed to have gone under a maddow comment. regardless of where ed sent the declared funds, i dont think anyone believes msnbc does not work for the dem party.
but then, thats just my opinion Amac my friend
Much of which goes to the working middle class Americans they represent, that in the face of the 1000% increase in CEO pay over workers since 1950.
Where does the traditionally anti-union money come from and where does it go?
JoAnne, it was sure apparent in the '08 election on NV...every MSNBC article was 'strongly' pushing Obama. They had to have been paid by the Democratic Party to do that.
Unlike the altruistic Fox News.
We just disagree and your opinion is no less important than mine or that of anyone else.
I don't perceive Fox News as even pretending to be altruistic . But msnbc does present itself as neutral and unbiased ... that is the real problem , not the bias .
That might depend on the particular local and company. What do you mean "much of which goes to the working middle class Americans they represent"?
Are you meaning any gains/losses made through bargaining (not physical dues contributions)? Again, that depends on the local and the company. Mine weren't generous with employees' gains - very minimal, and with some contracts, maybe just gains in certain areas...e.g. retiree benefits. I actually think that was good -- not a lot of greed going on...*except* union dues continued to rise! The union made out like a bandit, imo. As an aside, I've read some of the greedy details from a union such as the steel mills union--that never happened in my experience; employees understood that asking for the moon would only hurt everyone else. I don't like unions.
i know msnbc is a direct info dump for the dem party, and typically like to watch to see what they are going to float in propaganda.
Unlike the altruistic Fox News.
Which entity interviews both parties on a regular basis?
Its not the interviews [which they both do for both parties] . Its the "journalists" .
That's what I mean. Dues money pays for things like officials' salaries, arbitrations, legal fees, negotiators/negotiations, strike funds, health and welfare funds for represented members, operations, facilities PAC funds they don't even come close to corporate and private money given overtly and anonymously without limit (CU decision) to Republicans.
Greed and dishonesty by union officials is every bit as corrupt and wrong as when perpetrated by any one in a position of responsibility and trust.
Exactly! We are not all thugs.
CEO pay has enjoyed a 1000% increase over workers' pay since 1950. And corporate profits have been at record levels for several years.
I understand you don't like unions -- your prerogative -- but condemning them all as "thugs" -- not realistic.
imho, when the white house "forgot" to invite them to a meeting, the ag action against their reporter, and most recently, the parade of msdnc "journalists" leaving our white house after individual meetings with the executive, smaks just a tad as over the top propaganda outlet control
Wow!
Now there's a load of specifics!
Your idea of "journalism"
Discussion at its pinnacle.
And I wonder if you read what I posted about his giving that union money to charity.
You think?
Anyone can play the "I wonder" game.
It's called "innuendo" (an allusive or oblique remark or hint, typically a suggestive or disparaging one).
All you need to do is back it up with specifics.
Well...see, that's the thing. I didn't want any of that. I didn't utilize any part of the union, and would never expect to. I went to meetings once in a while to see what was going on. They claimed they had enough for about two month's pay for everyone in the event of a strike, continually encouraging everyone to back themselves up for at least six months, independently, because the company has as many salaried as non-salaried employees, so can suffice for a long time.
The company was doing just fine with scheduled raises, salaried and non-salaried got along just fine before the union came along. I didn't see any advantages on a personal level to having the union, and as I mentioned, at contract time, I would say the company often benefited more than the employees...yet the union dues always went up. It wasn't a strong local, but I actually thought that was best, as I mentioned.
I agree with you, they all aren't thugs...my experience proved that to a degree; but really, how good was that to get a hundred a month raise, but the union took 40% of it...and then with taxes... it really wasn't much of a raise.
Talk about "having balls"!
Hey Bill he gave the money to charity; tell the folks here who run with story from TRUTH-REVOLTING they forgot to mention it.
Are you saying that your dues amounted to 40% of your wages? Please clear that up for me. Typically, union dues are 1% of the negotiated salary per member.
Hey Fox lovers here's your "journalism"!
AT A CONGRESSIONAL HEARING TODAY!
