╌>

The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dr-trevor-k-johnson  •  11 years ago  •  17 comments

The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science

The Science of Why We Don't Believe Science

How our brains fool us on climate, creationism, and the vaccine-autism link.

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/03/denial-science-chris-mooney

"A MAN WITH A CONVICTION is a hard man to change. Tell him you disagree and he turns away. Show him facts or figures and he questions your sources. Appeal to logic and he fails to see your point." So wrote the celebrated Stanford University psychologist Leon Festinger (PDF), in a passage that might have been referring to climate change denialthe persistent rejection, on the part of so many Americans today, of what we know about global warming and its human causes. But it was too early for thatthis was the 1950sand Festinger was actually describing a famous case study in psychology.

Festinger and several of his colleagues had infiltrated the Seekers, a small Chicago-area cult whose members thought they were communicating with aliensincluding one, "Sananda," who they believed was the astral incarnation of Jesus Christ. The group was led by Dorothy Martin, a Dianetics devotee who transcribed the interstellar messages through automatic writing.

Through her, the aliens had given the precise date of an Earth-rending cataclysm: December 21, 1954. Some of Martin's followers quit their jobs and sold their property, expecting to be rescued by a flying saucer when the continent split asunder and a new sea swallowed much of the United States. The disciples even went so far as to remove brassieres and rip zippers out of their trousersthe metal, they believed, would pose a danger on the spacecraft.

Festinger and his team were with the cult when the prophecy failed. First, the "boys upstairs" (as the aliens were sometimes called) did not show up and rescue the Seekers. Then December 21 arrived without incident. It was the moment Festinger had been waiting for: How would people so emotionally invested in a belief system react, now that it had been soundly refuted?

Read also: the truth about Climategate.

Read also: the truth about Climategate .

At first, the group struggled for an explanation. But then rationalization set in. A new message arrived, announcing that they'd all been spared at the last minute. Festinger summarized the extraterrestrials' new pronouncement: "The little group, sitting all night long, had spread so much light that God had saved the world from destruction." Their willingness to believe in the prophecy had saved Earth from the prophecy!

From that day forward, the Seekers, previously shy of the press and indifferent toward evangelizing, began to proselytize. "Their sense of urgency was enormous," wrote Festinger. The devastation of all they had believed had made them even more certain of their beliefs.

In the annals of denial, it doesn't get much more extreme than the Seekers. They lost their jobs, the press mocked them, and there were efforts to keep them away from impressionable young minds. But while Martin's space cult might lie at on the far end of the spectrum of human self-delusion, there's plenty to go around. And since Festinger's day, an array of new discoveries in psychology and neuroscience has further demonstrated how our preexisting beliefs, far more than any new facts, can skew our thoughts and even color what we consider our most dispassionate and logical conclusions. This tendency toward so-called " motivated reasoning " helps explain why we find groups so polarized over matters where the evidence is so unequivocal: climate change, vaccines, "death panels," the birthplace and religion of the president (PDF), and much else. It would seem that expecting people to be convinced by the facts flies in the face of, you know, the facts.

The theory of motivated reasoning builds on a key insight of modern neuroscience (PDF): Reasoning is actually suffused with emotion (or what researchers often call "affect"). Not only are the two inseparable, but our positive or negative feelings about people, things, and ideas arise much more rapidly than our conscious thoughts, in a matter of millisecondsfast enough to detect with an EEG device, but long before we're aware of it. That shouldn't be surprising: Evolution required us to react very quickly to stimuli in our environment. It's a "basic human survival skill," explains political scientist Arthur Lupia of the University of Michigan. We push threatening information away; we pull friendly information close. We apply fight-or-flight reflexes not only to predators, but to data itself.

We apply fight-or-flight reflexes not only to predators, but to data itself.

We're not driven only by emotions, of coursewe also reason, deliberate. But reasoning comes later, works slowerand even then, it doesn't take place in an emotional vacuum. Rather, our quick-fire emotions can set us on a course of thinking that's highly biased, especially on topics we care a great deal about.

Consider a person who has heard about a scientific discovery that deeply challenges her belief in divine creationa new hominid, say, that confirms our evolutionary origins. What happens next, explains political scientist Charles Taber of Stony Brook University, is a subconscious negative response to the new informationand that response, in turn, guides the type of memories and associations formed in the conscious mind. "They retrieve thoughts that are consistent with their previous beliefs," says Taber, "and that will lead them to build an argument and challenge what they're hearing."

