╌>

Police Can Download Your Smart Phone Without a Warrant?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  13 years ago  •  7 comments

Police Can Download Your Smart Phone Without a Warrant?

[ L ink ]

No one is saying that police should not be able to seize a smartphone, Jules Epstein, a professor at Widener University School of Law, said in an interview Tuesday. The question is, can they open it?

David Rileys smartphone ratted him out.

San Diego police used photos and videos found on Rileys Samsung Instinct device to connect him to a gang-related shooting. Convicted on attempted murder and other charges, the 22-year-old is doing time at Californias Kern Valley State Prison.

Now, hes calling the Supreme Court.

Mobile forensic devices can extract data from seized
cellular phones.
[Photo by Graham Kuzia]

Using technology to collect evidence is no longer an option. It's a necessity. Yes, cell phones can provide investigators with a call history, text messages. and contact lists. They can also provide us with other valuable data that's sometimes overlooked.
[ POLICE The Law Enforcement Magazine]

In a case thats unique to the iPhone era, ju stices are being asked to consider whether police need a warrant to search the capacious and sometimes incriminating digital files many people now carry in their pockets. So far, the question has divided judges.

No one is saying that police should not be able to seize a smartphone, Jules Epstein, a professor at Widener University School of Law, said in an interview Tuesday. The question is, can they open it? Can they open the folder called photos? Can they go through my last 10 Google searches?

On Monday, Sept. 30, Rileys petition was one of dozens put on the docket for potential consideration by Supreme Court justices meeting in a private conference. At least four justices must agree for a petition to be granted and the case set for full argument, and most petitions fail. No decision was issued for the Riley case on Tuesday.

But his case has some definite buzz. His lead appellate lawyer is Jeffrey L. Fisher of the Stanford Law School Supreme Court Litigation Clinic, who argued four cases before the high court last term. Only three attorneys appeared more often during the 2012 term.

The omnipresence of smartphones and the split opinions from different courts could also help Riley get a hearing. An estimated 91 percent of U.S. adults now own a cellphone, and 61 percent of these are info-packed smartphones such as Apples iPhone, Googles Android and Samsungs Instinct.

In light of the frequency with which people are arrested with cell phones and the judiciarys confusion over whether the police may search the devices digital contents, this courts intervention is critical, Fisher and his colleagues wrote in a brief.

The Supreme Court has previously ruled that police may conduct certain warrantless searches incident to arrest without violating the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures. In 1973, for instance, the court approved a search in which Washington, D.C., police patting down a man in custody found heroin inside a crumpled cigarette pack.

Smartphones are really different, Rileys lawyers say.

Modern cell phones provide ready access to a vast array of personal data, and are distinct from the types of possessions, such as cigarette packages and footlockers, this court has previously considered, Fisher said in the brief. For one thing, while physical containers face obvious space-related constraints, cell phones are capable of storing a virtually limitless amount of information in a single, compact device.

Three appellate circuits have, nonetheless, upheld warrantless searches of cellphones. One federal appellate circuit has struck down such searches, as have some state supreme courts. In May, in a case arising from a Jacksonville, Fla., robbery, the Florida Supreme Court struck down a warrantless search of a cellphone taken from a suspect before he was placed in a police car.

The cellphone included incriminating photos. One showed the suspects fiance holding a bundle of money a day after the robbery.

Electronic devices that operate as cell phones of today are materially distinguishable from the static, limited capacity cigarette packet in (the 1973 D.C. case) not only in the ability to hold, import, and export private information, but by the very personal and vast nature of the information that may be stored on them or accessed through the electronic devices, Justice R. Fred Lewis wrote for the Florida Supreme Court.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

" The California Legislature passed a law in 2011 requiring police to obtain a search warrant before searching the contents of any portable electronic devices, but it was vetoed by Gov. Jerry Brown. The issue, Brown said, needs resolution by the courts. " [ 1 ]

Should the police be able to go through all the data stored on your smart phone, photos, text messages, voice mail, google searches and speed dial numbers, without obtaining a warrant?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

The supreme law of the land says that police need probable cause and a search warrant.

{ Gets back on his chair }

Yeah, sorta like the 4th Amendment says.

" The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan wants more information about how Michigan State Police troopers are using devices known as cellular data extractors to retrieve information from a citizen's mobile device during a traffic stop without their consent. "[ POLICE The Law Enforcement Magazine]

M-Cellebrite-UFEDstandard-web.jpg?width=300

Cellebrite's UFED standard is a mobile forensic device that extracts data from 95% of cellular phones on the market today, according to the company. [Photo via Cellebrite].

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

"The Fourth Amendment protects citizens from unreasonable searches," according to the ACLU's letter . "A device that allows immediate, surreptitious intrusion into private data creates enormous risks that troopers will ignore these requirements to the detriment of the constitutional rights of persons whose cell phones are searched."

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

The supreme law of the land says that police need probable cause and a search warrant.

According to the article;

"The Supreme Court has previously ruled that police may conduct certain warrantless searches incident to arrest without violating the Fourth Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures."In 1973, for instance, the court approved a search in which Washington, D.C., police patting down a man in custody found heroin inside a crumpled cigarette pack.

That was 1973.... but things have changed.

Modern cell phones provide ready access to a vast array of personal data, and are distinct from the types of possessions, such as cigarette packages and footlockers, this court has previously considered, Fisher said in the brief. For one thing, while physical containers face obvious space-related constraints, cell phones are capable of storing a virtually limitless amount of information in a single, compact device.

Three appellate circuits have, nonetheless, upheld warrantless searches of cellphones.

Would you agree this issue needs to be revisited by SCOTUS some 40 years later?








 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

on a related-tech-story, mika and schmo had on a gal from cnbc today, who felt it rediculous the obamawreck website was such a disaster given the ability for nsa et al to be able to trace a fart back to 1 out of 300 million of us.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

Jerry

Interesting article and an important issue, worthy of the attention of the Supreme Court.

As you point out, certain warrantless searches can be accomplished without violating an individual's 4th amendment rights

The issue to be addressed is what are the parameters of allowable warrantless searches.

A personal note -- Only a damn fool would maintain files and photos on his or her cell phone that would incriminate them in a crime

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    13 years ago

BadFish

Are you referring to the text of the fourth amendment implicitly covering our cell phones?

How so?

 
 

Who is online



Hal A. Lujah
Gazoo


87 visitors