Issa To Texas Health Official: 'You Need To Watch More Fox News'
Caitlin MacNeal December 17, 2013, 12:02 PM EST 16289
Talk all the bullshit you like; I prefer empirical information.
Anyone else want to talk "shills"?
Well A.Mac, what do you expect? They (Fox) did get a court to rule in support their right to lie and invent things.
And I still think they are the only news outlet that has had to do that to date.... Hmmmm.
I wonder if Bill-O ever came to understand what causes the tides to rise and fall? Not that the rest of his low information followers would care to understand.
I report, they decide
not to acknowledge it.
Reminds me quite a bit of some people we both know.
Not the annual salary, the increase, which isn't always the same percentage of cost of living with each contract, and some contract years, no raise. The percentage also depends on if the employee is at the top pay of their job title or not.
dennis,
That's true, but in the context of the particulars of this discussion, it is just rhetorical.
Who is the bigger culprit? The one the utters the lie, or the one that knows it's a lie but promulgates it.
They are partners-in-crime if they are both willing to keep the lie alive especially after it's been revealed as such.
There's a difference between spreading an opinion and spreading a lie; but once an opinion has either been specifically debunked, or, placed in serious question by virtue of a plausible set of counter-opinions or facts, those who fail to acknowledge that are somewhat like liars.
You don't even have to listen to all the BS by Ed. Just start at 2:40 seconds and you will get the message as to Ed Schultz hypocrisy.
And hes too stupid to even know it.
OK , but its alright to watch his fucking show ... Your "fucking" syntax is all fucked up !
J4T....... You talking to me? You can't be talking to me. I use to mess around on the Ed Schultz poll question on the vine, but I never watched the show to amount to anything. Ed is like eating a candy bar before dinner. After a few minutes of Ed you've lost your appetite. The first time I saw him I thought it was a comedy program.
I'll explain it.
Schultz, like all other taxpayers, are required to calculate their returns based on rates applicable to the tax year in which they must be filed. NO ON GETS TO NEGOTIATE THOSE RATES WITH THE IRS -- NOT YOU, NOT I, NOT ED SCHULTZ!
And unlike a lot of tax payers, instead of "pocketing" the money to which he is legally allowed under the tax code, SCHULZ GIVES A TON OF IT TO CHARITY! SO HE'S NOT "POCKETING" it in the way the caller and others imply!
And before some of us intentionally lose sight of the headline of this article and its intent to make Schulz look like a paid shill for unions, as I posted earlier HE GIVES ALL THAT MONEY TO CHARITY!
So before bashing Schulz for another (phony) issue, have the character to acknowledge the the initial bashing was bullshit from an organization that won't reveal "who" it is, whether or not it's a front organization for the Koch Brothers, or, give any other information about itself!
All funds from speaking engagements were donated to charity, in keeping with company policy.
Ed has donated the honorarium from speaking engagements to charity, per network policy.
All the money he received for speeches went to charity; in this case, the American Cancer Society. A letter from the Society shows that it received $100,000, roughly half the total Schultz received from unions.
We're not talking about syntax, Petey, we're talking about income tax.
Bad pun funny though.
Why don't you acknowledge that the implication of the headline of this article has been addressed and the important facts it omitted make it bullshit?
Pissed off are you let's see how selective your piss is.
Report: 26 U.S. Companies Not Paying Federal Income Tax
What about corporations whose attorneys write the loopholes that favor them in the tax code?
Not at all; people who earn below the poverty line (which the IRS defines and they do not), do not pay Federal Income Tax because the IRS set it up so as not to have to send refund checks.
These individuals still pay state, local and payroll taxes.
Corporations on the other hand, DO WRITE THE TAX CODE LOOPHOLES FROM WHICH THEY DIRECTLY BENEFIT! It's one of a number of deals they get for contributing without limit to legislators.
dennis, I never bluff when making a point. I back what I state and invite others to rebut with specific counter points if the are able to do so.
Fact Check: Mitt Romney's '47 Percent' Claims Wildly Inaccurate
good afternoon Amac sir.
how much of somones income, in %, do you believe a citizen has a right to keep?
