Who Lied to Our Faces About ObamaCare... ?
There has been a lot of media coverage and political rhetoric, from both sides of the political spectrum and everywhere in between and beyond, about the President's lie concerning the PPACA.
But it is apparent that he was not alone in promulgating the falsehood "If you like your current plan you can keep it <period>"
Here is a sampling of those who chanted the mantra --
Rep. Butterfield : For North Carolinians who already have health insurance, the only changes you will see under the Affordable Care Act are new benefits, better protections from insurance company abuses, and more value for every dollar you spend on health care. If you like your plan you can keep it, and you dont have to change a thing due to the health care law. ( Health Care Resources, as seen on 10/24/2013 )
Rep. Castor: If you like your health insurance, you can keep it. Keep your current doctor as you see fit. ( What Does Health Insurance Reform Mean for You? ). Nothing in this bill will force you to drop your current coverage. Rest assured, if you like your health insurance, you can keep it. ( Press Release, 7/31/2009 )
Rep. Conyers: Your premiums and other costs will not increase as a result of health care reform and if you like the coverage you have now, youll be able to keep it. In fact, youll get some additional help paying for premiums and out-of-pocket costs. ( How Will Obamacare Affect Me? Questionnaire )
Rep. DeFazio : The legislation is not a government takeover of health care. It will not get between anyone and their doctor. If you have insurance, you can keep your current plan. ( Press Release, 3/24/2010 )
Rep. Ellison : If you like the insurance you have, you can keep it. Dont listen to that stuff you heard in the last hour, Mr. Speaker. The truth is, you get to keep your health insurance if thats what you want. ( Floor Speech )
Rep. Fattah : This plan means that those who are satisfied with their current coverage and doctor can keep their plan and their physician. However, if they arent happy with their coverage then this plan will help them find and afford quality healthcare. ( Press Release, 7/14/2009
Rep. Grijalva : No one is forced to do anything. The entire premise of this legislation is to build on what works in todays system. If you have employer sponsored health care today as do most insured people than little to nothing will change, except that your premiums will no longer subsidize coverage for the uninsured. If you are covered in the individual insurance market, you can keep your plan permanently and it will count as acceptable coverage even if it doesnt meet those terms under the new law. ( Obamacare FAQ )
Rep. Hastings (FL): Individuals who already have health insurance through their employers or are self-insured will keep their insurance. There is absolutely no provision within the ACA that would remove existing coverage from individuals and families. Furthermore, the law will make existing plans more secure and affordable.( Obamacare FAQ )
Rep. Hoyer: We need to build upon the current system of employer-sponsored care, with a system that provides patients their choice of insurance coverage and their choice of doctors. In other words, if you like what you have, you should be able to keep it. ( Town Hall Meeting, 4/21/2009 )
Rep. Rangel : This plan tells every American if you have coverage and a doctor you like, keep it. ( Press Release, 7/15/2009 )
Rep. Van Hollen: If you like your doctor and your plan, you can keep them. ( Press Release, 7/14/2009 )
Rep. Wasserman-Schultz (DNC Chair) : Let me be clear: if you like your current plan, youll be able to keep it. Rather, we will build on our current system, so we can give you the freedom to choose what works best for you and your family. If you like your doctor, keep your doctor. If you like your current plan, keep your current plan. If you dont, or if you dont have one, then get one that works for you. ( Press Release, 7/1/2009)
There are many more at --
http://www.ijreview.com/2013/11/94710-wasnt-just-barack-obama-lied-faces-obamacare/
Tags
Who is online
140 visitors

Seems like there are a lot of members of the House that have some explaining to do --
John
Your unflagging support and adoration for elected officials that lied to the faces of the American people is totally transparent
How many people need to be affected before a lack of honesty and integrity is unacceptable in our elected officials?
John
The articles are not about whether the PPACA or good or bad and if you were to read them slowly and understand them you would know that or perhaps you do and just ignore it because you want to defend the president.
The articles are about the promises made, the debacle of the implementation so far and the blame shifting by those who trumpeted the promises
What can be concluded about your obsession is that you refuse to accept that the administration can be wrong about anything or do anything wrong and that anyone who does question their actions is simply wrong.
