NARF And NCAI Advise Tribes To Stay Away From Supreme Court
" The relationship between the Supreme Court of the United States and Native Americans has a rocky history and recent rulings have not gone the way Indian Country hoped. The Supreme Court, friend or foe, is charged with interpreting the law of the land.
John Echohawk (Pawnee), Executive Director of the Native American Rights Fund (NARF) and Jefferson Keel (Chickasaw), president of the National Congress of American Indians, joined together to create the Tribal Supreme Court Project.
We clearly saw, as tribal leaders did, this developing disturbing trend in the U.S. Supreme Court to basically rule against Indian tribes and Indian interest in virtually any case that came to the Supreme Court such that the winning record we had had beginning in the 1970's, when the Native American Rights Fund started, had turned into a losing record where basically three out of every four Indian law cases argued before that Court resulted in significant losses, Echohawk said ."
http://kgou.org/post/narf-and-ncai-advise-tribes-stay-away-supreme-court

The U.S. Supreme Court has accepted the case of Michigan v Bay Mills Indian Community in Michigan, Echohawk said.
It basically involves gaming issues and raises issues relating to the interpretation of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA), which of course, a lot of tribes utilize across the country and also raises a whole issue of sovereign prerogative that tribes have, Echohawk said.
That's their sovereign immunity from suit without their consent and both of those issues - interpretation of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act and the extent of tribal immunity from suit - are raised in this case before the U.S. Supreme Court.
With the way the Court has been interpreting things in recent years we're just not very hopeful that any decision on those issues would be favorable to the tribes. And so we're working with Bay Mills Indian Community hopefully to try to get the case resolved in some other way so it doesn't get heard by the US Supreme Court later this year.
Precedents not favorable to Indian Country could be set if the Supreme Court goes against the tribe.
Many people don't understand that when a tribe's case goes before the Supreme Court, like the Bay Mills Community case here, the result not only affects the Bay Mills Indian Community itself, but it stands as a precedent that courts would use then to rule on the rights of any other tribe, Echohawk said.
So its a precedent that really is going to affect all tribes.
Supreme Court Justices Roberts and Alito have never voted pro-Indian, another problem being addressed by the Supreme Court Tribal Project."
That last sentence is the telling one - since 1986, when Rhenquist was the supreme Justice, the court has ruled in favor of tribal claims/court cases 12% of the time. Rhenquist was a master at issuing/writing opinions that had absolutely nothing to do with the case (Oliphant v. Susquannah) that had significant impacts on ALL the tribes - and there is nowhere the tribes can appeal the SCOTUS decisions.
Scary - truly scary.
As can be seen from their last decision, the worst thing that can be done it take a case to this Court.
It's interesting - back in the '50's, there were probably 'bout 600 Indian attorneys - total. Today, the number is somewhere in the neighborhood of 7,500 and climbing fast, primarily because of the SCOTUS decisions since '86.
After a "Plaintiff" files with the state and the Feds, in most cases, the tribes win the cases. But, by the time they get to SCOTUS - well, the wheels come to a grinding halt. Case in point - Baby Veronica - the State Family Court ruled in favor of Dusten Brown, as did the State Supreme court. Both courts had agreed, unequivocably, that the case was an ICWA case, but Roberts and Thomas, both adoptive parents, stated that the case wasn't an ICWA case.
So friggin' weird.
I think the tribal courts will become a lot more organized in their approach to SCOTUS.
''So friggin' weird'', not really 1st. They brought their own feeling into it, and were not doing what they should have damn well done.
I hope that they do 1st, cos if they don't, there is going to be hell to pay for the tribes.
Interesting quote - kinda puts it all in perspective:
"The Court said that tribes are "...prohibited from exercising both those powers of autonomous states that are expressly terminated by Congress and those powers inconsistent with their status." The danger of such an approach is that it allows the Supreme Court, at its own discretion, to determine which attributes of internal tribal sovereignty are inconsistent with the tribes' status as "domestic dependent nations." The assumption of this role by the Court not only changes the usual division of power in the federal government (where Congress has the primary power to deal with Indian tribes), but also enhances the power of the Court to diminish the scope of tribal sovereignty.
At least two troubling aspects of the Court's treatment of the sovereign rights and powers of Indian tribes emerge from a look at the development of the doctrine of tribal sovereignty. First, the Court has moved away from the concept of intrinsic tribal sovereignty that predated the coming of the European conquerors, and has adopted the view that tribal sovereignty, and the concomitant freedom of the tribes from encroachments by the states, exists solely because Congress has chosen to confer some protections on the tribes.
Second, whatever the doctrinal underpinnings of tribal sovereignty may be, it is clear that the sovereignty of American Indian tribes has been progressively and systematically diminished by the actions of the federal government, including the Supreme Court."
So, the question to ask is - where, in the U. S. Constitution, does it give SCOTUS the authority to denude the tribes of their sovereignty?
Excellent quote 1st.
The U.S. Constitution does not give SCOTUS any authority to denude the tribes of their sovereignty. With many screaming to follow the Constitution, they would be best served to follow their own advice.
The SCOTUS against the tribes lately has been William Rhenquist.
His rulings on tribal issues can be found at in the article "Justice Rhenquist's Theory on Indian Law. Shows how he went from to supportive in the '70's to combative/overbearing in the 80's 'til he retired in 2005. Almost 30 years on the bench, molding Indian law into his interpretation, not the Constitution's.
I think it is sound advice! Hasn't the entire history of the Supreme Court been one against the Indians? Yet, I would have no idea how to redress wrongs without the court system... I guess the state and federal lower levels are just as bad.
I am more afraid of the SCOTUS than I am of Indians.
Me, too!!!
LMAO, Grump/Dowser. Good one
Grump's reply just made me spit my iced tea all over my screen.... haven't done that since our UNA days.....
"Circle the tipis, SCOTUS is in session!!!"
Always to the heart of the matter, eh?
Makes you wonder, why the change in him''. Perhaps he found out his son/daughter was going to marry ''one of us''...
Technically the Feds because the money comes from the Fed coffers. The tribes are "supposed" to set up an accounting trail to ensure that doesn't happen - but - . . . . . .