ObamaCare's Troubles Are Only Beginning -- Be prepared for eligibility, payment and information protection debacles—and longer waits for care. -- Michael J. Boskin -- WSJ Opinion -- 12-15-2013
The White House is claiming that the Healthcare.gov website is mostly fixed, that the millions of Americans whose health plans were canceled thanks to government rules may be able to keep them for another year, and that in any event these people will get better plans through ObamaCare exchanges. Whatever the truth of these assertions, those who expect better days ahead for the Affordable Care Act are in for a rude awakening. The shockseconomic and politicalwill get much worse next year and beyond. Here's why:
The "sticker shock" that many buyers of new, ACA-compliant health plans have experiencedwith premiums 30% higher, or more, than their previous coveragehas only begun. The costs borne by individuals will be even more obvious next year as more people start having to pay higher deductibles and copays.
If, as many predict, too few healthy young people sign up for insurance that is overpriced in order to subsidize older, sicker people, the insurance market will unravel in a "death spiral" of ever-higher premiums and fewer signups. The government, through taxpayer-funded "risk corridors," is on the hook for billions of dollars of potential insurance-company losses. This will be about as politically popular as bank bailouts.
The "I can't keep my doctor" shock will also hit more and more people in coming months. To keep prices to consumers as low as possiblegiven cost pressures generated by the government's rules, controls and coverage mandatesinsurance companies in many cases are offering plans that have very restrictive networks, with lower-cost providers that exclude some of the best physicians and hospitals.
Next year, millions must choose among unfamiliar physicians and hospitals, or paying more for preferred providers who are not part of their insurance network. Some health outcomes will deteriorate from a less familiar doctor-patient relationship.
More IT failures are likely. People looking for health plans on ObamaCare exchanges may be able to fill out their applications with more ease. But the far more complex back-office side of the websitewhere the information in their application is checked against government databases to determine the premium subsidies and prices they will be charged, and where the applications are forwarded to insurance companiesis still under construction. Be prepared for eligibility, coverage gap, billing, claims, insurer payment and patient information-protection debacles.
The next shock will come when the scores of millions outside the individual marketpeople who are covered by employers, in union plans, or on Medicare and Medicaidexperience the downsides of ObamaCare. There will be longer waits for hospital visits, doctors' appointments and specialist treatment, as more people crowd fewer providers.
Those with means can respond to the government-driven waiting lines by making side payments to providers or seeking care through doctors who do not participate in insurance plans. But this will be difficult for most people.
Next, the Congressional Budget Office's estimated 25% expansion of Medicaid under ObamaCare will exert pressure on state Medicaid spending (although the pressure will be delayed for a few years by federal subsidies). This pressure on state budgets means less money on education and transportation, and higher state taxes.
The "Cadillac tax" on health plans to help pay for ObamaCare starts four years from this Jan. 1. It will fall heavily on unions whose plans are expensive due to generous health benefits.
In the nearer term, a political iceberg looms next year. Insurance companies usually submit proposed pricing to regulators in the summer, and the open enrollment period begins in the fall for plans starting Jan. 1. Businesses of all sizes that currently provide health care will have to offer ObamaCare's expensive, mandated benefits, or drop their plans andexcept the smallest firmspay a fine. Tens of millions of Americans with employer-provided health plans risk paying more for less, and losing their policies and doctors to more restrictive networks. The administration is desperately trying to delay employer-plan problems beyond the 2014 election to avoid this shock.
Meanwhile, ObamaCare will lead to more part-time workers in some industries, as hours are cut back to conform to arbitrary definitions in the law of what constitutes full-time employment. Many small businesses will be cautious about hiring more than 50 full-time employees, which would subject them to the law's employer insurance mandate.
On the supply side, medicine will become a far less attractive career for talented young people. More doctors will restrict practice or retire early rather than accept lower incomes and work conditions they did not anticipate. Already, many practices are closed to Medicaid recipients, some also to Medicare. The pace of innovation in drugs, medical devices and delivery is expected to slow significantly, as higher taxes and even rationing set in.
The repeated assertions by the law's supporters that nobody but the rich would be worse off was based on a beyond-implausible claim that one could expand by millions the number of people with health insurance, lower health-care costs without rationing, and improve quality. The reality is that any squeezing of insurance-company profits, or reduction in uncompensated emergency-room care amounts to a tiny fraction of the trillions of dollars extracted from those people overpaying for insurance, or redistributed from taxpayers.
The Affordable Care Act's disastrous debut sent the president's approval ratings into a tailspin and congressional Democrats in competitive districts fleeing for cover. If the law's continuing unpopularity enables Republicans to regain the Senate in 2014, the president will be forced to veto repeated attempts to repeal the law or to negotiate major changes.
The risk of a complete repeal if a Republican takes the White House in 2016 will put enormous pressure on Democratic candidatesand on Republicansto articulate a compelling alternative to the cost and coverage problems that beset health care. A good start would be sliding-scale subsidies to help people buy a low-cost catastrophic plan, purchasable across state lines, equalized tax treatment of those buying insurance on their own with those on employer plans, and expanded high-risk pools.
Mr. Boskin, an economics professor at Stanford University and senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, was chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President George H.W. Bush.
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

I know folks are reluctant to deal with this because we all have Obamacare fatigue from overexposure. But the troubles are just beginning and we need to gird ourselves for a long night (or the proverbiallong dark tunnel). So let us redouble our efforts to understand what is happening.
the desease that keeps on giving
Hi John. Can you once, just once, comment on the substance.
That is the grown-up way.
Obamacare sign-ups continue to increase
More than 250,000 people selected plans in November, a report says, more than double the number in October. But errors in transmission may complicate enrollment.
Got more if you need it.
States' Exchange Success Will Hurt Texas Republicans' Fight Against Obamacare
Mon Dec 16, 2013 at 02:03 PM CST
15 million registrants expected and a quarter of one million inquired but manymay not get enrolled because of back-end problems.
Everyone must be enrolled in two more weeks.
Well, a journey of 1000 miles begins with one step.
Oh the Irony; Liberal NYC Elites are ObamaCare Losers
In the last few weeks the country has gradually become acquainted with the large and growing class of Americans that fall into the category of ObamaCare losers. The president and his cheerleaders in the liberal media have tried to change the subject from the dysfunctional website and the broken promises about keeping your coverage to one about the poor and those with pre-existing conditions who will now get health insurance. But its been hard to ignore the equally numerous people who have lost their coverage and been forced to accept more expensive plans that dont suit their personal needs and come with enormous deductibles and other hidden costs. Most of these people are small business owners, contractors, and skilled craftsman in Middle America that arent likely to hobnob with the chattering classes.
But it turns out that some ofthe biggest ObamaCare losers in the country are liberal elites living in the media capital of the world. And, though they thought the whole concept of bringing government into the health-care business was great, they are none too pleased about personally being victimized by the presidents big idea.