In other words, when we think we're reasoning, we may instead be rationalizing. Or to use an analogy offered by University of Virginia psychologist Jonathan Haidt : We may think we're being scientists, but we're actually being lawyers (PDF). Our "reasoning" is a means to a predetermined endwinning our "case"and is shot through with biases. They include "confirmation bias," in which we give greater heed to evidence and arguments that bolster our beliefs, and "disconfirmation bias," in which we expend disproportionate energy trying to debunk or refute views and arguments that we find uncongenial.

That's a lot of jargon, but we all understand these mechanisms when it comes to interpersonal relationships. If I don't want to believe that my spouse is being unfaithful, or that my child is a bully, I can go to great lengths to explain away behavior that seems obvious to everybody elseeverybody who isn't too emotionally invested to accept it, anyway. That's not to suggest that we aren't also motivated to perceive the world accuratelywe are. Or that we never change our mindswe do. It's just that we have other important goals besides accuracyincluding identity affirmation and protecting one's sense of selfand often those make us highly resistant to changing our beliefs when the facts say we should.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dr. Trevor K. Johnson
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Dr. Trevor K. Johnson    11 years ago

Sure enough, a large number of psychological studies have shown that people respond to scientific or technical evidence in ways that justify their preexisting beliefs.

In a classic 1979 experiment (PDF), pro- and anti-death penalty advocates were exposed to descriptions of two fake scientific studies: one supporting and one undermining the notion that capital punishment deters violent crime and, in particular, murder.

They were also shown detailed methodological critiques of the fake studiesand in a scientific sense, neither study was stronger than the other. Yet in each case, advocates more heavily criticized the study whose conclusions disagreed with their own, while describing the study that was more ideologically congenial as more "convincing."

And it's not just that people twist or selectively read scientific evidence to support their preexisting views. According to research by Yale Law School professor Dan Kahan and his colleagues, people's deep-seated views about morality, and about the way society should be ordered, strongly predict whom they consider to be a legitimate scientific expert in the first placeand thus where they consider "scientific consensus" to lie on contested issues.

In Kahan's research (PDF), individuals are classified, based on their cultural values, as either "individualists" or "communitarians," and as either "hierarchical" or "egalitarian" in outlook. (Somewhat oversimplifying, you can think of hierarchical individualists as akin to conservative Republicans, and egalitarian communitarians as liberal Democrats.) In one study, subjects in the different groups were asked to help a close friend determine the risks associated with climate change, sequestering nuclear waste, or concealed carry laws: "The friend tells you that he or she is planning to read a book about the issue but would like to get your opinion on whether the author seems like a knowledgeable and trustworthy expert." A subject was then presented with the rsum of a fake expert "depicted as a member of the National Academy of Sciences who had earned a Ph.D. in a pertinent field from one elite university and who wasnow on the faculty of another." The subject was then shown a book excerpt by that "expert," in which the risk of the issue at hand was portrayed as high or low, well-founded or speculative.

The results were stark: When the scientist's position stated that global warming is real and human-caused, for instance, only 23 percent of hierarchical individualists agreed the person was a "trustworthy and knowledgeable expert."

Yet 88 percent of egalitarian communitarians accepted the same scientist's expertise. Similar divides were observed on whether nuclear waste can be safely stored underground and whether letting people carry guns deters crime. (The alliances did not always hold. In another study (PDF), hierarchs and communitarians were in favor of laws that would compel the mentally ill to accept treatment, whereas individualists and egalitarians were opposed.)

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Very nice article... It confirms my belief that people sometimes need to be dragged to the truth, and even that won't work.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
The stigmatization of GMOS are a great exampleOr obamacare forcing taxpayers to subsidize quack medicine like aroma therapy.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Climatology is too young to be considered a science yet . Trusting the "conclusions" of a popularity contest [consensus] is not a reliable way to get predictions about the future . The numerous unaccounted for variables keep getting in the way .

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

True word. Denial is rampant in America today on many different subjects. Almost exclusively for political reasons. They see the truth, but refuse to accept it as real, because it doesn't fit their politics.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Let me make it easier for you Elisabeth . The source of the "article" is Mother Jones , as biased a source as one can find . If you want to read something with a purely political agenda read Mother Jones ...

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

No one recognizes irony anymore...

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Not exactly someone I'd take medical advice from. Had he followed the doctors advice when they discover the melanoma and amputated his toe he might still be alive today.

 
 
 
Dr. Trevor K. Johnson
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Dr. Trevor K. Johnson    11 years ago

I think that the above article makes some fine points, but I also believe that we can theorize a much simpler reason as to why modern Americans choose to reject science.

The penetration of Junk Science into the mainstream.

Whenever I attempt to convince a person that a scientific reality is just that, reality, they remind me of the many times they have been convinced of the junk sciences, and the lasting effect is mistrust of ALL science, or at least a willingness to be skeptical.

