What Would Be The Global Impact If Wal-Mart Abruptly Shut Down?
An unexpected, abrupt shut down of Wal-Mart would have major impacts.
1. Unemployment: Wal-Mart employs a staggering 1% of the working US population. The unemployment rate would go up by 1% overnight, and that would be just the start. The ripple effect on unemployment would be dramatic as well. Thousands of companies that sell to Walmart would likely either go under or be forced to dramatically cut their workforces.
The thousands of companies that sell to companies that sell to Walmart would also be hurt. Industries from transportation to product packaging to retail analytics software would feel the impact immediately.
2. Businesses around Wal-Mart stores and offices would be impacted. Wal-Mart is often an anchor tenant, and the business that they would normally drive to a shopping area would be gone. Property owners would be hurt both by the immediate impact of lost leases and by the longer term price drops that Wal-Marts vacancies would drive.
3. Product Supplies: Many companies rely on the massive, steady volume they sell through Wal-Mart in order to drive their product costs lower. Without Wal-Mart, even those companies who survived would have a difficult time producing their products at the same cost as they did previously.
Some products would simply no longer be produced, while others might drop in price as vendors cleared out inventories and then rise as competitors were eliminated from the market.
4. Prices: Wal-Mart has done more than any company in history to drive prices down for consumer goods. While you can argue whether this has been good or bad, prices would likely increase in most markets with Wal-Mart gone, at least in the long term.
Produce and other perishables would be unavailable from shuttered Wal-Mart stores, and with a reduced supply in the market, there would be an immediate price spike.
However, vendors with goods previously produced for Wal-Mart and no other established channels in which to sell them would fill the market fairly quickly. Prices would then come back down until existing supplies were gone.
5. Government: Wal-Marts tax burden from sales tax to local and state taxes to federal payroll tax is massive. The immediate loss in tax revenue would impact governments at all levels.
6. Wages: With the economy already at high unemployment levels, wages for employees with the skill sets of those previously employed by Wal-Mart would likely decrease for some time.
While this would have a negative impact on employees, it could have a positive impact on businesses looking to hire people with those skills as they would have a well-trained, ready-made workforce for less money than they would have paid otherwise.
7. Small Businesses: To the extent that small businesses that compete with Wal-Mart still exist, they might eventually be some of the biggest winners in this scenario. While Target and others might take some Wal-Mart store locations, many towns would be left with a massive gap where Wal-Mart once existed. Small businesses, who can be more nimble than large retailers, could start to fill the gap fairly quickly. Necessities, such as food, gas, and sundries, would likely fair best.
To summarize, the impact would be massive, and would have an immediate and hugely negative impact on the lives of literally millions of people in the U.S. and around the world who rely in some part on the Wal-Mart ecosystem.
I like to think that capitalism would eventually fill the void with other options that would take Wal-Marts place, but no one has yet come close to building the culture, systems, and structure that enabled Wal-Mart to succeed as it did in the first place.
It would be a long, long recovery.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2012/06/18/what-would-be-the-global-impact-if-wal-mart-abruptly-shut-down/

Wal-Mart is the corporation that many love to hate, but the stores always seem to be full of customers and despite the wages a lot of people work there and seem to like.
Before heads start exploding, I think the minimum wage should be raised and pegged to the CPI for future changes
I remembers this article and dug it up as it still seems very relevant
I wonder if all the Wal-Mart haters have really given much thought to what would happen if the Walton family simply bought back the public held stock and closed down all the stores. They could certainly afford to do it and still be very, very rich. But what would the effect be on the economies, families and other businesses in the towns where they do business.
I wonder.
This did not do much to address the global aspects of such an event . Unless WM has changed their purchasing practices recently the biggest effect would be on China .
Egilman
I agree the impact would be immediate, significant and in many ways unpredictable
Thanks for the perspective
John ,
Frankly, I didn't bother to read the rest of your comment after the first lazyass sentence .
