Appropriating Native American Imagery Honors No One but the Prejudice
http://abcnews.go.com/ABC_Univision/ABC_Univision/native-american-imagery-appropriation-redskins-disrespectful/story?id=20286034
" Im not the only one who thinks that racists mascots dont belong in sports. Just ask a psychologist.
The American Psychology Association (APA) recommends retiring American Indian mascots altogether. First of all, the organization found that the stereotypical images were harmful for the development and self-esteem of American Indian students. That wasnt all. The portrayals had a negative effect on all students.
The problem, according to the APA, is that American Indian mascots are undermining the educational experiences of members of all communities-especially those who have had little or no contact with Indigenous peoples." And, it establishes an unwelcome and often times hostile learning environment for American Indian students that affirms negative images/stereotypes that are promoted in mainstream society."
One of the best films on the subject that Ive seen is the documentary film In Whose Honor? . The film focuses on Charlene Teters (Spokane) and her campaign against Chief Illiniwek," the mascot of University of Illinois. Other highly publicized Native American mascot battles are described here .
Unfortunately, this racial insensitivity extends beyond U.S. borders. Ian Campeau, an Ojibway father and member of the DJ group, A Tribe Called Red, has filed a human rights complaint with the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal against an amateur football club, the Nepean Redskins," in hopes of eradicating the use of the term altogether. The team is based in Canadas capital city, Ottawa, and uses a cartoon image of a red-faced Indian man with a large nose, a long, black braid and two feathers in his hair as their mascot.
The players call each other redskins on the field," said Campeau in a press release. How are they going to differentiate the playing field from the school yard? Whats going to stop them from calling my daughter a redskin in the schoolyard? Thats as offensive as using the n-word."
If Campeaus request is granted, the Human Rights Tribunal would order the National Capital Amateur Football Association to change the name and logo. His complaint also requests that the Tribunal draft a policy on the use of Indigenous imagery in sports, which could have an impact on teams of various levels that use the Redskins name in Canada.
The most in-your-face examples of racists mascots are in professional sports, including the football team of our nations capital, the Washington Redskins. The teams owner, Dan Snyder, refuses to change the teams name despite the obvious offensive nature of the imagery and name itself. Snyder has been quoted as saying, "We'll never change it. It's that simple. NEVER you can use caps."
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

"I had met one-on-one with the principal, my guidance counselor, a few teachers and several students to share my negative feelings toward our schools mascot an anonymous Native American warrior" with long, flowing, jet-black hair, a large nose and huge muscles. I guess I thought if I made it known that I felt appropriating Native American imagery was offensive, theyd stop. I was outnumbered, though, and my personal feelings didnt matter. But thats the thing: As Native people, especially as urban Natives (what we Indigenous people living in urban centers call ourselves), we are almost always outnumbered. So, we go unnoticed and unheard. Our opinions never really matter."
I didn't understand how face paint purchased from a drug store and a faux headdress made of brown construction paper and dyed arts & crafts feathers was respect. How does celebrating Native people with war imagery honor a living people? Well, it doesnt. It saddens me that this is all we are to you: people who speak in broken English (How.") and the only thing we do is engage in battle with bows, arrows and tomahawks. Oh, and perform an occasional rain dance when we hear a repetitive drum beat.
Racial stereotyping, inaccurate racial portrayals, and cultural appropriation do not honor a living, breathing people. Plain and simple, cultural appropriation -- especially when members of the culture protest the appropriation -- is not respectful.
Its beyond me why people are okay with this. With any other culture, people would be up in arms. "
Explain to me, if you will and if you can, why, when I tell you this bothers me, you tell me to"Get over it."??? If you offend any other ethnicity, you will get your balls handed to you in a paper bag - maybe. So why is it OK to offend us andwe're expectedto get over it?????
This is one of the reasons. Reservations, out of sight, out of mind. Treaties, the supreme law of the land, except if your Indian. The U.S. Government has violated every treaty signed with Indian nations.
