In its effort to extract concessions from Democrats in exchange for opening the government, the GOP has faced a fundamental strategic obstacle: They don't have the votes. A majority of the members of the House have gone on record saying that if they were given the opportunity to vote, they would support what's known as a "clean" continuing resolution to fund the government.
So House Republican leaders made sure no such vote could happen.
In the hours working up to the government shutdown on Sept. 30, Republican members of the House Rules Committee were developing a strategy to keep a clean CR off the floor, guaranteeing the government would remain shut down.
Though at least 28 House Republicans have publicly said they would support a clean CR if it were brought to the floor -- enough votes for the government to reopen when combined with Democratic support -- a House rule passed just before the shutdown essentially prevents that vote from taking place.
During a floor speech on Saturday, Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) drew attention to the quietly passed rule when he attempted to present a motion to accept the Senate's clean continuing resolution and reopen the government.
Rep. Jason Chaffetz (R-Utah), presiding over the chamber, told Van Hollen that the rule he was asking to use had been "altered" and he did not have the privilege of bringing that vote to the floor. In the ensuing back and forth, Chaffetz said the recently passed House Resolution 368 trumped the standing rules. Where any member of the House previously could have brought the clean resolution to the floor under House Rule 22, House Resolution 368 -- passed on the eve of the shutdown -- gave that right exclusively to the House majority leader, Rep. Eric Cantor of Virginia.
"The Rules Committee, under the rules of the House, changed the standing rules of the House to take away the right of any member to move to vote to open the government, and gave that right exclusively to the Republican Leader," said Van Hollen. "Is that right?"

Bastards!
Watch the video!
Funny thing about the rules of the House and the Senate - when they are used in a manner or by the party which people support they are reasonable and sensible but when they are used by the opposition not so much.
Funny that you did not respond to the very specifically stated subject of the article but rather gave a kind of "they all do it" non-response.
How 'bout telling us what you think of a rule change designed to prevent an open vote on a critical issue?
wasnt harry (the word is out, romney paid no taxes) reid going to change senate rules so only a 51 majority was needed to "stylistically" confiscate personal property for redistribution?
Everything but addressing my article that says a lot!
If you want to go to Romney as tax dodger, I posted an article on that way back when. There is every possibility that Romney was a tax evader given amnesty under an IRS deal!
You can look that up since it has nothing to do with this article.
Come on folks -- either try and justify what the Republican did or suck it up and call them out; but please, no more "two wrongs make a right."
Care to discuss what actually is the content of my article or do you also want to respond with "two wrongs," etc. ?
A Mac
A rule was changed - that is the subject of the article - and it precluded Rep Van Hollen from doing what he wanted to do, rather than "any member" being able to do something the rule now states that the majority leader can do it.
The House and the Senate have rules that are changed time to time
Not everyone is happy when the rules change
Your righteous, liberal indignation is noted though
A Mac
The rules of the House can be changed and have been changed in the past
This rule change did not allow the Democrats in the House to do something they wanted to do
I make it a habit, as a matter of respect, when addressing a serious article, to give the author/seeder his/her due by leaving at least one comment, usually my first one, at the same degree of seriousness (or lack thereof) as the article itself.
The rule change departed from regular order to prevent a vote from taking place -- to deny Americans the right to have a decision, up or down, on a serious matter -- in some cases, devastating to thousands.
Your Tea Party "screw-everyone-to-sabotage-black-President" is similarly noted.
Instead of allowing a vote that might end the government shutdown, Cruz, Palin and Obama-haters yesterday protested the shutdown they caused -- while displaying their love-of-the flag.
Yes!
THEIR JOBS -- the ones Americans expect them to do!
BF,
What a great debate style!
You need to develop.
Well, looks like Boehner, along with the Republican House, have screwed themselves. That is, unless the Democrats can snatch defeat from the jaws of victory by appearing too greedy at the trough. I am not holding my breath either way.
I heard an interesting piece of polling today: Over 60% of the country wants to fire all of the politicians in Washington.
No one has said that or implied that . From my POV the issue is A Mac's passionate outrage as a coverup for hypocrisy ...