John
That you did not read the article is perplexing, it wasn't that long and it was fairly clear and to the point without a political slant, simply about the economic impact
The validity of our perspective is tainted by not reading the article since you make a political comment about an economic topic
But thanks for stopping by anyway and hope you had a good holiday yesterday
Egilman
Easy there partner
As I said to John he wants to make a political comment about an economic topic (which he would have known if he bothered to read the article)
Let it go
Your points above are on target
Petey
There would be a significant effect on China but the biggest impact would be here at home, the employees of Wal-Mart, the city, state and federal tax revenue, neighboring businesses in malls anchored by Wal-Mart, local, state and national suppliers, etc
Thanks for the point on China though which is an important one
Hope your turkey day was a good one
Petey
No need to engage
Your perspective on the topic was valuable and in point and I thank you for it
Egilman
I know but engaging solves nothing really and simply leads to an angry exchange which is not needed in the debate of a serious issue
All valid points Robert. Petey comment re China is valid as well.
Another point I'd like to bring up is the amount of money that WM donates to charity. I know in our small town they have made some very large contributions to our charities.
I don't know how much they donate through the U.S. but I believe that it's substantial.
Just found it, $1 billion world widefor 2012.
Kavika
Yes it is thanks for pointing that out
I have no doubt the effect in the US would be large . But it would not be permanent . And the longer term changes might even be beneficial . Without WM there might be a resurgence of mom&pop businesses . That could add to employment stats . The biggest side effect would be I expect , price inflation .
In China OTOH , the effects would be more permanent . The loss of employment would be huge ... maybe even catastophic .
My turkey day was OK . How was yours ?
Who would make up for this loss of charitable contributions by WM?
Just another unintended result of a shutdown of WM.
I read there are 1.3 million workers...that's a lot.
RiO--
I'm somewhat perplexed at the whole point of the article & your seed?
We could go on and on with this fantasy, but it seems both pointless and ridiculous to try and offer logical 'responses' to such a blatant fantasy. The 'worst case' secenario is NOT the economic/labor/political taxation fairy-tale you're suggesting, but rather a short-term 'market adjustment' of exactly the short championed by neo-con ecnomists...
BTW... a billion $ in (tax-deductible) charitable contributions would have a fuck of a lot more economic impact if that same money went into wages increases for WalMart employees.
Well thanks for getting that off your chest Swamijim sez! I know you feel better now.
If Walmart or any big corporation of that size was to suddenly close down it would have devastating consequences on our fragile economy, plus it would be like China losing its biggest customer.
In the case of Walmart we all do know or at least hope that doesn't happen. Oh I always hate it when I say something like that.
Well I guess we wouldn't have Walmart to blame for paying the governments subsidies to all those employees anymore. And the ones who aren't interested in improving their position to make more money or improving their position with Walmart by using their company school assistance plan would just have to totally depend on us.
I kind of like the idea Walmart is taking some of the burden off me by paying their subsidy. I hope they are able to increase their wages so it will take more of the burden off me actually. Anyway that's what I have to say and I'm sticking to it.
swami
Sorry the article did not meet your standards but I appreciate your perspective none the less
Most economic scenarios (like those the CBO does) are hypothetical and are based on what if and allow for discussion and thought about what might happen
J F T
Appreciate the in depth look at the economic ramifications
And all the employees would immediately get better paying jobs right?
Dream on
Six
No worries I have thick skin
Thanks for your perspective on the situation
Lots of folks hate on WalMart all the time (some of it deserved) but never think much about what would happen if suddenly WalMart disappeared
A job, rather than no job...?
It does aid the economy some, but I'd rather see it being done by small business than Big Box.
Chloe
Good point
lol..
You know, I thought about writing an article with my thoughts on the Walmart issue, but changed my mind due to feeling that the environment is too biased here. Too bad EI isn't here any longer as he has way more economics knowledge than I do to shed some light on my thoughts, and I am not an Econ major, just an interested lay person woman over the years.
This isn't the topic of your article, so I'm just minorly ranting with some personal perspective thrown in. But what's frustrating to me on NT is there appears to be a lot of opinion and people that simply don't have enough economics/business knowledge to be commenting on the issue of Walmart/jobs/wages.