Death panels... Euthanize Grandma...
Do you know how to tell a politician is lying? Just assume that they always are. I think we need to back off several notches on the supposed pressure we are placing on our elected officials to have everything they say be true always and forever.
I mean, in today's parlance, if one of your campaign promises (Promises, really? Assertions to try, maybe...) turns out not to have come to fruition, you are then labeled a LIAR!!, and the personal attack media have a feeding frenzy.
Besides, I thought we had to pass the bill in order to know what was in it.....
Gunny
A lie is a lie
Well said
jwc2blue
Nice deflection
You seem to have cut and pasted someone's article herefrom a web site I am not familiar with, which is why I never commented on the article. Perhaps you should seed an article of your own.
I absolutely concede that there have been lies about what the PPACA would and would not do and cause have beenpromulgated from the Republicans as well as those highlighted above from supporters of the bill
I notice you did not deny that the comments above are misleading at best and in some cases clear falsehoods
Thanks for your deflective perspective.
It seems that politicians lie when rich people refuse to pay their share.
Interesting theory, but the cause and effect seems a little vague
John since October 1st, 185 have lost their insurance to 1 that has gained insurance. Aren't you concerned with them losing their insurance?
Thousands of doctors have been given notice they are being released from their association with United Health because of White House pressure.
Sixpick
Thanks for sharing your perspective and the facts but I doubt that you will sway John's opinion
Isn't it that the plans are being jettisoned by the insurer's, rather than upgrading them to meet the minimum requirements?
For North Carolinians who already have health insurance, the only changes you will see under the Affordable Care Act are new benefits, better protections from insurance company abuses, and more value for every dollar you spend on health care. If you like your plan you can keep it, and you dont have to change a thing due to the health care law.
So, he was wrong on that last bit, but more accurate on the first (bolded).
Health care in America: Where the rich get richer and the poor still get screwed.
You have to admit Robert, the wealthy are in a better position to buy influence. Just the nature of the beast.
The Top 1 Percent Of Americans Will Pay 30 Percent Of The Nation's Federal Taxes In 2013: Report
-- How much households at different income levels will pay in federal income, payroll, corporate and estate taxes for 2013.
___
Bottom 20 percent
Average income: $10,552.
Average tax bill: -$284.
Average tax rate: -2.7 percent.
Share of federal tax burden: -0.4 percent.
Middle 20 percent
Average income: $46,562.
Average tax bill: $6,436.
Average tax rate: 13.8 percent.
Share of federal tax burden: 8.6 percent.
Top 20 percent
Average income: $204,490.
Average tax bill: $55,533.
Average tax rate: 27.2 percent.
Share of federal tax burden: 71.8 percent.
Top 1 percent
Average income: $1.4 million.
Average tax bill: $514,144.
Average tax rate: 35.5 percent.
Share of federal tax burden: 30.2 percent.
___
Note: The average family in the bottom 20 percent of households pays no federal taxes. Instead, many families in this group get payments from the federal government by claiming more in credits than they owe in taxes, giving them a negative tax rate.
You'll notice the middle income is where the individual doesn't receive any subsidies and starts paying full premium for their healthcare through Obamacare.
Part of that full premium is paying for the subsidies that any income level falling lower than them is not covering. It's not free from the government as the school system has programmed Americans to believe.
It actually is costing the middle income all the way up to the highest incomes to pay for the majority of the healthcare for the county. As you can see they already pay the majority of the taxes for the country.
I mean, what would satisfy you for them to donate their entire income to the country and just work for free. Obama's plan is to make everyone poor.
A good example of this is if your make $35K a year and work enough to increase your income to $46K a year you get to pay $5k more in healthcare premium and pay another $2750 in Federal taxes on the extra $11k, so after you pay the state taxes you get to keep less than $2k of the $11k extra you earned. Now that is some kind of incentive to work hard, isn't it? Guess you didn't do it, somebody else did.
Where's the lies? I don't see any lies in your comment JW.
Chucky
Never denied it and in fact agree that lobbyists detract from rather than enhance the legislative process but that is really not the point of the article
Broliver
But the PPACA fixes that right?