Here is one of my favorites:

In 2013 radiation expert Robert Emery examined a research paper in his office at the University of Texas Health Science Center in Houston that declared a health crisis was at his door. Authors Joseph Mangano and Janette Sherman claimed they could link 14,000 American deaths to fallout from Japan's March 2011 Fukushima nuclear accident . Mangano, the executive director of the Radiation and Public Health Project (RPHP), holds a master's degree in public health; Sherman is an adjunct professor of environmental studies at Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo. "Public health means prevention," Mangano told Popular Mechanics. "It means removing any potential harm from our world."

Mangano and Sherman tallied the number of deaths in about 100 U.S. cities in the 14 weeks after the Fukushima accident, compared with the same time period from the year before. Projected across the entire U.S., the difference amounted to thousands of "excess" deaths. The study was titled "An Unexpected Mortality Increase in the United States Follows Arrival of the Radioactive Plume from Fukushima: Is There a Correlation?"

"I read the thing and was taken aback," says Emery, who has a doctorate in public health and is a licensed medical health physicist. The study implied fallout from Fukushima caused 484 deaths in Houston. If there had been radiation-related deaths in Texas, Emery was well-positioned to know about them. Following the disaster in Japan, he supervised the effort to set up extra air-sampling stations and Geiger counters throughout Houston to monitor any increase in radioactivity; elevated levels were not found.

Radiation from Fukushima did reach some parts of the U.S., but Emery says the doses were so low that there is no way they could have caused the immediate fatalities the study claimed. Even at Fukushima, where workers absorbed radiation doses thousands of times higher than Americans on the other side of the Pacific Ocean, no one died from acute exposure.

The paper's conclusions were based on a remarkably simplistic correlation that didn't stand up to further scrutiny; at least one scientist pointed out that RPHP saw an increase only because it counted deaths from 119 cities in the year after Fukushima versus 104 cities in the year before. (The authors say the disparity was due to incomplete data for some cities.)

The Mangano and Sherman paper is a prime example of a troubling new trend in which junk science is becoming harder to distinguish from rigorous research. It is an example of activists using the trappings of science to influence public opinion and policy. Today there are cottage industries that produce and disseminate skewed research in publications that masquerade as legitimate science journals. Celebrities and mainstream media outlets then tout the results, so that even retracted or clearly biased research can reach larger audiences than ever before. These studies cause real harmfor instance, by denouncing lifesaving vaccines and vilifying foods that could ease famine in developing countries.

People who produce junk science often come from outside the scientific mainstream, and they bend the rules of research in an attempt to legitimize their personal beliefs, says Mark Hoofnagle, a surgery resident at the University of Maryland who runs the science-monitoring blog Denialism.com . "What if your ideology is simply not supported by the evidence?" he says. "You can change your mind or you can hijack the system."

Joe Mangano is admittedly fixated on the risks of radiation. While low-level radiation can increase a person's chances of developing cancer over the course of a lifetime, Mangano hypothesizes that it also has short-term effects by exacerbating problems in people who are already sick.

"Saying low-dose radiation is harmless is like saying that if you smoke five cigarettes a day or less, that's a low dose so you don't need to do the studies," he told PM. But the lack of evidence linking low-dose radiation to immediate damage was lost in the headline of the RPHP press release : "Medical Journal Article: 14,000 U.S. Deaths Tied to Fukushima Reactor Disaster Fallout."

"This is the first peer-reviewed study published in a medical journal documenting the health hazards of Fukushima," the press release announced.

Ten days after the paper was published, United Press International ran a story about the study, quoting Mangano as saying the "findings are important to the current debate of whether to build new reactors, and how long to keep aging ones in operation." A San Diego ABC affiliate later ran a news segment describing the dangers of fallout from Fukushima, interviewing Mangano and describing "which children may be vulnerable." On-air reporter Michael Chen noted that "critics say there is no direct evidence" that the low radiation levels could cause harm, but there were no quotes from or on-air interviews with any of those critics.

When a journal publishes a paper outside its area of expertise it should raise a red flag, according to Ivan Oransky, a medical doctor and the cofounder of the Retraction Watch blog, which reports on the retractions of scientific papers. The Fukushima study deals with epidemiology. It appeared, however, in the International Journal of Health Services (IJHS), which specializes in public and social policy, including "the articulation of science and ideology in the pursuit of health."