Yesterday I did some research on the Co and comparatives. First, Productivity. This translates into how a company determines each employees' value [not individual, in an universal context] for the company to ensure they don't end up with surplus. It's computed by revenue divided by wage, I believe. Second, Walmart's prices are lower in comparison to the other Big Box Discount stores similar in product and sales [I looked at Target and Costco]. That means fewer revenues for a company. Third, Walmart is highly Stockholder based...that means that profits go back to the Stockholder - not the company's management. So the ninnies that are whining that they read these big dollar amounts going to the CEOs and others - don't know where those dollars are coming from, necessarily; they're talking like they think they're just sitting there raking in the bucks while their shelf stockers aren't getting enough of the pie. That's not how a corporation works. Also, they employ more people that the other Discounts I checked out, and that also means less revenue for the stockholders/owners of the business, as well as each individual -- larger means less, not more, depending... But, there is still the issue of productivity as the most significant factor in determining wages for a business...not what a director is taking home due to his investments.
Sorry to rant.
Upwards of 48% [possibly] now. My source is a little more updated than from 4 years and 8, almost 9 months ago.
From 2012:
There's also a statistics sheet on that link. Yes, some very big bucks being brought in and dispersed to the stockholders using that info of every hour and minute -- and they are open 24 hours a day, I believe... which might imply only revenue - but there is still 'cost' to consider [overhead], in having longer hours and additional employee time.
My point still remains...it's not what a stockholder has to put into the business, it's productivity that determines wage.
One thing I hope I am making clear, John, that my comments are not 'personal' in that they don't reflect value judgment of moralism which is projected, but rather is from the stance of doing business and how one chooses to invest.
Perhaps unions would fix this issue for shelf stockers, and if it does, I would be happy for them.
Do remember, as we both agreed, that everything is relative, as well as one thing leads to another. What we have seen in the past is that people really aren't very smart, it seems. More income tends to lead to more debt - not a better life, which we would hope...in fact, it tends to lead to a lesser life. It increases their 'borrowing' power with credit card debt...instead of more money to freely spend or save - they now have more money to 'lose' paying credit card debt. Inflation rises, prices rise....and the beat goes on.
I hope it all works out.
RW, That's interesting, and it makes sense that if a particular location can't support the cost, then they would have shorter hours.
There's only one in my Tri-city location, and they were 24-hour when they first opened.
Some of the Super-Store retailers are also open 24-hour here, mostly Safeways and two Albertson's.
John, Yes, I meant above minimum wage.
As an aside, I always thought minimum wage was only Federal and State determined, but from this article [funny to me that I read more of my state news from the NYT than I do from local sources], it can be locally voter approved.
In this article , the Airport District [incorporated now] is hoping they can raise the min wage from 9.19 to 15 dollars an hour (it also needs to be considered relative to cost-of-living).
That has me wondering why we all are wasting time pressuring Walmart specifically, why not the voters of a particular area around the country or world?
I figured that the discussion would shift to hating on WalMart rather than discussing the economic impact that a sudden closure of WalMart would mean but I am not surprised.
That's a very good point -- if Walmart closed, they're not likely to find a better paying job in a downturned economy, with retailers that don't hire that many employees -- that's also projected to be service-oriented. Competition for those jobs will go up.
BF, do I detect a bit of sarcasm in your post?
R W
It was a subtle attempt to get the discussion back on the topic of the article without offending or engaging anyone on the tangential topics that have been brought up
I am ignoring the tangents by not participating
Kavika
I can vouch that BadFish is never , rarely sarcastic
Thank you Robert, I though that he strayed out of his parameters for a moment.
Ok fellows and ladies we are hopelessly off topic now any thoughts on the economic impact of the WalMart corporation deciding to buy back all the stock and close its doors or are we done here?
BF, that's the best satire I've read in a long time!
I see Black Market Guaranteed Subsidy tax returns in the making.
Here's mine:
1. How much did you make?
2. How much were your bills?
3. How much is left?
4. Send it in.
Robert, Just want to apologize if having some fun with the issue of Walmart, in general, wasn't acceptable to you. I've tried to learn the personality of most of the regulars on NT - who likes strictly on-topic, and those that are more flexible, but not straying off too far or for very long.
Personally, I've found that if we stay strictly on topic, then there really isn't much too be said after an initial comment, so I had hoped that 'evolution' would be okay to allow, if some were so inclined [like John, Raven and I did]. However, now that I know you 'only' want a comment or exchange that deals with your basic premise - "economic impact" as a result of corporate closure, then I will honor that, as well as make sure I am 'strictly' on-topic [as I interpret it] in any of your future discussions.
