╌>

The-True-Purpose-Of-ObamaCare-A-Single-Payer-Trojan-Horse

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  13 years ago  •  62 comments

The-True-Purpose-Of-ObamaCare-A-Single-Payer-Trojan-Horse

obama_shush_AFP.jpg?width=700
The Affordable Care Act is already doing a fantastic job at it's true purpose: taking great health insurance plans away from people and replacing them with either a much higher-priced, inferior plan or....nothing.

In all the discussion about ObamaCare, many people are missing the point about the true purpose of the law. Supposedly, the purpose of the Affordable Care Act was to lower health insurance costs and provide better health insurance plans for people to purchase.

Far from it.

The actual purpose of the ACA is to prepare the ground for a single payer system to come later.

ObamaCare was designed to 'fix' the problem of a country in which most had health insurance coverage and were happy with the status quo.

Progressives realized they were never going to get this backwards country to a single payer system as long as 85% of Americans had coverage and the majority of them were satisfied with the health insurance plan they had. The top leadership of the Democratic Party rightly recognized this situation as a huge obstacle to ever getting a single payer system implemented on the entire country from Washington DC.

The goal of ObamaCare is a national transformation from a country where 85% had health insurance & of those 87% were happy with their plan, to one where almost no one will be happy with what they have been forced to take.

After a few years of this new situation, Progressives figured people would be ready to hear their solution to the problem: a single payer system.

If people were never going to voluntarily hand over their private insurance plans, they would just have to be tricked into it then.

Let that sink in: Since American citizens were never going to voluntarily hand over their health insurance plans, a strategy was formed in which those plans would be stripped from them involuntarily. And that strategy was the Affordable Care Act and the multitude of lies that Democrats told about it.

They repeatedly lied to the country about keeping plans and keeping doctors and premiums being lower, knowing full well the entire time that this would not be the case.

But by the time the public figured this out, it would be too late. The law would have already passed and be in force, and millions of people will have had their insurance plans ripped from their fingers before they could even protest about it.

As I discussed in this previous column, Obama and the Democratic Party knew they had to deliberately mislead as many Americans as possible about what the ACA would do to their health insurance plans in order to pass the bill.

President Obama asked the country to trust him when he repeatedly promised it the ACA wouldn't affect people who liked their current plans and wanted to keep them. He performed perhaps the biggest political dirty trick ever pulled on the American people and he did it openly and brazenly.

He could do that with a clear conscience because like many Progressives, Obama believes in lying to people for their own good.

At least Conservatives will treat people like adults. To the Progressives, Americans will always be stupid children who need to be coerced, bribed or tricked into doing the 'right' thing.

How could Democrats think they could get away with this kind of shameless behavior? They were convinced back in 2008 they had at last grown their base to the point they would never lose another election. Many of them still think this, despite the setback of losing the House of Representatives in 2010 and 2012. They still see a 'permanent Democratic majority' out there and so remain confident they can propagandize their way out of any consequences.

The arrogance of the Progressive Left knows no bounds. They fully expect to get away with this.

loading

"What a bunch of suckers. Wonder how long it'll take them to figure it out?"

At this point, no one has even asked Barack Obama about all the false promises he made to the American people about the ACA. How much longer will the President be allowed to skate by on this before he's confronted with the fact the promises he uttered so freely and extravagantly in 2009 have now been shown to be utterly false?

The radical Leftists in control of the Democratic Party remain convinced despite having pulled a gigantic fraud upon the American people with the Affordable Care Act, enough of their base will stick with them to deliver election victories in 2014 and 2016.

It'll be up to the American people to prove them wrong.
Link


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

You could not be more poorly informed!

These are PRIVATE insurance companies and come under the grandfather clause; people who now have their junk policies can keep them IF THE INSURANCE COMPANIES THAT SELL THEM, CONTINUE TO SELL THEM.

And because they are still part of the free market, they can cancel policies whenever they feel like doing so like when someone gets sick and makes a claim ((until the PPACA kicks in, in January, 2014). Preventing these bastards from doing so along with other reforms THAT PROTECT THE CONSUMER, is what the "Reform Law" is all about.

I love when the Tea Party screams about "regulations" then bitches when health insurers cancel policies arbitrarily BECAUSE OF THE LACK OF REGULATIONS!

The reason the policies are being cancelled is BECAUSE UNDER THE PPACA, PEOPLE WILL BE ABLE TO AFFORD BETTER POLICIES FOR LESS MONEY AND THE COMPANIES NOW CANCELLING KNOW THAT THEY WON'T BE COMPETITIVE. So, they will be offering the "Obamacare"-type policies instead of the type they're cancelling!

Righties refuse to believe this because you listen to the Tea Party. The Tea Party is lying about the law and the cancellation particulars and the willing-dupe Obama haters run with the lies.

From now on, concerning those of you just don't want to know, it's Matthew 7:6.

Believe what you want; you are misinformed or simply do not want to accept the truth.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago
At least Conservatives will treat people like adults.

As in, "I'm sorry sir, but your pre-existing condition is your problem. Stop whining and take it like a man."