Sixpick
Tax contributions could be a good article but that is off topic here
Let;s focus
Thanks for the information
May as well put some faces on those liars. Or they could have just been ignorant and just saying what their dear leader told them to say.
GK Butterfield Democrat
Kathy Castor Democrat
John Conyers Democrat
Peter Difazio Democrat
Keith Ellison Democrat
Chaka Fattah Democrat
Alcee Hastings Democrat
Steny Hamilton Hoyer Democrat
Charles B. Rangel Democrat
Chris Van Hollen Democrat
Debbie Wasserman Schultz Democrat
Yes these are the people who didnt read the bill or just lied to us while being good little comrades in the fundamental transformation of the USA doing their part in their collective way.
Sixpixk
Didn't seem necessary as I thought folks could click on the link if they needed the pictures
Thanks for making it easier on everyone
jwc2blue
Nice use of text sizing, looks very professional
If your read and understand the comment I made, you would note
(I added the bolding this time so you would notice)
I seeded an article and provided the data that was in the article, I invited you t seed an article supporting the point you made and do so again.
I don't know if blue's comment was a deflection or not . But I have received a message from Buzz in China . He wants to thank you blue . Your text was large enough to read from China without the internet !
The funny thing is that everyone who has commented on this article is absolutely 100% correct. Go figure.
Chucky
It is always nice when everyone can be correct
Whenever the question is "Who lied, the republicans or the democrats?" the answer is always "YES".
Robert,
Did you read any current information that included *both* the statement that those private policies that were being cancelled have now been extended for another year AND that employer-based coverage will also be removed over this time frame or longer -- to force everyone into the exchange? I can't find the video and report from yesterday that I had read.
Chucky
You are a true sage
I answered your question you merely failed to comprehend
The article I seeded dealt with democrats if you want to delineate out Republican lies aboutthe PPACAplease seed a article
You can always be counted on to take personal shots when confronted with facts that you do not like
You never disappoint
jwc2blue
I did not dispute the validity of what you posted, it was off topic for the article I seeded so I moved on which dealt with Democrats who lied about the PPACA
If you wish to seed an article proving your point do so
Or you can just continue to wail
I am done with it and I am not in need of an apology from you
It's not that so much . It's just that your comments tend to be a mite biased . It is a lot of work to sort through them to find any nuggets of truth that may be hiding among the rubble ...
Not that its any of your business but there is an easy way around the copy/paste problem . I'd tell you what it is but it appears you are not done ranting yet ...
Thousands Of Small Businesses Will Also Start Losing Their Current Health Policies Under Obamacare. Here's Why
President Obamas simple line If you like your current health plan you can keep it is haunting him amidst reports that 3.5 million Americans who purchase health plans on their own, in the individual market, have lost that coverage as a result of Obamacare.
Very soon, small businesses will be faced with a similar fate.
They will also see their health plans canceled as a result of Obamacare.
Small businesses, with fewer than 50 employees, are not forced to provide coverage under Obamacare.
But when they do, policies sold in the small group market are subject to the same regulations now forcing the termination of millions of health plans sold directly to consumers.
But late last year, businesses that employed fewer than 50 employees began exploiting a loophole they found in the Obamacare text. If the businesses renewed their policies early, before the end of 2013, then those plans would not be subject to Obamacares costly mandates for a full year, in many cases until December 31, 2014.
But that clock is already ticking. Starting in October 2014, many employees of small businesses will start getting the same notices that are now being mailed to individuals, informing that their existing health plans are also being cancelled.
These small businesses will be faced with a bleak choice.
Find another policy thats compliant with Obamacare, but also more costly. Or put their employees into the Obamacare exchange.
For many of the largest insurers, including Aetna, United Healthcare, Wellpoint, and Cigna; the small group market is among their most lucrative insurance products. For this reason, these big insurers are likely to try and hold onto some of this business.
But they will not be able to fully shield businesses from the new costs.
