President calls GOP and insurance companies' bluff - I'M LOVIN' IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!
One must always be careful what one asks for. Many have been accusing President Obama of breaking his promise: "If you like it you can keep it." The president ill-advisedly decided to "apologize" in an interview with MSNBCs Chuck Todd.
On Thursday the president gave an extensive news conference. Republicans may have been caught flat-footed judging from the less-than-inflammatory rhetoric that followed. Maybe they thought the president would have to resort to legislation that they would be able to politicize and block.
The fix the president has instituted is rather ingenious. More importantly it immediately ensured that Congress, the insurance companies, and the American citizens absorb responsibility for the solution.
The president said, "Insurers can extend current plans that otherwise would be canceled into 2014 and Americans whose plans have been canceled can choose to re-enroll in the same kind of plan." He then said, "This fix won't solve every problem for every person, but it's going to help a lot of people. Doing more would require work with Congress."
The presidents fix allows insurance companies to extend the cancelled policies even if they do not conform to the Affordable Care Act for one year. The insurance companies cannot enroll new customers into the substandard policies. The insurance companies are also required to inform the purchasers of these substandard policies that they may qualify for federal subsidies only through the exchanges. They must disclose that these policies do not have the consumer protections that all new insurance policies must have. They must also inform them that they may qualify for Medicaid,
President Clinton was the master of triangulation. Unfortunately while he seemed to win at triangulation, the poor and the middle class usually became its victim (e.g., Glass-Steagall, welfare reform, supply side economics). This move by President Obama if allowed to go through is how a masterful triangulation should be effected.
President Obama tells insurance companies they have the freedom to extend the policies but cannot force them. That removes the narrative of Obama/government takeover of your health care. He forces insurance transparency by requiring insurance companies to come clean on their substandard policies relative to the Affordable Care Act. In doing this the American citizens purchasing these policies know upfront that they are purchasing junk.
The fact that many will now have the comparison and the knowledge that there may be subsidies on the exchange will limit the size of that insurance market. This means it is unlikely many insurance companies will bite. There are some people who will not get subsidies, will not have policies extended by insurance companies, and will be upset that they will pay higher rates. The president put the onus of fixing that on working with Congress. Congress can choose to engage or not. Not engaging becomes a new campaign direction for Democrats.
The insurance companies are now upset. When they cancelled policies they did so with an up-sell of more expensive policies as opposed to encouraging folks to go to the Obamacare exchanges. In doing so they created a political firestorm instigated by Republicans. Now the insurance companies are complaining about the fix disrupting the insurance markets.
Tags
Who is online
140 visitors

Please Mike.....
From the party that "Has no shame, and will take no blame.....!"
Mike... There are huge differences between the two parties!
More to my concern is that there is a larger, and hidden force at work pulling the strings that ensures a perpetual 50:50 split between our citizens. Theirs is a divide and conquer approach that keeps us at each other and controllable at the same time. Somehow, we have to get at those behind the curtain.
YeeeHaaaa!
Insurance companies make me mad.....
Maybe they thought the president would have to resort to legislation that they would be able to politicize and block.
God forbid the President "have to resort" to legislation to change a law! What a foreign concept! What kind of system is this where the President, the unquestioned leader of the world, should have to get the consent of the people before unilaterally dictating changes to the law of the land. Thankfully he never had to "resort" to that.
The fact that Republicans with 40 House Democrats passed stronger legislation to protect those hurt by Obamacare completely undermines this whole fantasy, but obviously this exercise in fiction has nothing to do with reality.
"accusing President Obama of breaking his promise"?
hasent everyone seen all the tapes ofhim lying over, and over again?
President Obama tells insurance companies they have the freedom to extend the policies but cannot force them.
correct, which is why one of the dems who also lied about keeping your healthcare, doctor, etc, is sponsoring a bill in the senate, to make it a law.
"He forces insurance transparency"
speaking of transparency, why wasent the meeting between obama and all those insurance executives televised?
Those behind the curtains are right in our faces on the air waves, that's where the divide and conquer approach comes from, gullible people listen to the trash and absorb the misinformation and then spit it out to whomever will listen to that garbage they preach, it seems like people these days, especially, if they dislike a person for one reason or another, will latch onto anything they can get there minds around to justify their hatred...