I could list a lot more, but this will do to start.
I'm sure this argument has been made, but here goes.
Are 'Cowboys' insulted by a football team being named for them?
How about 'Patriots'?
We could go on and on. My high school mascot was a 'Highlander', a mythical Scottish character.
'Aztecs' are the (whatever) of my alma mater SDSU.
Naming a team after a group is an honor.
That said, who are the 'redskins'?
Well..... I never really thought about the word "Redskin" in the context dealing with scalp before it was brought to my attention on a previous article. I can understand why Indians would detest the word.
As far as sports, I could care less about sports. Most I know who can't wait for the Monday Night Football, couldn't walk a hundred yards, must less run it, unless there was a six pack between the goal post.
After coming home from the service, sports had just turned into another "Dancing with the Stars" as far as I'm concerned. That doesn't mean I care if some of you love sports. Go for it. I don't care if you call em Whiteskins, Redskins, Blueskins or whatever you want as far as I'm concerned.
You can call me whatever you want. I don't care. Maybe "Toughskin" will be satisfactory. It's alright with me.
If you believe in something and you feel strongly about it, then I don't blame you for fighting for what you believe in.
As far as psychologist are concerned. I really don't care for them, either. They've destroyed the lives of many children as far as I'm concerned by putting a young healthy colt under some debilitating drug to deprive him of his sudden burst of energy and make him a old stallion long before his time. I think the whole damn country is on drugs and it ain't pot because of a lot of doctors and psychologist have put too many on them when it wasn't necessary and I believe has proven to be detrimental to normal mental development and taken away the dreams of way too many people.
Getting back to "Redskins" and "mascots" and Hopa's comment. I don't think that is the way it is at all. If you think that is true, then I am unable to communicate with you, because I know a lot of Indians and I sure don't feel that way and I don't know anyone who does feel that way.
I expect that statement was based on emotion, not reality. I think you'll find it hard to locate any football fan who thinks of Indian scalps when they think of the word "Redskins".
Take this from an ignorant white boy, "I think of warriors or fighters, something to be proud of, not the scalping of Indians." I don't think any football fan would want to support a mental image of scalping an Indian when they think of their favorite team if it is the Redskins.
If you feel so strongly about it then by all means go for it. I don't want to sound mean, but sometimes I feel like my glasses have "Don't walk on the grass" printed on the inside of the lens. I'd vote in your favor if presented to me to do so because I'm not you and I can not see it the way you do, but can understand how it could be very offensive and it doesn't matter to me either way.
Has this been going on for years? I've only heard of it since I believe 1swarrior put the article up about the scalping in the early part of the USA history, which I thought was an atrocity which I'm ashamed ever happened, but as with slavery, I wasn't around then and neither were any of you. Obviously I'm uninformed. But I will tell you if a player from the other team starts running around the field with a scalp after winning a game against the "Redskins", then I think I would run out there and whip their ass really good.
Lotsa stuff there.
I think I agree with everything you wrote, after reading it twice, especially about how it doesn't really matter what the team names is.
Mostly I like the way you write.
On this:
Indeed. It was the same way in the 'Aztec' mascot issue at SDSU. A small minority made a lot of noise in protest to the mascot. They were successful at changing the mascot, but its still the Aztecs, a minor change.
But, I can see the complaint against 'Redskins'. That's almost as bad as calling a team the 'Irish' !
Just kidding, 'redskins' is kinda bad, I guess.
The biggest reason is apathy by the majority.
Hollywood didn't start it - Thomas Jefferson did in the Declaration of Independence and it was carried on by the Supreme Courts up until the 1950's.
It was been made, and doesn't hold water.
None of the names you mentioned above, carry the horrific history with them that the term ''Redskins'' does.
We are the Native Americans. We have a problem with term "redskins" because of the history with it. We have asked sports teams to stop using it because it offends us.