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The current plan as it sits is unsustainable, You actually hinted on this yourself with your article titled:

REALITY - Without a mechanism that encourages younger, healthier individuals to buy coverage and spread the risk and cost of insurance, programs composed of very costly applicants are not sustainable

There is a difference between not wanting to contribute and not wanting to flush money down the toilet.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

A few weeks ago I wouldn't have paid much attention to this article. But when you start adding the facts up, it becomes hard to ignore:

  1. They knew damn well anyone with "catastrophic" or "junk" policies (as you like to call them) would lose their insurance. (if you try to argue they didn't know this then please be prepared to explain how they could be so ignorant of their own law.)
  2. The "fine" is a joke and will not get a healthy person to pay many times more for insurance they don't use. This means the number of "Healthy" participants is not going to even come close to cutting it.
  3. Some "Healthy" that can no longer afford insurance will get "help" from the government and further exasperate the problem of not having enough PAYING healthy to tow the line.
  4. The spiraling cost of care must be detained for ACA to work as well. (so far I see little to no effort in this respect)

The system as it stands is unsustainable and our government knows it. Unless fines are jacked up to almost parallel insurance cost, and these other issues are addressed it will collapse under it's own weight. After that happens single payer will be an easier sell, wouldn't it? If single payer isn't the goal, Why aren't they working to fix these problems that they already know will be the death of it?

It is starting to look like either this was the plan all along, we will see it collapse and single payer will be the solution. Or our government is inept and incapable of handling health care at all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But the ACA mandates that these companies must sell policies that comply with the new regulations. Or, lose their right to sell policies. What are they supposed to do? stop selling policies or comply with the new laws and regulations?

That applies to the selling of new policies not those that are grandfathered; but, when the full law kicks in, the new regulations will apply to the grandfathered policies as well as far as cancellations and coverage caps. Still, the grandfathered junk policies will retain their meager coverages and high deductibles, so, when those insured realize they can buy better policies for what they now pay for "junk" policies (because of subsidies), it will be a no-brainer. That's why the companies are cancelling the junk -- going forward, to be competitive, they'll have to offer the better policies.

I've yet to see an actual case of a person with a policy not getting care for a covered illness or injury. Please show me one. Now don't be like all the rest and show tons of examples of people being denied coverage for illness and injury not covered by their policy . That's not the same thing

Disagree; if a policy says it covers "X", then, when an insured develops "X" and is promptly dropped, that's tantamount to "not being covered." And that will be precluded under the PPACA.

people who have been trying to get the proof have been stymied by both the governments intransigence in releasing the enrollment, sales and policy data and the actual bungled rollout itself has been a real info stopper.

That's a logistical problem not a plan problem. Feel free to call me out if it turns out I'm wrong. Some are already getting policies with better-than-junk-coverage for less premium cost.

150,000 Sign Ups Under New York Obamacare Exchange

...

Obamacare just cut Oregons uninsured rate by 10 percent

...

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

ObamaCare saving more money than CBO projected! Dropped policies were also "Junk Policies."

...

How elitist of you, nice to know that you and your compatriots are the only ones who KNOW what is best for us all

I don't know about "best," but the PPACA policies are certainly BETTER than a $54/month health insurance policy that covers virtually nothing, one that will bankrupt the holder with a deductible and/or out-of-pocket costs upon the first major illness/claim

IMO, government has an ethical responsibility to protect citizens from being "had" because of their own ignorance -- I'll bet that most junk policy holders never read their policies and would be shocked if they did upon learning how vulnerable they are betting on the notion, i.e. "I'm young and healthy -- I'll get better insurance when I'm older and really need it." That tells you I agree with your comment

".....people are destroyed from lack of knowledge ..." Hosea 4:6.

Ironic my friend.

And once more, we show that it is possible to disagree up on the high road.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

We should be so fortunate as to wake one morning to Universal/Single Payer!

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Red Flags? Company behind ObamaCare site has checkered past

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

According to campaign records at OpenSecrets.com, CGI Group contributed $345,600 to federal candidates and parties -- both Democratic and Republican -- during the 2011-12 cycle. Some $147,000 went to the Republican Governors Association; and $35,000 to the Democratic Governors Association. The company spent $400,000 in lobbying expenditures between 2011 and 2012.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

(Matthew 10:8 KJV)

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"When I sent you without purse, and scrip, and shoes, lacked ye any thing? And they said, Nothing."

But that was then and this is now and many live with deficiencies because of a rigged game.

I am not a religious man and abhor the bastardization known as "organized religion"; still, to some extent, I am my brother's keeper.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

It's an insurance revision ('who pays' for the policy, and forced coverages to make the industries wealthier - both insurance and business, as business gets out to let the taxpayer pay the way), not "Health Care" reform, which implies 'services in the health care industry - doctors, nurses, diagnostics, procedures.'

It's *insurance reform,* and yes 96, I believe that was the plan all along -- forced payroll deduction, just like the Medi insurances.

I have a question: how constitutionally legal is it for them to automatically deduct those medi - insurances from paychecks and other's SS (if they are collecting it)?? *Note - I said "Constitutionally" -- which does not equate with Congressional lawmaking in this context...that is supposed to follow the document, but they 'create' ways around it, so my point is ethics.

Please don't conflate my question with all of the personal benefits to you, or how nice it is to have someone else buying it for you, or please don't use persuasive rhetoric to promote it; it's a simple - yes, it is, or no, it's not question.

