Cohn thought such a death spiral was unlikely, and frankly so did I. Between the stick of the mandate, the carrot of subsidies and the planned P.R. blitz, it seemed as if enough Americans would sign up to at least postpone the cost problem and get the system off the ground.
But it seemed that way because it was hard to imagine the Obama White House botching the design and execution of its national health care exchange. Building Web sites, mastering the Internet this is what Team Obama does!
Except this time Team Obama didnt . Like the Bush administration in Iraq, the White House seems to have invaded the health insurance marketplace with woefully inadequate postinvasion planning , and let the occupation turn into a disaster of hack work and incompetence . Right now, the problems with the exchange Web site appear to be systemic a mess on the front end, where people are supposed to shop for plans, and also a thicket at the back end, where insurers are supposed to process applications.
The disaster can presumably be fixed. As Cohn pointed out on Friday, many of the state-level exchanges are working better than the federal one, and somewhere there must be a tech-world David Petraeus capable of stabilizing HealthCare.gov . And the White House has some time to work with: weeks before the end-of-year enrollment rush, and months before the mandates penalty is supposed to be levied.
But if the fix-it effort moves too slowly, its possible to envision a worst-case scenario unfolding . If the Web site doesnt work soon, even liberals concede that the mandate would have to be delayed, because you cant very well fine people for failing to buy a product they cant access. And that combination a hard-to-navigate online portal and no penalty for staying uninsured could effectively discourage all but the most desperate customers from shopping, which in turn would create an unsustainably expensive insurance pool, driving prices up and driving people away, and potentially wrecking the entire individual insurance market in short order.
If this happens, there will be a lot of schadenfreude on the right at the spectacle of technocratic failure. But the wreck of the exchanges may actually be worse for conservative policy objectives than a more successful rollout would have been.
Thats because while conservatives think the Obamacare exchanges are overregulated and oversubsidized, they are actually closer to the right-of-center vision for health care reform than the Obamacare Medicaid expansion , which is happening no matter what transpires with Healthcare.gov . So if the exchanges fail and the Medicaid expansion takes effect (and, inevitably, becomes difficult to roll back), well be left with an individual market thats completely dysfunctional and a more socialized system over all.
In that scenario, the Democratic Party would probably end up pushing, not for the pipe dream of true single payer, but for a further bottom-up/top-down socialization, in which Medicare is offered to 55- to 65-year-olds and Medicaid is eventually expanded even more.
Meanwhile, the task for serious conservative reformers already not the most politically effective bunch might actually become harder, because they would have to explain how their plan to build an effective, exchange-based marketplace differed from the Obama White Houses exchange fiasco.
So while Republican politicians may be salivating over a potential Obamacare crisis, the conservative policy thinkers I know are not. Theyre hoping, as Im hoping, that this isnt as bad as it looks. The chance to say I told you so is always nice, but not if the price is a potentially irrecoverable disaster.
<nyt_author_id>
Congrats on beating my seeding this great article.
As Ross wrote in the linked piece:
Jonathan Cohn's FiveObamacare anxieties (Excerpt from article written May 13, 2013 in New Republic)
1 NOT ENOUGH HEALTHY PEOPLE WILL SIGN UP
O bamacares success depends heavily on the new health care exchanges, where anyone without employer-sponsored insurance can buy coverage, no matter what medical problems they have. But if the right kinds of people dont sign up, the exchanges wont function properly.
Health insurance needs lots of healthy people to sign up for coverage. Their premiums cover the big bills for the relatively small number of sick people. So if the exchanges dont enroll enough young, healthy people, insurers will have to raise everyones premiums. In the worst case, this could create what actuaries call a death spiral: Rising premiums prompt people to drop out, causing premiums to increase even more.
To encourage participation, Obamacare offers generous income-based subsidies . If you dont purchase insurance, youll be hit with a small financial penalty. Still, convincing healthy people to pay for insurance isnt easy, even when its cheap. In the first year of the Childrens Health Insurance Program , in 1997, less than a million children signed upa fraction of the eligible population. Since then, that number has increased to around eight million. But Obamacare is under far more pressure to prove itself early.
Administration officials say theyve developed a sophisticated strategy for persuading young consumers, partly by applying the data-analysis techniques developed during the presidential campaign. If theres one thing we know how to do, says a senior administration official, its reach young people. Theyre also conducting person-to-person outreach through social media, churches, unions, and other groups.