That should be the end of the discussion.
Black people have a problem with the terms "nigger, spade, darkie, coon, boy".... to name a few, and America has stopped using the terms as common language and they have been termed racist and bigoted and prejudiced and you can be sued (if a business) for using them, and charged with a "hate" crime (if an individual) for using them while engaged in a confrontation with a Black person.
Hispanic and Latinos find the terms "spics, wetbacks" offensive and they have been deemed racist and prejudiced and bigoted. You can be sued (if a business) for using them, and charged with a "hate" crime (if an individual) for using them while engaged in a confrontation with a Black person.
Need I go on with the hateful terms for Jews and repeat the paragraphs above?
I don't care how many fucking "polls" are done "across America" with "Americans" about "they" feel about the name "Washington Redskins."
We are the Native Americans. We have a problem with term "redskins" because of the history with it. We have asked sports teams to stop using it because it offends us.
That should be the end of the discussion.
Sixpick:
Hopa is unfortunately correct in that there are indeed some people whoconsider Indians as subhuman.
Rick Perry has an Evangelical preacher who commands a large following of Christians and a huge amount of dollars for donations to the Republican party who strongly follows this line of thought and preaches it.
If you were to spend any time on the Newsvine political forum whenever there is any opportunity for someone to mention Native Americans, there are several who crawl out of the woodwork who have no hesitation about saying that Indians are ignorant savages who should have been all wiped out while they were rounded up in one place on the reservations, the problem taken care of once and for all.
If you ever have the time and really want to know what past presidents thought of Indians, just enter "Native Americans/(president of your choice" and have at it. Thomas Jefferson, Andrew Jackson, Abraham Lincoln (yes, Lincoln... the bastard). Many have had a use for the loyalty and fighting skills of the Warriors, only to double cross and either murder them or cast them away afterwards.
"White man speaks with forked tongue like snake" may be a staple of the Hollywood movie, but it had its origin in the Great White Fathers of Washington, D.C. So did the old joke, "We're from the government and we're here to help you.... ask any Indian."
Cletus:
Cowboys are not an ethnic group.
Patriots are not an ethnic group.
Highlanders are not an ethnic group.
Aztecs are the name of a Tribe, not an ethnic group, just as Seminoles are a Tribe not an ethnic group.
"Redskins" is an offensive name because of the history associated with the word, just as the word "squaw" is. Do you understand what 1stwarrior is trying to tell you here?
Even if the word were associated with the color of our skin, and we said the word was offensive, that should be the end of it. If the team name were " Washington Blackskins" and the NAACP asked them to change it would you fight the change? Would Snyder?
jwc - I was stationed in Savannah, GA for a couple of years and, yes, I just HAD to attend the St. Paddie's Day festivities.
Almost to the contrary, the "mostly" Irish folks I hung out with were offended by the festivities because there was no educational value, i.e. - telling what the Irish are truly about and like. They said their culture has almost been dissimated in the U. S. purely because of St. Paddie's Day. But, they also said that there were not enough people who would say anything because - hey, the money's coming in and everyone loves the Irish on that day.
You can't say that about Native Americans. Hell, even on "Native American Day" (which there isn't one) we're still told to "get over it".
That is sad.
"He has excited domestic insurrections amongst us, and has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions."
Thank you President Jefferson.
Deleted by author.
Perrie, I'm having trouble posting here. I posted two responses, refreshed the page later, both responses were gone. Did another post (couldn't remember the exact words of the first one) when it posted, the first posts were there.
But then I've been having troubles with many sites since those damn talking ads have started popping up.
I'm even getting kicked out of both Anishanaabe and NT in the middle of posting and having to sign back in to both groups.
I have Irish in my family as well. And when I think of Irish, I think of early policemen who seem to have invented the police force.
Also have some Scots in the bloodline. Little people, Druids, Manitous.... caretakers of Mother Earth.
