╌>

Obama's United Nations Backdoor to Gun Control

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  13 years ago  •  14 comments

Obama's United Nations Backdoor to Gun Control

Even before his most ambitious gun-control proposals were falling by the wayside, President Obama was turning for help to the United Nations. On April 2, the United States led 154 nations to approve the Arms Trade Treaty in the U.N. General Assembly. While much of the treaty governs the international sale of conventional weapons, its regulation of small arms would provide American gun-control advocates with a new tool for restricting rights. Yet because the Constitution requires that two-thirds of the Senate give its advice and consent to any treaty, Second Amendment supporters still have a political route to stop the administration.

Associated Press

General Assembly building at the United Nations.

Like many international schemes, this treaty has seemingly benign motives. It seeks to "eradicate the illicit trade in conventional arms and to prevent their diversion to the illicit market," where they are used in civil wars and human-rights disasters. The treaty calls for rigorous export controls on heavy conventional weapons, such as tanks, missiles, artillery, helicopters and warships.

Yet, as with many utopian devices, the treaty fails the test of enforcement. Some of the world's largest arms traffickers either voted against the agreement or abstained. The U.S., quite rightly, already has the world's most serious export controls in place, while nations such as North Korea, Syria, Iran, Russia and China will continue to traffic in arms with abandon.

But the new treaty also demands domestic regulation of "small arms and light weapons." The treaty's Article 5 requires nations to "establish and maintain a national control system," including a "national control list." Article 10 requires signatories "to regulate brokering" of conventional arms. The treaty offers no guarantee for individual rights, but instead only declares it is "mindful" of the "legitimate trade and lawful ownership" of arms for"recreational, cultural, historical, and sporting activities." Not a word about the right to possess guns for a broader individual right of self-defense.

Gun-control advocates will use these provisions to argue that the U.S. must enact measures such as a national gun registry, licenses for guns and ammunition sales, universal background checks, and even a ban of certain weapons. The treaty thus provides the Obama administration with an end-run around Congress to reach these gun-control holy grails. As the Supreme Court's Heller and McDonald cases recently declared, the Second Amendment guarantees an individual right "to keep and bear Arms" such as handguns and rifles. Congress's power to regulate interstate commerce remains broad, but the court's decisions in other caseseven last year's challenge to the Affordable Care Actremind us that those powers are limited.

International treaties don't suffer these limits. The Constitution establishes treaties in Article II (which sets out the president's executive powers), rather than in Article I (which defines the legislature's authority)so treaties therefore aren't textually subject to the limits on Congress's power. Treaties still receive the force of law under the Supremacy Clause, which declares that "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land."

Some have argued over the years that this difference in language between laws and treaties allows the latter to sweep more broadly than the former. In Missouri v. Holland (1920), Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes followed this logic to declare that no "invisible radiation from the general terms of the Tenth Amendment" applies to the Treaty Power. Congress could win greater favor from the courts for gun-control measures, or President Obama could issue executive orders for a gun registry and background checks, on the claim that he is implementing the treaty.

Missouri read the treaty power broadly under the Supremacy Clause at a time when the courts gave Congress's powers short shrift, but the decision was fundamentally mistaken. The Supremacy Clause referred to treaties "made under the Authority of the United States" not to expand their scopebut to grandfather in existing agreements such as the Peace Treaty with Great Britain. In Reid v. Covert (1957), a plurality of justices agreed that the treaty power could not undermine the Bill of Rights, rightly trying to close the huge loophole that Missouri had erroneously opened.

The attempt to advance gun control through the Arms Trade Treaty might surprise average Americans, but not liberals, who have been long frustrated by the Constitution's limits on government. Gun-control statutes, like any others, have to survive both the House and the Senate, then win presidential approval. It is far easier to advance an agenda through treaties, unwritten international law and even "norms" delivered by an amorphous "international community."

Opponents of capital punishment have used treaties to press the Supreme Court to stop the death penalty in Texas. Women's rights groups advocate an international convention that would achieve the goals of the failed Equal Rights Amendment. And supporters of bans on "hate speech" invoke international norms to defeat First Amendment objections. There also is an international legal doctrine that during the period when a country has signed but not yet ratified a treaty, it must take no measures that defeat the treaty's object and purposes. Under some liberal theories, this would allow the president to put some measures of the new arms treaty into effect by executive order.

Fortunately the Framers required that the president submit all significant international agreements to the Senate, which must consent to the treaty with the same supermajority needed to send a constitutional amendment to the states or to override an executive veto.