But theyre doing this on a tight budget. The Bush administration spent $1.5 billion on outreach for the Medicare drug benefit. The Obama administration gets substantially lower funding to promote a more ambitious law to a less receptive population: Young people arent nearly as desperate for health insurance as seniors were for assistance with prescriptions. So far, congressional Republicans have refused requests for more funding. Nonprofit organizations are trying to fill the gap, but they may not be able to do as much as they would like.
Nor can the administration count on private-sector help, at least in states where political and corporate leaders oppose the law. Those just happen to be the states with the most uninsured. When Massachusetts introduced its reforms, enrollment became a civic cause; Red Sox players touted its benefits in TV ads. Nobody expects the Dallas Cowboys to do the same.
2 THE COMPUTERS WONT WORK
O bamacare supporters like to say that buying insurance online from the exchanges will be as simple as arranging travel on Expedia or Travelocity. This is highly optimistic. The health care law requires a vast electronic infrastructur e to be created from scratch, so that every state has its own website. Some states are building their own; others are letting the federal government do it. The sites are supposed to go online on October 1 , and itll be no small accom p lishment if they work at all.
C onsider what the new system has to do. First, it determines whether youre eligible for Medicaid or for subsidized private insurance. If its the latter, i t will figure out what subsidies, if any, you qualify for. To do that, it must verify your identity, residency, and income, which means communicating with the Social Security Administration, Homeland Security Department, and Internal Revenue Service. Youll be presented with insurance choices, based on a separate set of communications with the carriers. Finally, the system will c alculate your premium, taking the subsidies into account.
Ensuring all the different entities communicate seamlessly is a headache-inducing taskespecially when some of the systems are old and idiosyncratic. Federal officials are particularly nervous about states that have asked Washington to run their exchanges but insist on determining Medicaid eligibility themselves. Many states already make Medicaid enrollment arduous. Under Obamacare, they could make it cumbersome to connect to Medicaid websites or force applicants to wait many weeks before hearing whether they qualify. On top of all this, the whole online operation has to run with ironclad security, given the sensitive nature of the data involved.
Officials have reportedly been testing the systems extensively, both internally and with outside troubleshooters. Despite stories of missed deadlines, the administration is confident the federal IT will function as planned. But among implementers, theres plenty of angst. Everybody will breathe a sigh of relief when its up and running, one Democratic state official told me. Its possible the websites will be a work in progress: The early versions could be rudimentary and, in the worst cases, officials would have to work around bugs until they can be fixed. Jon Kingsdale, who ran Massachusettss exchange and has been advising the states, told me most exchange directors expect a rocky start. But, he said: Over time, they will learn, improve. October first is not the end, but just the start.
3 INSURANCE COMPANIES WILL ACT LIKE INSURANCE COMPANIES
Its not exactly comforting that Obamacare may need the good faith of insurersthe one group of health companies that resisted the law all along. The biggest fear is that insurers will jack up premiums, scaring consumers away.
Right now, insurers selling to individuals can make coverage very cheap, if they only offer such policies to relatively healthy people and dont offer very generous benefits to anybody. Obamacare outlaws both practices. Insurance companies, worried that theyll need to pay out more to hospitals and doctors, are going to raise premiums.
Most people buying on the exchanges wont notice this. If your income is at or below four times the poverty line (about $94,000 for a family of four), the subsidies limit what youll pay for a standard plan, no matter how high the premiums. But increased premiums would affect people who dont qualify for subsidies, as well as small businesses that buy group plans. (Subsidies for businesses are lower than for individuals.) They would also drive up the overall cost of the law to the government, since higher subsidies would be needed to cover the rising premiums.
A lot of this depends on how insurers behave. Many people working on implementation worry that they will simply seize the opportunity to raise premiums, regardless of whether its necessary. Marylands insurance commissioner has hinted that she will reject a rate hike averaging 25 percent proposed by CareFirst . But officials in many states lack that power. Then theres the danger that insurers will simply refuse to participate in the exchanges: Aetna corporate officers have told investors that the company might limit offerings or pull out of exchanges if they cant get sufficiently high premium increases.