And, if you think it ' is ' constitutionally legal to deduct forced insurance policy payments from paychecks and SS payments --- please tell me 'how' the Constitution supports doing that. Pretty please? Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I have a question: how constitutionally legal is it for them to automatically deduct those medi - insurances from paychecks and other's SS, if they are collecting it??

Ask the SCOTUS, or, read the Constitution.

The Commerce Clause describes an enumerated power listed in the United States Constitution. The clause states that the United States Congress shall have power "To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes. ...
The Commerce Clause authorizes Congress to regulate commerce in order to ensure that the flow of interstate commerce is free from local restraints imposed by various states. When Congress deems an aspect of interstate commerce to be in need of supervision, it will enact legislation that must have some real and rational relation to the subject of regulation. Congress may constitutionally provide for the point at which subjects of interstate commerce become subjects of state law and, therefore, state regulation.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

The whole Obamacare thing is a Republican idea.

Exhibit 1 that Obamacare is a disaster is the compulsive need of the left to associate it with Republicans. If it were going well, you'd be hearing how no Republicans supported this great and perfect thing.

The sad part is how desperate and pathetic it is. The Republicans rejected a similar program offer from Bill CLinton after the Hillarycare fiasco and never bothered to propose it when they controlled Congress and the Presidency. Finally no Republican voted for it. Yet they still call it a Republican plan. How sad.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

Democrats, if nothing else, can read polls. They knew in 2009 that the overwhelming majority of people with health insurance were happy with it. So any plan that forced hundreds of millions of Americans out of their plans was an automatic no-go in 2009, even if going to single payer was their ultimate goal. It would have been political suicide, much much worse than 2010 ultimately turned out to be. In order to get support for his reform up to even a significant minority of the country, President Obama had to lie repeatedly about how people could keep their insurance if they liked it. If he had been honest, Obamacare would have never passed.

Instead the President lied and the administration issued regulations that ensured that millions of Americans would not be able to keep their health care plans. According to the administration's own estimate, more than half of employer plans will lose their grandfathered status and be cancelled, dumping another potential 90 plus million people into the group who've lost their insurance.

Once these 90 million plus million people are on the exchanges and have to pay significantly more money for insurance, the idea of single payer will seem a lot more palatable to them. We are just in the first steps of taking the policies away from those that like them.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

My question isn't something that will be stated as a yes or no in the Constitution, as many aren't. It's a matter of taking the words in the context that they were meant.

My point is that 'they' (the wealthy) interpret, as they should not, to aid their own wallets, if they can benefit from interpreting "Commerce" to also include 'forced purchasing of products' - not just 'trade,' as should be obvious in context, then they will.

__

How would all of those people collecting SS like it if they suddenly have a huge deduction from their SS checks --which *should happen* if socialized medicine goes the route of electronic deduction-- since they weren't paying for all of those extra people previously, so now they should.

So assuming that forced socialized medicine happens, maybe that means medicare and medicaid will go away - and the working and the elderly that used to work, will pay for the whole nation *in one lump sum* out of their checks?

My sarcasm is based on - how fair is that to force the middle class to pay for 'both' the new insurance and the older people insurances? They can't; just like the older people that aren't working will have a hard time handling a huge allotment coming out of their SS check to pay for the other group of people.

Forced socialized, nationalized medicine- to work -has to mean two things: loss of personal income and loss of choice for the taxpayer, due to forced loss of income. And, I don't like the sound of that. Someone that does should move to France where they have 75% or more of their incomes lost to taxes.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    13 years ago

I have to disagree with you on this 96 (had to happen someday). The net effect of ACA is to make the health insurance industry (a corrupt and entirely useless middleman) stronger. Money that would have gone elsewhere is now flowing into this industry through government mandate. And the majority of the health insurance industry's new found wealth is being transferred there from the middle class. By strengthening the industry's hold over our health (as if our health was some sort of market commodity akin to corn), Obama has taken us several steps back from single payer. The health insurance industry is now stronger than ever and Obama has practically ensured it won't go anywhere anytime soon.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

dennis,

Thank you; I appreciate your saying so.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I give up; I answer you directly and you change the question.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

The question remains the same...you deflected by trying to equate my questions with the Commerce Clause, which was not meant to suggest that anyone should be 'forced' into buying products.

Commerce in a government context was to address inter-state trade issues, should be obvious.

___

I like to use words and phrases that don't attempt to trick the mind.

Doesn't single payer essentially mean payroll deduction for the purchase of insurance products forced on the peoples of that nation or state?

If that happened here, I hate to think what the obvious consequences would be -- the poor would arrive in masses, and so would the wealthy from other countries that don't have it. If we were a closed border country like Canada or Denmark, then we might be able to prevent some of the abuse.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The question remains the same...you deflected by trying to equate my questions with the Commerce Clause, which was not meant to suggest that anyone should be 'forced' into buying products.

Your question was

I have a question: how constitutionally legal is it for them to automatically deduct those medi - insurances from paychecks and other's SS, if they are collecting it??

My answer was

The Commerce Clause describes an enumerated power listed in the United States Constitution. The clause states that the United States Congress shall have power "To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes. ...
The Commerce Clause authorizes Congress to regulate commerce in order to ensure that the flow of interstate commerce is free from local restraints imposed by various states. When Congress deems an aspect of interstate commerce to be in need of supervision, it will enact legislation that must have some real and rational relation to the subject of regulation. Congress may constitutionally provide for the point at which subjects of interstate commerce become subjects of state law and, therefore, state regulation.
I'm finished the bait-and-switch with you.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Exhibit 1 that Obamacare is a disaster is the compulsive need of the left to associate it with Republicans.

