Unions and ObamaCare – The Honeymoon is Over It Seems.
Few, if any, demographic groups have supported Pres Obama more vocally, financially or consistently, s than organized labor and now a rift seems to be forming.
The White House has been unequivocal in stating that changes to the PPACA will not be made to accommodate union demands for subsidies to offset higher premiums which will be charged for the Cadillac Plans offered by man unions to their members.
The White House said late Friday that it can't legally make the primary change unions are seeking to the new health-care law, a long-simmering dispute between President Barack Obama and one of the main backers of his signature domestic initiative.
As you might imagine union leaders have been vocal and animated (shocking isnt it) in their response to the breaking news that the PPACA will adversely affect the health insurance plans of millions of union members.
The largest U.S. labor federation approved a resolution yesterday urging amendments to the law in a voice vote on the final day of its quadrennial convention in Los Angeles.
The action by the AFL-CIO, which endorsed the law when it passed in 2010, adds to the political challenges facing the Obama administration as it implements the law. Republicans have vowed to block the union-backed changes, making it unlikely they could get through Congress.
If the Affordable Care Act is not fixed and it destroys the health and welfare funds that we have all fought for and stand for, then I believe it needs to be repealed, Terry OSullivan, general president of the Laborers International Union of North America, said on the convention floor. We cant have the unintended consequences for the proud men and women that we represent to be collateral damage in the health care fight in this country.
Avik Roy a Forbes contributor offered the following insight on the unions real concern about the PPACA when he wrote
..the real reason for unions concern about the Obamacare-driven demise of Taft-Hartley multi-employer health plans. One of the major reasons that people pay dues to unions is because unions do a great job negotiating health benefits for their members. If those members instead have the opportunity to shop for their own non-union-granted coverage on the Obamacare exchanges, workers have far less incentive to join unions.
In addition, there can be little doubt that union members themselvesafter having been asked by their leaders to support Obamacare and Democrats at the pollsare upset. Union leaders, feeling this political pressure, are stepping up their rhetoric. What they are asking for is not a fix of an Obamacare glitch; they are instead asking for special treatment so that subsidies, originally intended for the low-income uninsured, would also be available to union members who already have health insurance.
But like the White House, Congress has little intention of making the changes being demanded by union leaders
They point out that the statutory language of [the health law] clearly prohibits such subsidies.
Sen. John Thune (R., S.D.) has introduced an amendment called the Union Bailout Prevention Act that would explicitly prevent ACA subsidies from being directed to Taft-Hartley enrollees. In theory, such a bill isnt necessary, given the fact that the ACA already bars this practice, but with the way this White House goes around Congress to change the way the law works, one can never be sure.
Union reaction has been quick, unequivocal and lively
Joseph Nigro, president of the Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Union.We are not going to take it anymore! We are going to fight for our workers!
said Terry OSullivan, to a standing ovation. Its gonna be a big fricking deal if our members lose our health insurance.
It will interesting to watch this issue play out and to see how it affects (if at all) the solid union support that the Obama administration and the Democratic Party have enjoyed on policy as new issues are brought to the table in the second term.
It will be entertaining to say the least.
Quoted text and further information available from these articles --
http://www.forbes.com/sites/theapothecary/2013/09/12/labor-leader-obamacare-needs-to-be-repealed-if-union-demands-arent-met/
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-09-11/call-to-change-obama-s-health-law-opens-rift-with-labor.html
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324755104579073733055974464.html
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

AN interesting development in the ongoing political soap opera officially known as "Implementation of the PPACA".
Latest crisis of faith developing between organized labor and the Obama administration (Democratic Party)
Please note that the article and debate here is not about whether the PPACA is great or terrible and not about whether unions are great or terrible - the discussion is on what effect the tax on "Cadillac plans" will ultimately have on the relationship of organized labor and the democratic party.
It seems the unions have painted themselves into a corner on this issue . I don't see any way this will be beneficial to their association with Dems . Is this the beginning of a major schism within the Dems ... and if it is what are the possibilities of a 3rd party forming ?
Petey
I wondered myself whether there would be enough anger in the organized labor ranks to facilitate the formation of a more liberal (labor friendly) party that could be better controlled and focused (policy wise) by the union leadership
They seem to have drawn a "red line" but time will tell if it is really their red line or if it belongs to someone else.
Looks like organized labor finds themselves in line with a lot of other folks (e.g. Congress and its staff)
But they are not going to get an exception and it pi$$e$ them off it seems
Geez ... where can I get 1 of those exemptions ?
Petey
Just call - 1-800-gimme!!
is there really anyone who still thinks unions are out to protect the worker?
really?
JoAnne
i apologize RIO. as a tea party patriot, one of a group of Americans that a union leader suggested be "taken out" (killed) before introducing obama at an election campaign rally, i hope you can give me some quarter in my feelings towards the union mafia.
thanks.
JoAnne
I respect that all have their opinions and on a topic about the pros and cons of unions your comment would be a pivotal one in the discussion
Another topic for another day perhaps, The Future of Unions - Growth or Decline?