╌>

Abortion, Big Money In Elections, And Eleven Other Huge Cases The Supreme Court Will Hear Next Term

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  13 years ago  •  6 comments

Abortion, Big Money In Elections, And Eleven Other Huge Cases The Supreme Court Will Hear Next Term

XCKNseN.jpg?1 "Its become a clich at the beginning and end of each Supreme Court term to comment on how important the term is or will be, and how the justices are hearing a myriad of major cases. And certainly after two terms featuring high profile cases on health care, immigration, voting rights and marriage equality in addition to under the radar decisions blasting worker and consumer rights there can be little doubt of the Courts immense power to do harm (and its less frequently exercised power to do good).

The term that begins this fall, however, has the potential to be even more significant that the previous two. By this time next year, fair housing law could be neutered, unions could be hobbled, billionaires could be free to spend millions to put their favorite candidates in office, and the right to choose an abortion could be meaningless. With a wave of their hand, five conservative justices could achieve outcomes that Scott Walker, Rick Perry and Sheldon Adelson could never dream of accomplishing even at the height of their power.

Heres a taste of whats at stake in the next Supreme Court term:" (click on the link and read it yourself) - http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2013/09/18/2284641/abortion-election-buying-huge-cases-supreme-court-hear-term/

**********************************

This is a time to be fearful...very fearful. With a conservative court headed by the loose cannons, Scalia and Thomas, our civil rights stand in grave jeopardy.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    13 years ago

Great article, thanks.

On this one:

Nearly a century ago, the Supreme Court held that, when the United States enters into a valid treaty, there can be no dispute about the validity of the statute [implementing the treaty] under Article 1, Section 8, as a necessary and proper means to execute the powers of the Government. Bond now asks the Roberts Court to repudiate this holding, or at least to limit it enough to allow her to avoid prosecution for her use of the stolen poison under the statute implementing the chemical weapons treaty. If the justices take her up on this request, they could potentially curtail Americas ability to meet its treaty obligations to a significant degree.

If they do reach such a result, it would not be the first time the Roberts Court cut into our nations ability to meet our international obligations. In 2008 in a case argued by future Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) the Court held that Texas could ignore a treaty requiring foreign nationals arrested within the United States to be informed of their right to request assistance from the consul of his own state. Even North Korea honored this treaty in 2009 when it took two American journalists captive, although Texas did not.

Huh?

... all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    13 years ago

But its so much easier to take advantage of people's ignorance and scare people! Remember how the "unitary executive" and "signing statements" signaled Bush's dictatorship?

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    13 years ago

I'll agree with the last part. The Constitution does say notwithstanding State laws, so there are points to be made on both sides when there is a conflict.

In this specific case, there is also: Justice Stevens, concurring in the judgment .

There is a great deal of wisdom in Justice Breyer s dissent. I agree that the text and history of the Supremacy Clause, as well as this Courts treaty-related cases, do not support a presumption against self-execution.

...

On the other hand, the costs of refusing to respect the ICJs judgment are significant. The entire Court and the President agree that breach will jeopardize the United States plainly compelling interests in ensuring the reciprocal observance of the Vienna Convention, protecting relations with foreign governments, and demonstrating commitment to the role of international law. Ante , at 28. When the honor of the Nation is balanced against the modest cost of compliance, Texas would do well to recognize that more is at stake than whether judgments of the ICJ, and the principled admonitions of the President of the United States, trump state procedural rules in the absence of implementing legislation.

I understand the heinous nature of Medellin's crimes. SCOTUS could have just as easily ignored the case, and Medellin's fate would not have been effected. So, seems to me Roberts et al wanted to wade in on the general issue.

I agree with Breyer, the 'self-executing' argument the majority used is states-rights mumbo-jumbo.

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    13 years ago

My complaint is with the interpretation that 'undertake to comply' in the signed and ratified treaty doesn't mean anything.

As Stevens wrote:

On the other hand Article 94(1) does not contain the kind of unambiguous language foreclosing self-execution that is found in other treaties. The obligation to undertake to comply with ICJ decisions is more consistent with self-execution than, for example, an obligation to enact legislation. Cf., e.g., International Plant Protection Convention, Art. I, Dec. 6, 1951, [1972] 23 U.S.T. 2770, T.I.A.S. No. 7465 ([T]he contracting Governments undertake to adopt the legislative, technical and administrative measures specified in this Convention). Furthermore, whereas the Senate has issued declarations of non-self-execution when ratifying some treaties, it did not do so with respect to the United Nations Charter.

 
 

Who is online



93 visitors