The "need" is to illustrate how the Tea Party/Republican Party will denounce even their own initiative if Obama is for it.

10/20/2011 @ 8:26AM

How the Heritage Foundation, a Conservative Think Tank, Promoted the Individual Mandate

...

This came up at Tuesdays Western Republican Leadership Conference Debate, where Mitt Romney and Newt Gingrich tussled on the question:

ROMNEY: Actually, Newt, we got the idea of an individual mandate from you.

GINGRICH: Thats not true. You got it from the Heritage Foundation.

ROMNEY: Yes, we got it from you, and you got it from the Heritage Foundation and from you.

GINGRICH: Wait a second. What you just said is not true. You did not get that from me. You got it from the Heritage Foundation.

ROMNEY: And you never supported them?

GINGRICH: I agree with them, but Im just saying, what you said to this audience just now plain wasnt true.

(CROSSTALK)

ROMNEY: OK. Let me ask, have you supported in the past an individual mandate?

GINGRICH: I absolutely did with the Heritage Foundation against Hillarycare.

ROMNEY: You did support an individual mandate?

ROMNEY: Oh, OK. Thats what Im saying. We got the idea from you and the Heritage Foundation.

GINGRICH: OK. A little broader.

ROMNEY: OK.

(Romney was prepared to go on, but Michele Bachmann , in her usual role as the person who makes the debates less useful, interjected and changed the subject. Heres a YouTube video of the entire debate. The Gingrich-Romney exchange begins at the 27:38 mark .)

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Instead the President lied and the administration issued regulations that ensured that millions of Americans would not be able to keep their health care plans. According to the administration's own estimate, more than half of employer plans will lose their grandfathered status and be cancelled, dumping another potential 90 plus million people into the group who've lost their insurance.

Once these 90 million plus million people are on the exchanges and have to pay significantly more money for insurance, the idea of single payer will seem a lot more palatable to them. We are just in the first steps of taking the policies away from those that like them.

Yes, common sense that many, whether they want forced single-payer or not, would always choose cheaper to have similar coverage. It's just that it's not necessarily quality care - because it's cheaper. The best and the brilliant will go somewhere else where they can expect compensation like they had before socialized medicine. I don't understand why anyone would think you can pay less and have more.

In fact, that's part of why my attitude is poor today. My cheaper, online car insurance carrier makes mistakes, and due to the forced online processing (no paper, in order to get a cheaper price from them), takes forever to get discussed, and then they make mistakes in processing corrections, leading to more money lost by me because it has to be cc billing. I am going to cancel them and go back to one of the majors...like State Farm or something.

I relate this to medical insurance in that my Group Health plan was a fumbling mess of first come, first serve, wait times..assistants, more than docs....and reminds me a lot of the same experience I had with cheap car insurance. :)

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

I see. so any idea that a single democrat or think tank supported at any point in time is now fairly described as a democratic plan. For instance, the Republicans could pass a total ban on abortion and claim its a Democrat plan. Make sense.

 
 
 
MalamuteMan
Professor Silent
link   MalamuteMan    13 years ago

Geez AMac!!! You got way more patience than I have... More power to ya!!! But I gotta tell ya,I don't think you are going to change any of their minds...

I got so dizzy going round and round on the merry-go-round with lisaed (years ago) that I jumped off... Just reading that little back and forth made me dizzy...

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Instead the President lied and the administration issued regulations that ensured that millions of Americans would not be able to keep their health care plans. According to the administration's own estimate, more than half of employer plans will lose their grandfathered status and be cancelled, dumping another potential 90 plus million people into the group who've lost their insurance.

Once these 90 million plus million people are on the exchanges and have to pay significantly more money for insurance, the idea of single payer will seem a lot more palatable to them. We are just in the first steps of taking the policies away from those that like them.

Yes, most people will choose the other if it means cheaper, forgetting that cheaper does not mean they will get 'more' or better, for less.

I just had that frustration going with cheaper car insurance. I don't like paying extra for an agent, but those kind of problems that I had never happened before. Oh well...time not to think about car insurance when all of this other is frustrating me, too. Smile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Sean,

You don't see, and while you can create straw men scenarios, when you've been specifically corrected, just admit it or remain silent.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Hey Mal, always good to see you my friend.

I'm not trying to change their minds, just to illustrate when and why they are showing how misinformed (willingly or otherwise) they are.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Ok, but you're not being fair in addressing my rebuttals. "Commerce" in a Federal Government's context does involve regulating trade - but not *'forced'* buying and selling products from a consumer products industry. The obvious point in your highlight was to 'prevent' a state from blocking inter-state trade.

This mandated insurance scam has absolutely nothing to do with inter-state trade.

You never answered my question about where in the Constitution does it say that a Federal Government can 'force' the citizenry to purchase consumer goods?? As well as, where is there anything in writing in that document that says they can *automatically deduct* monies from our checks to *purchase* consumer goods that we never asked to purchase?

You deflected with red herring fallacy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Fair enough; I will then direct you to the SCOTUS decision re:PPACA

But the Constitution does give Congress the authority to "lay and collect Taxes," Roberts says.