While a smaller percentage of business plans may get cancelled (relative to the fraction of individual market plans that are now being terminated) the small group market is nonetheless much bigger than the individual market. Even if Obamacare materially affects a smaller slice of the business plans, it will still encumber far more people than the 3.5 million individuals now losing coverage.
Insurers that are dumping their individual market policies are doing so now to meet a January 1, 2014 deadline to either comply with Obamacare or terminate their plans. They need to give consumers 90 days notice under HIPPA rules.
In contrast, by renewing their policies off cycle, the small businesses were able to lock in another year before they have to comply with Obamacare. Many of these small business plans wont be subject to the laws mandates until January 1, 2015.
This means that employees of small businesses wont get their cancellation notices until November of 2014. Thats because these plans are subject to ERISA rules. These regulations require businesses and health plans to notify consumers 60 days before they plan to change or terminate policies. News of cancellations will go directly to employees, just like the termination notices now arriving in the mail .
(Some individual market policies were also renewed off cycle and bought themselves more time. Many of these plans will also get terminated next year).
A hint of these woes could start to filter out earlier. Health plans have to submit their products to state insurance commissioners (and get rates approved) in the spring of 2014. Thats when politicians will start to get a more precise view on how many policies will be canceled.
And how much will the remaining small businesses plans be affected once they are also made subject to the full brunt of Obamacare?
Aetna has already warned in its marketing materials that dramatic increases in premiums might be in the offing. Factors such as essential health benefits, maximum plan deductibles, the application of new taxes and fees and new rating rules will combine to push insurance premiums up substantially for some small businesses, the insurer said.
In December, Aetna Chief Executive Mark Bertolini said he expects that premiums for individuals or small groups seeking coverage on health insurance exchanges will rise by 20% to 50% in 2014.
This is what really has Democrats so worried. These cancellation notices are going to hit small businesses one month before the next election.
Congress could introduce legislation to allow the existing small business plans to be extended indefinitely. Most of these are good plans already subject to strict regulation. There is no reason Obamacare should force changes.
Its another painful blow set to befall consumers as a result of Obamacare.
Every time another layer of this law gets peeled away, or another provision gets implemented, another block of Americans gets harmed.
Small business policies are the next to fall.
Aren't 'all' current employer-based plans, regardless of the size of the employee base, going to eventually be cancelled, in the Gov's quest to force everyone into the exchange? (or pay the fine for that year for not buying their product) Maybe the word isn't in all of the edited and censored MSM sources, yet.
Robert,
"But the PPACA fixes that right?"
It is too early to see if the actual law will have it's intended effect... Hell, there are different interpretations of just what it was supposed to do.
If it was meant to increase the number of people with health insurance by subsidizing the purchase of same, then I think that it will work, and almost by default.
If it was meant to control the rising costs of healthcare, until the profit motive is addressed, it doesn't stand a chance. From what I have seen and heard, it does not appear that it was designed to do that in any way.
But all this hue and cry, this gnashing of teeth by one person, faction, party or the other and the pandering to the lowest common denominator by most of the media outlets is primarily a distraction, intentional or not, to keep the American public from viewing things as they are and having the people realize that the other party, the other person is not who they should be fighting against. More often than not, they should be doing things together.
When I first came to NT, the Main Chat room was beeping all of the time, and one got to know and foster relationships with people before you knew all of their political ideologies. The Main room created a kind of buffer for the tit-for-tat bickering by showing that we could interact and get along despite our widely varying points of view. Today, the Main room is mostly silent, and the relationships formed are more antagonistic and much less friendly because we only interact on the articles.
Broliver
You are 100%, absolutely correct. I agree totally
I also agree with your assessment that the PPACA will broaden access, through taxpayer subsidies, but will do little to control or lower the spiraling costs of health care. I was being a little sarcastic above when I said "But the PPACA fixes that right?"
I am not sure if that is why it has gotten so antagonistic (you are likely correct to some degree) but it certainly becomes more and more hostile with more commentary on the people making comments or posting articles than on the issue itself.
Always enjoy and appreciate your feedback even when we disagree.
The intent of Obamacoverage was to identify 'who' will be paying for 'everyone' to have an insurance product=those that pay taxes and are working. That's it. But, not 'everyone' wants or needs a policy or wants or needs to pay a premium for his basic 'ten.'