The Senate should block this latest effort to evade the Constitution's controls on federal power. There could be no greater justification for senators to exercise their veto over treaties than the cause of protecting the individual liberties of Americansincluding the right to bear arms.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324504704578413110123095782.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Bullshit! Those who run with the NRA/FOX/NEOCON/TEA PARTY line don't have a clue what the treaty addresses.

IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH U.S. GUN CONTROL!

It changes in no way any U.S. Law. What it does is regulate the $70 billion business in conventional arms and keep weapons out of the hands of human rights abusers . It regulates the international trade in conventional arms, from small arms to battle tanks, combat aircraft and warships. The treaty will foster peace and security by putting a stop to destabilizing arms flows to conflict regions. It will prevent human rights abusers and violators of the law of war from being supplied with arms. And it will help keep warlords, pirates, and gangs from acquiring these deadly tools. That's it!

The authors of the seeded article will tell any informed person all he/she needs to know.

JOHN BOLTON

JOHN YOO

He served as a political appointee, the Deputy Assistant U.S. Attorney General in the Office of Legal Counsel , Department of Justice (OLC), during the George W. Bush administration . He is best known for his opinions concerning the Geneva Conventions which legitimized the War on Terror by the United States. He also authored the so-called Torture Memos , which concerned the use of what the Central Intelligence Agency called enhanced interrogation techniques including waterboarding .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Talk about "ass lickers".

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Read the f'n treaty instead of the NRA bullshit! It has nothing to do with the 2nd Amendment.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

It is loosely written and bans "private sales" of semi automatic weapons, this is something currently legal in this country. You can argue the virtue of this, it doesn't change the fact that it is in conflict with our laws. It also leaves the door wide open for National registry in order to comply with the "national control system" portion of the treaty.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The NRA has the "registry" in case you weren't aware.

What the fuck is it with people who piss on health insurance for millions of people, food stamps for 170,000 veterans, kids, elderly and sick people --

AND WET THEIR FUCKING PANTS OVER GUNS!

NRA built massive database of gun owners while opposing national gun registry

The National Rifle Association has frightened Americans about the prospect of a federal registry of firearm owners, but the NRA itself has secretly created a database with information from tens of millions of Americans who do not hold a membership.

The NRA has spent years secretly collecting information about gun owners from state and local offices and has built the countrys largest privately held database of current, former and prospective gun owners, according to a BuzzFeed report.

News of the NRAs database is particularly surprising, since the pro-gun agency heavily protested the idea of a federal gun registry after the Newtown massacre led to debates on increased background checks. Even though 91 percent of Americans supported universal background checks, lawmakers were unable to push such an initiative through Congress. At the time, the NRAs Wayne LaPierre instilled a widespread fear that universal background checks would lead to a national registry of gun owners, which critics said could lead to taxes on guns or confiscation.

Thats what [the feds] are after, the names of good, decent people all over this country, who happen to own firearms to go into a federal database or universal registration, every lawful gun owner in America, LaPierre said in a speech at the Conservative Political Action Conference. Thats their answer to criminal violence are they insane?

But thats exactly what the NRA has been doing for years. The organizations database includes personal information from people who have attended gun-safety classes taught by NRA-certified instructors or gun shows. The NRA also collected gun permit information from state and county offices, as well as the names of gun magazine subscribers.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    13 years ago

Yea I am not a fan of the NRA either. The point I was trying to make is that there are provisions that were agreed to that currently don't exist. Or as you have pointed out, at least not that anyone will admit to. How are we going to comply? We will have to make new laws to fulfill our obligations in this treaty won't we?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago
Yes. The part that has number 2!
 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land."

Look, people, don't get all excited here.

The Authority of the United States, the "supreme Law of the Land," has made over 500 Treaties with Native Americans of this Land, and has not honored a single one of them. NOT. A. SINGLE. ONE.

Therefore, I see no reason that it should have to honor a Treaty made with the United Nations. What are they going to do? Kick us out.24.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The Constitution doesn't really have an ass, Amac.

Sorry I confused you.

Thanks for the clarification!

Can you say "dueling metaphors"? How 'bout "hypotheticals"?

Weak retort Robert G.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If you licked ass just once, does that make you an ass licker forever?

That depends on your personal tastes.

Talk about "tongue-in-cheek" remarks.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

I don't think they have the ratification votes in the senate , its basically the same legislation that was voted down on the national level not too long ago. nor do I think many inividuals would abide by such a treaty anyway , so what will the UN do? send in troops to enforce it ? those blue helmets and beanies make excellent targets no matter what nationality the person is that wears them.

I think , don't block the core principles of the treaty, and abide by them , but don't sign it either , we don't have to sign a damn thing to do the right things.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

why not?: according to the latest wash post/nbc poll: 90% of UN members want background checks!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

why not?: according to the latest wash post/nbc poll: 90% of UN members want background checks!