The Obama administration and congressional PPACA supporters have avoided calling the penalty to be imposed on taxpayers who fail to meet individual health insurance ownership requirements a tax, but, under one Obama administration theory, "the mandate is not a legal command to buy insurance," Roberts says. "Rather, it makes going without insurance just anotherthing the Government taxes, like buying gasoline or earning income. And if the mandate is in effect just a tax hikeon certain taxpayers who do not have health insurance, itmay be within Congresss constitutional power to tax.The question is not whether that is the most naturalinterpretation of the mandate, but only whether it is a 'fairly possible' one."

Whether you agree with the decision or not, this answers your question.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

No, that does not answer what I asked, and you're not....because you can't. Grin.gif

Ok, let's address your and their's first deflection: They passed this into law "unconstitutionally." I don't know how to challenge it, but I hope to God it gets challenged. Whether it means putting massive funds into those industries, or whether it eventually means single-payer (forced payroll deduction?) --- No! There are plenty of other countries doing that - one should go there, if that's what they want. The SCOTUS knows that to force us into socialism is not what the Constitution is all about - it's about the individual, not the group, and they did not honor us.

As others have pointed out, the penalty fee might be lower now than it will be in the future (they've only shown up to 2016). Pelosi supposedly once said that the only way they we can pay for this is if they force everyone to buy coverage and increased coverage. Surely, it's obvious that they will have to eventually force the fee to be the same price as a basic policy to make that happen. Common sense.

The fee is clearly a fee, not a tax. A tax is a surcharge on a product that gets 'used' - not one that does not get used. Obviously, they 'had' to call it a tax, because they can't legally impose fines on something we didn't use. The only thing I can think of that they can 'legally' fine - is not paying the income taxes they impose on us.

His reasoning is using tactical 'sleight of mouth' persuasion - "gasoline and earned income" -- DO get used.

It does not answer my question with anything they 'passed'.

This isn't about 'opinion' or agreement -- it's what is Constitutional.

As I said in my opening comment, I was addressing the "ethics," not any unethical/illegal/immoral "interpretations" from Congress or the Judiciary. ...I was asking for proof from the Constitution itself that states it's legal to force the embodiment to buy consumer products - and where it states they can legally deduct monies from our paycheck to *purchase* insurance products of any kind that we did not request.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

J4T,

A challenge from a large enough group of people is worth a try, imo.

I realize there are a lot of people that want the concept of - everyone has to 'buy' it whether they want/need it or not. I hate car insurance, too. I know, I know...wait til you need it, and then you'll change your mind...well, I've helped pay other people's messes before, so I understand the "mess." Frown.gif And, I still say it should always boil down to 'personal responsibility.' ...And, I do begrudgingly play the game with insurance.

But, something is different this time to me. I think it's because I see we've let the Big Guys - AMA, Insurance and Pharma (and the Branches in Government) go too far - and will be too costly, even with single-payer, because we have open borders... I do believe that it will bankrupt some states, as well as lower the economics of this country by removing the responsibilities and liabilities from Business.

But then too, I had to get upset over some things with my cheap car insurance policy today (why I'm going to go back to one of the majors) ...so that made it easy for me to whine about this side of insurance.

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

iwhen you've been specifically corrected,

When that happens, I will gladly admit it. You have such a superficial knowledge of this topic that its quite exhausting explaining the details to you. Or do you think Obamcare only consists of the individual mandate? It's like you never heard of the employer mandate or minimum coverage requirements of Obamacare.

Because I'm feeling generous, I'll lay this out for you as explicitly as I can. The original post said Obamacare (not the individual mandate, but the entirety of Obamacare) is a Republican idea. My response dealt with the fact the Republicans have never proposed or championed Obamacare (with employer mandates etc..) despite controlling the Congress and the Presidency. Accordingly, your attempt to "prove" Republican ownership of Obamacare by pointing to the fact that some people in a think tank supported the idea 20 years ago falls flat on its face.

Say it with me. Obamacare and the individual mandate are not the same thing!

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

The extension was pushed out to March, I think. But it was also stated by some "experts" in the business that the 'clean up' is so big, that they aren't sure when it will actually be ready.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Those being dumped appear to have been those with preexisting conditions that are saying in order to meet their special needs, they are having to consider plans that cover way more than what they needed....sort of sounds like they were pushed out so that they can help pay for those preexisting needs.

Another thing to keep in mind is that these were just a few companies--it was stated that it will take up to a year. So, if the mess isn't cleaned up for a year, and if it takes a year to finish the "dumping" - election time could come without us seeing a 'true' picture, couldn't it?

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

Egilman, seems so, doesn't it. Smile.gif

Hmmm, this was supposed to land down below. I still don't understand why this happens. I clicked the last reply button. Or maybe not...lol

Oh well, "Mine is not to reason why, mine is but to do and die." lol

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

"My response dealt with the fact the Republicans have never proposed or championed Obamacare (with employer mandates etc..) despite controlling the Congress and the Presidency. Accordingly, your attempt to "prove" Republican ownership of Obamacare by pointing to the fact that some people in a think tank supported the idea 20 years ago falls flat on its face."

Sean you're just wrong in your conclusions that today's health care plan isn't the same as the one championed by the Republican party back in 93.

