How Helicoptered Kids Become Hypersensitive College Students Happy is the child, 8 or 18, who is not constantly afraid and aggrieved.
How Helicoptered Kids Become Hypersensitive College Students
Dreamstime This is the article everyones talking about: The Coddling of the American Mind ,by Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt , on the cover of this months Atlantic . It discusses the idea taking root on college campuses that students cannot be exposed to ideas, words, or phrases that perturb them.
Thats why schools are embracing trigger warnings , which are placed at the top of readings that might trigger flashbacks to some unpleasant episode in a students life. Some Harvard University law students, for instance, balk at the idea that they would have to learn about rape lawhearing about that crime might re-traumatize anyone who had lived through it.
The article also discusses microaggressionsremarks made, even innocently, that are received as blows by the person being addressed. For instance, asking Asian or Hispanic students where they were born could come across as a hint that the speaker does not consider the other student totally American. Thats the aggression.
Theentire article is so brilliant, I am ashamed of my simplistic reduction of it, but I want to get to the Free-Range meat of the matter: Why are college students being treated as so supremely fragile that they cant read a disturbing book, and must be constantly on the lookout for any remarks or attitudes that could somehow be labeled aggressive?
Because thats how we have been taught to raise our children these past 20 or 30 years: thin-skinned, super-sensitive, and primed to turn to the authoritiesparents, teachers, and now deansany time they feel the slightest bit uncomfortable or aggrieved.
After all, this is the generation we raised with baby knee pads to make crawling less painful, and helmets to protect them while toddling. Somehow, we became utterly convinced that our kids bruise so easily and permanently that special precautions must be takenprecautions that were never necessary until this moment in history. That message grew up into trigger warnings: Watch out, kids! You are too easily hurt.
This is also the generation that grew up getting trophies for 8th place. My son got one, on a league with nine teams. With that trophy came the same message: Kids, you are too fragile to handle the micro-misery of losing.
And this is also the generation of students who grew up surrounded by posters at school exhorting them to be on the lookout for bullying. When bullying is the thing you look for, bullying is what you see. What starts as hyper-alertness to bullying in third grade ends as hyper-sensitivity to microaggressions on college campuses.
Are we doing are kids any favors? Lukianoff and Haidt say no:
What are the effects of this new protectiveness on the students themselves? Does it benefit the people it is supposed to help? What exactly are students learning when they spend four years or more in a community that polices unintentional slights, places warning labels on works of classic literature and in many other ways conveys the sense that words can be forms of violence that require strict control by campus authorities?
Students are learning that they are as helpless and easily hurt as infants. This, of course, is not helping them at allnot in terms of their education, and not in terms of their psychological health. The authors quote a survey of the American College Health Association that found 54 percent of college students surveyed said they had felt overwhelming anxiety in the past 12 months, up from 49 percent just five years before.
Naturally, you are going to feel anxious if youve been told from infancy that basic locomotion is dangerous, losing is unendurable, classmates are out to get you, and you are not equipped to stand up for yourself.
And its not that I blame us parents! I blame a society that keeps telling us, through products and programs and even laws, that our kids are in constant danger, so we must make things safer, safer, safer. For Gods sake, I got a press release last week from the Environmental Working Group asking restaurants to pledge to give kids only asbestos-free crayonsas if the tiny exposure to the tiny amount of asbestos in a crayon while waiting for chicken fingers is going to scar their lungs for a lifetime. Our society sees every micro as macro.
Free-Range Kids has always championed our childrens resiliency. Not that we endorse danger or callousness or cruelty (who would?), but that we believe our kids can roll with some puncheseven touch an off-brand crayonand live to see another, non-paranoid day.
In our understandable but misdirected desire to keep our kids super-safe, we have succeeded in making them super-sensitive instead. Happy is the child, 8 or 18, who is not constantly afraid and aggrieved.

Helicopter parenting has been getting worse the last thirty years. The harmful effects are now seen on college campuses all across the county. Unfortunately these kids are probably going to be scarred for life.
I think so too, Dean.
Couple aggrieved attitudes, a sense of entitlement, and lack of civility, and we have a recipe for miserable lives! I'm not trying to be pessimistic, and there are many fine kids out there, who have good values, and are healthy, both physically and mentally, but there are quite a few who are going to be wack jobs.
The only kids I really know that well are the band kids-- and they are usually good kids-- but even then, there is that percentage of drama queens, (both male and female), etc. I shudder to grow old with them at the helm...
It is difficult for me to have a mutual frame of reference, when these kids don't know who Elvis is!
And, too, on the opposite end of the scale, so many of my son's marching band mates have been neglected by their parents. I think the kids who have been neglected will likely be happier, or more independent, in the long run, but their parent's lack of affection and concern is going to be a huge stumbling block to them in establishing their own households.
Yes, parenting is a delicate balancing act. Too much supervision is as bad as not enough. The single parent family probably makes it even harder on the kids.
My son's close friend, a girl, has an alcoholic, narcissistic father, and a drug-addled mother. She cares for her whole family, and receives not one iota of thanks or credit. Her parents seem to think that they paid their debt to society by giving birth to her-- and are forcing her to repay them for the gracious gift of life, every day.
I love this sweet, loving girl, and would take her in, if I could. She deserves to be loved!
But then, I think all kids deserve to be loved-- and allowed room to screw up every now and then... We learn more from our failures than our successes, and these kids need to be able to experience failure while they are young enough to recover and learn safely...
That really is a sad story and I feel for her. Narcissists are damaged at an early age and really don't have the ability to love. Alcoholics have a better chance of changing their lives than narcissists do. So many problems that show up in adults later in life can be traced back to their childhood. Often narcissism is past down from one generation to the next and it's hard to break the cycle.
How to prepare them for the real world? I'm personally at a loss as to the answer for that one? No wonder so many college students are jobless and want student loan debts forgiven.. That may be the worse thing that could happen for them.
Yes-- you are right.
It's a mess...