╌>

The Republicans Fighting Obamacare Aren’t Crazy -- Bloomberg Sep 30, 2013

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  0 comments

The Republicans Fighting Obamacare Aren’t Crazy -- Bloomberg Sep 30, 2013

By Ramesh Ponnuru

For many supporters of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, continued resistance to the law isnt just mistaken. Its downright pathological.

They view it this way: Republicans were within their rights to oppose the law while Congress was debating it, but fighting it three years after it was enacted, and more than a year after the Supreme Court ruled it constitutional, is extreme and dangerous. Republicans are "sabotaging" and trying to "nullify" a democratically passed law.

Its true that because the elections turned out the way they did -- with President Barack Obama re-elected and a Democratic majority in the Senate -- Obamacare will almost certainly stay on the books for the next few years. Its also true that, as one might expect in such a heated debate, opponents of the law have sometimes used unwise tactics, hyperbolic language and false claims in attacking it. If you want to say that trying to stop Obamacare by shutting down the government or hitting the debt ceiling is a terrible idea, youll get no argument from me.

But theres nothing wrong with continuing to resist Obamacare even though it has been on the books for three years. What would be strange is if Republicans ended their opposition to it. The law was, after all, passed over almost-unanimous Republican objections. Other large government programs havent seen as sustained a campaign against them, but they had more bipartisan support at the outset. Obamacare was unpopular with the public when it passed, and it has only become more so. Republicans generally think it will have bad effects on the economy and on health care. And it isnt yet entrenched. Why wouldnt they keep opposing it?

Making Choices

Most of what the laws supporters call "sabotage" is perfectly legitimate political action. Obamacares architects envisioned a lot more cooperation from state governments than theyve gotten so far. But the law allowed states to refrain from setting up insurance exchanges and from expanding Medicaid. States that exercise those options arent disobeying the law or even sabotaging it; theyre just making choices that the laws supporters wish they would not. State governments can even (as some have) make it illegal for their officials to participate in Obamacare. Thats not "nullification"; it doesnt require state officials to break any federal law.

Obamacares critics are actually doing a better job of obeying the legislation than the administration itself, which has repeatedly found creative ways around the laws requirements or just acted as though it says things it does not say. Obamacare doesnt authorize the federal government to offer tax credits and impose certain penalties in states that have opted not to create exchanges. The administration is nonetheless barreling ahead as though it does.

Obamacares supporters often suggest that Republicans should try to improve the law rather than junk it. (They say this more and more as the laws flaws become clearer.) The prospect of improvement, though, is mostly an illusion. Its not as though some set of major modifications to the law would command bipartisan support. Nor can the law really be pushed in a more conservative direction while retaining its basic character.

A few conservatives have suggested deregulating Obamacares exchanges to make it easier to provide policies with high deductibles. But that would mean offering people what the laws advocates call "skimpy" coverage, which Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius has said isnt real insurance. Deregulation would also fit poorly with the laws requirement -- one its supporters consider very important -- that insurers treat sick people and healthy people exactly the same. Enforcing that rule requires a lot of regulation: What if an insurer offers policies that appeal more to healthy people? If you have a different view of how health insurance should work, youd need to rewrite the law so much that youd effectively replace it with something new.

A Replacement

Republicans have too often failed to outline a replacement that would make health insurance affordable for people outside the current system. Even if they do, putting such a plan in place will require years of effort that will often seem futile. It took decades for liberals to get the Affordable Care Act. But no sensible person during that time told them to give up because the matter was settled. Nobody said they should quit out of respect for all the elections that had failed to yield enough politicians committed to their health-care plan.

Theres no reason for conservatives to accept rules of the game in which its always appropriate to agitate for an expansion of government, but illegitimate to roll it back. Republicans may have all sorts of things for which to apologize, but wanting to scrap Obamacare isnt one of them.

(Ramesh Ponnuru is a Bloomberg View columnist, a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a senior editor at the National Review.)


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc

Who is online







99 visitors