Administration officials say they expect strong competition. And its worth noting that the Massachusetts exchange, which most closely resembles the one the federal government is setting up, has generally only offered a handful of plans, and yet premiums have remained low. (The limited choice has also arguably been easier for consumers to navigate.) But Massachusetts gives officials power to aggressively negotiate bids , in order to drive down prices and encourage competition. In many states, exchanges will lack that authority. Jay Angoff, a former insurance commissioner from Missouri who worked on Obamacare, says its possible that what develops is a government-compelled, taxpayer-subsidized market, but most of the inefficiencies of the [current] system are still there. For insurers, thatd be the best of all worlds.
4 RICK PERRY WILL SEEK REVENGE
E ven in places where officials want to make Obamacare work, a smooth start isnt guaranteed. But a bigger worry is the states where leaders arent interested in seeing Obamacare succeedor are actively trying to make it fail.
More than half the states still havent agreed to expand their Medicaid programs, potentially leaving millions without insurance. And there are other ways hostile officials can mire the law in chaos and confusion. They can use their power over Medicaid to halt enrollment or decline to help resolve problems with insurers. (Good luck getting any help in Texas, where Governor Rick Perry has called Obamacare a violation of our Constitution and our founding principles.)
When it comes to Medicaid, all but the most hardened state-level adversaries should come around eventually. The federal government covers nearly the entire cost of the expansion, money most states wont refuse. But at the federal level, opposition may prove implacable.
Complex legislation always has problemsdrafting errors or issues the architects didnt anticipate. The ACA is based on the Senate version of the bill, written with less technical precision because the effort to pass it was so difficult. In such situations, Congress usually addresses snags with narrow, uncontroversial measures. In the real world, when we implement a law, we learn and we adapt, says Drew Altman, president of the Kaiser Family Foundation. Its not quite ready, fire, aim, but its close, especially for something as complex as this.
So far, however, congressional Republicans are resisting even simple fixes. When a question arose over when employers will be responsible for providing coverage for employees, the criteria for calculating employee income was unclear. Congress could have easily settled the matterbut didnt. The administration was forced to reduce employer responsibility for coveragea decision that will potentially leave a few hundred thousand people uninsured.
The law doesnt state explicitly that the federal government can offer tax credits when its running a states exchangealthough its obvious thats what the authors intended. Again, Congress could fix this with a few lines attached to any bill. But it wontenabling conservatives to file a federal lawsuit that could block the government from subsidizing coverage in states that arent setting up their own exchanges.
5 OBAMA WILL GET SMACKED NO MATTER WHAT
H ere are a few predictions of things that will happen during the first year of Obamacare: Many people will experience long waits before being able to see a doctor. Insurance companies will refuse to cover important treatments that doctors say are necessary. Employers will balk at the rising cost of providing care to their employees. These predictions are certain to come true because they come true every year. And while Obamacare was designed to address some of these problems, they wont all vanish overnight.
Perhaps my biggest fear about Obamacare is that the inevitable, predictable troubles become full-blown political firestorms, undermining the entire system. The national Republican leadership doesnt share the goal of universal health care coverage and neither do Rush Limbaugh or the pundits on Fox. Theyve made it clear they want to get rid of the entire ACA and replace it with nothing at all. You can expect these forces to exploit even the slightest sign of troubleeven problems in the general realm of health that dont actually have anything to do with Obamacare. [The administration] own[s] the health care system, says Mark McClellan, the former administrator of Medicare and Medicaid, who oversaw implementation of Bushs prescription drug benefit. And ... they only get the things that go wrong.
This could have a snowball effect. Insurers could get skittish about participating in the exchanges and stop offering plans. Wavering state officials might come to the conclusion that its too politically risky to help federal officials to fix the system and instead let the problems pile up. Individual consumers might decide that its too expensive to purchase insurance on the exchanges and opt to simply pay the penalty instead. Thats the true nightmare scenariothat the predictions of doom become self-fulfilling.
Thats why expectations are so important. Starting in January, millions of people will get the kind of affordable, comprehensive, and stable insurance they never could before. This may be quicker to happen in some states than othersand the experience may not always be easy. But it will certainly be an improvement on the current state of affairs. And even those who anticipate difficulties also expect that things will get better over time. I have described my expectations for 2014 as bumpy, says economist Gail Wilensky, who was in charge of Medicare and Medicaid under President George H. W. Bush, but something I assume the country will muddle through.
...