The thing is...not 'every' state is willing to risk default. And, as it has been shown by Six and perhaps others, it's not always the best route for a low income person to take -- they could end up with less income.
Chloe
Thanks for your perspective
Once the rollout and implementation are complete (date TBD), we will be able to evaluate the actual results and see what got better and what got worse
Sixpick
Thanks for the info a lot to absorb
Chloe
I had not seen that point reported
Thank you, Robert. Waiting for them to force everyone off of their employer supported plans would be too late. Everyone would then be forced into the exchange (or pay a fine for not buying a government product).
As I had mentioned on my article, the unfairness in this, is that companies with unions negotiated medical benefits 'in lieu of' pay...so if the government is going to step in on private business and remove a negotiated benefit -- then someone - either the Government or the Company had better make sure the payscale is changed. That would be a contractual item, of course, but what gets negotiated is less often wages.
Anyone with employee coverage now, is going to be put into a 'paying a lot more' for the same benefits they had with an employer, and because their union might not negotiate high enough wage increases...they will be put into the position of paying more overall (for others' benefits and their own - as well as big tax increases over the years....while bringing in less income), and having less disposable income.
With the logical onset of this issue affecting small, community-based businesses, I can't help but wonder what will happen to local economies.
CL, Well, I don't really agree with the statement:The intent of Obamacoverage was to identify 'who' will be paying for 'everyone' to have an insurance product because the expressed intent was to provide more people for the insurance companies to carry on their roles and this would provide enough of a buffer to carry everyone. The insurance companies loved this, especially when they found out that itwas to be subsidized by the public.
For profit insurance, IMO is morally wrong. I think that we should have a plan fully subsidized by everyone, along with rates for medical services that are in line with the rest of the world, instead of this cyclic circle jerk that we call US health care, because it really is a system that is out of control, empowered and emplaced by the money it siphons off of everybody it touches.
Brolly,
You are essentially making the same point as I did, but you're leaving out the part about 'who' pays for all these increased policies when people are being forced out of their current plans that either pays for themselves or an employer pays part of it for 'the employee' - not the whole nation!---and that is what is clear to me, especially when ACA demands a 'projected' 2.5 billion in tax increases in just ten short years...and a trillion in increased taxes over twenty -- all paid for by whoever happens to be working. If it isn't obvious, this is about Business and Government 'shifting' financial responsibility, accountability, and 'liability' to American citizens to pay for someone who 'isn't.'
As was mentioned previously, the exchange income requirements will keep some (low income) out (opt out) because it would mean they would end up with less income. Only someone with a condition might consider losing income, but most would seem to logically opt out.
Your welcome Robert. There's only so much you can focus just on the others who repeated what Obama said, so a little extra information or opinion can't be a bad thing as long as it stays within the area of the problems caused by the deceptive measures used to persuade the people to continue on with this monstrosity.
After all 80% of the people were happy with their insurance. There has never been more than half the people in this country who were in favor of Obamacare and when you consider basically only half the people will be paying 100% of their premium and subsidizing all the others that says a lot in itself.
And considering the whole thing was done behind closed doors not open for public discussion thru Louisiana Purchase and all the other underhanded measures taking a bill to help the returning vets with their mortgages and turning it into Obamacare in spite of at least half the people against it, I think most any information can be beneficial.
2015 Will Be Worse For Obamacare Than Its 2014 Debut As A Result Of New Burdens The White House Is Saddling Onto Insurers
An ominous and largely ignored outcome of Obamacares failed launch is that the large insurers have not signed up to offer health plans on the state exchanges.
The nations big insurers have mainly sat out of the program, even after a reported browbeating from the White House .
The reason is simple. Offering plans on the exchanges is a bad business deal.
This past week the White House took some additional steps to make that market even worse for big insurers (on top of the problems with the web site). The Obama team seems to be going out of its way to squeeze the insurers. These measures make sure that 2015 will be an even more dismal experience for Obamacare than 2014.
Its already off to a bad start.
As I noted recently in the New York Post and on Forbes.com ,Obamacare regulations force insurers to either be all in, or all out of a particular state exchange.
