Meet Butch Matthews, A Republican Who Came To Love Obamacare After Realizing It Will Save Him $13,000
Meet Butch Matthews, A Republican Who Came To Love Obamacare After Realizing It Will Save Him $13,000
By Sy Mukherjee on October 2, 2013 at 4:52 pm
61-year-old Butch Matthews, left, with his wife Debbie
Butch Matthews is a 61-year-old former small business owner from Little Rock, Arkansas who used to wake up every morning at 4 A.M. to deliver canned beverages to retailers before retiring in 2010. A lifelong Republican, he was heavily skeptical of the Affordable Care Act when it first passed. I did not think that Obamacare was going to be a good plan, I did not think that it was going to help me at all, he told ThinkProgress over the phone.
But after doing a little research, Matthews eventually realized how much the law could help him. And on Tuesday, his local Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) provider confirmed that he would be able to buy a far better plan than his current policy while saving at least $13,000 per year through Arkansas Obamacare marketplace.
Matthews was self-employed between 1997 and 2010, meaning he had to purchase his own plan on the individual market. He chose a Blue Cross Blue Shield plan for himself and his wife that charged a $250 per month premium and had a $2,000 deductible. But the price of that policy kept rising even as it covered fewer of his costs, eventually devolving into his current rate of $1,069 per month with a $10,000 deductible. At this point, it doesnt even cover his medication or doctors visits particularly concerning considering he had to have two stents placed in his heart in 2006.
I do not work now, Im 61, and we do have assets saved up. But still, to come up with that $1,069 per month. he said, trailing off. I went to Blue Cross Blue Shield, and they dont even sell that plan anymore, but I could not change it to anything else. So I was locked in with it.
That all changed once Obamacares state-level marketplaces opened to the public on Tuesday. Matthews knew that, at his income level, the law would help him pay for insurance. But even he might not have expected just how good of a deal he could get: his new coverage will cost him absolutely nothing in monthly premiums after factoring in federal subsidies, and has a deductible of $750. Which is a lot different from $10,000, he pointed out, laughing.
The mid-level Silver policy that he picked out also offers a significantly better benefits package. Its a lot better plan, Matthews said. His old plan was considered to be Bronze and had much higher co-pays. Under Obamacare, when Matthews visits a doctor, it will no longer cost him around $150. It will cost $8.
So what would Matthews tell other Americans who are skeptical about Obamacare? I would tell them to learn more about it before they start talking bad about it, he noted. Be more informed, get more information, take your time and study and not just go by just what you hear on one side or the other. Actually check the facts on it.
I still am a very strong Republican, but this Im so happy that this came along, he continued. Our home is paid for, vehicles paid for, this is our expense that we have. We have more expense on medical care than everything else put together, so this is going to be a great help for us.
Tags
seeder
CM
13 years agoThe intelligent thing to do is compare plans and prices, shop around, that's the opportunity Obamacare has given consumers, the power to see what other Health Plans are been offered and at what prices..
Petey Coober
13 years agoOh well ... so the millenials will end up paying for this boomer . Who cares about that generation ...
jennilee
13 years ago
seeder
CM
13 years agoGood for you that your employer offers health care insurance, this program was not for you anyway, it was for the people who have employers and make a little too much to qualify for medicaid and not enough to purchase their own policies because of cost..I hope your employer continues to cover your health care and you will not need an individual policy anytime in your lifetime, Life just have a way of changing for people and we never know, the things we seem to own today, may not be available for us tomorrow, in other words, "Good" you trust you will be employed for the next 10 years or so, your employer's business will continue to be prosperous and life is just full of "peaches and cream", for the folks who have had a setback in life, it's good Obamacare is available for them and they will not have to unnecessarily die for lack of been able to see a doctor, I know the Republicans motto is "just die already"....
sixpick
13 years agoI can't speak for anyone else, but I can tell you this gentleman seems to have qualified for the Arkansas Medicaid 1115 Waiver. What this amounts to is for all practical purposes the government has made a deal with Arkansas to qualify this family of two for Medicaid being administered by BCBS at least for the next 3 years.
I hope no one would want anyone to lose everything they have ever worked for in their lives because of the medical cost of premiums and services they may require. I really don't think many or any of us feel this way.
This is a win for BCBS who will be more than happy to administer the policy since the government is paying them the appropriate premium to do so.
Understand the actual cost isn't affected because this gentleman isn't paying anything. The cost is shifted to the tax payers who are not receiving any subsidies, which are individuals making $45,000 or more. Actually the cost is shifted to any individual or family who is not receiving subsidies to help pay their premium.
Let me give you an example:
An individual paying $8400 annual premium with no subsidies making $45,000 is actually paying more than the actual cost of the health coverage premium. This extra amount is to help those making less pay their subsidy.
Now another individual under the same conditions makes $35,000. Instead of having a $8500 premium, the premium is reduced to $3300. The cost has not changed. The excess of $5200 is being subsidized by the person making $45,000.
Now I think anyone would be happy to pay nothing or have their premiums reduced by $5000. I don't think anyone would argue with that.
One thing I ask everyone here is are you for all Americans or are you selective in who you are for? What is motivating about a person working harder to increase their income from $35,000 to $45,000 if it were possible? First think about this. By doing so that person would be taxed on the extra $10,000 which would be the last dollars earned and would be the higher tax rate of the overall average tax rate.
I looked at the Federal tax tables and the tax on a single person making $35,000 is $4819. The tax on a single person making $45,000 is $7286. The difference is $2467 not including the state income tax.
Now think of this. If a single person increases their income from $35,000 to $45,000 the Federal tax on that extra $10,000 is $2467 which is calculated at 24.67%. So the single individual brings home $7533 after Federal taxes. Now no one wants a single individual making $45,000 to be in the $25% tax bracket, but understand this is just on last dollars earned and when you calculate the total tax bracket the Federal tax is only 16% for the tax on $45,000.
