Looking Left and Right for Answers –Jobs Report Statistics - Informative, Confusing or Misleading?
Every month the nation (at least the talking heads of Washington and the media everywhere) anticipate the release of the Jobs Report. A massive and complicated report that presents the national unemployment rate, real unemployment, under employment, the labor participation rate, jobs created, the part-time economy, temporary staffing options, minimum wage, living wage, benefits and on and on. The statistics and factors are chucks of red meat for political messaging and policy spinning from both sides of the political aisle.
Are all terms and figures confusing? You bet they are! Is the information selectively utilized to prove political points? Every day! Do any of the statistics, taken alone, reveal the strength or weakness of the economy? Absolutely not!
Political junkies wait with bated breath for the monthly jobs report in order to use the underlying statistics of the report to prove whatever point (positive or negative) they wish to make about the economy in general, job creation, employment or unemployment. Politicians sitting on either aisle of the aisle and those straddling the aisle trumpet the value of certain of the statistics which support their position and dismiss others as irrelevant and misleading.
Some important definitions both clarify and cloud the picture formed by the statistics of the monthly jobs report, for example -
The unemployment rate is defined as the percentage of the total labor force that is unemployed but actively seeking employment and willing to work.
The labor participation rate is defined as the participation rate refers to the number of people who are either employed or are actively looking for work.
The real unemployment rate includes the total unemployed, plus all persons marginally attached to the labor force, plus total employed part time for economic reasons, as a percent of the civilian labor force plus all persons marginally attached to the labor force.
Labor that falls under the underemployment classification includes those workers that are highly skilled but working in low paying jobs, workers that are highly skilled but work in low skill jobs and part-time workers that would prefer to be full-time.
We have heard much political messaging concerning the fall of the unemployment rate in recent months to slightly more than 7%, but a lot less about the real unemployment rate which is nearly double (13.6%) the national unemployment rate. It is hard to argue against the level of unemployment falling being a good thing, but we must be aware that while job creation has contributed to the decline we must also be aware of the real unemployment number and realize the that a significant reason for the lower unemployment rate is a falling labor participation rate and a rising level of under employed Americans.
Under employment is having a crushing effect on many of the middle class and is also particularly devastating to many college graduates of the past four or five years. There is a growing number of low paying entry level positions and part-time positions being filled by workers who formerly filled skilled and semi-skilled positions in manufacturing as well as degreed individuals working in positions unrelated to their education and/or experience. Many jobs have been lost in the past five years and likewise many jobs have been created as part of what some called a modest recovery, some call economic stagnation and some even see as a continuing economic crisis.
Similar to a falling unemployment rate it is hard to view job creation, any jobs, as a bad thing, but the fact of the matter is that the number of high paying upper middle class jobs lost is much greater than the number of high paying middle class jobs that have been created and in fact many of the jobs created and the hiring which has lowered the unemployment rate are entry level jobs, part-time positions or jobs being filled by temporary staffing agencies.
It is hard to argue with those that offer the argument that we are heading in the right direction or that things are better than they were three years ago, but it is likewise difficult to discount experts who conclude that the U.S. economy has an ever growing percentage of its work force in part-time and temporary status.
As you might imagine there are wildly varying proposed solutions to the economic and employment woes of the nation from the right and left. But before we can evaluate the proposed solutions in an honest and knowledgeable way it is critical that we clearly and completely understand the problem to be solved.
Definitions are from www.investopredia.com/terms with the exception of real unemployment which is from http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t15.htm .
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

The Bureau of Labor Statistics monthly jobs report is one of the most quoted, most misunderstood and most politically spun collection of data available from our government.
It is almost laughable how so many take isolated statistics from the report, while ignoring other relevant data points, to try and prove some obscure point about how ell or poorly the economy and/or the administration is doing.
The report, all of the data points, must be taken in aggregate and looked at over a period of time to identify trends in order to be useful
I was confident that many would want to discuss the merits and relative order of importance of the Jobs Report metrics on their own and how they interrelate to the other metrics and to economic performance as a whole.
I get a "term of the day" email from Business Dictionary and today's was very relevant to the reason I wrote the article (bold added by me)