And when times are hard and people are hungry, nothing is more welcome than a bag of potatoes, the most versatile food staple in any kitchen.
Screminmimi..... I disagree. I think it should be the start of the discussion. I remember the article, I believe 1stwarrior put up the enlightened me tho the savage of the white man in the early part of the history of this country. And several of the presidents were part of this ignorance as well.
Like I said, I'm not a sports fan, but I were an Indian, then I wouldn't want a name used that originally represented the scalping of my forefathers. Like I said, you'd get my vote.
To put it in context again, which may help some to understand it a little better as well as I have come to understand it better think of a player running around the field with a scalp holding it up high after winning a game against the Redskins.
Now how would you feel. I don't think this would ever happen and the player committing this act would probably be fined, fired and burned at the stake, though it be an extreme example, it is still a possibility in this idiot society we live in today.
I would love to see that - let me know ahead of time so I can prep for it.
Yeah - English, Irish and Chickasaw here. The English history - well, 'nuff said. The Irish I would love to know more of and to actually travel to the Green Isles and walk the ferns and dales and see some of the Ol' homelands. Sadly, not that much is taught about the Irish in our schools - nor any other ethnicity for that matter.
Aye - and then not many folks remember that the Irish got their potatoes from the Native Americans - just a small point there folks
Blue, you might be interested in this. A little known part of Irish and American Indian history.
...
BTW, there is a rumor that I have a spot or Irish blood. Mostly though, Ojibwe, Metis and a bit of French.
Sixpick:
You make a very good point and it's true, in this idiot society today it could happen.
I think you are wrong, though, about what would happen to the player. Look at Michael Vick and how he came out smelling like a rose after his horrible crime. There are others who have fared as well.
The player who did such a thing would "apologize" and say that he is going to "counseling." Then he would have a picture taken with the black guy who claims to be part Indian because his long lost relative was something-or-other so he wears chicken feathers and insults Native Americans by being a mascot.
No big deal, just Indians, you know.
Burned at the stake, then their ashes would be thrown in the ocean for the fish to eat and then defecate to the bottom of the ocean floor - yup - that'd work.
Oh, 1stwarrior, you have such a way with words....
It is Blue, and the relationship still exists today. I'll see if I can find another link to what the latest is.
1st, if I may..
flame, we have had many a good discussion, and I hope thatwe have both learned from them. I know that I have from you.
I think that you made a good point, it may concern some that they will misstep. I think that you learned that a misstep doesn't divide, and in fact can become a teaching/learning moment.
I think that the simple answer, (if one actually exists) is if you don't try, they you'll never learn. We all make mistakes, I've sure made my share. If a mistake is an honest error than there is nothing to fear.
Hope that puts to rest any concerns that you have.
''Counting coupon a bound prisoner''...smile, good one.
''Counting coup on a bound prisoner'' - Totally concur - excellent one.
Flame - on one part of your comment 'bout "I've spent years believing that NA is the appropriate designation" - aaahhhhhhh - if we could get the PC folks to leave us alone, all would be well. Indian is a good designation - probably most preferable among the people. Their tribal name, i.e., Chickasaw, Ojibewa, Cherokee, Hopi, Comanche is most preferable, if you know it. But "John, George, Suzi, David, Melanie" work wonders - it shows you are looking at the individual and not singling them out.
Thanks so much for your comments and insight. I enjoy your discussions.
Thank you my dingo.
Even in the worst of times, the tribes still give - sez it all, eh?
You welcome RW.
I came across it a few years ago, did more research on it and found it to be fascinating.
Flame,
I am 62, a Southern Rebel, and an Indian, and I had no idea until joining Kavika's group that the word "squaw" was offensive.
Never feel embarrassed or guilty about learning. I enjoy your comments.
Flame - as mimi sez - you don't ask, you'll never know.
Ask, receive an answer and grock.
Blue, you may enjoy this link as well.