All people have to do is read the law...
in obama we trust
You know what they say, 'if you want to eat an elephant, you have to eat one bite at a time", I read the chapters that pertained to the questions I had at the time and I did understand what I read, I wanted to know if congress people would also be covered under Obamacare, and they are, so I went to the table of contents, decided what I wanted to know and read that portion, do you think representatives could have done the same thing and have a good report for their constituents? yes, the could, but they decided to Lie and repeat that it was too big to read, what the heck do they get paid for? if that's the case, they do not read anything, I know their staff reads and then advises the representative what is written, in other words, its the staff members that are running the country not the legislatures, staff members gets to decide what laws they would like to see on the books...
Not necessarily Mike, but it helps to have a good college level dictionary, sometimes you just have to read the paragraph over to get the gist of what is been said, I don't think its easy to understand but with patience, you will get the understanding...
You 2 should "get a room" ...
Sounds like the article was written by Obama himself.
Notice that he does not include himself. It is always someone else's fault and he retreats to the golf course. Rescue; you cannot rescue Obama. He is inup to his ears.
It took the insurance companies four yearsto come up with plans and rates. Obama is fantacizing if he thinks they can prepare new policies in two months for almost 200 million people whose policies were or will be canceled.
And the article is lying by presuming that the OC plans are better than the cancelled ones.
What does Pres. Obama needs to be rescued from??? you make funny jokes, you should be at the comedy club...
Where are you getting your information from?? the right wing talk show hosts have you confused and you buy every garbage they sell...
hat "stronger legislation" is going to bite them in the behind
Right. Self employed people and others in in the individual market are idiots who have no idea what their policies cover. They shouldn't be allowed to drive cars, let alone make choices about their own health care.
I'm not the one doing this :
I don't know why there is so much celebration over this . It is what the Repubs asked for a while back ... a delay in the individual mandate .
,I managed to do it, and I wasn't a paid senator.
That's a great start. Now you can read the 30,000 plus pages (so far) of regulations that actually govern how the law operates. You are about 1/30 of the way towards finding out what's in the law! Reading and understanding a bunch of "the secretary shalls" is well and good, but reading the actual nuts and bolts is another matter altogether.
didnt they just "deem" it read?
Mike, I am not a bullshitter here is a link to the health care law:
I do not know what link you have, but you can click on all sections in the link posted here because it is live...
Your sections did not open..
The Affordable Care Act, Section by Section
Below you will find all 10 Titles of the Affordable Care Act, with amendments to the law called for by the reconciliation process. Click on each Title to see a brief outline and then read the law section by section.
Title I. Quality, Affordable Health Care for All Americans
Title II. The Role of Public Programs
Title III. Improving the Quality and Efficiency of Health Care
Title IV. Prevention of Chronic Disease and Improving Public Health
Title V. Health Care Workforce
Title VI. Transparency and Program Integrity
Title VII. Improving Access to Innovative Medical Therapies
Title VIII. Community Living Assistance Services and Supports Act (CLASS Act)
Title IX. Revenue Provisions
Title X. Reauthorization of the Indian Health Care Improvement Act
This is what you gave me, yours copy/paste did not open all the sections, my link allows you to read what is in each section..
Where is Mike??? did you see the live links in my version???you can open all the links and read the details if you are interested..
This is what Republican Legislatures at Federal and State levels do not want you to have:
Key Features of the Affordable Care Act By Year
OVERVIEW OF THE HEALTH CARE LAW
2010: A new Patient's Bill of Rights goes into effect, protecting consumers from the worst abuses of the insurance industry. Cost-free preventive services begin for many Americans.
See More 2010 Changes .
2011: People with Medicare can get key preventive services for free , and also receive a 50% discount on brand-name drugs in the Medicare donut hole.
See More 2011 Changes .
2012: Accountable Care Organizations and other programs help doctors and health care providers work together to deliver better care.
See More 2012 Changes .
2013: Open enrollment in the Health Insurance Marketplace begins on October 1st.
See More 2013 Changes .
2014: All Americans will have access to affordable health insurance options. The Marketplace allows individuals and small businesses to compare health plans on a level playing field. Middle and low-income families will get tax credits that cover a significant portion of the cost of coverage. And the Medicaid program will be expanded to cover more low-income Americans. All together, these reforms mean that millions of people who were previously uninsured will gain coverage, thanks to the Affordable Care Act.
See More 2014 Changes .