"The Democrats' 2010 Health Reform Plan Evokes 1993 Republican Bill"

In 1993, at the height of President Bill Clinton's health care reform initiative, Sen. John Chafee, R-R.I., along with 19 other Republicans and two Democrats, put forth a bill which was considered the major GOP proposal. One of the co-sponsors was then-Sen. Dave Durenberger, R-Minn. The bill, just like the Democratic version, never passed. But in a sense, it's been revived this year.

In fact, the key provisions in the Chafee bill may seem familiar, as they bear a strong resemblance to those in the current Democratic Senate bill, and now in President Barack Obama's proposal. A mandate that individuals buy insurance, subsidies for the poor to buy insurance and the requirement that insurers offer a standard benefits package and refrain from discriminating based on pre-existing conditions were all in the 1993 GOP bill.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

They passed this into law "unconstitutionally." I don't know how to challenge it, but I hope to God it gets challenged.

I quoted Justice Roberts the law was challenged and was upheld by the SCOTUS.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mac, Not a full callout yet, but the info now coming out doesn't look good for support of your position...

The media has been content thus far to go with the negatives without questioning; that has begun to change.

Another Obamacare horror story debunked

Deborah Cavallaro is a hard-working real estate agent in the Westchester suburb of Los Angeles who has been featured prominently on a round of news shows lately, talking about how badly Obamacare is going to cost her when her existing plan gets canceled and she has to find a replacement.

She says she's angry at President Obama for having promised that people who like their health plans could keep them, when hers is getting canceled for not meeting Obamacare's standards.

"Please explain to me," she told Maria Bartiromo on CNBC Wednesday, "how my plan is a 'substandard' plan when ... I'd be paying more for the exchange plans than I am currently paying by a wide margin."

Bartiromo didn't take her up on her request. So I will.

The bottom line is that Cavallaro's assertion that "there's nothing affordable about the Affordable Care Act," as she put it Tuesday on NBC Channel 4, is the product of her own misunderstandings, abetted by a passel of uninformed and incurious news reporters.

I talked with Cavallaro, 60, after her CNBC appearance. Let's walk through what she told me.

Her current plan, from Anthem Blue Cross, is a catastrophic coverage plan for which she pays $293 a month as an individual policyholder. It requires her to pay a deductible of $5,000 a year and limits her out-of-pocket costs to $8,500 a year. Her plan also limits her to two doctor visits a year, for which she shoulders a copay of $40 each. After that, she pays the whole cost of subsequent visits.

This fits the very definition of a nonconforming plan under Obamacare. The deductible and out-of-pocket maximums are too high, the provisions for doctor visits too skimpy.

As for a replacement plan, she says she was quoted $478 a month by her insurance broker, but that's a lot more than she'll really be paying. Cavallaro told me she hasn't checked the website of Covered California, the state's health plan exchange, herself. I did so while we talked.

http://www.latimes.com/business/hiltzik/la-fi-mh-debunked-20131030,...

Please go to the link and read the rest. More of these reports will be forthcoming on a regular basis.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

All of which have a functional, competent government, we should be so lucky.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

"You like you plan? you can keep it" The people who are finding out that that is not true already number in the millions, the people who will soon find out that their new plan is going to cost them even more is soon going to be in the millions.....

I'll concede he explained it poorly, and he was correct in saying "You can keep your plan if you like it," BUT SHOULD HAVE EXPLAINED "Health Insurers operate in a free market; they can, before the law kicks in, CANCEL YOUR POLICY WITHOUT ADVANCED NOTICE. Obviously, if an insurance company cancels a plan you like, you won't be able to keep it."

How interesting that conservatives decry market "regulations" but now bitch that the heretofore unregulated insurers can cancel policies!

I have explained several times why the cancellations are occurring; the junk policies being cancelled will not be able to compete with policies available under the PPACA. The companies cancelling their junk policies know that.

One more time

Are many Obamacare horror stories being caused by insurance companies?

The Affordable Care Act was signed into law by President Obama on March 23, 2010. According to Kaiser Health News, most of the policies now being cancelled were sold after the ACA be... . Think about what that means. Between March of 2010 and October 2013, insurers were selling health care policies that they knew did not comply with the law. Those insurers knew that they could not continue to sell those policies after January 2014, yet they offered them to customers anyway.

Why? A very good question. Were consumers notified when they purchased these policies that they would have to be replaced when the ACA went into effect? Judging by the number of people telling their Obamacare horror stories to the media, the answer appears to be no.

There are more questions that need to be asked surrounding the various Obamacare horror stories, and the mainstream media is not asking them. At the present time Congress is not aiding in fact finding, as Republicans are much more interested in wrecking the law than in fixing it. Given the historical conduct of insurance companies, it is not totally out of the question to wonder whether some of them are aiding opponents of the law through legal yet deceptive sales practices. For example, did insurers explain to customers why the policy they were purchasing would have to be replaced in 2014? Of course we cannot expect the corporate media to look at that and other questions too closely, given that insurance companies sponsor some of the very shows that should be reporting on them. So get used to it whether there is any merit to them or not, Obamacare horror stories are going to be with us for a while.

...

Policies sold before the cutoff date are grandfathered; if the companies don't cancel them, clients who like them can keep them.

And

Obamacare insurance prices less expensive

...

And

Obamacare: Millions to pay less than $100 per month for coverage

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

they are having to consider plans that cover way more than what they needed

The reason people purchase insurance is in anticipation of the moment in time their needs suddenly change auto accident, cancer diagnosis.