A survey of 36 federally run exchanges (plus six state exchanges where data was available) found that Aetna [NYSE:AET] was offering health plans in just eight states and was even more selective in the counties where they chose to play. In Florida, for example, Aetna was only operating plans in 23 of the states 67 regions.
Cigna [NYSE:CI] only entered five states. United Healthcare [NYSE:UNH] (the nations largest insurer) entered just 12.
Humana only went into 14 states. In Colorado its offering plans in just 2 of 11 regions and in Florida, just 12 of the 67 state regions.
The result? According to one recent analysis, just one or two insurance carriers are serving exchanges in more than half of the countrys 2,500 counties.
The problem is that the law was tilted against the health plans at its inception . These challenges are being magnified by the Obama teams present day decisions that will discourage plans that sat out of the market in 2014 from entering in 2015.
One such ruling, made last week , will allow third parties (like drug companies and hospitals) to subsidize the cost of health plan premiums.
The decision was laid out in a letter sent by the Department of Health and Human Services to Representative McDermott (D-WA) indicating that the Obama team does not consider qualified health plans purchased through insurance exchanges to be federal healthcare programs. This includes plans purchased through state and federal exchanges, as well as plans for which consumers receive advance payments of premium tax credits and cost-sharing reductions.
This means that exchange plans are not subject to federal anti-kickback rules. So manufacturers can offer direct support to exchange enrollees. Most interpreted this to mean that drug companies can provide financial assistance to help offset drug co-pays . But the impact of the decision probably extends much further.
Drug companies, for example, can probably help offset the costs of plan premiums, under the ruling, and not just the costs of individual drugs. Simiularly, hospitals could help subsidize the cost of buying health coverage for a local population of uninsured individuals who are frequently admitted to their institutions. This would reduce the hospitals bad debt (from unpaid bills) by getting these chronically ill individuals into insurance schemes. Even if these local residents were very sick, so long as they are young and poor, then purchasing entry-level coverage for them could cost very little (owing to premium subsidies and favorable age-based rating).
This ruling is clearly good for some consumers. Its also good for the President. The decision will encourage the use of private-market subsidies to help more people purchase coverage (boosting the dismal enrollment numbers). The Obama team is trying to stuff as many people into the exchanges, as quickly as possible. Once these exchanges grow big enough, they become politically inevitable.
Even when a bare bones bronze plan saddles a lower-income beneficiary with hefty cost-sharing (that could go unpaid), to a local hospital, the covered portion of the hospital stay will still be worth the negligible cost of purchasing the plan for the consumer.
But you can see how the decision could spell trouble for health plans, which are already worried about adverse selection of a mostly older, sicker population of patients into the exchanges as a consequence of Obamacares failed launch.
Hospitals and drug makers arent going to subsidize the purchase of healthcare for the healthy beneficiaries that insurers need in order to make these new exchanges viable. These entities are going to cherry pick the sickest consumers, and help to pay for their coverage.
Drug makers want to find patients who will use expensive medicines. Hospitals want to find local residents who are uninsured but are being frequently admitted to the hospital for chronic and costly conditions.
As one Wall Street analyst noted this week, premium outlays would be small relative to the potential uncompensated care cost burden borne by health care providers on behalf of these heavy users of the health care system.
This single decision could do a lot more than the botched web site to help make sure that the pool of consumers who enter Obamacare are a sick and costly population.
The Obama team is set to unload other challenges onto the insurers.
The White House has to make a decision about how it will apportion cuts to the cost-sharing subsidies that are a consequence of sequester. The White House has strongly hinted that it will force the insurance companies to absorb these cuts. The general refrain is that the Obama team was waiting until after an October 31 st deadline, when health plans could still pull out of the exchanges for a material breach of their contracts. Expect the White House to announce this soon .
Its looking more inevitable that Obamacare will remain a niche market, and become mostly a high-risk pool. It will provide coverage to lower-income families who earn too much to qualify for Medicaid and will benefit most from the exchanges subsidies. The exchanges will also benefit consumers with chronic medical conditions who have an reason to put up with the exchanges comparatively high premiums. They will buy more comprehensive Gold or Platinum coverage rather than Bronze plans that are likely to sold much more cheaply outside the exchange risk pools.