Mike, if you go to my link and click, you will get a summary page then click on each section and the details will be revealed, also on the side panel of the first page there are additional information you can click on and also details will be revealed for additional articles..
Mike, I wanted to verify that there are indeed 2409 pages in the ACA and there are not, you have linked a PDF version, well, my google search did not show a that pdf version for hhs.gov the only information I had for # of pages were 906 pages which shows the beginning H.R 3590 to the last pages # 906 the link below is attached:
To verify that there are only 906 pages, I asked google "numbers of pages for ACA and the link for that answer is also attached:
How Many Pages Was the Obama Health Care Bill?
How many pages are in health care reform bill ?
Mike, I went to your link twice and my computer froze, I don not know why, its been happening lately, so that is why I found my own link.
That's Ok Mike, all we know is that there is a Law, number of pages we don't know for sure, everybody says something else..
Mike, you may be right, the think is, to know if there are really 2409 pages, a person would have to go through each page and make sure that all the data is there and no duplications or not just a date on a few pages or just one line, that count could add up to more than it really is...talk to you later Mike..
I do not rely on the news, I go to the White house.gov if I really want to know what the laws really says, News people lie, I can read for myself, I do not need an interpreter...
That's correct RW that is why some people are been misled, they rely on the news...
Nine hours later, you are still waiting on BF to list that "hurricane of poor legislation." what amazes me is someone not in the health care industry suggesting the requirements in a health care plan as a "hurricane of bad legislation" I mean, by whose authority do you have this opinion??? don't tell me some right wing doctors in congress who have not or ever practiced medicine has an opinion, to have an opinion or suggestion, you have to be currently working and studying in research or a practicing professional before an opinion can be respected, that means that person knows what they are talking about...
Medicare Part D "was far more expensive than the Affordable Care Act and unlike" the act, "was never budgeted."
Obamacare law was funded and expected to save billions; not so for Medicare Part D
"Obamacare? Expensive?" says a photo-quotation mashup that a reader sent us on Facebook.
Beneath a photo of President George W. Bush making a face, the caption reads, "Bushs Medicare D was far more expensive than the Affordable Care Act, and, unlike the ACA, was never budgeted."
The Facebook-shared image is unattributed, but its caption tracks word-for-word with an Oct. 18, 2013, tweet and blog post by writer and pundit Andrew Sullivan.
Sullivans post doesnt elaborate on Part D -- Medicares prescription drug program, created in 2003.
But others have made similar comparisons.
Economist Paul Krugman wrote in a Dec. 29, 2009, New York Times blog entry about "the trouble Republicans have been having as they try to explain why, if they consider the fully-funded, deficit-reducing Democratic health care reform unaffordable, they voted for the completely unfunded Medicare drug benefit six years ago."
Did Congress "budget" enough for the promises made under the Obamacare law but not those in Medicare Part D -- and was Part D "far more expensive"?
Budgeted
Via email, Krugman told us, "Not sure about what never budgeted means, or exactly how more expensive is defined. But the ACA designated cost savings and revenues to pay for the outlays; Part D just specified outlays with no offset."
Alan Auerbach, an economist at the University of California-Berkeley and research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research (a nonprofit, nonpartisan organization), told us by email, "It's certainly true that the ACA was funded while Medicare Part D was not."
Part D is an optional insurance program for prescription drugs for senior citizens on Medicare. Private insurance companies offer a variety of plans subsidized by the government, and beneficiaries get to choose the plan that's best for them. Obamacare requires Americans to buy health insurance, extends Medicare to cover more people and makes numerous other changes.
Auerbach said, "The ACA was funded in the sense that taxes were increased to pay for the estimated expenditure cost. Medicare Part D provided a new benefit with a substantial long-run cost... and did not raise any taxes."
Steve Ellis, vice president of Taxpayers for Common Sense, told us by email, "Medicare Part D was always coming out of general revenues (unlike most of the rest of Medicare)," because the federal deficit was a less prominent concern at the time, "whereas ACA/Obamacare was drafted in a more deficit-conscious era." Ellis group, based in Washington, D.C., describes itself as a nonpartisan watchdog advocating more transparency and less waste in government spending.
In a Nov. 3, 2013, fact-check , PolitiFact summed up tax increases in the Obamacare law, aside from the penalty Americans will pay if they dont have approved health insurance: Medicare payroll taxes for the wealthy, investment income taxes and others on insurance companies, the health care industry and more are included. Other provisions are intended to push Medicare costs down.