We all buy insurance of all kinds hoping we never need to make a claim.

By definition, INSURANCE is

a practice or arrangement by which a company or government agency provides a guarantee of compensation for specified loss, damage, illness, or death in return for payment of a premium

It is a hedge against what can arise in that insecure place known as "reality".

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Mac,

I noticed you left out:

As for a replacement plan, she says she was quoted $478 a month by her insurance broker, but that's a lot more than she'll really be paying. Cavallaro told me she hasn't checked the website of Covered California, the state's health plan exchange, herself. I did so while we talked.

Here's what I found. I won't divulge her current income, which is personal, but this year it qualifies her for a hefty federal premium subsidy.

At her age, she's eligible for a good "silver" plan for $333 a month after the subsidy -- $40 a month more than she's paying now.

SO her plan would have went up $180.00/month but since she qualifies for SUBSIDY it is only about $40.00 a month. This is exactly the point I am trying to make when I say this system is unsustainable. It is no secret the healthy (who CAN afford to pay more) MUST get on board for this system to work. If they help the healthy pay for higher insurance with subsidies, who will be left to make up the difference?

Yes, as you mentioned single payer is best (if you have a functional government to implement it, anyhow) and SOME people are better off under ACA, But you seem to be dodging all the facts that point to an unsustainable system. The system will fail as it stands.

I guess it will be great until it all falls apart, eh?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

SO her plan would have went up $180.00/month but since she qualifies for SUBSIDY it is only about $40.00 a month. This is exactly the point I am trying to make when I say this system is unsustainable.

You may be right, but that remains to be seen; I was addressing the myth of "sticker shock".

As for "functional government", Medicare functions just fine and Single Payer would be Medicare for all.

It is no secret the healthy (who CAN afford to pay more) MUST get on board for this system to work.

Not necessarily; healthy does not equal wealthy.What has made the current system "sustainable" are the higher premiums paid by the insured to compensate health providers for what they fail to receive in the way of payment when treating the uninsured.

Thus the idea of the "individual mandate"/"personal responsibility". The holders of junk policies, when they cannot pay the deductibles and/or out-of-pocket costs, end up costing those of us who have insurance or die for lack of care! The fallacy of "why should I pay for coverage I don't need" is at best, the manifestation of a false sense of security ("I'm not going to need hospitalization, chemo, etc.") and at worse the self-serving "They won't turn me away from the E.R. even if I can't pay".

But 96, I appreciate your question and a good give-and-take debate.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Mac,

I now see that some of the problem is that you believe medicare is functioning well, and I do not. Now let me be upfront is saying I think in order for something to function well it has provide the services intended and it must be sustainable. In other words, if it keeps racking up debt it is NOT functioning well.

That being said, medicare is, in fact, NOT functioning well,. Here is a little info on how well medicare is functioning in this respect:

$27.0 trillion ($27,000,000,000,000) in obligations for current Medicare participants above and beyond projected revenues from their payroll taxes, benefit taxes, premium payments, and assets of the Medicare trust fund. [13]

...

I do not consider a program that is 27 TRILLION in debt to be "functioning well".

Would you invest in a business that functioned this way?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The Medicare Hospital Insurance fund will exhaust its assets in 2026, two years later than projected last year and the assets in the Social Security funds will be depleted in 2033, the same date thetrustees predicted in last year's report.

Thetrustees explained that the pushingback of the trust fundsexhaustion date for Medicare'shospital insuranceprogram is duepartly to lowerprojectedspendinginthefuture for skilled nursing facilities and other services.

And

Medicare Is Not Bankrupt
Health Reform Has Improved Programs Financing

PDF of this report (3pp.)

By Paul N. Van de Water

Updated June 3, 2013

Claims by some policymakers that the Medicare program is nearing bankruptcy are misleading. Although Medicare faces financing challenges, the program is not on the verge of bankruptcy or ceasing to operate. Such charges represent misunderstanding (or misrepresentation) of Medicares finances.

Medicares financing challenges would be significantly greater without the health reform law (the Affordable Care Act, or ACA), which substantially improved the programs financial outlook. Repealing the Affordable Care Act, a course of action promoted by some who simultaneously claim that the program is approaching bankruptcy, would make Medicares financial situation much worse.

One other point; Single Payer would have a much larger pool than Medicare. I'm not sure of the logistics, but were the ceiling on Social Security contributions lifted, should monies go into a combined Medicare/Social Security Program, I believe that "solvency" would never again be an issue.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   CM    13 years ago

And the hate shows its ugly claws...

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Are you trying to imply we currently have a functional, competent government? The government is comprised of two parties you know. Both Democrats and Republicans share the blame for our current state. Do you argue that this is not one of the most inept government compilations in our nations history or are you just throwing around partisan hack comments.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Haha well "in debt" is not the same as "bankrupt" especially when you can print as much money as you want. My argument is not that it is bankrupt, but that it is continuing to rack up debt. No, it won't be bankrupt until the world shuns the dollar as the reserve currency.

My point is that a system that has about 27 trillion in debt and climbing, is not functioning well. So I guess if ACA delivers health care you would deem it a success regardless of whether we can pay for it or not, and regardless of the debt it accumulates?