A Mac
Thanks for sharing your perspective and many agree with you I am sure just as many agree that Leader Reid uses the rules of the Senate in a way that best promulgates his (and his party's) agenda.
But of course two wrongs ....like you said
A MAc
You are always talking about relevance
Hos is your picture relative to this article?
Your ignorance of the facts is clear when you think I support or back the views and positions of the tea party
I am against the politics that have brought us to this shutdown, I am not a fan of the PPACA but accept it as the law of the land and it has no place in the budget/debt ceiling conversation.
Your unthinking leap to brand anyone who dares disagree with you as tea party or right wing nut shows your ignorance of the fact that a person can be adamantly against the policy positions of a politician or party without having hatred or animosity against the people as individuals.
You jus shout and shout -- backing in the glow when people agree with you and attacking when they do not.
You do not seek debate you seek agreement, sorry not likely here
Have a nice evening
How can this be legal? I bet the lawyers are ding donging around about that...
I don't understand this underhanded, ugly, double dealing-- how can some members of the house change the rules?
This is NOT a democracy!
From my POV, you have attacked the messenger but have not discussed the ramifications of (any) legislators preventing other legislators from taking a position and then dealing with reactions of voters.
Disagree; by saying or implying that "they all do it" is in fact saying "two wrongs make a right."
Discuss the particulars of the issue and leave the platitudes at the door.
Now THAT is a scary thought!
RIO,
Any "leader" or legislator who uses procedures to prevent other legislators from allowing citizens to know where those legislators stand on an issue that impacts lives, owes at the very least a detailed explanation as to why it is or is not self-serving, and, at best, a vote.
It is not the messenger I am attacking . It is the phony outrage . The events you describe are just politics as usual . In that respect getting all hot under the collar [see the title of this piece] is phoney & hypocritical and inflammatory ...
Fair question.
The demonstration dealt with the very issue that could immediately be resolved by allowing legislators to vote. Cruz is clearly the legislator who led the country to shutdown using the Tea Party's indolence to guarantee that shutdown.
Yesterday, Cruz led a rally to protest what he caused AND BY VIRTUE OF THE APPEARANCE OF THE CONFEDERATE FLAG AT HIS RALLY, AND, IN THE FAILURE OF CRUZ TO DIRECT THE FLAG BEARER TO TAKE THAT FLAG DOWN, it became clear that RACISM IS A FACTOR IN TEA PARTY POWER!
I have said many times that the various sabotage efforts against virtually all Obama initiatives are driven to one extent or another by HATERS/RACISTS/BIGOTS.
I rest my case.
What the fuck does a Confederate flag have to do with re-opening the government?
You might be projecting, RIO.
dennis,
The issue is USING PROCEDURE TO PREVENT LEGISLATORS FROM DOING THEIR JOB BY VOTING ON A GIVEN ISSUE.
One more "two wrongs make a right" -- STILL DOESN'T ADDRESS THE ISSUE.
Note: Not surprised.
Yeah; WTF was I thinking.
Entirely different.
Try and address the issue, not the temperature under my collar.
You're the one who can't stand the heat.
If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.
Harry S. Truman
And you're the one who has no interest in a discussion ... Bye .
Cop out!
Holy shit; Palin looks different without makeup.
Racist Tea Pary runs Ted Cruz/Sarah Palin Rally.
It is and has been about Obama -- not Obamacare; the Tea Party base is significantly backed by racists.
Let's not make this personal.
A Mac
Not at all, you seek the approval and reinforcement and shun alternate views on most articles that you post.
You ask
Well what does a picture of that flag have to with a rules change in the House of Representatives?
Let me answer that for you - it has nothing to do with the topic, it is totally irrelevant and off topic but it projects the hate, stirs the pot and gets people angry and arguing rather than debating the point which seems to be your objective.
No one is projecting around here except you, you are projecting your hyper partisanship and hate politics for all to see
RIO,
Debunking weak-ass positions with specific counter points is neither shunning nor seeking approval. It's what happens in discussions/debates.