Sam Walton would be spinning in his grave if he saw what Walmart has become.
The question in my mind : Why is Forbes making this elaborate apology for Walmart ?
pw--
I think the conclusion we'reexpected to draw is that IF Walmart were ever 'forced' to raise their pay scale, the Walton heirs would suddenly do a Galt and close down their multi-billion dollar empire, thereby throwing the entire planet into economic chaos. Notice that there's no attempt whatsoever to explain how a mega-rich global multinational corp is supposed to 'abruptly' vanish from the face of the earth. We're just supposed to imagine this horrible catastrophe (gasp OMG) and be so stricken with fear that no right-thinking person would even want Walmart to do something as self-destructive as give people a qaurter-an-hour raise and plunge Western civilization into chaos...
Makes you wonder why we even need outmoded concepts like nations and/or government, really--- it would be so much simpler to just turn the running of the planet over to Walmart.
lol...
But wait... jobs, food, electronics--available across the planet--what more do we need? They are the answer to welfare programs AND smaller government!!
I don't ever picture them fully shutting down, but closing a few stores could happen.
I agree, Swami, fear has always been a driver of compliance of the masses.
I'm actually always amazed at the number of NT posters who are so horrified, repulsed and mistrustful of 'Big Government', but readily assume that Big Walmart (or Big BP or Big Halliburton) are SO trustworthy and admirable...
Yep-- all we have to do is convince the Army, Navy & Marines to put their lives on the line for $8 an hour & then get the Chinese to build aircraft, tanks & battleships for us instead of toasters, lawnmowers & patio fire-pits. Capitalism-- it's the genie in the lamp all right...
LOL...
It's not even a doggie analogy, RW... When you're looking for the optimal capitalist greed analogy, consider the wolverine-- if they can't eat the full kill, they piss on whatever's left, just to make sure that nobodyelse can have any...
RiO,
I doubt seriously that Wal*mart could possibly go under in a single day. Even small companiestake time to go out of business. That is, it takes time to liquidate all of the stuff, the machinery, the product on the shelves, the property, etc. that is there and in place. The liquidation of these assets at a company so large as Wal*mart would, by necessity, take a good deal of time and require the retention of a good deal of labor for months and possibly even years. So, given that some catastrophe of heretofore unseen epic proportions does not occur, the effect on the labor markets would not be so vast and sudden.
Something that would occur in the labor markets is the displacement of the Wal*mart workers in the home region: The managerial staff and support structure that exist in the corridor along I-71 between Fayetteville and Belle Vista, Arkansas. This region has seen incredible growth of higher paid office type workers over the past decade and more. To this specific region, the sudden closure of Wal*mart might be crippling economically, due to the higher rates of pay and subsequent higher unemployment benefits hitting the area at the same time as the tax base decreasing.
From the article:
Thousands of companies that sell to Walmart would likely either go under or be forced to dramatically cut their workforces.
The thousands of companies that sell to companies that sell to Walmart would also be hurt. Industries from transportation to product packaging to retail analytics software would feel the impact immediately.
These statements may or may not be true... It is a poor business plan to have a sole outlet for your goods. Most of the goods that I see in Wal*mart, should I deign to darken their door, are national brands. (At least the last time I checked.) While they would be affected, most would not simply cease to exist.
2. Businesses around Wal-Mart stores and offices would be impacted. Wal-Mart is often an anchor tenant, and the business that they would normally drive to a shopping area would be gone. Property owners would be hurt both by the immediate impact of lost leases and by the longer term price drops that Wal-Marts vacancies would drive.
Wall*mart is an anchor tennant, but if you drive around, you can tell where Wal*mart used to be by the businesses left in an area. Stores such as DollarTree have a ubiquitous and seemingly symbiotic presence at WallyWorld, yet when Wal*marts close up, as they do often to move to another location, these businesses are not always left to wither, they can make it on their own if they establish themselves in the community. So, the fact that Wal*mart is not there is not the sole determining factor for survival.
Undoubtedly the property owners would be affected by Wal*mart moving out , so it is in their interest to have in their business plan a what if scenario and subsequent actions to be taken.
3. Product Supplies: Many companies rely on the massive, steady volume they sell through Wal-Mart in order to drive their product costs lower. Without Wal-Mart, even those companies who survived would have a difficult time producing their products at the same cost as they did previously.