Let me ask you another question. If you loaned someone say $100.00 and they kept coming back for more even though they haven't paid off the first loan, how long until you stop lending them money?

How long will the rest of the world continue to lend money to a deadbeat nation?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Are you trying to imply we currently have a functional, competent government? The government is comprised of two parties you know. Both Democrats and Republicans share the blame for our current state. Do you argue that this is not one of the most inept government compilations in our nations history or are you just throwing around partisan hack comments.

We have a system that was designed to be both functional and fair; BUT WE HAVE AN ELECTORATE, TOO MUCH OF WHICH VOTES ITS RELIGION, RACE, GENDER AND/OR SPECIAL INTERESTS WHICH RESULTS IN PANDERING-SELLOUT LEGISLATORS REPRESENTING CORPORATIONS INSTEAD OF CITIZENS.

Stupid individuals who vote against their own practical interests are the ultimate problem.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

How long will the rest of the world continue to lend money to a deadbeat nation?

As long as we don't keep shutting down the government as a tactic to prevent the U.S. to fail to meet its obligations TO MAKE A BLACK PRESIDENT LOOK BAD!

The dollar and U.S. Bonds are what the world runs to as a safe haven. Self-serving, asshole, panderer legislators undermine that reality.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    13 years ago

Are you one of them?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Ah yes, the old "it's all the Republicans fault" line. Sorry but I have seen way too much crap on both sides of the isle to believe that one.

We have a system that was designed to be both functional and fair; BUT WE HAVE AN ELECTORATE, TOO MUCH OF WHICH VOTES ITS RELIGION, RACE, GENDER AND/OR SPECIAL INTERESTS WHICH RESULTS IN PANDERING-SELLOUT LEGISLATORS REPRESENTING CORPORATIONS INSTEAD OF CITIZENS.

I think we could agree both parties are guilty of this.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I report, you decide.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I think we can agree both parties are guilty of this.

Indeed we can. The difference between the two parties is that Democrats lie while championing the causes of the poor and middle class, women, minorities and the historically disenfranchised.

Republican/Tea Party liars champion the criminal rich.

In life, one often has to choose between the lesser-of-two-evils if not the evil-of-two-lessers.

For me personally, choosing between corporate welfare or health insurance for everyone is a no-brainer.

Term limits with a legal provision prohibiting elected officials from EVER BECOMING CORPORATE LOBBYISTS, or, in any way, shape or form, subsequently being paid corporate money, or, running for office having been in such positions, would be a nice house cleaning start.

Enforcement/scrutiny of such a provision is another story.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

The difference between the two parties is that Democrats lie while championing the causes of the poor and middle class, women, minorities and the historically disenfranchised.

There was some truth to that at one time, but that was quite some time ago, you are showing your age Mac. ;) There was also some truth in "the Republican party is the party of small government and the champion of small business" some time ago...today both parties champion the criminal rich, and are, in fact, the criminal rich. That is why I stopped claiming either long ago. Time for a third IMO and I don't see the current crap coming to a stop until it happens. Why would it? As long as they know sheeple will vote within the "lesser of evil" party, just like they always do... This is how the Duopoly came to be, and how it survives. We are offered the same party in a different gift wrap any more my friend....once the wrap is off, the booby prize is the same.

Term limits with a legal provision prohibiting elected officials from EVER BECOMING CORPORATE LOBBYISTS, or, in any way, shape or form, subsequently being paid corporate money, or, running for office having been in such positions, would be a nice house cleaning start.

Enforcement/scrutiny of such a provision is another story.

Term limits can be a double edged sword, but I do agree there should be a limit of some kind.. on the rest...fully agree.

There are precious few representatives of the people in either party and we must pay attention and find them. Voting along party lines in this day and age is for the stupid and lazy.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

There was some truth to that at one time, but that was quite some time ago, you are showing your age Mac. ;)

Maybe so about my age, but check which party sabotages which legislation and which party advances which and you'll see the generalization is on target.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

My comment on voting along party lines stands.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

My comment on voting along party lines stands.

As does my on determining who best represents who based on voting records by issue. They all lie, we agree, but the parties vote issues differently and ultimately, that's what has the most effect on our lives.

 
 
 
Chloe
Freshman Silent
link   Chloe    13 years ago

It's only a "practical" interest for those that benefit, not for everyone AMac.

I prefer an environment that benefits individuals when they want and need it.

I'm thinking of two *community paid for* situations that I am involved in that both cost me less initially, but have become expensive over time because of increased customers and their usage. The quality of the service is reduced and the fairness issue bothers me. Only those that have more to lose (a large family, instead of single household) benefit from forcing everyone to pay the same. If, say, electricity and other power sources worked like that, I wouldn't like it either. It should be pay for what you need and use...not -- everyone pays the same whether it involves you or not.

So the person with more to lose, benefiting by forcing everyone to pay for their large family responsibilities, would likely agree with your reasoning: " Stupid individuals who vote against their own practical interests are the ultimate problem. " ...because it mostly benefits 'their' best interests to do so. Not the individual with much less responsibility. What's "stupid" is that we are allowing others to scam us.

I'd much prefer to have metered water and pay for what I used, than to pay a flat fee of a higher amount that helps that family of six, but costs me more.

Same with insurance, it should be pay for you want and need....not pay a double premium so that others can buy a product free or reduced, imo.

 
 

Who is online




90 visitors