Senate "Nuclear Option" is No Option
Yogi Berra once warned, Youve got to be very careful if you dont know where you are going because you might not get there. That advice might well be given to Senate Democrats and Republicans as they careen toward a third conflict over reforming the filibuster in less than a year.
Republicans created this crisis by returning to a strategy of obstructing President Barack Obamas nominees. At immediate issue are the confirmations of Rep. Mel Watt (D-N.C.) as director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency and attorney Patricia Ann Millett to the D.C. Circuit Court. Both thus far have been blocked by filibusters in the Senate. The GOPs filibuster of Millett is especially galling because it is a part of a strategy to prevent the president from filling any of the three vacancies on the important appeals court. They are making the transparently absurd argument that filling these seats constitutes court packing.
Democrats are responding by rolling out the now-familiar threat to invoke the nuclear option a parliamentary sleight of hand that Joe Biden back in 2005 called a lie about a rule. Unfortunately, he has recently been quoted as having said at a fundraiser, I think its worth considering.
The vice president knows better. As a senator, he was crystal clear, calling the nuclear option a fundamental power grab by the majority party. Bidens views are critical because he, as presiding officer of the Senate, would be called upon to ignore its rules and precedents, and the almost-certain advice of the parliamentarian that ending debate requires a two-thirds vote. He would be asked to rule that debate can be ended and the rules changed at any time by a simple majority vote, a break with more than 200 years of Senate tradition. Soon, such a Senate would resemble the House, where the majority exercises strict control, debate is limited and amendments are often not permitted.
Many on the left openly call for ending the filibuster entirely. No senator has been openly willing to take this position. Senate proponents of the nuclear option claim they wish to make only moderate changes to address GOP abuse of the filibuster. This ignores the inevitable. Majorities do what majorities do when they can: They take control. This is a slippery slope so slick that there is no return.
And the slope is getting slippery already. In advance of this session of Congress in January, Senate Democrats argued that the nuclear option could be used only on the first day of a new session. In fact, the majority leader kept the Senate technically in the first legislative day for several weeks (by recessing the Senate instead of adjourning it) while negotiations about rules changes proceeded. This left open the exercise of the nuclear option if the negotiations failed. The assertion then was that reformers wanted only to make small changes in filibuster rules. The showdown ended when both parties agreed to adopt several moderate changes to the rules.
In July came nuclear option crisis 2.0. Republicans were blocking a number of Obamas executive branch nominees. Again, some Democrats wanted to go nuclear. Since it was inconveniently no longer the first day of a new session, they simply dropped the first-day requirement. They asserted, however, that they wished to eliminate the filibuster only for presidential executive branch nominees. This second rules crisis ended in a bipartisan compromise that has led to the confirmation of a number of the appointments in question.
We now face nuclear option crisis 3.0. This time, the focus is mostly about judicial nominations. The nuclear option, it is argued, should be used to prohibit filibusters not only on executive branch nominations but judicial nominations as well. These were left out in July because federal judges serve for life. Democrats, although currently in the majority, were divided about risking the possibility of future Republican presidents working with Senate Republican majorities to stock the courts, including the Supreme Court, with more conservative judges.
We only narrowly averted a nuclear option crisis 4.0. Last month, Republicans appeared to be preparing to block legislation to open the government and lift the debt ceiling. The leading proponents of the nuclear option began calling for its use to change the rules and thwart such obstruction an unprecedented expansion of this unusual parliamentary ploy to legislative matters.
The nuclear option has never been used, nor should it be. Democrats should back away from that slippery slope before they make a decision they may later regret.
Richard A. Arenberg, who worked on Senate and House staffs for 34 years, is co-author of Defending the Filibuster: The Soul of the Senate. He is an adjunct professor at Brown University.
http://www.politico.com/story/2013/11/senate-nuclear-option-filibuster-99681.html#ixzz2kT0wgOVz
Tags
Who is online
124 visitors

I agree wholeheartedly that gridlock in the Senate is contrary to the best interests of the nation and fervently hope that it becomes less prevalent in the near term and going forward.
Such a rule change would give us two chambers (versus the current one) of Congress in the stranglehold of the majority and I am not sure that will be good in the long term for the country
cant harry just "deem" them concented to?
it worked for obamacare
the main thing is that the rules be changed when the liberals run the senate and house, but not conservatives.
that is whats really important.
JoAnne
I think the word you were looking for was consented and I fail to see the relevance of your comment to the topic
The topic is the wisdom and likelihood of changing the Senate rules
Care to comment on that
J F T
That the process has been abusedin the past decade plusis inarguable but a rule change is forever and would have dramatic effect on the Senate and how it operates.