JoAnne asked me,
Ideally, all of it, BUT, we don't live in "IDEALLY", we live in "REALLY".
As much as we'd like to believe we don't need government, that's simply pie-in-the-sky. The real question is, "What is fair when it comes to taxation" given we are all dependent to one degree or another on things like infrastructure, police and firefighters, food and drug safety standards, defense and other elements of what we think of as "civilization."
Let's use Social Security taxes as a kind of barometer regarding your question:
Using simple arithmetic, not taking anything else into account .062 x $113,700 = $7049.40
So, the CEO making i.e. $10,113,700/year pays $7049.40 in payroll taxes just like the man or woman making, in my example, $10 million/year less.
Is that fair? It's certainly not equitable, at least not theoretically or philosophically.
That multimillionaire will never need Social Security or Medicare benefits, but that's of no consolation to those who contribute as much in payroll taxes but who will likely need those benefits down the road. I'd advocate broadening the base and lowering the rate everyone pays payroll tax on every penny but pays at a much lower percentage. That doesn't hurt the millionaire and helps the little guy.
I believe that those who argue for "less government" really mean "less government for all but their wealthy selves". Cutting assistance for the working poor from the Farm Bill while giving billions to BIG AGRICULTURE is unconscionable.
In answer to your question, I can't give you a percentage; I can only answer by saying that as long as "fairness" and some human compassion are not some part of how a nation enacts its tax structure, the rich will be able to buy the government and live by the philosophy, "screw everybody else -- I GOT MINE!"
Unfortunately, those who see it that way, won't be satisfied until they also get MINE.
_______________________________________
Hope you are well.
thanks. i think 20% should be the max (including state, local, fed, all of it)
always nice conversing with you.
I think we set a good standard for dialogue when members don't agree (and of course, when they do).
Peace to you.
I'm some of both ideologies, why we don't fully agree, but sometimes, more or less, agree. There are two points made up above; one I agree with, but with one, I don't.
I want "less government," but there's no 'wealth' factor in it... it's strictly an 'ethics' pov relating to the individual - incentive to be the best one can be - motivation to try harder, do better because we want to think we will reap our own rewards from having done so. Income tax with a graduated system of "the more you make, the more we'll take" stifles any incentive to better oneself. Essentially, that's *punishing productivity.* Not very smart, ethical or an aid to man's self-worth.
I agree with a logical need for local taxes and infrastructure. I agree with taxes to support a country's needed infrastructure. But we all know very well that objectives by government officials have moved far away from those needs, and they legislate and collect taxes that steal our prosperity and 'individualism' from us.
Some like that because it selfishly benefits them, and others don't like it because it means loss of disposable income - that they worked harder to have, to enjoy their lives after the bills were paid. Why work harder if those extra dollars are going to be stolen from you and given to someone else?
__
Your second statement re subsidies, I agree with your point -- if subsidies are going to have to happen in that industry, then yes, it's 'wrong' to cut assistance to the working poor, but give billions to Big Ag. But there's your greedy government at work again --- why are they doing that? It sure isn't to help the Farmers---it's to help 'themselves' - the wealthy Congress to turn the corn or soybean crops into profits that benefit themselves, not in the best interests of 'food' for the nation.
So, instead of raising our taxes so that the gov can pull billions for Big Ag -AND- the working poor -- how about getting them to 'spread the wealth' of Big Ag's billions to their workers.
That only materializes when jobs are not exported to .25/hour labor markets and when the minimum wage in America is a "living" wage.
It's the Tea Party agenda that called that tune.
Exactly right; and that means consumerism immediately increases, and in an economy that's 70% consumerism, it will generate jobs, increase the tax base, reduce the amount of unemployment compensation, increase business profits
1. But there are still a lot of people employed in our country that are unhappy, realizing that working harder only means loss of income; we want to 'keep more' of what we earned, not only because we earned it, but why should we work harder, so that someone else doesn't have to. Doesn't make any sense.