Consumers who are younger or largely healthy will gravitate to the risk pools outside the exchanges, and to the cheap bronze plans. They will end up with policies that are more costly (and less generous) than the plans many of them currently enjoy. But for families of four earning more than about $60,000 in annual income (and individuals earning more than about $30,000) these bronze policies sold outside the exchanges will be cheaper than the pricey risk pools in the exchanges, (even without the benefit of the subsidies that they could get under Obamacare).
As I noted in Forbes, by staying completely outside the exchanges, insurers will be able to create a separate risk pool , and price premiums to these lower costs.
The Obama team is spinning the lack of participation by the big insurers as natural business caution during a new programs initial year.
But the launch of Medicare Part D didnt face similar woes. The pundits said that the problem with Part Ds launch was too many plans initially entering the market, not too few (creating confusion for consumers). Rest assured, the Obama White House spent a lot of time trying to coerce the big insurers to enter more state exchanges.
The insurers sat out because it makes better business sense for them to be completely outside the exchanges, rather than in them even just a little.
The failed launch of Obamacare meant that the initial pool of applicants this year was likely to be older and sicker than what the insurers had envisioned. The Obama teams subsequent decisions seem to be squeezing the health plans still further.
Nobody should feel overly sorry for the nations big insurers. So far, theyve been able to pass most of their new costs to consumers. They also made a Faustian bargain in supporting Obamcares passage in the first place (on the premise that it would boost their business) only to find that the Obama team was a bad partner. Their early and obsequious support now looks nave.
The fiery speech that President Obama gave in Bostons Faneuil Hall last week, reprising some of the same anti-insurance-industry demagoguery that he used in the run-up to passage of Obamacare, is likely to be standard fare going forward.
The insurers can expect to catch the blame at each glitch. The administration broke the marketplace , and now the insurers will get to own it.
Well, at least it's not over 2000 pages long with thousands of additions added since the inception like Obamacare.
I had thought showing everyone how my employer-based coverage changed, that I was made aware of in 2012, that more than doubled the premium for the employee - was proof enough that this is all about shifting responsibility to the taxpayer, and taking more of the responsibility off of Business...negotiated in my case, but the point remains.
As I have previously mentioned, an MSNBC report in '08 quoted Pelosi saying that the only way they could make Obamacoverage work, would be to force everyone to pay, and those that had policies would have to pay more.
But, I don't want national socialized health insurance. We work to buy 'products' we need or want in life. If our pay doesn't afford a product, then we can't buy it, of course.
In my opinion, (and that + $1 willget you a cup of coffee), I don'tthink ANYONE really knows how it is all going to work, until it is fully implemented. Then, it will be tweaked, so as to fix the problems it has caused, and augment the benefits. Even when it all is implemented, I feel sure that it will change...
I do agree that people have misled us. Giving them the benefit of the doubt, I don't know that everyone did it on purpose-- they just don't know. Some, I admit, have either painted a gloomy/rose picture for their own personal gain. And please don't ask me for examples, as I do not wish to get into a finger-pointing game.
But, for me:
There doesn't seem to be much any of us can really do about it, but adjust. We will all have to make decisions based on what is best, or even the least awful, for ourselves. Me stewing over it, getting angry about it, is going to help anyone. Nor is it productive. Besides, the more I stew over things, the more likely I'll need that medical care... Paid for, or not.
Take care--
Dowser
As thanks for the thoughtful and insightful feedback
Your perspective is a very good one and I agree that everyone was likely not purposefully dishonest and deceitful on this issue, but it is just as disturbing that some of them would not know the truth to me.
The serenity prayer is indeed a good path to follow in dealing with politics and economic issues these days.
And on a lighter note, not too many places left where you can get a cup of coffee for a $1
Take good care
Broliver
A lot of people agree with you regarding for profit insurance, but if we follow the path you discuss why stop there?
Why not imply have the government nationalize all health care (hospitals, clinics, pharmacies etc and all medical services, devices, medicines etc would be provided by the government and all medical professional would work for the government?