So do 74% of NRA members!

Ain't that a kick in the head?

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
July 24, 2012

NEW POLL OF NRA MEMBERS BY FRANK LUNTZ SHOWS STRONG SUPPORT FOR COMMON-SENSE GUN LAWS, EXPOSING SIGNIFICANT DIVIDE BETWEEN RANK-AND-FILE MEMBERS AND NRA LEADERSHIP

Gun Owners Believe Protecting Second Amendment Goes Hand-in-Hand with Keeping Guns Out of the Hands of Criminals

Overwhelming Support for Background Checks for All Buyers; Barring Terror Suspects from Firearm Ownership; and Requiring Reporting of Lost and Stolen Guns Measures Opposed by the NRAs Washington Office

Mayors Against Illegal Guns today released the findings of a survey by GOP pollster Frank Luntz showing that NRA members and gun owners overwhelmingly support a variety of laws designed to keep firearms out of dangerous hands, even as the Washington gun lobby prepares to spend unprecedented millions supporting candidates who pledge to oppose any changes to U.S. gun laws. The poll also dispels the myth among many Washington pundits that there is a lack of public support for common-sense measures that would help keep guns out of the hands of dangerous people and keep Americans safe.

Among the surveys key findings :

  • 87 percent of NRA members agree that support for Second Amendment rights goes hand-in-hand with keeping guns out of the hands of criminals.
  • There is very strong support for criminal background checks among NRA members and gun owners:
  • 74 percent of NRA members and 87 percent of non-NRA gun owners support requiring criminal background checks of anyone purchasing a gun.
  • 79 percent of NRA members and 80 percent of non-NRA gun owners support requiring gun retailers to perform background checks on all employees a measure recently endorsed by the National Shooting Sports Foundation, the trade association for the firearms industry.

NRA members strongly support allowing states not the Federal government to set basic eligibility requirements for people who want to carry concealed, loaded guns in public places, with 91 percent of NRA members stating states should decide.

By contrast, the NRA leaderships top Federal legislative priority national reciprocity for concealed carry permits would effectively eliminate these requirements by forcing every state to allow non-residents to carry concealed guns even if they would not qualify for a local permit. NRA members support many common state eligibility rules for concealed carrying:

  • 75 percent of NRA members believe concealed carry permits should only be granted to applicants who have not committed any violent misdemeanors, including assault.
  • 74 percent of NRA members believe permits should only be granted to applicants who have completed gun safety training.
  • 68 percent of NRA members believe permits should only be granted to applicants who do not have prior arrests for domestic violence.
  • 63 percent of NRA members believe permits should only be granted to applicants 21 years of age or older.

The NRA rank and file also supports barring people on terror watch lists from buying guns (71 percent) and believe the law should require gun owners to alert police to lost and stolen guns (64 percent). The NRAs Washington office strongly opposes both measures.

The Luntz findings are in line with previous research showing that Americans are nearly unanimous in their support for closing loopholes that allow dangerous people to buy firearms without a background check. A January 2011 poll conducted for Mayors Against Illegal Guns by the bipartisan polling team of Momentum Analysis and American Viewpoint found that 86 percent of Americans and 81 percent of gun owners support requiring all gun buyers to pass a background check, no matter where they buy a gun or who they but it from.

Gun owners and NRA members overwhelmingly support common sense steps to keep guns out of the hands of criminals, even as the NRA leadership continues to oppose them, said Mayors Against Illegal Guns Co-Chair and New York City Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg.Its time for those in Washington and those running for President to stand with gun owning citizens who are concerned about public safety, rather than influence peddling lobbyists who are obsessed with ideology.I join with NRA members in urging Washington to pass a law requiring universal background checks for all gun sales and to take other common sense steps that will save lives.

This poll shows plain and simply how seriously out-of-step the leadership of the NRA is with its membership and how, despite what previous polls say, there really is support for common sense gun laws in the U.S., said Mayors Against Illegal Guns Co-Chair and Boston Mayor Thomas M. Menino. The best way to honor the memory of those who senselessly lost their lives in Aurora is to make it harder for this to ever happen again. Our political leaders need to lead and we demand they act now.

The Luntz poll of 945 gun owners nationwide was conducted in May 2012 and was divided evenly by gun owners who were current or lapsed members of the NRA and non-NRA gun owners. The poll has a margin of error of + 3 percent.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     13 years ago

So its best to slam their peckers in the door now..... and not sign or ratify but do the core principles that other acts and national law cover, goes back to enforce the laws already on the books.

 
 

Who is online



78 visitors