╌>

Of Paint and Men; An Allegory

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  13 years ago  •  4 comments

Of Paint and Men; An Allegory

In the world I worked for more than thirty years, contract language, proposals, negotiations and enforcement were part of day-to-day business-as-usual. At times, there were work stoppages/strikes -- one, in the early 1970's lasting almost an entire winter, another morphing into two strikes in successive years, that over the same negotiated agreement.

That world, as contentious as it was at times, was nevertheless subject to rules, written and unwritten, and laws, one of which could impose sanctions for what was, and is still, known as "A Failure to Bargain in Good Faith."

For sure, the White House, the Senate and the House of Representatives are not the world in which I worked, but certain parameters and elements, like fairness, integrity and common sense are what Americans have a right to expect from their elected representatives regardless of whether or not those phenomena are rendered to writing or floating in the atmosphere.

One sure way to poison any form of human interaction, is for one party in a relationship to insist that what has previously been formally agreed to, or, understood as a matter of good faith, be arbitrarily and unilaterally abrogated and used as a "bargaining chip" in future interactions within that relationship!

And that is exactly what the Tea Party has done, not just to the Federal Government, but to hundreds of thousands of Americans directly, and millions upon millions indirectly.

One simple reason for an entity to bargain in good faith, is to avoid painting itself into a corner so that down the road, it won't have to figure a way out of that corner in an effort to save face. Catastrophically for many working people, sick people, children and others, the Tea Party has in fact, painted itself into that proverbial corner and colored their lives in the bleakest shade of gray and this afternoon

those self-serving pieces of legislator-crap, went home to enjoy the Columbus Day holiday.

Whatever one chooses to believe about the discovery of America, what we've discovered about its Tea Party is disheartening, sickening and unthinkable; the Tea Party is self-serving, dishonest and allowed to go on that way because of its zeal-without-knowledge supporters who are themselves, blinded by the "white paint" that they purposely brushed in their "corners".


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I have taken great care in presenting this allegory; as always, I invite intelligently presented dissent; Those incapable of that needn't embarrass themselves herein.

Do it somewhere else.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

So my summation is this is just another partisan bash the Tea party seed ignoring the fact all political parties are just asguilty of the same things, you want to paint the Tea Party of..

This allegory is about degree of guilt and how a situation that could and should have been avoided, was instead promulgated and sustained because of the support assured by gerrymandering in voter districts that are white and conservative.

If you can, make your case as to why that is not so, Mike, but don't think you can simply negate reality by implying that all political entities and all humanity is flawed and biased. I laid it out and you are more than welcome to pull it apart -- but not by summarily saying in essence -- "two wrongs make a right." Jay Bookman

How the GOP gerrymandered itself into trouble

Political analyst Charlie Cook, writing in National Journal , muses about gerrymandering and the Republicans difficulty in breaking out of their demographic cul de sac in a way that I hadnt thought of before.

As Cook notes, the GOP got 48 percent of the House vote in 2012 yet still won 54 percent of House seats, indicating that gerrymandering did produce benefits for the party. But .

But could the Republicans arguably rigged House majority actually be a curse disguised as a blessing? Its an interesting question. They clearly did everything they could to purge Democratic voters from their districts ahead of 2012, no matter whether those voters were white, black, Hispanic, left-handed, or right-mindedjust as Democrats would have done had the roles been reversed. But in the process of quarantining Democrats, Republicans effectively purged millions of minority voters from their own districts, and that should raise a warning flag. By drawing themselves into safe, lily-white strongholds, have Republicans inadvertently boxed themselves into an alternate universe that bears little resemblance to the rest of the country?

When I read that paragraph, my mind jumped immediately to this photo compilation of Georgias GOP Senate caucus that I ran last month:

gopsenate1
gopsenate2

(Since then, yet another white male has been added to that caucus in a special election.)

As Cook points out, the degree of gerrymandering that produces outcomes like that pictured above means that even if Republicans wanted to reach out to minority voters, they cant. They have few if any such minorities in their districts. By making their districts whiter and whiter, they have essentially trapped themselves.

As Cook notes:

For example, using only 2010 census data, Rep. Daniel Websters Central Florida district jumped from 57 percent white to 66 percent white; Rep. Pete Sessionss Dallas-area district leaped from 42 percent to 53 percent white; and Rep. Pat Tiberis Central Ohio district soared from 68 percent to 88 percent white. All three Republicans had relatively close races in the last decade but won easily in 2012.

...

NOTE TO ALL WHO STOP HERE: Mike and I disagree vehemently on many political issues, but we share a mutual respect for one another and any "barbs" we stick in one another are academic, philosophical, ideological but not personal.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Again, I'm talking degree of culpability; it is a disaster-waiting-to-happen any time a critical moment in time is barricaded by threat of trying to go back in time; that is, where one party attempts to renegotiate, UNDER A THREAT OF DOING GREAT, UNNECESSARY HARM, that which was previously negotiated and ratified according to prevailing rules/protocol/law!

To allow such a precedent (as Obama unfortunately allowed in 2011) renders every future such negotiations vulnerable to similar sabotage tactics! The Tea Party could not have precipitated the current shutdown WITHOUT THE ABILITY TO THWART MORE MODERATE CANDIDATES IN PRIMARY ELECTIONS VIA GERRYMANDERING!

Ironically, because of the resultant impending global economic meltdown from a U.S. credit default, the Koch Brothers and Wall Street have come to realize their whacko Tea Party, the C.U. decision and a galvanized demographic of white voters, has come back to bite them in the ass!

If you want to talk "collective guilt," I'll agree if that guilt takes the form of Boehner and the Tea Party initially threatening a credit default, Obama caving to their threat and the gerrymandered districts making it all possible.

Fair enough?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Just curious; do you dispute that gerrymandered districts are essentially "white-voter" districts and that they were intentionally configured thus as a result of Republican wins in 2010.

I did not mention any names, only a phenomenon.

The Lasting Impact of 2010 Election: Redistricting Cementing Republican House Majority

By: David Dayen Thursday October 25, 2012 1:17 pm

Whether you think that Democrats lost the House and a majority of state legislatures in 2010 because of a lack of improvement in the economy, the natural cycle of out-party gains in a midterm election, the clever use of Republican obstructionism to dampen economic performance, those damn liberals who didnt clap loudly enough, or whatever, you cannot deny the lasting impact of that massive thumping. The Brennan Center has a report out today about post-2010 redistricting, and how it has tilted the map in favor of Republican control that may last regardless of the mood of the nation.

Its the state legislative sweep for Republicans that matters here, more than the GOP takeover of the House. Because of those gains, Republicans controlled redistricting in 17 states controlling 173 Congressional districts, while Democrats controlled redistricting in just 6 states with 44 Congressional districts (four states with 21 Congressional districts featured split control of the process). Independent or politician-led commissions, state and federal courts, drew the maps for 15 states, and another 7 have no Congressional redistricting process because they only have one at-large seat (South Dakota, North Dakota, Wyoming, Vermont, Delaware, Alaska, Montana). The only state that the Brennan Center didnt model is Texas, because the outcome of the redistricting process is up in the air, with the legislative Republican-drawn maps ruled invalid by a court, and court-drawn maps being used for the 2012 cycle. If anything, the inclusion of Texas would make this look even worse, since their maps, even with the court-drawn process, are seen as more favorable to Republicans relative to the voter registration and demographics of the state.

Do I need to post some maps?

 
 

Who is online




100 visitors