2. I agree that the Tea Party in Congress is an influence, but I do not agree that they are the *only* influence.
3. Yes, putting money directly into the economy increases spending and prosperity--I've stated that myself in the past. But my point was more addressing 'where' it comes from. If we're going to let our wealthy and greedy Congress legislate subsidies, then they better not legislate them to benefit themselves--just like they do with tax codes--but rather, if we the taxpayers are going to be 'forced' to subsidize the wealthy --- then *they* had better be 'forced' to share those subsidies. Imo.
Or, if they would simply let the "Golden Rule" guide them once-in-a-while.
I agree, Dennis.
They [the wealthy Congress] use the lower class as an excuse to steal from the middle class for subsidies, while we all just ignore the fact that they are subsidizing themselves as well.
You broke the code!
dennis wrote,
dennis,
The seeder of this article asked me to comment on that topic
And so did you.
Anyway,
Merry Christmas to you and your family as well.
LoL...
isint that just following "the law of the land"?
nothing personal Amac sir, couldnt resist.
i am a proflat tax gal, no "loopholes", just income x 20%=amount of the check you write-staple it to the postcard with your w9, etc, and first class mail it.
(of course, would like it to be lower than 20%)
fire the irs, hundreds of thousands of attorneys, lobbyists, etc...gone
20% of $40,000 leaves the taxpayer with $32,000 whereas 20% of $1 million leaves the taxpayer with $800,000 (do their stock options get taxed, offshore accounts, bonuses, benefits, CEO perks, capital gains at the same rate as the $40k guys).
How is Hoffa a mass murderer?
yes, the definition of income, would be income
That would be a good start.
think of it, no more forms! no 200 to h/r block, etc.
all the saved time and money would be a huge boost to the economy too!
Are we getting rid of the W-2's, 1099's also will the 1040's just have three lines
LINE 1 My Income in Tax Year 20xx was $ X
LINE 2 20% of X is $______ (check enclosed)
LINE 3 Trust me, Signature _____________________________
Sorry, I think there needs to be one more line and a revision.
Line 1A My income from dividends, capital gains, and interest was $X________ X 39%=_________.
LINE 2 Line 1 X20%=_________ + sum of line 1A=___________ (check enclosed)
JoAnne, I agree with the flat tax for all of those reasons, too. I like the idea of 'everyone' is obligated to pay, not just some. No loopholes, and to make it more practical for low income, I would guess the percentage would need to be around 13%. They get a gift from the government of $1000.00, so that would pay their obligation, or close. Just think of all the lost revenues that would be collected if 100% paid instead of the current 49%. Then the trick is to try and figure out how to keep Congress from stealing it, and then passing arbitrary legislation of new tax burdens in an attempt to make up for it...which only leads to more bills...which only leads to more bills...which only leads to....
When are we going to pull our heads out of the sand and figure it out? Our Fed Representatives need to have a job in the community as everyone else does, for an income, with their Government jobs as a much lower paid second job than they currently receive, and the pay should be controlled by another agency of the people as a Federal employee. The two part time jobs might or might not pay them their current close to 200K a year...that's up to them, but the point is that they should be contributing in the same ways and means as 'the people' do, which might also change their attitudes... Sorry to tangent...one thing leads to another, sometimes.
A flat tax at this point will only cement the pooled money that is on the sidelines in place. You have to get that money back into circulation. This is one of the prime problems with our economy as is.
so, lets not try it. just like withobamacare, the left says: conservatives have no good ideas, over and over. what they really mean is, ok, if you dont like my idea to forward my agenda, then what ideas do you have TO FORWARD MY AGENDA!
meanwhile, keep repeating, the right has no plan, no suggestion, blah blah blah
No one is saying "let's not try it," they're saying let's refine it so it doesn't defeat it's own purpose.
And how many time has Obama challenged Republicans to come up with ideas to make the PPACA better only to have them offer nothing but repealing without replacing?
Not the same phenomena, JoAnne.
Can you explain 'why' it would cement it ? My thinking is that if they [extremely wealthy] can't prevent themselves from paying taxes [we would have to have control of the tax codes--not the current wealthy], then all of those hoarded or invested elsewhere dollars 'should' get put into circulation--as long as we have new mechanisms in place to 'control' what Congress does with the new influx.