Yeah, prolly. But oftentimes it is the quality of the products produced that suffers the knife of getting things for a better price, and the products that are offered to a Wal*mart customer are not the same.
Some products would simply no longer be produced, while others might drop in price as vendors cleared out inventories and then rise as competitors were eliminated from the market.
See above.
4. Prices: Wal-Mart has done more than any company in history to drive prices down for consumer goods. While you can argue whether this has been good or bad, prices would likely increase in most markets with Wal-Mart gone, at least in the long term.
This whole statement is questionable, because Wal*mart is not the only player in any of the arenas that they sell product. They have been and are a force, but not as large as all that.
Produce and other perishables would be unavailable from shuttered Wal-Mart stores, and with a reduced supply in the market, there would be an immediate price spike.
Again, Wal*mart is not going to shutter all of their stores in a day, so I view this statement as pure alarmism. The market would have all of those goods in it, because the people who produced those goods would be looking for somewhere to sell them, and fast.
However, vendors with goods previously produced for Wal-Mart and no other established channels in which to sell them would fill the market fairly quickly. Prices would then come back down until existing supplies were gone.
Proper planning prevents poor performance.
5. Government: Wal-Marts tax burden from sales tax to local and state taxes to federal payroll tax is massive. The immediate loss in tax revenue would impact governments at all levels.
It would impact them, local governments probably more than state or federal, simply due to the structure. It should be noted that Wal*mart places it's stores just outside the municipal boundaries when possible, strictly to avoid the local taxes.
6. Wages: With the economy already at high unemployment levels, wages for employees with the skill sets of those previously employed by Wal-Mart would likely decrease for some time.
While this would have a negative impact on employees, it could have a positive impact on businesses looking to hire people with those skills as they would have a well-trained, ready-made workforce for less money than they would have paid otherwise.
Translation: Get used to working for less money.
7. Small Businesses: To the extent that small businesses that compete with Wal-Mart still exist, they might eventually be some of the biggest winners in this scenario. While Target and others might take some Wal-Mart store locations, many towns would be left with a massive gap where Wal-Mart once existed. Small businesses, who can be more nimble than large retailers, could start to fill the gap fairly quickly. Necessities, such as food, gas, and sundries, would likely fair best.
Small businesses would rush to fill that void, where feasible. Gasoline, ehhh, not so much, the large franchisers fill that.
To summarize, the impact would be massive, and would have an immediate and hugely negative impact on the lives of literally millions of people in the U.S. and around the world who rely in some part on the Wal-Mart ecosystem.
I like to think that capitalism would eventually fill the void with other options that would take Wal-Marts place, but no one has yet come close to building the culture, systems, and structure that enabled Wal-Mart to succeed as it did in the first place.
Was this article written by a Wal*mart VP??? Especially that last sentence?
broliver
If you click on the link and look at the original article you will note that the author is
Mark Chatow, Head of Global Marketing at Sourcebits
RiO,
I was being Kind of snarky, actually. It seems that Mr. Chatow is in some kind of thrall about wallyworld that clouds his vision. In the first place, Wallmart ain't going to go out of business tomorrow, and it certainly wouldn't just padlock the doors of all the stores and walk away. It just is not done that way. Maybe at select locations where they were having problems getting their employees to sign up for food stamps....(s) The whole scenario is just too far-fetched to retain any credibility, especially written as it is with the breathlessness of "Look at all that Wallmart provides for the people! Look at what would be missing from our lives! Look at how horrible things would be!" The obvious message being, "We can't live without Wall Mart. It would be hell and everybody would be hurt!"
Walmart is large, but it is not the second coming and it is important to not inflate the importance of one business beyond the affect in a system as complex as the economies of today.
Broliver
The articlewas a hypothetical scenario to spur discussion and I doubt that the author thinks that he is predicting a short term event with any certainty
In my view, the intention was simply to relate what would happen if many people got their wish and Wal-Mart suddenly disappeared
I agree totally with your last statement and you might add, that Wal-Mart may contribute to the economic woes of the middle class but it is by no means the prime reason for the middle class decline and struggle
As to being snarky, snark away as your feedback is always appreciated by me