I understand your logic but ask if you really think it would be better for both chambers to be ruled by the iron hand of the majority?
JoAnne
Not an untypical comment but totally irrelevant as a change in the Senate rules would not work that way
Anything else?
yes, consented, thanks.
i thought it was a discussion about senate rule changes, and that brown taking teddy's seat, to vote against the trainwreck of obamacare, only to find that harry reid went around that rule, and simply "deemed it passed" was on point.
as in, he can just deem a nominee consented to
sorry if i am mistaken.
JoAnne
You are indeed mistaken
Thanks for your perspective but the topic is the wisdom and likelihood of changing the Senate rules and a partisan slap fest adds no value to that discussion
J F T
Possibly
But one party could control both chambers after the mid terms and surely it will happen at some point in the future and even without total control both chambers controlled by the majorities (even two different parties) does not sound like a good idea to me.
You could be right but I hope that they leave the Senate rules alone
From June 2001 to January 2003, when the Senate in the 107th Congress was controlled by the Democrats, many conservative appellate nominees were stalled in the Senate Judiciary Committee and never given hearings or committee votes.
During the 108th Congress in which the Republicans regained control of the Senate by a 51-49 margin, the nominees that the Senate Democrats had blocked in the 107th Congress began to be moved through the now Republican Senate Judiciary Committee . [ 10 ] Subsequently Senate Democrats started to filibuster judicial nominees. On February 12, 2003, Miguel Estrada , a nominee for the D.C. Circuit , became the first court of appeals nominee ever to be successfully filibustered. Later, nine other conservative court of appeals nominees were also filibustered. These nine were Priscilla Owen , Charles W. Pickering , Carolyn Kuhl , David W. McKeague , Henry Saad , Richard Allen Griffin , William H. Pryor , William Gerry Myers III and Janice Rogers Brown . [ 11 ] Three of the nominees (Estrada, Pickering and Kuhl) withdrew their nominations before the end of the 108th Congress.
That was TEN filibusters.
109th Congress [ edit ]
Things changed in 2005 due to the 2004 elections. With President Bush's re-election and the Republicans picking up further Senate seats (55-45) in the 109th Congress , the "nuclear option" became a more viable strategy to ensure confirmation. On May 24, 2005, seven moderate senators of each party, called the Gang of 14 , in a deal to avoid the use of the "nuclear option", agreed to drop the filibuster against three of the seven remaining affected court of appeals nominees ( Priscilla Owen , Janice Rogers Brown , and William Pryor ) but not two others ( Henry Saad and William Myers ). [ 13 ] In addition, the senators in the group agreed not to block future judicial nominees with filibusters except in cases involving "extraordinary circumstances".
As a direct result of the deal, the two filibustered nominees not mentioned in it ( David W. McKeague and Richard Allen Griffin ) were confirmed, as was Thomas B. Griffith , the person nominated to replace Miguel Estrada after his withdrawal. Griffith too had become the subject of controversy. [ 14 ] Since Saad had no hope of a successful cloture vote to overcome his filibuster due to the deal, he withdrew his nomination in the spring of 2006. [ 15 ]
At the end of the 109th Congress, a new controversy arose over William Myers and three other Bush court of appeals nominees who had not been specifically mentioned in the Gang deal but were still subject to its provisions: Terrence Boyle , William J. Haynes, II and Michael B. Wallace . These nominations were returned to the White House according to Senate rules on August 3, 2006 in advance of the annual August recess of Congress. When the Senate returned in September, it was only for a short period before a break for the 2006 midterm election. Although Boyle, Myers, Haynes and Wallace were renominated, again no action was taken on them in the Senate Judiciary Committee before the break, and their nominations were sent back a second time to the White House on September 29. [ 16 ]
After the November 7, 2006 election in which Democrats picked up six additional Senate seats, President Bush again renominated the candidates whose nominations had been sent back to him in September. The Republican Judiciary Committee chairman, Senator Arlen Specter , however, said that he would not process these nominees during the lame duck session of the 109th Congress. [ 17 ]
110th Congress [ edit ]
At the beginning of the 110th Congress in January 2007, President Bush did not renominate Boyle, Myers, Haynes and Wallace in an attempt at reconciliation with the Democrats. [ 18 ] However, that did not stop many Bush judicial nominees from being blocked in committee by the new Democratic chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Senator Patrick Leahy . Among those stalled in committee until their nominations lapsed were appellate nominees Peter Keisler , Robert J. Conrad , Steve A. Matthews and Glen E. Conrad .
List of stalled, blocked or filibustered Bush nominees
Now tell us again about Republican abuse of the filibuster.
Len
Thanks for the info
Len
Again thanks for all the info
Any comment other than the data