The IJHS is peer reviewed. Peer review alone, though an important step in establishing scientific credibility, is no guarantee of accuracy. During the typical review process, a scientist submits his or her research paper to a journal. If the journal editors want to publish it, they usually ask two experts to anonymously assess whether the findings are novel, important, and supported by the data. But journal reviewers don't typically scrutinize raw data, re-run the statistical analyses, or look for evidence of fraud. "What they're reviewing are mostly advertisements of research rather than the research itself," Stanford epidemiologist John Ioannidis says.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Now THAT we can agree on! I had a black spot under my nail on my left big toe and it was tested for melanoma. Fortunately it was negative (dried blood formed there for some reason?), but I would have had the toe off in a heartbeat. I realize he thought it was against his religion, but come on! It's just a toe!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

When a journal publishes a paper outside its area of expertise it should raise a red flag

Generally true BUT the exception is climatology . There are no experts in climatology since it is not yet a science . Worse than that opinions of the "scientists" are given as if they are fact . There is an obvious bias of these opinions since they support the need for more research . And the way they motivate that need is to make unproven alarmist predictions . The entire process is biased .

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    11 years ago

BEER, the cause of and cure for all of life's problems.

-the philosopher Homer Simpson

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    11 years ago

The penetration of Junk Science into the mainstream.

It's more than just "junk science". Americans have finally figured out that scientists also have agendas, not always related to discovering the truth. Mostly those agendas have to do with getting more government grants for additional studies, and keeping their income flowing in.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Consider a person who has heard about a scientific discovery that deeply challenges her belief in divine creationa new hominid, say, that confirms our evolutionary origins. What happens next, explains political scientist Charles Taber of Stony Brook University, is a subconscious negative response to the new informationand that response, in turn, guides the type of memories and associations formed in the conscious mind. "They retrieve thoughts that are consistent with their previous beliefs," says Taber, "and that will lead them to build an argument and challenge what they're hearing."

I can't think of a better way to describe some people's reaction to climate change. It is based on the false premise that studying climate is a new idea and is therefore climatology is not a "real" or established science, when in fact humans have been studying the weather, the climate, since ancient times and we have many experts in the field still studying it today.

Chinese scientist Shen Kuo (10311095) inferred that climates naturally shifted over an enormous span of time, after observing petrified bamboos found underground near Yanzhou (modern day Yan'an , Shaanxi province), a dry-climate area unsuitable for the growth of bamboo. [2]

Early climate researchers include Edmund Halley , who published a map of the trade winds in 1686 after a voyage to the southern hemisphere. Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790) first mapped the course of the Gulf Stream for use in sending mail from the United States to Europe . Francis Galton (1822-1911) invented the term anticyclone . [3] Helmut Landsberg (1906-1985) fostered the use of statistical analysis in climatology, which led to its evolution into a physical science.

Source

With Doppler radar and satellites and weather stations and weather and temperature buoys in the sea all feeding us reams and reams of valuable information of how our climate is changing, to say it's not a real science being studied by real scientists is silly and absurd. The methods of collecting weather data and predicting changes in patterns has improved with new technology, but it's still an ancient science, just brought up to date.

The weather and predictions of what was to come led to decisions such as when to go into battle and how to steer away from storms on the open sea since humans have been fighting wars and sailing the oceans. When will the rain clear up to make the best time to sow or plant a particular crop. When is the rainy season or the dry season and the cold or hot season and how do you adjust your life to the climate as it happens around you. So climatology, far from being a new, un-established science, is actually very well established with a long and rich history. The concept, the truth, of climate change is just another chapter in that long history.

However, since it is a new chapter, it is like a discovery of an unexpected example of an early hominid that doesn't fit and changes our views on something like evolution slightly or even dramatically. It's different, it's new and to some people it's frightening or threatening, so they turn to the people, the leaders, whom they have always drawn strength from. In the case of evolution deniers they turn to ministers of god who deny the very existence of this science themselves for comfort and reassurance, even if it is false reassurance. In the case of climate change deniers they turn to political leaders who have a financial reason to deny the existence of this science, just as the minister has an agenda of keeping his pews full by encouraging the rejection of evolution. So, like many new changes to a long established science, such as evolution or climatology, it becomes easier and more comforting to deny that the new change is real and they have leaders behind them with their own agendas, feeding them false data or outright lies, to give them something comforting to hold on to and to support their denial. To make them feel all warm and fuzzy, instead of facing the new reality of a truth they don't want to hear or deal with.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I can't think of a beter why to describe some people's reaction to information on climate change.

I can . See my above comments .

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    11 years ago

Most of those scientists, the ones with agendas, are not really following rigorous scientific methodology. They find the facts to fit their ideology and ignore the inconvenient ones. This is junk science. The profligation of junk science sites and publishers on the internet only leaves the common person wondering just what the hell is going on.

 
 

Who is online

devangelical
evilone


73 visitors