But we have to consider this person is only bringing home $7523 of the $10,000 he/she has earned.
Now we have to consider this person also doesn't qualify for any subsidies which we have determined to be $5200.
So we have to take this away from the $7523 as well leaving the person making an extra $10,000 with $2323 actual take home of the $10,000 extra income made.
Now I don't think anyone would like to know they have worked harder and increased their income by $10,000 and only gets to keep $2323 of it. Don't forget this isn't even considering the State tax there would be on that extra $10,000.
I would venture to say this individual would receive less than $2000 of the extra $10,000 they have been motivated to earn. There is no motivation to make $45,000.
Folks, this is the reason I say the only people who have suffered under the Obama Administration has been the middle class. The number of people who are now considered poverty has increase tremendously. 90% of all jobs created in 2013 have been part time jobs.
And to make matters worse, a person has to have more money to survive in this country than a part time job will provide, so they have to have two or more part time jobs, which will increase their income to the extent where they get around $2000 of the $10,000 extra they work so hard for because they won't get the $5200 in subsidies and will be taxed on the extra income they make at last dollars earned.
If there is anyone here who will be happy to take a job that allows you to keep only $2000 of the $10,000 you've earned, let them speak now.
The unemployment rate is still above 7% and most reductions to that rate have not been jobs created but people dropping out of the workforce. And the unemployment doesn't even consider all those who have left the job market, so I would say it is probably several points higher in reality.
Billions of dollars thrown away on green businesses who were and are Obama's supporters. Actually some of these companies gave themselves large bonuses even though they failed, such as Solyndra and many others.
Nancy Pelosi spent more money than all House Speakers in the history of this country during her time as House Speaker and I challenge anyone to show where any of that money spent provided a reduction in deficit or should we say some sort of profit for the economy.
Over 6 million people say they want a job, but if they haven't looked for one in the last 4 weeks. If all of a sudden they were to apply for work the unemployment rate would go up approximately 3%.
Over 47 million people are on food stamps. There were around 26 million in 2007 the year the Democrats took over the House and 27 million in 2008 when the Senate was taken over by the Democrats. Other years.... 2009/34 million, 2010/40 million, 2011/44 million, 2012/46.6 million and finally 2013/47 million. Does anyone think after 5 years under this administration this is something to feel good about?
Green technology only accounts for approximately 2% of the employment in the United States. But it has accounted for a much greater cost against the economy than that. This doesn't mean if all green technology was fully employed the unemployment would drop by 2% for those who are a little confused here.
Over 9 million less people are in the labor force since Obama took office.
Obama, who out of his own mouth just like Castro in Cuba calls himself "The Warrior for the Middle Class", when the only class who has suffered under Obama is the Middle Class. You see where Cuba is, don't you?
This is what Obama has in store for you.
Massive social engineering.
Massive intervention in the workplace, in your business, on farms, on assembly lines and mines.
Massive growth of bureaucracy dictating to you how to produce or whether to produce.
Massive increase of energy cost and food cost and the cost of automobiles and materials to build your homes. He didnt inherit that, hes creating that.
seeder
CM
13 years agoSix, this program was designed to assist people who have fallen through the cracks, they either make too much for medicaid and make too little to afford an individual policy, In order for this Obamacare to be successful, it requires all citizens to participate, the program needs to be improved but it is a good first step, at least it addresses the lack of health insurance for 30-50 million people, it has to be given a chance to see how it can be improved...
jennilee
13 years agoIn theory that sounds good, but the only way the government knows to improve or fix a program is to throw more money at it. So no matter what problems arise, what corruption or fraud comes up, it will never be streamlined, it will only get bigger from here.
jennilee
13 years agoI don't have the insurance yet, it will not be available until Jan 1, and I won't know the cost for me and my husband until Dec 1st. As of right not, we do not have health insurance. And to say that the Republicans motto is "just die already" is a bit dramatic, isn't it? Is it wrong to try to be fiscally responsible? or is 16 trillion and counting in debt really just ok with you?
jennilee
13 years agoMilitary deserves the mostest and bestest they can get. Subsidies to big business and ag could certainly be cut. I would also like to see pensions and lifetime benefits for congress go by the wayside too. Also, cuts to what we send out of this country. Government is getting bigger and bigger, and the more people who depend on it, the more powerful the politicians get. The more powerful they get, the more money and perks they can give to their big money donors, which is probably big business. So, while the individual is getting more and more dependent on the government and keeping those people in power, the corporations are getting richer and richer because these politicians owe them. Make the people more independent and able to think for themselves and they will elect not those who promise them the most, but who actually care about the whole of this country.
seeder
CM
13 years agoSounds to me you are waiting on something that has not taken effect yet, " A bird in the hand, is worth two in the bushes" is my motto, I would rather use what is available currently than wait for promises..
sixpick
13 years agoCM, I take it you would love to take the job which will allow you to keep $2,000 of the $10,000 you've earned?
Actually CM, this is the cruelest of horrible jokes on Americans, there are just too many who do not realize the full impact at this point.
sixpick
13 years agoRescue, these are exact comparisons.
Each person has a salary of either $35,000 or $45,000. Those are the figures on each of these individuals W2 forms.
I can grant you the one making $45,000 is taking home approximately $2,000 more than the one making $35,000 plain and simple.
I assure you the one making $45,000 isn't doing any better than the one making $35,000 with approximately $2,000 more take home pay per year after earning $10,000 more money. It's just plain simple math.

http://thinkprogress.org/health/2013/10/02/2721501/butch-matthews-obamacare-convert/