Medicare Part D wasnt "funded" in that a source of money was not created or dedicated to offset all its costs -- say, a tax increase or other funding mechanism.
Medicare trustees March 23, 2004, report explained Part D would be financed with general revenue (mostly federal income taxes) plus the enrollees premium payments and some money from the states.
Because the premium amounts and the amount of general revenue would be reset each year, they could be adjusted to cover anticipated costs, the report said: "Thus, Part D income will automatically track Part D expenditures fairly closely."
Which cost(s) more?
Part D and Obamacare are intended to extend into the future. How does one measure the cost of such efforts? One way is to look at projected costs over a 10-year span, as PolitiFact Virginia did in a Dec. 7, 2010, fact-check .
Which 10-year span? The photo-quotation that touched off this story gave no context.
First we looked at the cost estimates available to members of Congress when they voted.
On Nov. 20, 2003, the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office estimated that Part Ds gross cost would total $409.8 billion from 2004 through 2013. The net cost of the entire Medicare Modernization Act, including Part D and expected revenue increases, was given as $394.3 billion ($501 billion in todays dollars).
On March 18, 2010, the CBO and Congress Joint Committee on Taxation estimated that the Obamacare laws net effect would be to save the government -- that is, reduce the federal deficit -- $138 billion from 2010 through 2019 ($148 billion in todays dollars).
Our ruling
The image shared on Facebook said, "Bushs Medicare D was far more expensive than the Affordable Care Act, and, unlike the ACA, was never budgeted."
Its a vague claim without context. Looking for a reasonable way to evaluate it, we found the Obamacare law was "funded" and Part D "unfunded" and that, using estimated 10-year costs at inception, the former was projected to save $148 billion and the latter to cost something under $501 billion (in 2013 dollars).
We rate the claim as Mostly True.
READ THE FULL ARTICLE AT THE FOLLOWING:
Debunking Ryan's zombie lie: Obamacare doesn't add to the deficit, it actually reduces it
by Laurence Lewis Follow
As the Republican extortionists desperately thrash about in search of a rationale for their continuing government shutdown tantrum, Paul Ryan resorts to a zombie lie:
First of all, it would be hard for Obamacare to be a big driver of our debt, given that it just went live, but the bigger lie is that it would drive the debt at all. The Republicans claim this is all about fiscal responsibility and getting the deficit under control, which has no credibility at face value, given that Republicans themselves have no credibility on deficits , but specifically to the point, the Congressional Budget Office in 2011 scored Obamacare's budgetary impact (pdf) :
Estimated Budgetary Effects from 2012 to 2021: Direct Spending and Revenues
The legislation will have a number of effects on the federal budgetincluding added
spending to subsidize the purchase of health insurance and increased outlays for Med-
icaid, as well as reductions in outlays for Medicare and added revenues from taxes,
fees, and penalties. On net, CBO and JCTs latest comprehensive estimate is that the effects of the two laws on direct spending and revenues related to health care will reduce federal deficits by $210 billion over the 20122021 period (see Table 1).
Earlier this year, the right wing echosphere was abuzz because the new CBO score (pdf) supposedly projected a huge increase in the deficit. This was dishonest. The new CBO score did project that the health insurance coverage provisions will be enormously expensive, but the earlier score also projected that obvious fact. But that's not the bottom line. As you can read beneath the fold, the new CBO report made this explicit:
And in fact, the CBO now projects that the very expensive health insurance coverage provisions will cost $49 billion less than had been previously estimated. And the new CBO report then referenced its 2012 letter to John Boehner (pdf) , which estimated the effect of the Republican bill H.R. 6079, which would have repealed Obamacare:
That Obamacare would add to the deficit is one of the GOP's most insidious zombie lies. The CBO has been explict, both in its regular reports and in its letter sent specifically to John Boehner. The facts are clear, and must be repeated at least as often as are the zombie lies themselves. The truth is that Obamacare does not add to the deficit, it reduces it. The truth is that repealing Obamacare would not reduce the deficit, it would increase it.
The Republicans are lying. Again. The ostensible rationale for their attack on the ACA is exactly backward. Obamacare reduces the deficit. With Obamacare, the president and the Democrats not only are expanding the availability of health insurance, they are reducing the deficit.