What was the purpose of the rule change -- to prevent a vote that could re-open the government -- correct?
Stay with me.
What was the purpose of the Cruz/Palin rally -- to protest the fact that the government in general and the Veterans Memorial in particular, ARE SHUTDOWN!
Still following?
There are reasons to believe that the shutdown never had anything to do with the disdain of "Obamacare", RATHER THE DISDAIN/THE RACIST DISDAIN OF OBAMA the BLACK MAN IN THE WHITE HOUSE THE RACISTS THINK BELONGS TO THEM.
The appearance of a confederate flag at the Cruz/Palin rally, the disgusting, racist piece-of-shit rant by Larry Klayman (I posted the video) AND THE FAILURE OF CRUZ OR PALIN TO REPUDIATE BOTH ON THE SPOT is what the picture of the flag has to do with the rule change.
BOTH OF THOSE PHENOMENA HAVE TO DO WITH THE SHUT DOWN.
Need more?
On the one hand, REPUBLICANS CHANGE A RULE MAKING IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR A VOTE TO TAKE PLACE THAT WOULD END THE SHUTDOWN, WHILE ON THE OTHER, A PACK OF BIGOT BASTARDS (what's my headline) ATTEND A RALLY PROTESTING THE SHUTDOWN!
Get it?
Your attack-the-messenger comments reveal your apparent inability to
A. Deductively reason
B. Mount a viable counter argument, and
C. Recognize when you've had your ass handed to you.
Do you want to have a discussion or a pissin' contest?
Perhaps one time you'll get around to the actual issue which is NOT THE PROCEDURE, RATHER THE UNDERHANDED INTENT OF THE PROCEDURE.
Is that helpful?
And hopefully, if/when they do, the same bunch of BASTARDS who have both caused this, WON'T PULL MORE PROCEDURAL SHIT TO BLOCK A VOTE.
No argument.
A Mac
I get your perspective and wish that happened with all of the bill sitting on Leader Reid's desk that he has received form the House in the past months, weeks, days
A MAc
It is rich and ironic that you would accuse someone of attacking the messenger
That is exactly you r modus operandi when someone disagrees with your views or fails to applaud your position and pronouncement
You initiate the pissing contest and then ask someone if that is what they want.
The counter argument to your article, the topic of which you have long abandoned is that the rules of the House were changed and you do not like the change. I pointed out that rule changes happen and a lot of the time they happen for political reasons at which point you began your rant
Not only have you handed no one their ass but you have fled off the topic of the rule change to spout hate politics when you could not counter the point that chamber rules are changed for political reasons.
You are internally focused on your views and positions that you do not want to discuss the counter positions or ideas of others you simply want to dismiss them. If it were not so much fun to watch you spew and fume I would not poke you with a stick nearly as often as I do.
I never "simply dismiss" summariy dismissal "arguments" -- I provide specifics. If I enter a pissin' contest it's because someone leaked first.
But I'm thrilled to know I amuse you, RIO.
Even after I have given you a detailed, specific answer to your question regarding why the confederate flag is an issue, you return with an attack on me rather than discussing the answer.
Your out of your league.
well the Constitution does allow for each house of congress to make their own rules, usually dictated by the majority leadership at the time , so this current rule change is about as bastardly as the "deem and passed " rule used not so long ago, it is what it is .
Mark,
I do not question the practice -- I question its intent, namely to deprive American citizens of a vote on a critical matter that currently affects millions.
Mark,
I do not question the practice -- I question its intent, namely to deprive American citizens of a vote on a critical matter that currently affects millions.
Only a coward evades taking a stand and facing the outcomes. And this particular pack of cowards do what they do to avoid angering a faction that panders to haters of a President based on his race!
Again
A mac , I can somewhat see your point , my disagreements with this administration has nothing to do with the presidents race , simply his politics and that of progressive socialists. its time the federal entity lives within its means, and let them live with the unintended consequenses of their actions , and notsaddle future generations with debt they do not have a say in for something THIS generation wants , time to stop kicking the can down the roadand expecting future generations to accept it and pay for our folly.