I don't advocate that approach but I am sure that it has the support of some and maybe even many
Broliver
I think this is pretty close to the facts. The underlying foundation of the PPACA is that young healthy people will pay for the older and sicker people who need more care and that the government will pay for those that cannot afford to pay themselves.
So Chloe is not that far off in my view
Boy, that's the truth! Try $5?
When I lived in Arkansas I had a friend who was self employed and running his own, profitable business. He thought that he had a good insurance plan, until his wife had cardiac arrest and spent a month in the ICU. That is when he found that his plan was really worthless. And, of course, he couldn't get new insurance because of her now pre-existing condition.
The specific thing I am not agreeing with about the quoted statement is the word intent. Everyone is supposed to pay something for their health insurance. Everyone who works or has an income is already paying for those who do not have and/or cannot afford health insurance. By increasing the numbers of insured, we are removing a dark area in terms knowledge of those people, and helping to remove one of the excuses that insurance companies used to make rate increases.
Personally, I think that we all have a responsibility to maintain our society, and the vector of money and peoples relationship to it bears close scrutiny. As long as we think that we have no financial responsibilities to society and perceive everything that we extract from society as purely ours (Kind of like Wall Street is doing right now), we will continue to bicker and quibble and gnash our teeth at the so called injustice of making sure that everyone has access to quality health care.
It was not the intent of the ACA to identify who is going to be paying for whom.
She may be correct in her assertions of who will be paying, but that was not the intent of the law.
I am game. Sounds a bit extreme, though.
How about some transparency on the actual costs of medical services and look at the foundations of the problem? The medical arena has been for far too long a place where the numbers just see to be made up of whole cloth and the players seem to perceive it as a way to make money because everyone likes to be healthy and alive, so just charge more.
Which payroll tax is that?
I have never suggested that generalization; I fully agree with local infrastructure taxes. I just don't agree with being forced to buy someone consumer goods.
If you pay for insurance, you are (according to the insurance industry and every pundit or shill for) paying the costs of treating uninsured people). Using that same logic, I am sure that you can attribute a portion of every penny spent in the world to paying to health care and, by extension, the uninsured.
You are buying the assurance health care, and that should not be treated as a "Consumer Good"...
I think we should have a tax for that very reason.
All in all, Brolly, I understand you are wanting this to end in single payer.
Whether it's single payer or an exchange product, no one seems to be focusing on where this 'has to lead.'
I'm reading statements in articles about 'affordable' and affordable premiums. 1) affordable to whom? 2) why is the product affordable to that consumer?
1. No one is addressing the massive tax increases that will have to occur to pay for this. Sure, it's very affordable to someone that doesn't have the responsibility. 2. The reason why that product is affordable to that consumer is because someone else is picking up the tab, and by the time that someone else finishes paying for the other person (subsidies), themself and the ACA tax bill, the combined pkg. is only affordable if they make sacrifices in their lives - sacrifices that someone else isn't having to make. I don't want this because we're already being forced to pay for the other end (elderly), now we're being forced to pay for the opposing end (non-retirees) of a nation this large - Huge! ..with open borders! I don't want to see 60-70% tax rate with no disposable income left to enjoy one's life.
I agree to disagree.
Chloe
It appears that there is a belief by some that shifting the cost to the government is the same as lowering the cost of health care
Robert, I think that's what some must be assuming. i.e. I read the article recently put up by another when they made a test requesting insurance through the exchange [re Mr. Boehner]. The two examples that came up using his criteria were: 1) $400 a month with a $ 6000 deductible; 2) $1000 a month with no deductible. That's nearly the same as what my old policy [employer-based] was changing to starting in January [I had been paying $400 with no deductible]. I changed policies because I thought that was ludicrous. It's unfathomable to me that an average person would think those figures are acceptable after having very reasonable coverage through an employer. Healthy people that aren't high-risk won't be accessing the policy, or won't have enough expense to ever get past their deductible; it's really unfair, imo, to be forced into paying a monthly amount whether we want to or not, or pay a fine - that who knows what the cap is, or if there is one.